Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

You demanded I falsify intelligent design.

I found falsification.

I can't help it if you remain stubborn and lack the humility to absorb it, but if you'll question everything, it might bring peace to your unrest.
 
<<"AAAABBBB" contains less information than "AAAABxBB".>>

What you do not understand is that neither one of these little snips contains
any useful information. Feel free to post any assertions from those links
and I will provide the rebuttal. They are all easily shown to be either incongruous
or strawmen. You are missing the point about falsifiability and useful
information. So are they.

Ah. Hand waving. How convenient. And those darn pesky information theorists. They don't know the first thing about information, do they?

But well, please, go ahead. Show whats wrong with the posted articles. Show whats wrong with the definition of shannon information or kolmogorov information. Show why the experiments performed by Richard Lenski fails to provide information increase by natrual methods. This should be good.

On a general note though, let's say we have a genome sequence

X = AT AT AT AT

Further, let I() be a function defining the inforation content of a given genome, using any definition of information.

Let P() be a function introducing a random point mutation in a given genome. Now, let's say:

Y = P(X) = AT AT GC AT

Your contention, and that of all ID advocates, is that:

I(X) > I(Y), irregardless.

However, As well as P() can go from X -> Y, the reverse transformation (Lets call it R()):

X' = R(Y) = AT AT AT AT = X

is just as possible.

So, from previous:. I(X) > I(Y) => I(X') > I(Y) thus the transformation R() *MUST* increase the information content, irregardless of the definition of I(), or you claim that I(X) is always larger than itself, which is ludicrous.

So, random transformations can increase infromation without intelligence behind. Even if you define I() as only "useful information" whatever that is, our random transformation can supply it.
 
Last edited:
Information increase incongruous to useful information forming from random - ground O

Show why the experiments performed by Richard Lenski fails to provide information increase by natrual methods. This should be good.

Incongruous to my point because you are starting with information.

How about starting with no information at all. Now observe the formation
of USEFUL information from random.

This is my point.

~Michael
 
Incongruous to my point because you are starting with information.

How about starting with no information at all. Now observe the formation
of USEFUL information from random.

This is my point.

~Michael

From your own, earlier post:

The proof of supreme intelligence is in our uniform and repeated experience that Information of arranged complexity always comes from an INTELLIGENT
SOURCE!! If you disagree, then by all means "falsify it." I fully claim
that the law of information is falsifiable and always have. If you can
produce information by random process or observe replication form at
random under natural conditions,

Those goal posts sure are zipping along at relativistic speeds at the moment...

And start with no information at all:

Sure,

X ={}

P(X) add or remove random elements to X

Y = P(X) = { A }

I(X) > I(Y),always, no? But since P(X) can remove elements from its set, then:

X' = P(Y) = {}

Same situation as previously. P() can add information, even if starting with none.

Now, can we fix the goal posts at their starting location and you can rebutt the articles linked earler, and explain Lenskis' experiments?

ETA: Oh, and please deifne "useful information", preferably from a shannor, or kolmogorov framework, and please also show how this changes the arguments I lined out in any way. Thanks.
 
Last edited:
Sadness keeps the laughter in check...because responses are incongruous

You demanded I falsify intelligent design.

No I demanded that you falsify what I called "the law of information" and
the "law of biogenesis."

To falsify intelligent design I will go with Behe's claim for falsification.
(not on irreducible complexity, but on the observation of the growth of
a bacterial flagellum without the gene). I said observation.

I found falsification.
I'm sorry but
it was not only a strawman, based on above it was also a red herring.

I can't help it if you remain stubborn and lack the humility to absorb it, but if you'll question everything, it might bring peace to your unrest.

Does unrest possibility include laughter? I'm sorry, but as serious as this
is for you there is indeed peace from this end, but clearly sadness of the
realization of the results of error keeps the laughter in check...

Seek the Creator's answers when you question.
~Michael
 
If God were have to come from "somewhere," then whereever He came from, THAT would be God. How can you create a Personal Existence that is Infinite beyond the dimensions of time and space?? Why in the name of all that is reasonable would be suppose creation for God's Infinite existence?


Yes, yes. As any moron can clearly see, it's turtles all the way down.
 
I am not reading the messages here of a good number of posters, because they are in my observation engaged in non-thinking ways of writing, and giving a black eye to atheists.


Just the same if anyone says that the brain of man is not an organ of man whereby man undergoes experiences, enabling man to come to the human certitude of the existence of things outside man's mind...

Just give me the link in this thread.



Can man's brain experience God as defined by yours truly in the following words?

God is an existent entity independent of man's mind, creator of heaven and earth and everything.​

In my own case, I see for example the moon, and I know what is an artificial satellite made by man, from that point as by a flash of light my brain or I experience the human certitude of a shall we or may I say a fragment of God's existence.



Yrreg
I think you need to come to a clearer understanding of what is meant by empiricism and empirical proof, so that you can distinguish between inference and sensation. This is pretty basic fodder for philosophy. You can assert that the brain experiences, but if you have evidence that the brain directly experiences anything external to itself you should come up with the links or the proof.

And please, while speaking about others' "non thinking," give some thought to the basic and fundamental epistemological problem involved in your definition above. Whether or not you count the brain as an organ of experience, and whether or not you can claim it as an organ of direct, external experience, I challenge you to come up with a rational explanation that uses words in any way resembling their accepted meaning, for how the knowledge of God as "creator of heaven and earth and everything" could be arrived at empirically. I suggest that this is inherently impossible unless you redefine experience to mean something other than experience.

This is not to say that it would be ultimately impossible to know, sufficiently to say "I know it," that God is the creator of everything, if at some point one could demonstrate that God can, indeed, be experienced. We can use evidence, testimony and inference to arrive at knowledge without direct experience.

I do not believe that this has happened in a way sufficiently provable to say that what you define as God can be, or has been, experienced, and for myself I believe that this is because the God in question does not exist. Again speaking for myself I believe that the God usually meant by the term cannot exist without violating fundamental logic, but this is a matter for another discussion, or rather from other discussions, since it has been done to death already. In the context of this thread, the question is whether or not God could be experienced if he existed, and whether, should that occur, whether or not we could know empirically that God is what you define him as. I contend that that last point is not possible, even if the first is.
 
Last edited:
Breckmin, you're not doing so hot here. Maybe you should question your own cherished beliefs and take a closer look at what's really going on in the world.

Careful observation of the universe reveals that information (the term 'useful' isn't much help without carefully defining a frame of reference) spontaneously forms all the time without intelligence. In spite of the laws of entropy, matter and energy is always organizing in specific complexity on local scales, without the intervention of intelligence. Such a universe only supports a concept of a deist god - one who sets initial conditions, then steps back and doesn't interfere. Is such a god worthy of worship?

Meanwhile, there is a specific problem with a deity who exists beyond spacetime - it's a morbidly depressing thought. A deity beyond spacetime is incapable of variation in thought or action - in fact, is incapable of thought or action. Time is required for such variation. On the other hand, a deity included within spacetime becomes subject to scientific inquiry, and eventual discovery, analysis, and categorization. Neither deity in this case is worthy of worship, either, although a deity within spacetime might be capable of causing problems or providing solutions for man in the meantime. But since such a deity doesn't appear to exist either....

To those who claim that specific complexity never arises naturally, I merely refer them to snowflakes and diamonds. No intelligent being is out there sculpting these things; science understands quite well how things crystallize, quite without any intervention.
 
God is not a result. He is not just information. He is not just a living
cell. The problem with atheists is they do not understand this for some
reason. They do not differentiate between "result of creation" and the
Fundamental Reality which is the "cause of everything that was specifically
created." God by very definition is the uncaused cause of the universe.

[bolding mine]

You can't use a definition as proof of anything. A definition is just a statement of equivalence. It is a tautology, so of course it is true because x=x is always true.

YOU say "Let God=the uncaused cause of the universe."

I say, "Let God=the Flying Spaghetti Monster, or the Orbital Teapot, or the Invisible Pink Unicorn, or nothing at all, or impossible to say anything about."

Either of us could be right. However, there is just as much evidence for my FSM or Orbital Teapot or IPU or nothing at all as for your uncaused cause of the universe, so how do you choose?

If you want to say, "I believe in God as the uncaused cause of the universe because it brings me peace," or, "because that's what my parents taught me," or, "just because I do," that's fine. You can believe anything you want to. Just don't pretend you have any evidence, simply because you came up with a definition.

And you might try toning down the arrogant condescension of your posts. If you are a Christian, you are not very good at following the example set for you.
 
You can not use imaginary finite constructions
that based on your uniform and repeated experience you know don't exist
and apply them as tantamount to Infinite Personal Existence which would
explain the origin of the universe and its complexity.

How would Infinite Personal Existence explain the origin of the universe and its complexity? It looks to me like you're making up a fictional contsruct and defining it as something that created the universe.
 
No I demanded that you falsify what I called "the law of information"

I can find no definition for this term. Care to define it for us all?

and
the "law of biogenesis."

I can find this term, but wonder if you'd care to explain what you take it to mean?

To falsify intelligent design I will go with Behe's claim for falsification.
(not on irreducible complexity, but on the observation of the growth of
a bacterial flagellum without the gene). I said observation.

Then give Behe's claim to us and explain it.

I'm sorry but
it was not only a strawman, based on above it was also a red herring.

Define your terms and show your proof, then.
I don't think you understand the terms and again are simply borrowing the cachet. But I'll let you prove that.


Does unrest possibility [sic] include laughter?

Oh my, yes, you've kept me in stitches! :D I believe you wanted "possibly" there, but could be wrong.

I'm sorry, but as serious as this
is for you

It's not serious for you? Just killing some time, then?

there is indeed peace from this end, but clearly sadness of the
realization of the results of error keeps the laughter in check...

Rephrase that so it's not so horribly mangled, change your passive voice to active, and try to say what you mean without mangling the language so badly. Then perhaps I shall understand your ham-handed attempts at insult and we can both laugh. :)

Seek the Creator's answers when you question.
~Michael

Love to, but both of my parents are dead. Those are the only "creators" I recognize.
 
Why aren't I allowed to call the whole reality 'god'?
Is it necessary that i attribute a persona to it, for it to qualify?
The definition is up for grabs, imho.

And it comes down to a definition of a word.
That's the difference between theism an atheism.
 
Why aren't I allowed to call the whole reality 'god'?
Is it necessary that i attribute a persona to it, for it to qualify?
The definition is up for grabs, imho.

And it comes down to a definition of a word.
That's the difference between theism an atheism.
Indeed, the definition is up for grabs in the world at large. However, I think that in this thread, a working definition, provided by Yrreg, has been put forth for discussion, and it is possible to engage in discussion using that definition. It's just too bad that he can't seem to concentrate on the topic, being so busy composing off-topic responses to those he refuses to respond to because they're off the topic.
 
Love to, but both of my parents are dead. Those are the only "creators" I recognize.

I wonder when genetic engineering get to the point where intelligent design becomes scientific fact.

That would give meeting your creator a whole new meaning.
Kid could get birthday cards from their design team.
:D
 
I am not reading the messages here of a good number of posters, because they are in my observation engaged in non-thinking ways of writing, and giving a black eye to atheists.


Just the same if anyone says that the brain of man is not an organ of man whereby man undergoes experiences, enabling man to come to the human certitude of the existence of things outside man's mind...

Just give me the link in this thread.



Can man's brain experience God as defined by yours truly in the following words?

God is an existent entity independent of man's mind, creator of heaven and earth and everything.​

In my own case, I see for example the moon, and I know what is an artificial satellite made by man, from that point as by a flash of light my brain or I experience the human certitude of a shall we or may I say a fragment of God's existence.



Yrreg


I am still waiting for people anyone to tell me they are of the mind that:

the brain of man is not an organ of man whereby man undergoes experiences, enabling man to come to the human certitude of the existence of things outside man's mind.​

If you anyone are of that mind, please indicate in your next post at the very top of your message the following notice:

The author (you) here is of the mind that the brain of man is not an organ of man whereby man undergoes experiences, enabling man to come to the human certitude of the existence of things outside man's mind.​

This notice from you will save readers here time from having to continue reading your message.



N.B. If however you can't understand my English, please don't read my messages here or anywhere in this forum.

Put me on ignore.


My purpose here is to exchange ideas ONLY with people who are of the mind that man's brain is his organ whereby man undergoes experiences, enabling man to come to the human certitude of the existence of things outside man's mind.




Yrreg
 
Hmmm. This is heading in the direction of "don't post in this thread if you don't agree with me"

What is the point?
 
My purpose here is to exchange ideas ONLY with people who are of the mind that man's brain is his organ whereby man undergoes experiences, enabling man to come to the human certitude of the existence of things outside man's mind.
Yrreg
Translation" I'm only here to listen to people who agree with me and ignore everyone else."
 
My purpose here is to exchange ideas ONLY with people who are of the mind that man's brain is his organ whereby man undergoes experiences, enabling man to come to the human certitude of the existence of things outside man's mind.

This is somewhat unclear.
Using the brain as a sensory organ would normaly require mushroms or similar.
Isn´t there a christian cult that does that?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom