Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

Atheism as a result of skepticism is intelligent. Atheism as a result of emotion-based rejection/rebellion is not.

Why, because you think emotion is primitive, immature, and somehow just not as good as robotic, emotionless intellect?

I beg to differ with that assessment.
 
Can't you guys read intelligently the title of the thread and the first post?

~snip~
Yrreg

Well maybe if you wrote something intelligent.


Which kind of intelligence are you eventually going to come around to?

The capacity for cognition or the ability to use it effectively?
 
I repeat. Yregg will only accept the definitions that fit his world view.

He wants the answer to be 'no'. He doesn't think Atheists are intelligent.

I haven't placed anyone on ignore.. yet. But he's obviously ignoring anyone who DOES answer his questions, but he himself does not seem to be posting intelligently.
 
I beg to differ. I think pretentious wanking can be completely guiltless... especially if done by an exhibitionist.

Pretentious wanking will lead to hairy tergiversaters and dried polysemous stains on garments.






or so I've heard.
 
Last edited:
Straw-man. I said emotion was irrational, not inferior.

You could argue that a coresponding emotional reaction to a specific event is rational.
Such as crying at the loss of a loved one. Crying would be the rational emotional response. Laughing at the loss of a loved one would be irrational.
 
Can't you guys read intelligently the title of the thread and the first post?

Here, let me reproduce them for you to intelligently read them and get it into your brain that this thread is about intelligence of human persons.





[ I have not read the posts subsequent to this one from KingM, which comes after my last post here before the present one, in which preceding post I reminded people to keep to human persons in this thread. ]​


I really have very serious doubt whether atheists are born naive or playing naive, either way they are not exhibiting intelligence before people who take them seriously, for continuously failing to take into their attention that this thread is about human persons in regard to intelligence in their worldviews, specifically the intelligence of atheists in embracing the worldview of atheism.



I will be back later in the evening and see whether atheists here after this post are now attending to themselves as human persons in regard to their intelligence in embracing their worldview of atheism.


And don't give me that facile excuse that you can't know whether you are acting intelligent or not without comparing yourselves with animals, compare yourselves with other humans and see whether you are intelligent like them or more or less.

That for me is an absolutely certain ground to suspect the absence of the phenomenon of intelligence in your brain -- your having to bring in animals to verify the presence of your intelligent brain.




Yrreg
You reproduced that very well! In many ways that capability you have demonstrated brings back pleasant memories of your previous posts and threads.
 
You reproduced that very well! In many ways that capability you have demonstrated brings back pleasant memories of your previous posts and threads.
Those are pleasant memories? They burn like stupid (or, for gerry, clarity).
 
You could argue that a coresponding emotional reaction to a specific event is rational.
Such as crying at the loss of a loved one. Crying would be the rational emotional response. Laughing at the loss of a loved one would be irrational.

You can argue anything. Laughing in the face of tragedy is actually a fairly common emotional response: it's a defense mechanism against overwhelming despair.
 
You could argue that a coresponding emotional reaction to a specific event is rational.
Such as crying at the loss of a loved one. Crying would be the rational emotional response. Laughing at the loss of a loved one would be irrational.

You can argue anything. Laughing in the face of tragedy is actually a fairly common emotional response: it's a defense mechanism against overwhelming despair.

Emotions are never rational in my opinion. This all boils down to semantics though so feel free to ignore me.
 
That for me is an absolutely certain ground to suspect the absence of the phenomenon of intelligence in your brain -- your having to bring in animals to verify the presence of your intelligent brain.
Ok, now move on.
 
You can argue anything. Laughing in the face of tragedy is actually a fairly common emotional response: it's a defense mechanism against overwhelming despair.

Yes, humans require a release of stress, or if you want to look at it chemically, the build up of neuro-transmitters. This is done by an emotional response.

KingMerv00
Emotions are never rational in my opinion. This all boils down to semantics though so feel free to ignore me.
Yea I know my argument probably is semantical. My argument is that the emotional response is rational in refrence to psychology and biochemistry. Our actions due to emotions can be objectively judged irrational.

BTW I'm watching a show on the History International Channel about the military's techniques for helping the soldier control the panic response. They say they are attempting to control or overrule the signals from the amygdala by using situation training. To be honest some of ot sounds a little bit like woo. (e.g. repeating positive words to promote positive thinking)
 
Originally Posted by yrreg
That for me is an absolutely certain ground to suspect the absence of the phenomenon of intelligence in your brain -- your having to bring in animals to verify the presence of your intelligent brain.

Ok, now move on.

Yea I knew yrreg would facetiously conflate "intelligence as congnition" with "intelligence as mental capacity" for the purpose of insult.

yrreg is simply here in an attempt to stroke his ego.

Pretentious wanker as some one accurately put it.
 
Yea I knew yrreg would facetiously conflate "intelligence as congnition" with "intelligence as mental capacity" for the purpose of insult.

yrreg is simply here in an attempt to stroke his ego.

Pretentious wanker as some one accurately put it.
It would be nice if the discussion could progress.

I'll be back in 24 hours to see if he has stopped tergiversating.
 
Emotions are never rational in my opinion. This all boils down to semantics though so feel free to ignore me.

I dunno, I'd say that you need both emotions and reason in order to be rational. Emotions by themselves are not rational or irrational, good or evil, moral or immoral; it's how you act on them that matters. For instance, you can act on anger destructively, by putting your fist through a wall, or constructively, by focusing it towards a creative outlet. But whatever.
 
Emotions are never rational in my opinion. This all boils down to semantics though so feel free to ignore me.
I've been following AI for decades and it is believed, by some smarter than I, that emotion and feelings are what gives concepts meaning. Food to us isn't first something to simply keep us alive. It is that thing that stops our hunger and gives us a sense of well being. Emotion then, is in part, a seat of intelligence. It is, again in part, what separates us from a simple computer program. When he wrote 2001, Clarke gave Hal emotion, in part because it will likely (I think) be requisite for advanced AI.

Have you ever worked really hard to understand something and when you finally did you felt really good? It's that light that goes off. We often have an emotional response when we learn something profound or something that has "meaning" to us. Those things that we are most likely to remember are things that give us an emotional response. Not so much those things that we memorize by rote.

That's the hypothesis, AIU. :) I'm not sure if it is theory.
 
Last edited:
I've been following AI for decades and it is believed, by some smarter than I, that emotion and feelings are what gives concepts meaning. Food to us isn't first something to simply keep us alive. It is that thing that stops our hunger and gives us a sense of well being. Emotion then, is in part, a seat of intelligence. It is, again in part, what separates us from a simple computer program. When he wrote 2001, Clarke gave Hal emotion, in part because it will likely (I think) be requisite for advanced AI.

Have you ever worked really hard to understand something and when you finally did you felt really good? It's that light that goes off. We often have an emotional response when we learn something profound or something that has "meaning" to us. Those things that we are most likely to remember are things that give us an emotional response. Not so much those things that we memorize by rote.

That's the hypothesis, AIU. :) I'm not sure if it is theory.

It sounds like you are saying that emotion provides the motivation for intelligence. (i apologize if misunderstand). Does the emotional range need to be complex to provide that motivation, or is pleasure/pain enough. Are pleasure/pain emotions?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom