Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

Please don't waste readers' time and this forum's bandwidth.


He says, as he quotes himself needlessly yet again. :rolleyes:



Regarding your "choices":


Just choose, one or two or all three of the following:

1. Atheists have no working brain.

2. Atheists' brain lacks belief in God.

3. Atheists' brain is still in the state of babies' brain.​


1. Plainly, this is wrong. Humans require a brain to live. It regulates our bodily functions, among other things. So it works.

2. My brain lacks belief in god? Sure. So does my heart, so does my liver. So do my testicles. However, unless you are conflating the brain (an organ) with the mind (conciousness), this point is meaningless.

3. Seriously? This doesn't even warrant a detailed response.


I can also see right through your little game, Yrreg. You play out an insult, trying to provoke a reaction or get us to deny the point. You hope we will deny all three, then you can come out and say we have no reason to not believe in god, therefore we are acting unintelligently in "embracing" atheism.


Understand something: Atheism has no credo, no ideology, no doctrine or dogma.

It is simply a term to describe, as a collective, people who lack a belief in god.

It is not something one can embrace, any more than one can embrace being caucasian, blue-eyed, or having five toes.

Your three option are a poor attempt at a logical fallacy.

If you can't understand what that fallacy is, look up "false dichotomy".

We are intelligent enough not to fall for it.
 
I have followed this a bit for a few days...fun stuff.

The entire question may be intellectually dishonest, but it can be falsified easily. Rarely does a person's atheism or deism come to light during everyday interactions. Most people would judge a person as intelligent or not--with their own definition--long before knowledge of that person's beliefs.

Yrreg has a stacked deck here since quite a few are atheists. Who asks a doctor, "are you an atheist," before the life saving heart tranplant is performed. If the doctor responded with: "yes," who would assume the doctor is not intelligent enough to perform the surgery. Perhaps only yrreg.

glenn
 
Yrreg, you could save yourself a lot of grief, wasted bandwidth, and embarrassing nonsense if you went back to the beginning and asked yourself the basic question: does possessing intelligence guarantee that one will always use it well?

The answer obviously being "no," you could then save bundles of the bandwidth you're so solicitous for, by skipping the obviously spurious and unproductive discussion of brains and addressing the question of faith on its own merits. That is assuming it has merits, and that you have the intelligence to discuss it thus.
 
Yrreg, please restate the opening post in your own words, in 20 words or less. I will return in 24 hours to see if you have done so.
 
I for one am a baby without a working brain. But mind, my intelligence might not be sufficient to ascertain such.

I also waste bandwidth.
 
I will be back later in the evening.



Please don't waste readers' time and this forum's bandwidth.


Yrreg, you have here posted, word for word, what you had posted less than an hour earlier (albeit in an even more confused format), along with the worthless and innacurate information that you would be back later in the evening (it was morning where you are when you posted, and well over 12 hours later you have yet to return). Do you realise that demanding that others not "waste readers' time and this forum's bandwidth" in this context might make you look like something of a hypocrite?
 
Howdy. I'm BBqutioner, and new to this forum - yeh, hello :D

Now I havn't read all of what you've writte on this topic, but I would love to contribute, if just by sharing my own view on this matter.

I've seen many defenitions of the word Intelligent and I can't stress enough what a relative word this is. What I think of as intelligence is individual thinking and originality, where some think of intelligence as a measureable extent of how logic you think, how creative you are, so on.

I don't think Atheism is a very intelligent view, because when someone call themself an atheist they basicly say they don't accept god. Not that there is anything wrong with that statement, but when you are trying to find a word that best describes your veiws on how we came to be, what is beyond the cosmic, etc. You dont want to label yourself "godless" because that alone is just a rebelious, arbitrar view on theism. You might feel liberation out of calling yourself a non-believer, makes you feel kinda enlightned and superior, don't it? well, labeling yourself as a "godless" is no less dogmatic that any world view we have.

Atheists finally realize that there is no way an immortal, allpowerful and allknowing creature is flying in the skies, well kudos. But what you are forgetting is your very own opinion on the very matter. You don't have the gals to think of any? there are no reasonable explanation as to how we came, but mocking religious without really having it figured out yourself is not in any way intelligent.

I prefer views such as agnostisism, ignostisism, nihilism, and so on.

Sorry about all the "english fuzz" but I don't have that good language yet, and I find it very hard to express myself, but I tried my best.
 
True only if you assume that the working certainty of atheism is "absolute," and only then if you redefine omniscience to mean something it doesn't.

OTH, with that definition of omniscience, it's impossible for anyone, including God, to have it. God can't know he's omniscient, therefore he's not.
 
Welcome, BB. We will try to make allowances for your English, some of us have been speaking it since we were children and still have trouble.

What do you think of Yrreg's posts?
 
I understand what you're trying to say here, quarky, but your statements are open to misinterpretation of the "OMG He sed that athiests are ultra-relgious!!1one!" type. Be careful. :)

yeah, I was being provocative because yrreg's stuff was getting boring.
I felt we could raise the bar of the thread without him.
 
I made an honest attempt to answer you yrreg. Is there a problem?

Replying to your post would advance the thread, therefore...yes, there's a problem. Maybe if you threw in something about masturbation. Yrreg seems more likely to respond to posts that involve masturbation.
 
I'm sure that I have seen data somewhere that shows atheists as a group being better educated and more intelligent than theists. Don't know where to find it though. It is also clear that religion/superstition is greater in third world countries.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom