Anyone Heard of the Scent of the Departed?

Will you Please stop saying , "mattress?" It was NOT the darn mattress! It was in the air for ten seconds! And do not quibble about whether I said nine or fifteen.

Ok so the only two possibilities in order of likely hood are

1. Dead grandmother

2. Jesus' mum

Those are the only 2 things you have admitted to that smell like roses. The only reason Jesus' mum in second is because you have only hearsay that she smells like roses where as you where there when the flowery deceased grandmother sprinkled your nose.
 
"How can the scent be "above" you? It has to be at head level in order for it to enter your nose." Ask any dog. When a dog smells something cooking they smell up in the air. Nose goes UP. But, but you say...the bbq grilling was down the block. Woof. So tell the dog he's irrational .

And this proves what?
 
You just knew. We knew.

Earlier you posted this:

I wanted ideas on what it could have been that happened to me.

If you already know for sure what it was that happened to you, then why do you want people to give you ideas on what it could have been that happened to you? Either you don't know and are looking to find out, or you do know and are looking to get into a conflict with people about it by asking them to suggest alternatives.
 
Like all ghost stories, this one starts out rather mundane, but sufficiently odd to the originator that they feel compelled to tell people. When their audience is bewildered and mystified as well, the originator is perfectly happy because they have their beliefs validated. However, if someone listening presents a possible explanation that the originator hadn't thought of, the originator is placed in the uncomfortable position of looking foolish for not having considered a simple cause. They have two choices, admitting that there is another possibility, or inventing increasingly dubious caveats to preclude the possibility of the explanation being anything BUT the originators pet theory.
 
It was in the air for ten seconds! And do not quibble about whether I said nine or fifteen.

I won't quibble about whether you said nine or fifteen, but I will quibble about the fact that you initially said that it lingered and now you're saying that it didn't:

So that night he says, "Deranged! Wake up! Do you smell that?" and it was really strong: this scent of old perfume or flowers and it lingered.

Hours later, after we had been asleep for a long time, the scent was so strong it woke us up. Lingered, then vanished.

He woke me up and it was really quite lovely how it lingered then left completely.
 
Like all ghost stories, this one starts out rather mundane, but sufficiently odd to the originator that they feel compelled to tell people. When their audience is bewildered and mystified as well, the originator is perfectly happy because they have their beliefs validated. However, if someone listening presents a possible explanation that the originator hadn't thought of, the originator is placed in the uncomfortable position of looking foolish for not having considered a simple cause. They have two choices, admitting that there is another possibility, or inventing increasingly dubious caveats to preclude the possibility of the explanation being anything BUT the originators pet theory.

It is amazing how detailed and accurate a person's memory gets when their basic narrative about an event is questioned.
 
Six pages already, has another realistic source for the claimed smell -other than the mattress- been identified yet?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom