Anyone Heard of the Scent of the Departed?

Ok so the only two possibilities in order of likely hood are

1. Dead grandmother

2. Jesus' mum

Those are the only 2 things you have admitted to that smell like roses. The only reason Jesus' mum in second is because you have only hearsay that she smells like roses where as you where there when the flowery deceased grandmother sprinkled your nose.
I'm sure it wasn't Mary. Although the grandmother's name happened to be just that. Why do I know it wasn't Jesus' mother? That's too off the wall to answer. Now, if we were suffering horribly and/or we were in a convent I might consider it. Maybe.
 
Earlier you posted this:



If you already know for sure what it was that happened to you, then why do you want people to give you ideas on what it could have been that happened to you? Either you don't know and are looking to find out, or you do know and are looking to get into a conflict with people about it by asking them to suggest alternatives.
I knew what happened to me. I wanted others' opinions on what happened. That's what I meant. Sorry.
 
"I think the most ridiculous idea yet is that there are people out there claiming to know what Jesus' mother smelled like." I know why they do this. A few people think they've seen Mary and that they smelled roses. They tell people this and next thing you know ? Most Catholics believe it. I would never be so crass and cold as to tell someone , "you saw Mary and smelled roses? What a laugh, you big fake. Drop dead." I'd be respectful at least.
 
I knew what happened to me. I wanted others' opinions on what happened. That's what I meant. Sorry.

My opinion is that you decided to post some guff on the internet so you could get annoyed when people didn't believe you.
 
I knew what happened to me. I wanted others' opinions on what happened. That's what I meant. Sorry.

That's what Squeegee Beckenheim said. You did not answer the question as to why you were asking others' opinions/ideas on what you claimed had happened.

...
If you already know for sure what it was that happened to you, then why do you want people to give you ideas on what it could have been that happened to you? ....
Hilite by Daylightstar
 
There is a very large, heavily vetted, robust body of experimental evidence that has conclusively demonstrated the precise conditions under which the Virgin Mary will manifest, and as a result she can be excluded from this bedroom scenario entirely.
 
Wrong again. Receiving messages from forum members saying not only that they believe me but that their relatives experience similar phenomena.
I bet I could put names to at least some of those forum members.


"I think the most ridiculous idea yet is that there are people out there claiming to know what Jesus' mother smelled like." I know why they do this. A few people think they've seen Mary and that they smelled roses. They tell people this and next thing you know ? Most Catholics believe it. I would never be so crass and cold as to tell someone , "you saw Mary and smelled roses? What a laugh, you big fake. Drop dead." I'd be respectful at least.
What if they told you they saw a giant flying burrito and it smelled of Lysol? What then? How ridiculous would a story have to be before you would discount it?
 
"...or inventing increasingly dubious caveats to preclude the possibility of the explanation being anything BUT the originators pet theory." I'm not inventing a thing. And only dubious to you.
 
"...or inventing increasingly dubious caveats to preclude the possibility of the explanation being anything BUT the originators pet theory." I'm not inventing a thing. And only dubious to you.

Is your quote button broken?
 
"...or inventing increasingly dubious caveats to preclude the possibility of the explanation being anything BUT the originators pet theory." I'm not inventing a thing. And only dubious to you.

The smell was strong enough to wake the dead (but it didn't wake you for some reason)

It was at the ceiling (except that it was nine inches above the bed, or everywhere except the mattress)

It came and went suddenly, in ten seconds (or not)
 
I don't forgive you. it's good that you offer though. Try and learn from it and stop posting stupid lies simply in an attempt to get called a liar and moan about it.


How do you know he's lying? I mean, it's possible, but how do you KNOW it? After all, he could just be some "average" person (quite likely) who isn't going to state things in a scientifically-rigorous manner.
 
Last edited:
I assumed that the initial post was truthful. The follow-up posts seem to be as described, increasingly dubious caveats to avoid having to admit that the entire episode is completely banal.
 
I assumed that the initial post was truthful. The follow-up posts seem to be as described, increasingly dubious caveats to avoid having to admit that the entire episode is completely banal.

Hmm. So perhaps "something" really did happen to him, the initial post really was truthful insofar as that he really did smell something, but it was not paranormal, and he's just really, really desperate to believe it is. So he's making various ad hoc "Rationalizations" to try and save his beliefs instead of admitting he might be wrong. Or maybe he was lying from the start, and nothing happened, but I don't see anything that precludes something non-paranormal having happened to him.
 
Last edited:
Hmm. So perhaps "something" really did happen to him, the initial post really was truthful insofar as that he really did smell something, but it was not paranormal, and he's just really, really desperate to believe it is. So he's making various ad hoc "Rationalizations" to try and save his beliefs instead of admitting he might be wrong. Or maybe he was lying from the start, and nothing happened, but I don't see anything that precludes something non-paranormal having happened to him.

Yes, but I'm under the impression that Deranged (the OP) is a she. I could be mistaken and if I am mistaken I'm quite sorry if my mistake offended.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom