Anyone Heard of the Scent of the Departed?

'you think this experience of yours makes you unique and special.." Now you are telling me what I think of myself. I am an ordinary person who has had a few extraordinary experiences. And I am not 'special' in any way. Millions of people have unique things happen to them; many prefer to keep their mouths shut. I wonder why? Could it be because of ridicule, real or imagined?

Knock it off. You have not been injured in any way shape or form. Play the victim, pretend we are all harming you, that doesn't help you.
 
"Heck when i get back home I always smell the pungent scent of male cats." ok; but when we got in bed there was no smell at all. Then it came on STRONG, lingered, then LEFT TOTALLY. You guys just are not listening. There was this huge CONTRAST from Zero Scent to Strong Flowery Scent then it Left. The mattress was covered with blankets anyway. God.

You DID NOT READ what I wrote or you DID NOT THINK it thru.

I was saying, once a smell appears to your nostril (be it because you move location or because it jsut happened due to various reason), after a while you do not smell it anymore.

I am not saying the smell was there when youw ent to bed, you imaginated that.

I am saying :
1) you being in the bed warmed the scent molecules traped in the mattress enough for a bit of them to go out
2) you and your husband smell them
3) the odor is not pungent enough to stay permanentely exciting your nostril receptor and after a short while you do not smell it anymore (thus my kip on me not smelling my cat anymore after entering my flat).

Again read carefully, before accusing the other of not listening, you should be reading what we wrote. None of your counter argument invalidate the explanation above.

PS: and if you think blanket stops smells (basically a gas), I have to laugh at that one. ETA and anyway underblanket in a bed are usually very very thin, not the sort of thick stuff you have above.
 
Last edited:
You DID NOT READ what I wrote or you DID NOT THINK it thru.

I was saying, once a smell appears to your nostril (be it because you move location or because it jsut happened due to various reason), after a while you do not smell it anymore.

I am not saying the smell was there when youw ent to bed, you imaginated that.

I am saying :
1) you being in the bed warmed the scent molecules traped in the mattress enough for a bit of them to go out
2) you and your husband smell them
3) the odor is not pungent enough to stay permanentely exciting your nostril receptor and after a short while you do not smell it anymore (thus my kip on me not smelling my cat anymore after entering my flat).

Again read carefully, before accusing the other of not listening, you should be reading what we wrote. None of your counter argument invalidate the explanation above.

PS: and if you think blanket stops smells (basically a gas), I have to laugh at that one. ETA and anyway underblanket in a bed are usually very very thin, not the sort of thick stuff you have above.
"I was saying, once a smell appears to your nostril (be it because you move location or because it jsut happened due to various reason), after a while you do not smell it anymore."
That would be true with a diluted smell. A faint smell. For a baking turkey analogy: as it bakes (warms up like in your example of odors rising from a mattress) you begin to smell it. It increases in your olfactory glands and then, gradually, you smell nothing or close to nothing. This was not anything like that. This was as if we had been given pure oxygen. Hours later, as we inhaled the oxygen, someone injected suddenly, not gradually, a strong odor like perfume into our masks and jarred us (or him as in my story) awake with a start. It lingered, smelling strong, he said go away granny and it left instantly. It just reminded me of those naked men who jump into a half frozen body of water in winter. See that on tv? Except they're still cold when they exit the water. But I like the oxygen/perfume analogy better.
 
"So instead of considering the possibility you demonize those who proffer that explanation." haha. "Demonize."
Nope ; they're just mistaken , not demonic. And somewhat hateful and grouchy, some of them. No worse than hateful.
 
I am a bit mystified by your "victimization" claims.

You offered up an experience you claimed was paranormal.

You were given mundane explanations for this occurrence.

You swiftly rejected these mundane explanations because you obviously waould prefer to believe it was magical.

Evidence suggest people who believe in the magical do so because they don't like the idea that life is mundane. You appear to feel this way based on your posts.

If you don't like people giving you explanations about your magical experiences, perhaps you shouldn't be posting about them on a skeptic forum.
 
You still haven't answered the question of why you've been soliciting other people's views on what could have caused the smell if you already know the origin of the smell for sure.
 
"So instead of considering the possibility you demonize those who proffer that explanation." haha. "Demonize."
Nope ; they're just mistaken , not demonic. And somewhat hateful and grouchy, some of them. No worse than hateful.

And there you go again. If you can't argue the message attack the messenger. Intellectual bankruptcy.

I don't care how many ways you try to describe the scent it is still most likely that the scent came from a mundane source. You have offered nothing to refute this.
 
What if I had had five witnesses? Would that make a difference to you? I think not.

Why would it? You're not producing your witness. We don't know what he has to say.

That you say you have a witness who concurs with you doesn't mean squat in terms of evidence. No matter how many times this is explained to you, you'll still refuse to get it.

I have a story about that sort of experience too but I think I'll keep it to myself. :D

I'm sure you do. You probably have lots of "stories".
 
"Heck when i get back home I always smell the pungent scent of male cats." ok; but when we got in bed there was no smell at all. Then it came on STRONG, lingered, then LEFT TOTALLY. You guys just are not listening. There was this huge CONTRAST from Zero Scent to Strong Flowery Scent then it Left. The mattress was covered with blankets anyway. God.

1. If you mastered the quote function, it would be appreciated.
2. We are not listening? Seriously? You have entirely ignored perfectly rational explanations.
3. How do you know there was a huge contrast from zero scent (no capitalization ) to strong, flowery scent, when you were asleep at the time?
4. No, not god.
 
"I was saying, once a smell appears to your nostril (be it because you move location or because it jsut happened due to various reason), after a while you do not smell it anymore."
That would be true with a diluted smell. A faint smell. For a baking turkey analogy: as it bakes (warms up like in your example of odors rising from a mattress) you begin to smell it. It increases in your olfactory glands and then, gradually, you smell nothing or close to nothing. This was not anything like that. This was as if we had been given pure oxygen. Hours later, as we inhaled the oxygen, someone injected suddenly, not gradually, a strong odor like perfume into our masks and jarred us (or him as in my story) awake with a start. It lingered, smelling strong, he said go away granny and it left instantly. It just reminded me of those naked men who jump into a half frozen body of water in winter. See that on tv? Except they're still cold when they exit the water. But I like the oxygen/perfume analogy better.

It is also true for a STRONG smell.

If you have ever visited a cat owner home you would know that. Male cat ? two ? in a small flat ? Diluted small. please.

Now you are adding more and more details. Now it is going away instantely rather than linger for 10 seconds.

Soon you will be able to write a whole roman.

I am out of this.
 
And I don't think any of us have doubted that she and her partner really did smell flowers that night.

See post #14.

The problem is that Deranged has already made her mind up as to what the cause was and is totally opposed to any other explanation. No one here is going to give Deranged what I suspect she really wants: confirmation of her belief. If that is what she wants, there are other places on the internet that will be far better suited to her needs. We'll still be here if/when she is willing to open her mind.

Was speaking more to some people's antagonistic delivery/tone. I've been guilty of this myself and I'm trying (and sometimes failing!) to curb my own tendency toward it.

Even as a true account, it hardly seems in the realm of the paranormal. My house creaks in a heavy wind and the pipes often make noise. The only difference between the OP's story and mine is one of attribution, not of unaccountability.

Please see my response to Sledge, above.
 
"I had a witness. He remembers it clearly.

No. He had a witness. You.

He claimed to have smelled the odour the first night. You don't know if he did or not; it didn't wake you.

Second time around it didn't wake you either. He did.

How can you be sure he didn't spray some perfume in the air seconds before he woke you?

You have only his word for it.
We have only his word for it, second hand through you.
Except we don't even have that, because we can't ask him and for all we know, you didn't either.
 
"I think the most ridiculous idea yet is that there are people out there claiming to know what Jesus' mother smelled like." I know why they do this. A few people think they've seen Mary and that they smelled roses. They tell people this and next thing you know ? Most Catholics believe it. I would never be so crass and cold as to tell someone , "you saw Mary and smelled roses? What a laugh, you big fake. Drop dead*." I'd be respectful at least.

*That would be me being respectful.
 
"I was saying, once a smell appears to your nostril (be it because you move location or because it jsut happened due to various reason), after a while you do not smell it anymore."
That would be true with a diluted smell. A faint smell. For a baking turkey analogy: as it bakes (warms up like in your example of odors rising from a mattress) you begin to smell it. It increases in your olfactory glands and then, gradually, you smell nothing or close to nothing. This was not anything like that. This was as if we had been given pure oxygen. Hours later, as we inhaled the oxygen, someone injected suddenly, not gradually, a strong odor like perfume into our masks and jarred us (or him as in my story) awake with a start. It lingered, smelling strong, he said go away granny and it left instantly. It just reminded me of those naked men who jump into a half frozen body of water in winter. See that on tv? Except they're still cold when they exit the water. But I like the oxygen/perfume analogy better.

Why would a ghost create a molecule when it could just imprint the smell in your brain directly?
 
Deranged, how long ago did this incident happen? I know you said "years" - Two? Five? Twenty?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom