Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

It's only wrong from an intelligence standpoint when a claim of absolute certainty is made in reference to the impossibility of the supernatural. Such a statement assumes omniscience by default. You see, since we don't know if this Big Bang manifestation is the only one, or whether we are perceiving it correctly via our neural hardwiring, or if this dimension is the only one, proclaiming an ID highly unlikely, or worse yet, impossible based on our limited "observations" is illogical and doesn't speak well of our intelligence as defined by adherence to cogent reasoning criteria. So the OPED is very relevant to the issue since the atheist modus operandi, not always, but very often, indicates just such an approach.
If stating that the supernatural is an impossibility requires an assumption of omniscience, than....

Doesn't stating that abiogenesis is impossible also assume Omniscience?

Doesn't claiming that you know your religion is the true religion require an assumption of omniscience?

Doesn't claiming that you know the one true interpretation of the bible and that all others are false require an assumption of Omniscience?

Doesn't claiming that evolution is false because you haven't seen macroevolution requrie an assumption of omniscience?
 
I know I am on ignore, but someone who isn't may be able to quote this.

Radrook, do you believe abiogenesis is impossible? If so, doesn't that require omniscience, by your definition?
Sorry, I didn't see your post until after I wrote mine..
 
Do you need a working brain to lack a belief in God?

Atheism as a result of skepticism is intelligent. Atheism as a result of emotion-based rejection/rebellion is not.


You mean scientific skepticism, don't you?

--------------------

According to X, atheism is simply lack of belief in God.

And also I keep reading from atheists that babies are born atheists.



The lack of a working brain is also the lack of belief in God? Yes No.

So, either atheists lack a working brain or atheists' brain is still in the state of babies' brain?




Yrreg
 
But I am interested to discover something intelligent from atheists, in the present context whether they are being intelligent or acting intelligent in embracing atheism for a worldview.
Out of generosity, I will ignore your condescending tones and not treat you as a child, but rather address the discussion you claim you wish to have.

For this reason, I will ignore all of your self-agrandizing comments.


In other words, Is atheism an intelligent worldview?

So to decide, one must determine:
first what is an atheist
then what is his worldview as an atheist,
but of course have a knowledge of what is intelligence.

​

​
1.) An Atheist is a person who does not believe in the existence of god/gods.

2.) An atheist's worldview varies tremendously from person to person. There is no single unifying creed. There is no central philosophy.

3.) Intelligence is the ability to make rational conclusions based upon given information and the ability to generalize those conclusions to settings outside the original set of given information.



A person can view the observable world and note that
1.) evolutionary mechanisms eliminate the need for design in biology. especially as there are no known irreducible features.
2.) Can look at the shape and order of the planets and know that the principles of physics and gravity describe their motions and shapes. Again, there is no need for a designer to make these things occur.
3.) Can look at the extremely huge nature of the universe and see our extremely small place in it, and know that such a creation wasn't designed for us.
4.) Can look at the recent discoveries of chemical evolution and know that abiogenesis is likely to have a rational basis.
5.) All unexplained natural phenomena (lightning, disease, earthquakes, volcanos, storms....) all had a religious explanation. A god was described to explain them. We know that all of these things have a natural cause and that knowing these rational causes, we've been better able to protect ourselves from them.

The person can look at all of these things, see all of the instances where the god explanation is not needed, and then extrapolate that result to a more general conclusion:
"If god hasn't been needed in any explanation in science thus far, why would we think he is needed for the things we do not know yet?"

This is an example of who intelligence can be used to "embrace" athiesm.

Now, this doesn't mean all atheists intelligently embrace atheism. It also doesn't mean that all thiests unintelligently reject athiesm.


So, Yrreg. I have completely and fully answered and addressed the OP and your most recent post. Will you extend me the same generosity that I have shown you and honestly respond to my post?
 
The lack of a working brain is also the lack of belief in God? Yes No.
Yes.

So, either atheists lack a working brain or atheists' brain is still in the state of babies' brain?
You've committed multiple logical fallicies (False Dichotomy, Strawman, and hasty generalization)
Since this is a education website, I feel it appropriate to explain where your logic went wrong.

False dichotomy:
There were two false dichotomies built into your argument
You've given two choices that athiests could be, brain dead or infantile. There is no real reason to assume this to be true outside of silly rhetoric. And in fact since all atheists here are posting, it is clear that they do not fit into either category.

Also, you made the assumption that either all athiests are atheist for intelligent reasons or all atheists are atheist for unintelligent reasons. Again, this is false, as DeusPhasmatis had explained.


You've made a strawman argument:
Instead of addressing the realness of the situation (e.g., actually taking into account DeusPhasmatis's point that a person could be athiest for smart and/or stupid reasons) you decided to attack an easier target, one of your own creation. This is call strawmaning the argument and is a dishonest debate tactic. Although, to be fair, it is an extremely easy one to commit unwittingly, if you are unaware of it.


Hasty Generalization:
You took the argument that infants and the brain dead are atheists and extrapolated that to mean all athiests are either infants or brain dead. This is simply wrong. Another example of a hasty generalization would be

Northern Phillipinos are Muslim, therefore all phillipinos are muslim.

You can see that this is a wrong statement for the identical reason why your generalization is a wrong statement.
 
[snip]

No, I don't believe everything everyone claims to be true for this universe as I am perceiving it. However, I don't discount the possibility that it might be true beyond the range of human perception in areas of existence where our laws might not apply. Or even might be true for creatures hardwired differently from us. That would require omniscience.

Firstly, I didn't finish our debate about the morality of the bible on the other thread. I still think that the bible's moral lessons are not correct, but I lack the biblical knowledge to win such a debate with you, so I concede defeat.

Secondly, while I can't deny the possibility of deities outside reason and perception, I see no reason to concern myself over it. 'That which is unknowable is irrelevant'. Anything outside reason and perception can't be prepared for (by definition), so there's no point in ever considering them. So, that is what I consider is meant by statements of their non-existence
 
  1. According to X, atheism is simply lack of belief in God.
  2. And also I keep reading from atheists that babies are born atheists.
  3. The lack of a working brain is also the lack of belief in God? Yes No.
  4. So, either atheists lack a working brain or atheists' brain is still in the state of babies' brain?
(enumeration mine)

Wow. An argument. I'm impressed.

If by "the state of a babies' brain" you ONLY mean a lack of a belief in God then, drum roll, YES.

However, if by "the state of babies' brain" you mean lacking in education and cognizant capability then no, you've excluded the middle (a hell of a lot of middle).
 
The lack of a working brain is also the lack of belief in God? Yes No.

So, either atheists lack a working brain or atheists' brain is still in the state of babies' brain?

Speaking of a lack of working brains, let me explain the logical fallacy of affirming the consequent.

Your argument consists of:

P1: If you lack a working brain, you lack belief in God.
P2: Atheists lack belief in God.
C: Therefore atheists lack a working brain.

This is of the form:

P1: If B then G.
P2: G.
C: Therefore B.


Fail.
 
According to X, atheism is simply lack of belief in God.
Yes.

And also I keep reading from atheists that babies are born atheists.
Of course they are. Babies are born without beliefs. Babies lack belief in gods and unicorns as well as electricity and super-massive black holes.

The lack of a working brain is also the lack of belief in God? Yes No.
Yes. Rocks and trees lack belief in gods.

So, either atheists lack a working brain or atheists' brain is still in the state of babies' brain?
No. It does not follow that atheists are as dumb as rocks or even babies because they all lack belief in gods. Rocks and babies, like you, also lack belief in unicorns and the truth of Buddhism. If your argument is valid then your lack of belief in unicorns of the truth of Buddhism is due to your lack of a working brain or your brain being in an infantile state.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for not acting naive.

Posted by yrreg
You mean scientific skepticism, don't you?​
No, I mean pragmatic skepticism. Occam's Razor comes to mind.


Quote:
The lack of a working brain is also the lack of belief in God?​
Results in, yes.


Quote:
So, either atheists lack a working brain or atheists' brain is still in the state of babies' brain?​
A implies B is not B implies A.


You bring in skepticism and now pragmatic skepticism.

Suppose you tell me in very brief words which I appreciate what is the difference between scientific skepticism and pragmatic skepticism.

Are you saying that scientific skepticism does not subscribe to Occam's Razor?

------------------


Quote from Yrreg:
So, either atheists lack a working brain or atheists' brain is still in the state of babies' brain?​

A implies B is not B implies A.

​


Just choose, one or two or all three of the following:

1. Atheists have no working brain.

2. Atheists' brain lacks belief in God.

3. Atheists' brain is still in the state of babies' brain.​

-----------------

I invite atheists here to direct their attention to this exchange between DP and myself.




Yrreg
 
Speaking of a lack of working brains, let me explain the logical fallacy of affirming the consequent.

Your argument consists of:

P1: If you lack a working brain, you lack belief in God.
P2: Atheists lack belief in God.
C: Therefore atheists lack a working brain.

This is of the form:

P1: If B then G.
P2: G.
C: Therefore B.


Fail.

:rolleyes:

That too. :)
 
Last edited:
I invite atheists here to direct their attention to this exchange between DP and myself.
I invite you to address the fact that you have excluded the middle and affirmed the consequent.
 
Just choose, one or two or all three of the following:

1. Atheists have no working brain.

2. Atheists' brain lacks belief in God.

3. Atheists' brain is still in the state of babies' brain.

None of them. The brain is not the mind, as hardware isn't software, so not 2. 1 and 3 can't be right because of the intelligent behaviour of atheists on this forum.
 
Just choose one or two or all three of the following.

Posted by DeusPhasmatis
Posted by yrreg
You mean scientific skepticism, don't you?​
No, I mean pragmatic skepticism. Occam's Razor comes to mind.


Quote:
The lack of a working brain is also the lack of belief in God?​
Results in, yes.

Quote:
So, either atheists lack a working brain or atheists' brain is still in the state of babies' brain?​
A implies B is not B implies A.​

You bring in skepticism and now pragmatic skepticism.

Suppose you tell me in very brief words which I appreciate what is the difference between scientific skepticism and pragmatic skepticism.

Are you saying that scientific skepticism does not subscribe to Occam's Razor?

------------------


Quote from Yrreg:
So, either atheists lack a working brain or atheists' brain is still in the state of babies' brain?​

A implies B is not B implies A.

​


Just choose, one or two or all three of the following:

1. Atheists have no working brain.

2. Atheists' brain lacks belief in God.

3. Atheists' brain is still in the state of babies' brain.​

-----------------

I invite atheists here to direct their attention to this exchange between DP and myself.




Yrreg


I will be back later in the evening.



Please don't waste readers' time and this forum's bandwidth.




Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom