I don't think this directly replies to the OP, but I have experienced 'knowing' that a dear departed was next to me, years after her death. On the day I married Himself, as we were taking the limosine to our overnight destination (which I did not know, since he had handled it as a surprise--heck, the limosine was a surprise!), we drove along the short of Lake Washington. The limo had a sofa-style seat, facing sideways relative to the direction of travel, so we were looking out at the lake -- a big pool of softening darkness with city lights far on the other side -- at the end of a long, emotional, wonderful and exhausting day. I had no idea where we were headed, or how long it would take to get there; in some ways, it was a wonderful analogy for my new life, where I could trust this man to be In Charge sometimes and not have to always manage everything for and by myself.
I suddenly sensed, strongly, a presence next to my left side, so close I could have turned my head and seen the person. You know how it feels when you are on a bus or a subway, and there's someone in the seat next to you, but you're not looking at them? It felt like that, except it also felt familiar. It felt like...Mom. My mother had died when I was barely old enough to buy beer -- much earlier in my life --and except for the occasional pang at Christmas or the anniversary of her passing, I no longer experienced much active grieving. But all at once, she was THERE. The sense of her presence was immediate, personal, and strong. It lasted about half the length of the lakeshore drive -- maybe three minutes -- and in that time neither Himself nor I said anything. Then the sensation of closeness vanished, and I turned my head to look at the emptiness beside me. I felt it was a sign that my Mom would have approved of my husband, of my decision to marry him (even though she had never remarried after she and Dad divorced).
It was a powerful and wonderful experience; and it is a cherished memory. It is the kind of event that leads people to believe in the persistence of life after death, of the existance of souls. And I will take any form of polygraph, CIA-approved memory extraction technique, swear on my love of my husband and of my daughter, that I felt my Mom's presence there. I know what I felt.
But--and this is the relevance of this to the OP -- that doesn't mean that my Mom's spirit was somehow in the limo with us. It means that I felt her presence. It means that in the first real moment of relaxation in, oh, call it 14 hours, finally alone with my husband and able to start emotionally processing the huge impacts of the day's events, my brain immediately started connecting with other very big emotional, important things in my life. Our mothers are BIG deals, and the loss of a mother at the tender age of 21 is world-shaking. (It still impacts my emotional landscape, even more now that I am a mother myself; I am sure I'll have some strong resonance when my daughter reaches the age I was when Mom died.) It would probably be more surprising if I hadn't had some mother-related stuff going on, than that I did. My brain, pondering the What If question, concluded that Mom would have approved of Himself, and of our marriage; and that she would have enjoyed the wedding and been there beside me to celebrate afterwards.
So I unquestionably felt her presence; that is my experience, and it is valid. But what *caused* that experience is open for argument. Having some knowledge of neurology and some experience as well with hypnogogic hallucination (HH), I'm pretty certain that it was a result of the same kinds of dream-state processing. When I was in my 20's, HH's scared me silly; but when, years later, I read about them, I immediately recognized how this known neurological/psychological phenomenon explained the terrifying visit from the Hellhound, and subsequent apparitions, that I had sometimes had. Mom's "visit" was supernally important, like other HH's, but unlike the frightening nightmarish ones I had had, this was very very benevolent and loving. Great, wonderful experience that I would not trade for $10,000 cash money--even in this economy.
But do I think my Mom's spirit could somehow still exist, and come 'visit' me? No, I don't. There is such an absense of evidence for any kind of 'soul' that exists independent of the brain; and a known, documented, normal neurological/psychological phenomenon that will completely explain my experience. Not only do I know such events can occur, I've had such events happen TO ME, so I know my brain can make them. (For the record, I like this happy one much better than the Death Angel next to the bed or the WWII pilot with his head under his arm.) It is possible to both experience the 'magic' and know the reality underlying it.
That's the thing I think the OP might want to consider; that's the thing that people often don't understand about skeptics. It doesn't mean you live in a world without wonder, without poetry, without magic; it means that you don't ascribe those experiences to the same causes. Knowing how pyrotechnic chemistry works doesn't make fireworks less beautiful! But it does mean you don't think there are fairies in the rocket that are released when the casing gets blown apart.
Just my thoughts, Miss_Kitt