Anyone Heard of the Scent of the Departed?

Strong enough to wake the dead, but not strong enough to wake you on the first night. Your story lacks a certain consistency.

She hadn't awakened before her husband shook her awake. That doesn't necessarily mean that she wouldn't have woke up at all if her SO hadn't done it. Maybe he's got a better sniffer or is a light sleeper.
 
She hadn't awakened before her husband shook her awake. That doesn't necessarily mean that she wouldn't have woke up at all if her SO hadn't done it. Maybe he's got a better sniffer or is a light sleeper.

She didn't wake up at all the first night.
 
We all know damn good and well what the departed smell like, especially in hot weather.
 
"Heck when i get back home I always smell the pungent scent of male cats." ok; but when we got in bed there was no smell at all. Then it came on STRONG, lingered, then LEFT TOTALLY. You guys just are not listening. There was this huge CONTRAST from Zero Scent to Strong Flowery Scent then it Left. The mattress was covered with blankets anyway. God.
 
"She didn't wake up at all the first night." Finally, someone is beginning to see what happened. Now that I'm older I bet I'd wake up now! I don't know why he woke up and I didn't for certain. I do know he had known her all his life and I only was around her .... six times? through the years. APPROXIMATELY.
 
"Heck when i get back home I always smell the pungent scent of male cats." ok; but when we got in bed there was no smell at all. Then it came on STRONG, lingered, then LEFT TOTALLY. You guys just are not listening. There was this huge CONTRAST from Zero Scent to Strong Flowery Scent then it Left. The mattress was covered with blankets anyway. God.


What you seem unaware of is the ability of expectations and beliefs to color our impressions and alter our memories. There is a very clear emotional attachment you hold to the explanation you have for the event.

The thing I find so troubling is that you seem completely certain of your own sensory perceptions and the infallibility of your own memory.
 
'you think this experience of yours makes you unique and special.." Now you are telling me what I think of myself. I am an ordinary person who has had a few extraordinary experiences. And I am not 'special' in any way. Millions of people have unique things happen to them; many prefer to keep their mouths shut. I wonder why? Could it be because of ridicule, real or imagined?
 
"The thing I find so troubling is that you seem completely certain of your own sensory perceptions and the infallibility of your own memory." First, you are not 'troubled.' Secondly, my memory is suspect when recalling drawn out experiences. But this was so brief and extraordinary I recall it clearly. And so does he which surprises me since he has a Ph.d and a Psy.d I would think his educational level could make him the skeptic about this but he can't deny what happened. OK: flame me for this remark.
 
Last edited:
Millions of people have unique things happen to them; many prefer to keep their mouths shut. I wonder why? Could it be because of ridicule, real or imagined?

Most of us don't automatically assume something as banal as a whiff of bath powder and perfume is the work of ghosts. When we see something we don't understand, we're open minded enough to allow that 1) there is a material explanation, and 2) we may have been fooled by our own expectations.
 
"Hours later, after we had been asleep for a long time, the scent was so strong it woke us up. Lingered, then vanished."
I apologize. This post was incorrect. The only thing that woke me was him. And this only on night #2.
 
'you think this experience of yours makes you unique and special.." Now you are telling me what I think of myself. I am an ordinary person who has had a few extraordinary experiences.
And there it is. You cling to the idea that you've had extraordinary experiences and hate the idea that what happened was perfectly normal. For crying out loud, enjoy life! Go and do something you've never done before. Don't sit around trying to convince someone that an old woman's room smelling of flowers was an "extraordinary experience." Go and have some real extraordinary experiences.
 
Secondly, my memory is suspect when recalling drawn out experiences. But this was so brief and extraordinary I recall it clearly. And so does he which surprises me since he has a Ph.d and a Psy.d I would think his educational level could make him the skeptic about this but he can't deny what happened. OK: flame me for this remark.

Do you understand how the "Quote" button works?

Brief and extraordinary you say? You rolled over and went right back to sleep! In fact, to hear you tell it, I can't imagine that you were fully awake enough to be completely aware of your surroundings.

Furthermore, you seem to be assuming that your Phd ex ascribes the same explanation as you. Certainly, you both seem to have smelled something, but that doesn't mean that he believes it was a ghost. And regardless of his level of education, he could still be quite credulous. I've seen many very educated people who believe outlandish things.
 
Maybe you did have a witness. But how can we know? All we have is your word. And even if you did have a witness, how does that help anything? An anecdote is not data, and the plural of anecdote is not data, either.
What if I had had five witnesses? Would that make a difference to you? I think not.
I have a story about that sort of experience too but I think I'll keep it to myself. :D
 
"Why don't you take your little fantasies somewhere else, to some community of ghost hunters or spiritualists who'll believe anything, so you can all sit around and tell your little campfire stories without anyone letting unimportant things like facts, logic and deductive reasoning intrude on your fun?"
I laughed out loud at this ! Thanks!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom