Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

It's only wrong from an intelligence standpoint when a claim of absolute certainty is made in reference to the impossibility of the supernatural. Such a statement assumes omniscience by default. You see, since we don't know if this Big Bang manifestation is the only one, or whether we are perceiving it correctly via our neural hardwiring, or if this dimension is the only one, proclaiming an ID highly unlikely, or worse yet, impossible based on our limited "observations" is illogical and doesn't speak well of our intelligence as defined by adherence to cogent reasoning criteria. So the OPED is very relevant to the issue since the atheist modus operandi, not always, but very often, indicates just such an approach.

True only if you assume that the working certainty of atheism is "absolute," and only then if you redefine omniscience to mean something it doesn't.
 
I will be back later in the evening.



Please don't waste readers' time and this forum's bandwidth.




Yrreg

1. Theists beat their wives
2. Wife beaters have no brains
3. yrreg is a theist

Any problem with that logic, yrreg? Pick 1 or 2 or 3 or all.
 
I will be back later in the evening.



Please don't waste readers' time and this forum's bandwidth.




Yrreg
Option 2*.

*I'm ignoring mind/brain differences for sake of argument.
 
Last edited:
Do you MIKILLINI need a working brain to act intelligent? Yes No.​

No. This is a loaded question Yrreg: It's a matter of perception. I will share an example of perception and question you about the working intelligence.

Twenty years ago when I was working at a different machine shop, the owner of this business sent his oldest son to college. In order to partially pay for his tuition while attending college, "Scott" would work in the shop during the summer months to make some extra money. Scott moved around the plant working in all types of various jobs.

On one particular day the assembly area began to run low on lock washers (Scott had began training in this area at the beginning of the week), so the supervisor sent Scott to the supply crib for more.

It usually wouldn't take any more than ten minutes to acquire supplies from the crib and return to assembly, but Scott still had not returned after 25 minutes. This time the supervisor went looking for Scott and found him nowhere near the supply crib, but he had the lock washers with him.
He asked Scott why he didn't return to assembly right after acquiring the lock washers. Scott told the supervisor he was looking for the keys for the lock washers.

So Yrreg, was Scott's brain working intelligently? Yes or No
 
No. This is a loaded question Yrreg: It's a matter of perception. I will share an example of perception and question you about the working intelligence.

Twenty years ago when I was working at a different machine shop, the owner of this business sent his oldest son to college. In order to partially pay for his tuition while attending college, "Scott" would work in the shop during the summer months to make some extra money. Scott moved around the plant working in all types of various jobs.

On one particular day the assembly area began to run low on lock washers (Scott had began training in this area at the beginning of the week), so the supervisor sent Scott to the supply crib for more.

It usually wouldn't take any more than ten minutes to acquire supplies from the crib and return to assembly, but Scott still had not returned after 25 minutes. This time the supervisor went looking for Scott and found him nowhere near the supply crib, but he had the lock washers with him.
He asked Scott why he didn't return to assembly right after acquiring the lock washers. Scott told the supervisor he was looking for the keys for the lock washers.

So Yrreg, was Scott's brain working intelligently? Yes or No
my dad's a retired machinist. worked 44 years at the same shop. I think he'll get a kick out of your story.
 
You bring in skepticism and now pragmatic skepticism.

Suppose you tell me in very brief words which I appreciate what is the difference between scientific skepticism and pragmatic skepticism.

Scientific skepticism only cares about demonstrable evidence. Pragmatic skepticism allows personal evidence for personal conclusions. Pragmatic skepticism also allows for metaphysical speculation, which falls under philosophy instead of science.

Are you saying that scientific skepticism does not subscribe to Occam's Razor?

No, I'm saying you don't subscribe to Occam's Razor.

Just choose, one or two or all three of the following:

1. Atheists have no working brain.

2. Atheists' brain lacks belief in God.

3. Atheists' brain is still in the state of babies' brain.​

Atheists lack belief in God.
 
I'm starting to be tempted to place Yrreg on ignore.

He seems to be posting the exact same thing over and over and over again, but expects a different result each time. Isn't this a definition of insanity?

It is quite clear to me that Yrreg feels that Atheists are lacking in any intelligence. The only answer he wants, and will accept is the one that fits his worldview.

He has his conclusion, and is now looking for evidence to support it.
 
Some atheists are rational in accepting atheism, most I'd say.

There are of course some people who are atheists because they don't like being told what to do, or because something bad in their life shattered their faith in God.

Those who simply are atheists because they don't like being told what to do probably do so because of their personality rather than the rationality of the belief. Luckily it would appear that these types of atheists are not a majority.

The ones who became atheists because something bad happened in their life which shattered their faith in God can be completely rational depending what happened, it also could be irrational depending on what happened.


The reason I became an atheist is because of the following
- I am a fairly concrete person who is not big on symbolism, abstractness and such -- religion requires a lot of symbolism, abstractness and such.
- I did not like going to church as a kid as I hated getting up in the morning early on Sunday. I liked to sleep late on the weekends. Church was also boring, for the most part, I did not like Sunday School.
- Once confirmed I stopped going to church
- Over the years continuous scientific knowledge kept re-inforcing and confirming the fact that there is no such thing as God or an afterlife or re-incarnation or anything of that sort. I of course wanted to believe there being all those wonderful things, but I ultimately do believe in believing the truth (after all reality doesn't matter what you believe). As a result I stopped believing, for there was no good reason to believe.


INRM
 
Reality is wide open for interpretation. All the data is not in yet.
It never will be. A sense of awe and wonder is indicated for the curious and aware.

Pure observation can bring on ecstatic states. Such feelings are normally associated with religious, non-scientific persons.

There is magic without woo. The whole experience of existence is magical.
Spiritual, even.

Its a pity that atheists must be lumped into a category that implies a sort-of killjoy approach to all that is magnificent, incomprehensible, unlikely, extraordinary, beautiful beyond description, and worthwhile.

Some of us reject God because it isn't amazing enough; that it stifles the awesomeness of reality...God isn't big enough for the job, so to speak.

The god i was introduced to as a boy was simply too lame to go for.
Abandoning that, and taking on the atheist moniker, was an expression of a deeper 'faith'.

Its like music:

I pretty much quit listening to Bobby Vinton albums when the British invasion happened.
Bobby just wasn't getting it for me anymore.

Blue on blue, people.
 
quarky,

Yes, however when you consider that

1.) Religious beliefs seem to be based in human nature. The need to believe in something bigger than themselves to enable themselves to trust their parents, and to integrate into a society

2.) Believe in Paranormal and Religion originates in the fact that a false-positive is less dangerous as a false negative. A person nearly sees someone get killed by an animal -- prior to that there was russelling in the trees. The person sees a russling in the trees they decide to operate under the principle that there might be an animal there (if they decided to believe there was nothing there and there was -- they'd be killed). This ultimately evolves into a confirmation bias...

3.) Many religious experiences such as NDE's can be duplicated at least to some extent using hallucinogens including DiMethylTryptamine which can be produced by the Pineal Gland which is in the brain and is also linked to the visuals in dreams. It can also be produced by other body tissues.

4.) Feedback loops appear to eliminate any magical or supernatural, or quantum explanation behind consciousnes. It seems to enable the job to be done simply with the brain and associated neuro-transmitters.

These pieces of evidence are basically all I need to say there's no God or any Afterlife. Do I like it? No. It is the truth though, so I accept it.
 
I will be back later in the evening.

Please don't waste readers' time and this forum's bandwidth.

Yrreg
Yrreg, you are wasting forum bandwidth by quoting entire previous posts and leaving large spaces between your paragraphs. This message could have been conveyed in a much more compact manner than it was. You have been advised of this previously, and it is the height of hypocricy to quote entire posts that you have made before, and in the next breath exhort us to not waste forum bandwidth. Please do not do this again.
 
Last edited:
What's not to like?

Must we like something non-existent to get in on the liking of existence?
What I'm suggesting here, and lacking proper words, is that atheism is holier than theism.
Those that search with longing for the truth; those that refuse to cop to something lesser, even if it made life easier...they are the equivalent of the ultra-religious. Science won't allow false prophets. Science insists on a more sincere evaluation of how it is.

All the atheists go to heaven. Its good that they don't care.
Theists, on the other hand, have serious doubts.

How could they not?
 
What's not to like?

Must we like something non-existent to get in on the liking of existence?
What I'm suggesting here, and lacking proper words, is that atheism is holier than theism.
Those that search with longing for the truth; those that refuse to cop to something lesser, even if it made life easier...they are the equivalent of the ultra-religious. Science won't allow false prophets. Science insists on a more sincere evaluation of how it is.

All the atheists go to heaven. Its good that they don't care.
Theists, on the other hand, have serious doubts.

How could they not?
I understand what you're trying to say here, quarky, but your statements are open to misinterpretation of the "OMG He sed that athiests are ultra-relgious!!1one!" type. Be careful. :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom