Alcoholism, are there varying degrees?

Well, from my perspective, the definition of an alcoholic is someone who goes to meetings.

I have a kind and loving relationship with booze. I genuinely like the taste of beer & wine (and consider myself a bit of a wine snob). I'm really not a huge fan of spirits - I could have a mixed drink, or not. Maybe a cognac after an especially nice meal. But I definitely am not the type of person to open a bottle of whisky and drink it 'til its gone.

I probably have a drink or two on most days. Usually after work / with dinner. Generally a couple of beers, or a couple of glasses of wine. Some days, I feel like having more, so I do. Some days, I have none.

At parties, I do indulge, and can easily be swept away and get more than slightly inebriated. However, I do not:

- Drive drunk (I may have once or twice in my youth and gotten away with it, but am very conscious about minding my p's and q's now)
- Get violent when drinking (I ONCE was in a fight that I would describe as alcohol induced. I've been drinking for 25 years, so I hardly think that was a pattern established)

Now - I've been cautioned that I have a 'fatty' liver, which is I gather, a pre-cirrhotic condition, brought on both by diet and booze. I have curtailed my drinking accordingly, without experiencing withdrawal symptoms. I would rather be able to continue to have a healthy relationship with booze rather than be forced to go cold turkey because my liver becomes pate.

So - by some people's definition, maybe I am an alcoholic. Presumably some sort of low-grade 'not stuck on the street and completely dysfunctional homeless person' boozehound.

By my definition, since I a) have control over my situation and b) am able to control my intake through willpower / common sense, I'm not an alcoholic - I'm just a drinker.

You don't sound like an alcoholic to me, in fact I want to be you. :D
 
Of course. How can you possibly have a discussion about drinking causing problems without first defining what a problem actually is? I already gave one example where two people can have similar behaviour with similar effects on their lives, but where only one would generally be said to have a problem. Or look at Mark6's example of Russia, where behaviour that would be considered a serious problem drinking in many places is perfectly normal and actually expected.

sigh...if your drinking is causing you problems. You know what's a problem behavior in your own life, generally, and what's not. You may be in denial about it, but still, you are, in your "heart-of-hearts," perfectly aware of what's a problem for you and what's not.

I can give examples of what might, in general, constitute a problem, but in the final analysis, "problems" are individualized. Yes, it's my opinion that "needing" a drink, as opposed to wanting one, is a problem. That's my view.

So if Russian behaviors and cultural norms cause no problems, why would a drinker be labeled alcoholic? Perhaps there's a possibility that Russian norms are still problematic, but that one's culture is enabling?
 
sigh...if your drinking is causing you problems. You know what's a problem behavior in your own life, generally, and what's not. You may be in denial about it, but still, you are, in your "heart-of-hearts," perfectly aware of what's a problem for you and what's not.

I can give examples of what might, in general, constitute a problem, but in the final analysis, "problems" are individualized. Yes, it's my opinion that "needing" a drink, as opposed to wanting one, is a problem. That's my view.

So if Russian behaviors and cultural norms cause no problems, why would a drinker be labeled alcoholic? Perhaps there's a possibility that Russian norms are still problematic, but that one's culture is enabling?

Maybe acceptance of alcohol in a given culture is a factor, it causes few problems in France and the Med where its used as a beverage as opposed to a drug. Alcohol is one of the first things people generally think of in stereotyping Russian and other Eastern European people, ditto the Irish and Scots, in fact alcoholism is sometimes called the celtic curse. Maybe there is a genetic link in those groups ? Someone already mentioned the same for Native Americans.
 
A rehab counselor mentioned that the incidence of alcoholism in specific cultures is a function of how long that culture has had alcohol readily available.

The med area has had it for several millenia, ergo today, few alcoholics. The corollary is that alcohol abuse shortens lifespans, often at an early age with fights and accidents, and as an inheritable trait tends to get suppressed.

Amerinds and more recently inuits are at the other end of the scale.

Perhaps someone has more recent data where science has studied and proved (or disproved) the proposal.
 
I attended group therapy and personal counselling where "indentifying triggers" was taught and we were told if we learned everything about them we could combat our drinking. Didn't work for me, maybe it does for others.

Just one tool on a raft of many. If it helps someone fantastic, but different things set off the lightbulbs for different people.

In the relapse prevention models those are the times that you focus your plan on, how to cope without using.

:)

Yep. Self awareness is one of the keys to changing behaviour.

sigh...if your drinking is causing you problems. You know what's a problem behavior in your own life, generally, and what's not. You may be in denial about it, but still, you are, in your "heart-of-hearts," perfectly aware of what's a problem for you and what's not.

Not always. Denial is a huge factor for alcoholics and addicts and they can run with this for years.

A rehab counselor mentioned that the incidence of alcoholism in specific cultures is a function of how long that culture has had alcohol readily available.

The med area has had it for several millenia, ergo today, few alcoholics. The corollary is that alcohol abuse shortens lifespans, often at an early age with fights and accidents, and as an inheritable trait tends to get suppressed.

Amerinds and more recently inuits are at the other end of the scale.

Perhaps someone has more recent data where science has studied and proved (or disproved) the proposal.

Interesting.
As a bloke from an Irish background I always figured that because the water was undrinkable in times past, the circumstances were perfect for the alcoholic to breed and prosper. Who else but an alcoholic could survive on ale and spiced wine seven days a week 52 weeks per year. Does natural selection play a part.

Tis just a thought.
 
I'm sorry I shouldn't be using quantity to describe different forms of drinking. What I meant to describe was someone who could get adequately inebriated to enjoy the drug and then stop at the appropraite time before he was completely drunk.

But of course such people exist. Me, for example, along with the vast majority of people I know. The reason alcoholism exists as a concept is precisely because the majority of people don't have a problem with alcohol. For most people it's not a choice between having almost nothing or getting completely wasted. People often choose not to show restraint because there's usually little reason to do so, but given a situation where some restraint is necessary most people are entirely capable of doing so.

I suspect the problem you're really getting at is not whether such people exist at all, but rather whether a person who has previously been a problem drinker can later be such a person or whether they will always have to choose between having nothing or falling back into alcoholism. That I really can't answer. I assume such people must exist, but I certainly wouldn't recommend anyone assume it's true for themselves.
 
Not always. Denial is a huge factor for alcoholics and addicts and they can run with this for years.

Alfie, no one else decides for you what's a problem and what's not.
"Denial" means you won't or can't admit your problems. Not that you haven't any.
 
But of course such people exist. Me, for example, along with the vast majority of people I know. The reason alcoholism exists as a concept is precisely because the majority of people don't have a problem with alcohol. For most people it's not a choice between having almost nothing or getting completely wasted. People often choose not to show restraint because there's usually little reason to do so, but given a situation where some restraint is necessary most people are entirely capable of doing so.

I suspect the problem you're really getting at is not whether such people exist at all, but rather whether a person who has previously been a problem drinker can later be such a person or whether they will always have to choose between having nothing or falling back into alcoholism. That I really can't answer. I assume such people must exist, but I certainly wouldn't recommend anyone assume it's true for themselves.

I guess our social groups were completely different then. My experience almost always included drinkers form both ends of the spectrum, there wasn't much middle ground.
 
I guess our social groups were completely different then. My experience almost always included drinkers form both ends of the spectrum, there wasn't much middle ground.

Interesting, since I also know only a few people from the far ends of the spectrum. Most people I know can have a drink or two and leave it at that.
 
Alfie, no one else decides for you what's a problem and what's not.
"Denial" means you won't or can't admit your problems. Not that you haven't any.

I agree with this. Denial can be "can't" or "won't".
If I misunderstood you earlier I apologise, I read it as you saying denial is "won't" only.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom