Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

I dunno, I'd say that you need both emotions and reason in order to be rational. Emotions by themselves are not rational or irrational, good or evil, moral or immoral; it's how you act on them that matters. For instance, you can act on anger destructively, by putting your fist through a wall, or constructively, by focusing it towards a creative outlet. But whatever.

Judging from your context, we agree completely. It is just that we are using different definitions of "rational".
 
It sounds like you are saying that emotion provides the motivation for intelligence. (i apologize if misunderstand). Does the emotional range need to be complex to provide that motivation, or is pleasure/pain enough. Are pleasure/pain emotions?
I don't think it is so much a motivation for inteligence (perhaps but I don't see that, again I'm not at all an expert). Certainly it's a motivation to get us to eat.

As it relates to inteligence I think it is simply a basis. It's possible that our range of inteligence is dependant on our range of emotions. Ramachandran tells of an unusual and rare brain disorder where a patient with such a disorder will deny, upon seeing her, that his mother is his mother. Why? It turns out that the brain has a number of connections that signal a response. If the brain retains the part of the brain that makes a pattern match to the face but there is no emotional response then the brain has a difficult time making meaning from the image of the mother. It's easier for the brain to deny that it is the mother. A simplistic explanation of highly complex issue I assure you. :) The book is A Brief Tour of Human Consciousness: From Impostor Poodles to Purple Numbers
 
It strikes me as strange that the concept of gods and other invisable, woo devices are so universal in humans. One never hears of a primitive or ancient tribal culture that eschews such notions.

Perhaps the very fact of existing in such a profoundly mysterious universe is too much to handle in its raw form. God(s) would serve the function of compartmentalizing that overwhelming awe; making it more workable in an everyday world; once-removing it all from its heaviness.

That, and the need for a consensus outlook with one's immediate fellows.

Look at the fellowship that no-god fosters amongst atheists.
Atheism isn't something to handle solo.
 
Look at the fellowship that no-god fosters amongst atheists.
Atheism isn't something to handle solo.
I don't suppose it would foster any fellowship if there were no religious people.
 
It sounds like you are saying that emotion provides the motivation for intelligence. (i apologize if misunderstand).

I wouldn't say the motivation, but a motivation, yes. And not for intelligence, but for the expression of it, perhaps.

Empathy would be a strong motivator in seeking a medical or research career; curiosity stimulates questions and answers; mercy tempers justice; and so on. I don't think intellect and emotion are mutually exclusive, any more than I think nature and nurture are such.

Does the emotional range need to be complex to provide that motivation, or is pleasure/pain enough. Are pleasure/pain emotions?

I don't study the appropriate subjects, but I'd say pleasure and pain are sensory input which elicit an emotional response.
 
That, and the need for a consensus outlook with one's immediate fellows.

Look at the fellowship that no-god fosters amongst atheists.
Atheism isn't something to handle solo.

It is a shame that there isn't an equivalent to the church community for non-believers, where all are welcome. SusanB-M1 has suggested elsewhere that we should keep the church and just remove the religious aspects (of course, with the CofE we're practically there already).
 
It is a shame that there isn't an equivalent to the church community for non-believers, where all are welcome. SusanB-M1 has suggested elsewhere that we should keep the church and just remove the religious aspects (of course, with the CofE we're practically there already).

The problem with a non-believer church would be that the only thing in common is not believing in something, so the chances are it would end up as just a negative anti-religion organisation. Not that that couldn't be motivator to good things too, even if only to show them religious folks that you don't need God to do good things.
 
Arguably, we already have quite positive 'non-believer' churches. Ethical Culture comes to mind, and at least my particular Unitarian Universalist Fellowship is close enough for my purposes. A place for fellowship, something to do Sunday morning, a time set aside to learn about and contemplate ethical and psychological concerns, and allies for worthy causes. I could do without the old hymns, and maybe we have too many festivals, but it is a part of my life I value.

On the other end of the 'churchiness' scale, there's always atheist Meetups.
 
I'm certainly not omniscient. I don't know the ultimate nature of the universe but I am not convinced by the supposed evidence for the supernatural. What is wrong with that?

It's only wrong from an intelligence standpoint when a claim of absolute certainty is made in reference to the impossibility of the supernatural. Such a statement assumes omniscience by default. You see, since we don't know if this Big Bang manifestation is the only one, or whether we are perceiving it correctly via our neural hardwiring, or if this dimension is the only one, proclaiming an ID highly unlikely, or worse yet, impossible based on our limited "observations" is illogical and doesn't speak well of our intelligence as defined by adherence to cogent reasoning criteria. So the OPED is very relevant to the issue since the atheist modus operandi, not always, but very often, indicates just such an approach.
 
Last edited:
It's only wrong from an intelligence standpoint when a claim of absolute certainty is made in reference to the impossibility of the supernatural. Such a statement assumes omniscience by default. You see, since we don't know if this Big Bang manifestation is the only one, or whether we are perceiving it correctly via our neural hardwiring, or if this dimension is the only one, proclaiming an ID highly unlikely, or worse yet, impossible based on our limited "observations" is illogical and doesn't speak well of our intelligence as defined by adherence to cogent reasoning criteria. So the OPED is very relevant to the issue since the atheist modus operandi, not always, but very often, indicates just such an approach.


If the definition of supernatural entity is contradictory, then it is safe to say "it doesn't exist".

However, saying "I don't believe in <supernatural entity>" is not a claim to omniscience.

Unless you are positing that I must believe in winged pig fairies because I can't prove they don't exist. The default position, from your posts, seems to be belief. Which makes me wonder how you decide which god to believe in, and whether or not you automatically believe every pseudoscience claim that comes along, because not believing in them requires omniscience.
 
If the definition of supernatural entity is contradictory, then it is safe to say "it doesn't exist".

I don't think so. It might appear self-contradictory because of our neural hardwiring, the assumption that all we see must appply in all unseen reality, including all dimensions, alternate universes or BB universes and their dimensions. So the agnostic "I don't know!" position is the more reasonable one.

However, saying "I don't believe in <supernatural entity>" is not a claim to omniscience.

The unjustified irrational assumptions indicate otherwise.

Unless you are positing that I must believe in winged pig fairies because I can't prove they don't exist.

Not at all. But we shouldn't discount the possibility of their existing because that requires omniscience. Actually, there are physicists right now claiming that they exist based on probability estimates which are in turn based on their belief infinity of multiple dimensions where all that is imagined must exist. You know, something akin to your abiogenesis concept but taken a step further.


The default position, from your posts, seems to be belief.

Yes, I do believe in an ID.


Which makes me wonder how you decide which god to believe in,

The ID described in the Bible seems believable to me for many reasons which you will disagree with. But that's another subject and one which would deviate this thread.


and whether or not you automatically believe every pseudoscience claim that comes along, because not believing in them requires omniscience.

No, I don't believe everything everyone claims to be true for this universe as I am perceiving it. However, I don't discount the possibility that it might be true beyond the range of human perception in areas of existence where our laws might not apply. Or even might be true for creatures hardwired differently from us. That would require omniscience.
 
Last edited:
(of course, with the CofE we're practically there already).

In what way is that true?

Have you seen my "I went to church today" thread?

As of three days ago, theism, the bible and pretty strict theology was still well and truly part of the Anglican system.
 
I don't think so. It might appear self-contradictory because of our neural hardwiring, the assumption that all we see must appply in all unseen reality, including all dimensions, alternate universes or BB universes and their dimensions. So the agnostic "I don't know!" position is the more reasonable one.

Although it's not a position that you take.
 
Refuge in humor, I have seen that before with atheists.

Posted by yrreg
Can't you guys read intelligently the title of the thread and the first post?

Here, let me reproduce them for you to intelligently read them and get it into your brain that this thread is about intelligence of human persons.


[ I have not read the posts subsequent to this one from KingM, which comes after my last post here before the present one, in which preceding post I reminded people to keep to human persons in this thread. ]

I really have very serious doubt whether atheists are born naive or playing naive, either way they are not exhibiting intelligence before people who take them seriously, for continuously failing to take into their attention that this thread is about human persons in regard to intelligence in their worldviews, specifically the intelligence of atheists in embracing the worldview of atheism.


I will be back later in the evening and see whether atheists here after this post are now attending to themselves as human persons in regard to their intelligence in embracing their worldview of atheism.
​



Sure, you will go away again and return later to nitpick about somebody else who is only utilizing their sense of humor. Unless you have something to add to your argument so this thread can move forward, I will assume you have nothing else to add and failed in your quest.


Refuge in humor, I have seen that before with atheists.

As with someone who states that atheism gives him rational consistency and guiltless masturbation, then later he and fellow atheists say that they were just being funny.

You guys from your own mouths show yourselves to be funny in your worldview.



Is that the only defense you have for your worldview of atheism, the defense of humor?

Just as when politicians make fools of themselves using their mouth without thinking and then looking funny, they assure mankind that they were just being funny?

------------------

MIKILLINI, think intelligently now and don't be funny:


Do you MIKILLINI need a working brain to act intelligent? Yes No.​




Yrreg
 
I don't ever put anyone on ignore.

I know I am on ignore, but someone who isn't may be able to quote this.

[...]


I don't ever put anyone on ignore.



But I am interested to discover something intelligent from atheists, in the present context whether they are being intelligent or acting intelligent in embracing atheism for a worldview.

In other words, Is atheism an intelligent worldview?


So to decide, one must determine:

first what is an atheist
then what is his worldview as an atheist,
but of course have a knowledge of what is intelligence.​


To make a long story short, I submit that before anything else for a human person to act intelligent he must have a working brain.


That is simple and clear and direct enough for anyone human person with a working brain to understand.

Unless for an atheist his tergiversating machine will kick in and start working double-time to make him appear either born naive or acting naive, but in either case people will see in him no intelligence and therefore no working brain.




Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom