Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

Dear Yrreg,

Since your belief in God is so strong, what convinces you that God exists?

At what point did you arrive at your belief in God and how were you compelled? Was it from studying the bible/at a sermon/moved spiritually to come forward and accept Christ as your personal savior?

Or was it the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, philosophers, and artists that convinced you to believe in an existence of God?
 
Are you forgetting the most important organ of man for experiencing, the brain?

If you are brain-damaged what is the use of having eyes?




Yrreg


Nope, again you fail. Upchurch caught you out on it before I could. Now, show my eyes the evidence that convinced you of your god's existence.
 
Sensory organs experience. The brain interprets.
I suspect that Yrreg is hoping to introduce the brain as a sensory organ - perhaps the organ of revelation. However, even if the brain were added to our list of sensoria as the organ of revelation, and even if revelation came directly from the great Jehovah himself, empirical evidence of the creation of "heaven and earth and everything" would still be out of reach. Even if, against all science and all religous doctrines as well, mankind were the first thing created, the moment of creation would be devoid of experience.

post script: Yrreg, I have known many brain damaged people. I used to work with them on a regular basis long ago. Most of them found their eyes quite handy for getting around.
 
Last edited:
Ah, this is so exciting! It looks like yrreg is going for the Solipsism Detour combined with the Perfect Solution fallacy. I predict something like this:

"You can't know for certain that the rock you see, touch, and smell really exists. Therefore sense data and objective evidence is useless. Therefore empirical testing is impossible. Therefore God exists. Praise Jesus, and stop doing those naughty things with your private parts!"

That's ok, I've got Mornigton Crescent on the next move!

Could you be more explicit about those naughty things we are not supposed to do?
 
That's ok, I've got Mornigton Crescent on the next move!

Could you be more explicit about those naughty things we are not supposed to do?

Nope. Forum rules require me to tergiversate on this subject.
 
Evolution explains religions and God(s)

All religion around the world is an outcome of the evolutionary process. It was evolutionarily (is that a word?) beneficial for a group of primitive people to have an agreed world view and associated morals and “rules” of life.

If there were 2 tribes of people living in the same area and competing for limited resources during a tough drought for example. The group or tribe which had the stronger belief system or world view which allowed them to galvanize together and pull through the tough times by sharing food and cooperating because they honestly and wholeheartedly believed that their God was watching over them and would approve of certain acts of kindness and punish acts of “evil”. They would do much better than the neighbouring tribe who had no unifying world view and whom “every man for himself” was the order of the day due to limited moral agreement etc. This group would fight amongst themselves and whilst in evolutionary terms particular individuals may dominate others within this group, as a whole the group would be weaker during this tough period and potentially be over run by the competing group.

The above example scenario above is not an outlandish idea, it is what would likely have occurred during those times. Humans are a species which only survive well in groups and as such the evolution of groups is an important consideration when considering how religions around the world came to be.

If we look around the world at all the various people there is one constant with all creeds and races, this constant is that they all had their religion or “world view” which provided their tribe or community with a common belief system, a common unifying set of morals and over time would have assisted their tribe in surviving the “hard times” which would have occurred over the generations. Any group of people who did not have a common world view or religion to bind them or guide their morals would have been weaker as a group than the religious tribe competing with them and that group would have become extinct or over run.
 
Are you forgetting the most important organ of man for experiencing, the brain?


When you are asleep and dreaming (i.e. experiencing with your brain without sensory input), is what you are "experiencing" real?
 
Ok most of us do agree that we exist. The next step is to consider how we came to that conclusion. How did you? If you can lay out the process by which you came to believe that you and I and all other people exist then we can perhaps use that kind of thinking to address your next point. For my own part, being no kind of a philosopher, I believe that other people exist because they have detectable effects on the world: they build buildings and step on my toes. And other people can see these effects and agree with my perception: this is not the case with hallucinations or dreams and so I can tell the difference. That is one way and it is quite simplistic: but it seems to work for me. Perhaps you do something much more sophisticated in arriving at the same conclusion? So tell us about it...
<snip>

Fiona, is it at all possible you are a guy just using a girl's name as a screen name? Because I think I might be in love, and if I have to change orientation at this late date...

HOW can you be so patient?

God is an existent entity independent of man's mind, creator of heaven and earth and everything.​

I think this is as acceptable as any other definition of God...

...meaning it's also just as unacceptable...

If you want me to prove God's existence by empirical testing, please just first give me a brief exposition of what is empirical testing, and most important the organs of man whereby he can experience existing entities outside his mind as also inside his mind.

Oh, no, buddy, YOU'RE the one who said YOU would be doing empirical testing. YOU offered. So now it's time for YOU to do what YOU said YOU would.

If you don't give me a brief and coherent and workable exposition of empirical test or evidence, and enumerate the organs of man for experiencing realities outside his mind as also realities inside his mind...

Please go away and don't come back here.

YOU said YOU would be doing empirical testing.

So, if YOU don't do what YOU said YOU would do...

Please go away and don't come back here.

Don't waste people's time and this forum's bandwidth.

I couldn't have said it better myself. How about you take your own advice?

Ah, this is so exciting! It looks like yrreg is going for the Solipsism Detour combined with the Perfect Solution fallacy. I predict something like this:

"You can't know for certain that the rock you see, touch, and smell really exists. Therefore sense data and objective evidence is useless. Therefore empirical testing is impossible. Therefore God exists. Praise Jesus, and stop doing those naughty things with your private parts!"

Oh, gosh, this IS a problem. I thought I was in love with Fiona, but now...
 
Are you forgetting the most important organ of man for experiencing, the brain?

If you are brain-damaged what is the use of having eyes?


Yrreg



The brain is the organ of man that experiences consciousness and reason and intelligence.

If you are brain damaged or brain deficient you will not experience as much and as well as people i.e. humans who are not brain damaged, and whose brain is better than yours -- in terms of the quality and quantity of consciousness and reason and intelligence.




Yrreg
 
The brain is the organ of man that experiences consciousness and reason and intelligence.

If you are brain damaged or brain deficient you will not experience as much and as well as people i.e. humans who are not brain damaged, and whose brain is better than yours -- in terms of the quality and quantity of consciousness and reason and intelligence.




Yrreg

That doesn't sound like an apology.
 
The brain is the organ of man that experiences consciousness and reason and intelligence.

If you are brain damaged or brain deficient you will not experience as much and as well as people i.e. humans who are not brain damaged, and whose brain is better than yours -- in terms of the quality and quantity of consciousness and reason and intelligence.




Yrreg


The brain can interpret a god where there isn't one. Tell me again what evidence were you given to prove to you the existence of your god? Is there something that you can show my eyes?
 
The brain is the organ of man that experiences consciousness and reason and intelligence.

If you are brain damaged or brain deficient you will not experience as much and as well as people i.e. humans who are not brain damaged, and whose brain is better than yours -- in terms of the quality and quantity of consciousness and reason and intelligence.




Yrreg
All three of the things you list, experience, reason and intelligence, are internal. The brain is not generally considered capable of direct experience of things outside its own system, which makes it of little use in discussion of empirical knowledge of God. Empirical knowledge of God, if God is defined as outside ourselves, must come from somewhere else.

Of course, even if you decide to count the brain as an organ of empirical usefulness, no entity other than God himself can have experienced the act of creation, and therefore, it will be forever impossible, no matter how some hypothetical God might reveal himself to our senses, for any human being to have empirical knowledge that God is the creator of the universe. For that one must fall back on faith. Of course, if God actually appeared to me and said "Yeah, I did it!" I'd probably trust him. Alas, he has not. I don't think he ever will. I don't think he's there.
 
I think I may need to revise my prediction of yrreg's "argument." I'm anticipating a little "Sensus Divinitatus" with a "so atheists are either lying or brain damaged! HAHA! GOTCHA!" twist.

Perhaps yrreg has been inspired by the brilliant work of Jesus and Mo:

http://www.jesusandmo.net/2008/02/22/raft/

http://www.jesusandmo.net/2008/02/26/firm/

I think you've nailed it. It's that "Plantinga" (sp?) with a twist.

Yrreg has a "g-spot" (godspot) and we don't. Ours has withered because we are sexual libertines.

Jesus and Mo sum it up brilliantly as usual. (I'll have another helping of sin, please.)
 
Experiencing a fragment of certitude of God.

I am not reading the messages here of a good number of posters, because they are in my observation engaged in non-thinking ways of writing, and giving a black eye to atheists.


Just the same if anyone says that the brain of man is not an organ of man whereby man undergoes experiences, enabling man to come to the human certitude of the existence of things outside man's mind...

Just give me the link in this thread.



Can man's brain experience God as defined by yours truly in the following words?

God is an existent entity independent of man's mind, creator of heaven and earth and everything.​

In my own case, I see for example the moon, and I know what is an artificial satellite made by man, from that point as by a flash of light my brain or I experience the human certitude of a shall we or may I say a fragment of God's existence.



Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom