Are 4 to 4.5 hour office fire simulations valid?

Sometimes I simply allow myself the indulgence of extreme derail simply because the ridiculousness of the topic catches up with me.
The topic of this thread is no exception. As has been pointed out by many, TSz has grossly misrepresented the fire sim.
If course such gross and possibly deliberate misinformation must be addressed but it gets..... old.
 
Sometimes I simply allow myself the indulgence of extreme derail simply because the ridiculousness of the topic catches up with me.
The topic of this thread is no exception. As has been pointed out by many, TSz has grossly misrepresented the fire sim.
If course such gross and possibly deliberate misinformation must be addressed but it gets..... old.
Have you noticed - has anyone commented on - Tony's big shift of strategy over recent months?

I mean the move to found his claims in a high level "False Dichotomy".

Several ventures where he explores third party papers and claims to show where they are wrong...

...the implication being "If XYZ Expert is wrong it means that I, Tony, am right".

A false dichotomy of grand scale. ;)

All by deniable implication of course. And idiotic nonsense. BUT a change of strategic foundation.

Where "XYZ Expert" has included Nordenson, Arup, now this one by Weidlinger Associates...and a few others.

Is it a deliberate "New Strategy"? A big step OR simply the result of stumbling accidentally onto a sequence of similar issues?

It is certainly a big change from his eight years by my count of reliance on false starting premises. With "Missing Jolt" as the prime example.

The old strategy has been way past "use by date" for some time. So at least a welcome change...
 
Last edited:
Have you noticed - has anyone commented on - Tony's big shift of strategy over recent months?

I mean the move to found his claims in a high level "False Dichotomy".

Several ventures where he explores third party papers and claims to show where they are wrong...

...the implication being "If XYZ Expert is wrong it means that I, Tony, am right".

A false dichotomy of grand scale. ;)

All by deniable implication of course. And idiotic nonsense. BUT a change of strategic foundation.

Where "XYZ Expert" has included Nordenson, Arup, now this one by Weidlinger Associates...and a few others.

Is it a deliberate "New Strategy"? A big step OR simply the result of stumbling accidentally onto a sequence of similar issues?

It is certainly a big change from his eight years by my count of reliance on false starting premises. With "Missing Jolt" as the prime example.

The old strategy has been way past "use by date" for some time. So at least a welcome change...
I think it is a consequence of being caught out over not having actually done any analysis.
 
Have you noticed - has anyone commented on - Tony's big shift of strategy over recent months?

I mean the move to found his claims in a high level "False Dichotomy".

Several ventures where he explores third party papers and claims to show where they are wrong...

...the implication being "If XYZ Expert is wrong it means that I, Tony, am right".

A false dichotomy of grand scale. ;)

All by deniable implication of course. And idiotic nonsense. BUT a change of strategic foundation.

Where "XYZ Expert" has included Nordenson, Arup, now this one by Weidlinger Associates...and a few others.

Is it a deliberate "New Strategy"? A big step OR simply the result of stumbling accidentally onto a sequence of similar issues?

It is certainly a big change from his eight years by my count of reliance on false starting premises. With "Missing Jolt" as the prime example.

The old strategy has been way past "use by date" for some time. So at least a welcome change...
I thought that eliminating opposing thought was always his strategy, only now not so Bazantian.

It's the common conspiricist approach because it's less work to attack the other than prove your own, and it is easier to prolong the battle and teach the controversy. All based on the false Sherlock Homes premise that if you eliminate all other possibilities, what remains must be the Truth, which presupposes you can actually eliminate all nuances of the other possibility ("Off by an inch!!"), or enumerate all other possibilities.
 
I think it is a consequence of being caught out over not having actually done any analysis.
That must be a part of it - it is a long time since he tried to argue his own case other than by bare assertion and insult.

The last time he tried quantitative "analysis" i.e. numbers against me was on another forum. I had posted for other members the assertion that "when some columns in an array are cut the load redistribution ALWAYS produces some higher loadings than a uniform redistribution. He was arguing that loads are uniformly redistributed to the remaining columns - an error I remember seeing him make several times over the years.. And he produced a circular reasoning "rebuttal" - which was "old Style Tony" - viz assume your conclusion THEN reason in a circle to produce your self serving proof. Which - of course - was one of the fatal aspects of "Missing Jolt"

I thought that eliminating opposing thought was always his strategy, only now not so Bazantian.
That is also a true aspect - see my previous comment. The shift to "High Level False Dilemma" may be just a consequence of his drifting down a track. Certainly if it is deliberate strategy the deliberation would be new - as in actually decide to change strategy - by thinking about it - which would of itself be a new process. ;)

It's the common conspiricist approach because it's less work to attack the other than prove your own, and it is easier to prolong the battle and teach the controversy. All based on the false Sherlock Homes premise that if you eliminate all other possibilities, what remains must be the Truth, which presupposes you can actually eliminate all nuances of the other possibility ("Off by an inch!!"), or enumerate all other possibilities.
Sure. It is also "Dripping Stone" or "Broken Gramophone Record" tactics - keep repeating the same thing in the hope that it gradually takes hold.

Whatever the reason I have "called" him for it on another forum. And - believe it or not - got ignored...

...again. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
No matter how you look at it, CD explosives make a lot of noise that can be heard miles around.





What bright flashes? Nothing to do with explosives.





Talk about dismemberment, take a look at this photo and the condition of a steel frame building that collapse without the aid of explosives.


21-Story Steel Frame Building Collapse Photo

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipe...arthquake_-_Pina_Suarez_Apartment_Complex.jpg


No explosives and yet, that steel frame building collapsed. To sum it up, you either show us videos and audio depicting the sound of CD explosions as WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7 collapse or simply, you have no case for explosives.

In case you have never heard CD explosions, you can take a look here and hear what you don't hear as the WTC buildings collapsed.



The Sound of Demolition Explosions


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=65tzBUqxqd8

Check out this page: http://www.aquafoam.com/BlastingExplosions.html

Using foam and a tin barrier, they softened the sound of 5 pounds of c4 going off pretty well in that video. The foam is nostalgic of the spray-on fireproofing, too.
 
Check out this page: http://www.aquafoam.com/BlastingExplosions.html

Using foam and a tin barrier, they softened the sound of 5 pounds of c4 going off pretty well in that video. The foam is nostalgic of the spray-on fireproofing, too.


You must be joking! Since when does such foam cancel out the sound of CD explosions? Did firefighters or anyone who'd worked in WTC 7 notice any such foam? No! So once again, provide us with time lines that depict the sound of CD explosions and if you are unable to do so, you have no case.

BTW, how long did WTC 7 burn before that building collapsed?
 
Last edited:
Check out this page: http://www.aquafoam.com/BlastingExplosions.html

Using foam and a tin barrier, they softened the sound of 5 pounds of c4 going off pretty well in that video. The foam is nostalgic of the spray-on fireproofing, too.

How many explosives do you think would be required to bring down WTC 1,2, 5 and 7?

Once you get the answer calculate how much foam would be required and then explain how all these explosives and foam made it into 4 buildings with no one noticing.

After that please find an image showing this "foam" anywhere near ground zero on or shortly after 9/11.
 
Check out this page: http://www.aquafoam.com/BlastingExplosions.html

Using foam and a tin barrier, they softened the sound of 5 pounds of c4 going off pretty well in that video. The foam is nostalgic of the spray-on fireproofing, too.

I see. So you are going to create a fairly detailed description of what was done at the three of seven WTC buildings you have concerns about.
This apparently will include installation of some number of explosive sets with foam and sheet metal sound dampening.

When might this description be completed?
Before or after the turn of this decade?
 
How many explosives do you think would be required to bring down WTC 1,2, 5 and 7?

Once you get the answer calculate how much foam would be required and then explain how all these explosives and foam made it into 4 buildings with no one noticing.

If the upper 60 stories of a tower were rigged (because there's no chance of a plane flying lower than that), I'd estimate that would take 400 charges per twin tower if they're only placed on the outer core columns. Same math depending on how long the WTC 7 columns were, rigging all columns through the span of 8 floors.

Devices placed on the perimeter, who knows? I already gave photographic evidence for the perimeter being dismembered artificially. Someone asked for evidence of explosive destruction, I gave it, and they moved the goalpost with their coked out "silent explosives" meme. Imagine if this wasn't the World Trade Center, this was john's skyscraper down the street that burned down, no casualties or political pressure; Mr. Arson Investigator watches a video and sees how the perimeter of the building appears to be dismembering in mid-air after a flash of light and puff of smoke. What is that observation consistent with?



After that please find an image showing this "foam" anywhere near ground zero on or shortly after 9/11.

foam? foam?! FOAM?! FOAM?! WHERE WERE THE 50 TON HYDRAULIC PRESSES MAN.
 
I see. So you are going to create a fairly detailed description of what was done at the three of seven WTC buildings you have concerns about.
This apparently will include installation of some number of explosive sets with foam and sheet metal sound dampening.

When might this description be completed?
Before or after the turn of this decade?

Do you have reason to think that such a retrofit couldn't last the turn of the decade? I'm picturing the explosive hiding as a seamless lump of foam on the weld splices, among all of the other uneven layers of white foam fireproofing on the columns, and that's if someone you don't know is allowed to even look in the elevator shafts.

Could you tell from the Youtube video how tamping dampened the sound of 5 pounds of C4 (about half of a typical cutter charge)? If you had dozens of those going off close together hundreds of feet away, it could be comparable to collapsing/falling material.
 
If the upper 60 stories of a tower were rigged (because there's no chance of a plane flying lower than that),...


That is false because there is no sound of CD explosions nor were explosions detected by seismographs as the WTC Tower collapsed. In fact, no evidence of explosive hardware was ever found within the rubble of the WTC buildings. The claim that explosives brought down the WTC buildings is a fantasy.


... I'd estimate that would take 400 charges per twin tower if they're only placed on the outer core columns. Same math depending on how long the WTC 7 columns were, rigging all columns through the span of 8 floors.


Rig explosives in a building that was heavily occupied. You don't seem to understand what it takes to bring down a steel frame building with explosives. Have you ever wondered why demolition teams must first structurally pre-weaken the steel structure before explosives are placed? Have you ever wondered why the steel structure of WTC 1 remained standing within a huge bomb crater after the 1993 bombing? Ever wondered why the Chinese embassy remained standing despite absorbing multiple JDAM bomb strikes? Think about it.

Devices placed on the perimeter, who knows? I already gave photographic evidence for the perimeter being dismembered artificially. Someone asked for evidence of explosive destruction, I gave it, and they moved the goalpost with their coked out "silent explosives" meme.


There was no way to silence enough explosives to bring down the WTC buildings. You mentioned foam, but no way it could have been done. What you told me is that you have no clue as to what it takes to bring down a steel frame building with explosives. It also seems that you are unaware that explosives are wrapped during demolition implosion preparations.

So once again, either provide the time lines in the WTC videos where explosions are heard or you have no case. Simple as that!
 
Last edited:
You must be joking! Since when does such foam cancel out the sound of CD explosions? Did firefighters or anyone who'd worked in WTC 7 notice any such foam? No! So once again, provide us with time lines that depict the sound of CD explosions and if you are unable to do so, you have no case.

The foam looks exactly the same as the stray-applied fireproofing material. What are you literally even?

BTW, how long did WTC 7 burn before that building collapsed?

There is no photographic evidence for fires in the building until 12:10 PM. Let that be a marking point for when any serious fires could have developed. The building fell according to that engineer's prediction somewhere around 11:30 AM.
 
That is false because there is no sound of CD explosions nor were explosions detected by seismographs as the WTC Tower collapsed.





Rig explosives in a building that was heavily occupied. You don't seem to understand what it takes to bring down a steel frame building with explosives. Have you ever wondered why demolition teams must first structurally pre-weaken the steel structure before explosives are placed? Have you ever wondered why the steel structure of WTC 1 remained standing within a huge bomb crater after the 1993 bombing? Ever wondered why the Chinese embassy remained standing despite absorbing multiple JDAM bomb strikes? Think about it.




There was no way to silence enough explosives to brring down the WTC buildings. You mentioned foam, but no way it could have been done. What you told me is that you have no clue as to what it takes to bring down a steel frame building with explosives.

So once again, either provide the time lines in the WTC videos where explosions are heard or you have no case. Simple as that!

Ughhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
 
Does anybody have a study which shows some decibel levels related to how loud the WTC collapses actually were?
 
Could you tell from the Youtube video how tamping dampened the sound of 5 pounds of C4 (about half of a typical cutter charge)?

Just to let you know that using enough cutter charges and explosives to take down the WTC buildings would have generated shock signals that would have been sent into the ground where they would have been detected by seismographs in the area. Operators of those machines have stated for the record that their seismographs did not detect CD explosions.

The fact that the collapse of the WTC buildings created widespread damage is not indicative of the way demolition implosions are conducted. In other words, the WTC buildings did not fall at free-fall or even at near-free-fall speed nor did the WTC buildings fall within their footprints. Those are major clues that you have somehow, overlooked.
 
Does anybody have a study which shows some decibel levels related to how loud the WTC collapses actually were?

In case you missed it, I could have placed 1000 pounds of explosives on each floor level of the WTC Towers and detonate them all at once and the results would have been blown out walls and windows, but the steel structure would have remained intact.

You can't properly pre-weaken the steel structure of a building or rig explosives in an occupied building in secret because of the intense noise generated and hazardous conditions that would result.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom