Alcoholism, are there varying degrees?

The definition I've always used, and which I actually learned while my ex was in AA and I in Al-Anon, was this:

If your drinking is causing problems in your life and relationships, and you are unable or unwilling to stop, you are probably alcoholic.
I think this definition is pretty good, as long as one is aware it is context-dependent. Two people A and B drink exact same amounts, but A lives in environment tolerant of intoxication, and B does not. As a result, A has no problems in his life and relationships, and B does. The only thing different about A and B are people around them, but it makes B alcoholic and A not.
 
If by "tolerant," you mean your society as a whole is willing to overlook spouse abuse (mental, verbal, emotional, and/or physical), spotty job history or performance, physical illness such as liver disease; drunk driving arrests; jail time; and so forth, you might have a point.

I guess now one must define, exactly, what constitutes a "problem?" :rolleyes:
 
In my experience, what in US is considered an alcoholic (cannot get through the day without a few drinks), in Russia is a perfectly normal functional adult.

What in Russia is considered an alcoholic, in US is considered a lost cause.
 
If by "tolerant," you mean your society as a whole is willing to overlook spouse abuse (mental, verbal, emotional, and/or physical), spotty job history or performance, physical illness such as liver disease; drunk driving arrests; jail time; and so forth, you might have a point.

Not everyone who is an alcoholic will have a history of all of these. And in a society that simply tolerates drinking much more than another, alcoholism is simply far less likely to lead to some of these problems.

e.g. someone's job history is not going to be very spotty if people simply don't get fired just because they had a drink during work hours or came to work drunk or hungover.

I guess now one must define, exactly, what constitutes a "problem?" :rolleyes:

Yes. Needing a drink during work hours may be a problem or not depending on culture.
 
Not everyone who is an alcoholic will have a history of all of these.

I didn't say that. Those are just some of the problems that alcoholism can cause. Was I supposed to make an exhaustive list of every potential problem?



And in a society that simply tolerates drinking much more than another, alcoholism is simply far less likely to lead to some of these problems.

For argument's sake, then, what does make it alcoholism?

Here; is this what you want?

http://alcoholism.about.com/od/about/a/types.htm

Types of Alcoholics

The NIAAA researchers defined five subtypes of alcoholics by the following specific characteristics. They also listed the percentage of each type that composes the total number of U.S. alcoholics: [continued at above link]


Yes. Needing a drink during work hours may be a problem or not depending on culture.

The problem is NEEDING a drink during work hours. Culture be damned, that is a problem behavior in and of itself.
 
The problem is NEEDING a drink during work hours. Culture be damned, that is a problem behavior in and of itself.
NEEDING a drink I'd say is the full diagnosis: you, sir or madam, are an alcoholic, irrespective of cultural mores.

As to the 5 way split you cited, note that alcoholic=alcoholic=etc.
 
Last edited:
Right, but regardless of amount, did they have problems as a result of drinking, and continued anyway? If the only problem arising from their over-indulgence was that it affected their health--as it would--and they wouldn't or felt they couldn't stop, that's alcoholism, IMO.

When you continue any behavior in spite of negative impact from it, then it's a problem behavior.

If preferred, one could label them as "problem drinkers." Is that the same as being alcoholic? I dunno.




Agree. I've always heard it isn't physically addictive. The body and brain show no withdrawal signs when marijuana intake is ceased. But one can develop a psychological dependence on it.
Got a dead friend (if you're an SF fan, especially South/Mid-east it's K>M>) and this is around 2nd Anniversary of that. Alcohol, marijuana and the job retirement took him. Couldn't handle the combo + no con to run. A good but flawed guy (as are most of us).
 
The normal drinkers are people who have a one or two drinks and stop, they could really care less about alcohol and if it were removed from the planet forever wouldn't miss it all.

This is a problematic definition for basically the reasons Cuddles points out below. There are lots of things in life that people enjoy and would miss if they no longer existed; that hardly makes them addicted to those things.

Then there are the problem drinkers, people who once they start drinking don't want to stop. They have 8 drinks and want 8 more. If you held a party and told them it was alcohol free they probably wouldn't attend.

Probably an oversimplification but hopefully you'll get what I mean.

Definitely an oversimplification. Among other things, you're leaving out the people who have more than "one or two" drinks but less than eight, or the ones who have eight but don't want eight more.

I don't like labelling my clients and avoid doing so in most instances. That said, I do have a bit of a grading scale that I use for my own purposes when considering a treatment program with and for the client. This is by no means meant to be comprehensive, but I rank them a biit like this:

Alcoholic - total dependance, huge problems, inability to stop.
Problem drinkers - can stop, but have problems when they do drink
Heavy drinkers - no major problems, and have the potential to drink as much as the above two categories.
I have no name for this category but it's people like (say) my sister. Gets pretty pissed about twice a year, drinks safely the rest of the time.
Social drinkers - drink safely.
Tea total

Is is possible for people to move up or down the scale in some instances.

This is better, though I disagree with the implication that "drink safely" is inconsistent with "pretty pissed."

Again, this is a huge simplification. There are a lot of what you term normal drinkers who still enjoy alcohol quite a bit and would miss it if it were gone (I'd go so far as to say that applies to the vast majority of social drinkers). There's a wide continuum between being addicted to something and not caring at all if you can never have it again. Similarly, just because someone is an alcoholic does not mean alcohol is all they ever care about. Maybe they'd actually prefer an alcohol-free party because then they could enjoy the party itself rather than being tempted by their addiction.

It's just not as simple a situation as you seem to want to make it. Not only is there a continuum that happens to have one end labelled "alcoholic", it's not at all easy to point at where a person lies on it.

Excellent points.

For example, if you go with Slingblade's definition which, similar to medical definitions for many mental illnesses, emphasises actually causing problems with your life, that means that two different people with identical behaviour could be classified differently. A millionaire playboy who drinks himself stupid every night may not cause himself any problems at all, while an office worker working 9-5 and looking after a family probably will. Is one an alcoholic and one not, even though the only difference is external circumstance?

That doesn't strike me as problematic at all. (I mean, the idea that two people can have identical intake levels but be classified differently.)
 
I think this definition is pretty good, as long as one is aware it is context-dependent. Two people A and B drink exact same amounts, but A lives in environment tolerant of intoxication, and B does not. As a result, A has no problems in his life and relationships, and B does. The only thing different about A and B are people around them, but it makes B alcoholic and A not.

This is what I was talking about concerning my father's drinking. If you ask my mother, he has a problem, if you ask him he does not.

What led me to the rooms of A.A was the disgust I felt at letting my family down and putting them in financial distress once again. I wonder if I didn't have a wife and kids, would I have continued drinking.
 
I think this definition is pretty good, as long as one is aware it is context-dependent. Two people A and B drink exact same amounts, but A lives in environment tolerant of intoxication, and B does not. As a result, A has no problems in his life and relationships, and B does. The only thing different about A and B are people around them, but it makes B alcoholic and A not.

Hmmm,
I don't know usually when alcohol causes problems at work it is because people miss work or can not preform, or come in very drunk.

Now relationships it is a little less clear cut but usually not making dates, taking responsibility to be where needed, acting appropriately, lost weekends, blowing paychecks and the like are why people end relationships with someone using alcohol.

So if an individual has a relationship with someone who does not mind them never being where they agree to be, not doing the things they say they will do (like pay bills), getting into strange situations in social settings (like always fighting), spending the whole weekend in a stupor and never paying their share of the bills, I would say this:

that 'tolerant' individual has a :
higher tolerance for chaos than most
does not have very good boundaries
does not mind being homeless or being hounded by creditors
does not mind loosing their friends

I would say that goes past 'tolerance'.

:)
 
NEEDING a drink I'd say is the full diagnosis: you, sir or madam, are an alcoholic, irrespective of cultural mores.

As to the 5 way split you cited, note that alcoholic=alcoholic=etc.

I go with that:
-needing a drug to cope with everyday life
-needing a drug to socialize

and the clincher

-your primary relationship is with your substance
 
As someone who now abstains, I would say that I was a problem drinker but not a full blown alcoholic. My only problem was picking up the bottle in the first place, when I did drink I gave it 110 % so to speak, I'm lucky to be alive. I could drink constantly and not eat until I passed out and vomited whilst asleep on a few occasions, luckily I always seemed to pass out in the recovery position. When I came round I would stay sober for a week or so then repeat it. In the old days I believe it was called dipsomania. Other members of my family and social circle I would have called alcoholics, they would drink for more sustained periods than me but not necessarily to the same degree of intoxication. Its a grey area.
 
This is a problematic definition for basically the reasons Cuddles points out below. There are lots of things in life that people enjoy and would miss if they no longer existed; that hardly makes them addicted to those things.



Definitely an oversimplification. Among other things, you're leaving out the people who have more than "one or two" drinks but less than eight, or the ones who have eight but don't want eight more.

Yes I definitely should've explained myself better.

I think part of the problem lies is my personal bias, which is partly why I created this thread.

In my many drinking experiences with others there didn't seem to be much middle ground (those 8 drink people who didn't want more). It was either the party hearty all night long crowd or have a few drinks (or none) and be home before midnight folks. The former usually poking fun at the latter as they left.

I'm much happier being part of the last group, though for many years I believed the other group was the end all and be all of life.
 
As someone who now abstains, I would say that I was a problem drinker but not a full blown alcoholic. My only problem was picking up the bottle in the first place, when I did drink I gave it 110 % so to speak, I'm lucky to be alive. I could drink constantly and not eat until I passed out and vomited whilst asleep on a few occasions, luckily I always seemed to pass out in the recovery position. When I came round I would stay sober for a week or so then repeat it. In the old days I believe it was called dipsomania. Other members of my family and social circle I would have called alcoholics, they would drink for more sustained periods than me but not necessarily to the same degree of intoxication. Its a grey area.
Sorry, but that is a rather typical pattern that most imo would classify as alcoholism.
 
Hmmm,
I don't know usually when alcohol causes problems at work it is because people miss work or can not preform, or come in very drunk.

Now relationships it is a little less clear cut but usually not making dates, taking responsibility to be where needed, acting appropriately, lost weekends, blowing paychecks and the like are why people end relationships with someone using alcohol.

So if an individual has a relationship with someone who does not mind them never being where they agree to be, not doing the things they say they will do (like pay bills), getting into strange situations in social settings (like always fighting), spending the whole weekend in a stupor and never paying their share of the bills, I would say this:

that 'tolerant' individual has a :
higher tolerance for chaos than most
does not have very good boundaries
does not mind being homeless or being hounded by creditors
does not mind loosing their friends

I would say that goes past 'tolerance'.

:)

I go with that:
-needing a drug to cope with everyday life
-needing a drug to socialize

and the clincher

-your primary relationship is with your substance

Agreed 100%, much of that describes my former situation, but what if a person was single, with little or no responsibilities?
 
As someone who now abstains, I would say that I was a problem drinker but not a full blown alcoholic. My only problem was picking up the bottle in the first place, when I did drink I gave it 110 % so to speak, I'm lucky to be alive. I could drink constantly and not eat until I passed out and vomited whilst asleep on a few occasions, luckily I always seemed to pass out in the recovery position. When I came round I would stay sober for a week or so then repeat it. In the old days I believe it was called dipsomania. Other members of my family and social circle I would have called alcoholics, they would drink for more sustained periods than me but not necessarily to the same degree of intoxication. Its a grey area.

I'm glad you're okay now, did you find it difficult to quit?
 
I go with that:
-needing a drug to cope with everyday life
-needing a drug to socialize

and the clincher

-your primary relationship is with your substance
I'd agree that's an NA description, and an addiction.

For most alcoholics (not skid-row denizens) not being classical "addicts":
-wanting alcohol to cope with everyday life
-needing alcohol to socialize

-the primary relationship is with your substance, alcohol

We appear to both be well aware of NA attendees vs AA attendees.

ymmv.
 
Agreed 100%, much of that describes my former situation, but what if a person was single, with little or no responsibilities?

Well I am a libertarian when it comes to social services, so it is up to the individual, if they don't care then they don't care.

If they don't want help then they won't get it, but the collateral damage can be severe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom