Alcoholism, are there varying degrees?

I'm not sure if they are varying degrees of alcoholism, you're either an alcoholic or you're not. I'm most likely wrong about this, but thought the discussion might be interesting and hope to learn a lot from it.

It is really hard to say, there is first of all the difference between abuse and dependence.

There are those who have problems with alcohol, they loose a job, get a DUI or a relationship, but when confronted with the negative consequences, they adjust their patterns of use. These are the ones that are in the 'abuse' category.

themn there are those who when confronted with repeated negative consequences of their use, continue to use. Those are usually more likely the 'dependant' people, those who are addicts.

Now i have a friend, he meets the criteria for a type II alcoholic : family history, early high tolerance for alcohol, high tolerance for alcohol in general, alcohol as coping. he has definitely walked the line for years, he has had heavy use (for extended periods), and some strong negative consequences. But by and large his use has come under control after the consequences and he now uses without getting into the addictions space. But there are times he would have met the criterai for addiction.

So he beats the standard line of 'once an addict always an addict', I mention him only to say that the level of impact on functioning is the definition of addiction.

So there is huge variation in the expression of the traits. And it is really the impact on relationships, self care and work that make someone an addict.
 
Agree. I've always heard it isn't physically addictive. The body and brain show no withdrawal signs when marijuana intake is ceased. But one can develop a psychological dependence on it.


:) Beating my drum.

Physical withdrawal is not a criteria for addiction, it is a behavioral disorder.


:)
 
Either you're overweight or you're not. Either you're tall or you're not. Either you're rich or you're not. Just because the broad categories exist does not mean there is no variation within them. Someone who weighs 20 stone is overweight, but they're nowhere near as overweight as someone who weighs 40 stone. Someone 6'5" is tall, but not as tall as someone who is 7'. A millionaire is not as rich as a billionaire. Similarly, just because you're an alcoholic does not mean all alcoholics must be the same.

So of course there are varying degrees. Some alcoholics can have few problems resulting from their condition, while others end up ruining their entire lives. Just because they can all be described as alcoholics does not mean they have exactly the same problems or need exactly the same help.



Again, this is a huge simplification. There are a lot of what you term normal drinkers who still enjoy alcohol quite a bit and would miss it if it were gone (I'd go so far as to say that applies to the vast majority of social drinkers). There's a wide continuum between being addicted to something and not caring at all if you can never have it again. Similarly, just because someone is an alcoholic does not mean alcohol is all they ever care about. Maybe they'd actually prefer an alcohol-free party because then they could enjoy the party itself rather than being tempted by their addiction.

It's just not as simple a situation as you seem to want to make it. Not only is there a continuum that happens to have one end labelled "alcoholic", it's not at all easy to point at where a person lies on it. For example, if you go with Slingblade's definition which, similar to medical definitions for many mental illnesses, emphasises actually causing problems with your life, that means that two different people with identical behaviour could be classified differently. A millionaire playboy who drinks himself stupid every night may not cause himself any problems at all, while an office worker working 9-5 and looking after a family probably will. Is one an alcoholic and one not, even though the only difference is external circumstance?

It's like asking if there are varying degrees of cancer. Sure, any given person either has cancer or they don't, but there are huge differences between different cancers, different stages in cancer, different peoples' ability to cope physically and mentally, different responses to treatment, and so on.

Thanks Cuddles, you're right I oversimplified the two categories.

I think what I'm trying to get at is in all my years of drinking (and yes they're anecdotes, but thousands of them) I don't recall there ever being a person who had for example 8 drinks/night, three times a week.

It was either, a person had a couple and was home by a reasonable hour or they were with me closing down the drinking establishment and quite often we continued to drink elsewhere.

I know many people who fit the first description (my wife and mother being two of them), who once they started to feel the effects of alcohol would halt their consumption for the day. I tried several times to get my wife to have more than a few drinks thinking if she would just drink more, she wouldn't be able to complain about my intake or notice it. Never worked, she just wouldn't drink more than one or two and to my amazement would leave the second drink half finished. As I said I've seen others do the same.

I've been with the latter category too (drinking buddies or acquaintances).

These like to drink, have fun?, drink to the point of intoxication sometimes severely and do it a few times a week if not more.
Go golfing and get drunk, weddings drunk, relative graduation drunk, Christmas, Halloween, Thanksgiving and other holidays drunk.

I'm just wondering if there's a happy medium somewhere. I know whenever I drank it was to get drunk, I wouldn't dream of stopping after 6, 9 or 15 drinks. Even thinking about doing that now is painful, like having a large bandage ripped off.

I've often wondered if my father was an alcoholic or was just a regular drinker.

Whenever he drank he would get drunk, but at the peak of his "drinking career" between the ages of 20-50 he would normally only drink once per week usually during the weekend, never missed work and the only problems that arose from his alcohol consumption seemed to be my mothers distaste for it.
If my mother happened to be elsewhere during his drinking I don't think they would've any problems, aside from the fact he often missed visits to my grandparents the next day due to a hangover and I as a kid I really enjoyed those visits. :)
 
The subject of alcohol is a difficult one I think. In a country/culture where substance abuse is pretty much a given and acceptable social behaviour, then the lines can get blurred. I have drank, and continue to do so despite trying to stop multiple times. I wouldn't class myself as an alcoholic purely because the reason I can't stop isn't necesserily addiction. If I woke up and drank, or drank every day and couldn't stop myself that would (in my opinion) make me an alcholic. Whether I have a drink problem is a different question; when i do drink i drink too much. way too much sometimes. And I often do it when I don't plan to. But it doesn't affect my life, doesn't affect my health (too much), and hasn't as yet caused any other serious problems.

I do think it is somewhat of a problem and would like to slow down with it as I'm getting older. Anything you can't stop doing, you probably should for a while to at least make sure you can! I find though that drinking is so engrained in my life, and all my friend's lives that it is difficult just to quit. I wouldn't class that as addiction, but I would class it as alcoholism. I think the "ism" is important as it separates cultural/social/personal choice based behaviour from addictive.

Maybe if the health concerns were more of a question I would try harder.

It is really hard to say, there is first of all the difference between abuse and dependence.

There are those who have problems with alcohol, they loose a job, get a DUI or a relationship, but when confronted with the negative consequences, they adjust their patterns of use. These are the ones that are in the 'abuse' category.

themn there are those who when confronted with repeated negative consequences of their use, continue to use. Those are usually more likely the 'dependant' people, those who are addicts.

Now i have a friend, he meets the criteria for a type II alcoholic : family history, early high tolerance for alcohol, high tolerance for alcohol in general, alcohol as coping. he has definitely walked the line for years, he has had heavy use (for extended periods), and some strong negative consequences. But by and large his use has come under control after the consequences and he now uses without getting into the addictions space. But there are times he would have met the criterai for addiction.

So he beats the standard line of 'once an addict always an addict', I mention him only to say that the level of impact on functioning is the definition of addiction.

So there is huge variation in the expression of the traits. And it is really the impact on relationships, self care and work that make someone an addict.

I see myself in those posts. I've often rationalized to myself over the years that I'm not an alcoholic because I don't drink everyday. In fact I've never understood how people could. I was always so sick the next day or two that the even the thought of drinking repulsed me. Yet a few days later when I started to feel better, drinking seemed like a good idea again.

I managed to quit twice in my years of drinking for 30 days each time thinking I needed a "break", but I always went back to drinking because I missed it. When I first landed in A.A. I pondered the notion I couldn't ever drink again and it brought me to tears.

I can say my life is much better now that I don't drink but I miss it sometimes.

Actually I'm not sure if I miss the drinking or the romantic delusions I've built into it over the years.
 
:) Beating my drum.

Physical withdrawal is not a criteria for addiction, it is a behavioral disorder.


:)

Okay, but can it be modified.

I don't think I could ever learn to drink "normally" and am curious if it's possible for heavy drinkers with serious problems to drink in a reasonable fashion.

I've always believed it to be a physical problem, kinda like you can't be half-pregnant. You either have the gene or you don't.
 
Like everything else in life, alcoholism is just a word that describes a broad spectrum of human behaviors:

You can be dependent on alcohol but otherwise healthy and high-fuctioning with few problems other than the slow damage you are doing to your liver.

You can NOT be dependent on alcohol but engage in occasional binge drinking episodes where you end up with DUIs, losing your job, cheating on your spouse, etc.

Which of those is the alcoholic?

There is even more variety.

I do occasionally drink too much, and get to spend the next day hung over and, rarely, the night running between the bed and the toilet.

I don't drink and drive. (Almost, I will have a sip of a shot or one small beer - well within the legal limits.)

I don't get drunk before work days (Again, almost. Exceptions are either work related of the "going out with customers"-type or of the "maybe once or twice per year"-variety.

It's certainly not "good", but it is not what I'D call problematic. I would miss alcohol if it were just to disappear but then that's only because I drink whiskey. (Good one. Maybe a glass per week or so. Sometimes less, rarely more. The Whiskey I drink is far too expensive and far too good to get drunk on.)

What does that make me?
 
Words are tools, not straitjackets.
I can be sober today and drunk tomorrow- that makes me a person who drinks on average, but I'm neither a drunk nor a teetotaller on either day, because those are long term labels.
If someone has problems - or creates problems for others- due to drinking more than he can cope with, or afford- then there is a behavioural problem. If treating his behaviour as a symptom of an illness helps him fix it, fine. If smacking him upside the head works- fine. Generally, the difficulty is lack of willingness to admit and face the problem. If being unwilling to face a problem is genetic, so be it, but I'm sceptical that most drunks are drunks for genetic reasons any more than any other complicated human behaviour is genetic. There's probably a genetic factor - but social stresses are probably far more significant in most cases.
 
It's certainly not "good", but it is not what I'D call problematic.
[...]

What does that make me?

Any label is obviously going to be quibbled with, so why even ask?

What do YOU say it makes you?

The common answer is that you are a "social drinker." This is generally taken to mean that you use alcohol casually and in social situations, and do not have a long-term behavioral problem with it that needs your attention.

Asking for specific labels for each person's individual experience is just a waste of time, since no one can agree.
 
Any label is obviously going to be quibbled with, so why even ask?

It was more of a rhetorical question, really. The point was that I think there are at the very least degrees of alcoholism. (Unless you wanted to define it to just match a very particualr point on the spectrum of alcohol use.)

What do YOU say it makes you?

I don't care, as such. (We can discuss it, because it is interesting, and if the case study helps in the discussion I certainly don't mind.)

The common answer is that you are a "social drinker." This is generally taken to mean that you use alcohol casually and in social situations, and do not have a long-term behavioral problem with it that needs your attention.

Not right now it doesn't. My usage fluctuates - I am not sure if i ever conciously had to reduce it, but it somehow always ended up less before it could be too much.



Asking for specific labels for each person's individual experience is just a waste of time, since no one can agree.

Very true. (Well, if my behavior makes me an alcoholic then I can easily live with being an alcoholic, I guess. An alcoholic after that definition is not all bad, is it?)
 
My brother has been clean and sober for about twenty years and has the following definition of an alcoholic:

"Someone who has no damn business drinking."
 
I see myself in those posts. I've often rationalized to myself over the years that I'm not an alcoholic because I don't drink everyday. In fact I've never understood how people could.

I drink most days, but rarely do I even get so much as a buzz. I've only drunk to the point of sickness or hangover a handful of times in my life. Different people react differently, and I think there are both biological and social components in play.
 
I don't ascribe to the varying degrees theory. There are alcoholics who handle drinking, the persons they are with and how they treat them (are family members making trips to the emergency room for 'falling in the tub' and 'walking into doors'?), the places they go (would you be there sober?), and things (too much breakage follow you around?) better than others and may do so for long periods of time. When you reach the DUI's and jails parts I think you know the answer for sure, but most know it long before that.

I'd also say a non-alcoholic never asks himself the question "Am I an alcoholic?". No one else can answer it for any alcoholic.
 
What I was trying to get at is that I think Alcoholism is about control. Can you control your relationship with alcohol? For example, I have a family member who has been arrested for DUI, lost his job and squandered his relationships because he can't control his alcohol intake. I have another friend who crashed his car after a night of drunkenness and has never touched a drop again while he is responsible for driving home. It's about ability to control, not amount. Dependence is a separate issue entirely.
 
What I was trying to get at is that I think Alcoholism is about control. Can you control your relationship with alcohol? For example, I have a family member who has been arrested for DUI, lost his job and squandered his relationships because he can't control his alcohol intake. I have another friend who crashed his car after a night of drunkenness and has never touched a drop again while he is responsible for driving home. It's about ability to control, not amount. Dependence is a separate issue entirely.

No, it's not. It's that dependence that keeps some people unable to exert their control consistently or long-term. Part and parcel of some people's struggle, I'm afraid.
 
No, it's not. It's that dependence that keeps some people unable to exert their control consistently or long-term. Part and parcel of some people's struggle, I'm afraid.

I think it's a complicating factor for sure, but not the actual problem itself. Dependence is simply a physical condition that develops after long-term use of alcohol. Dependence can be fixed by stopping the use for a long enough period of time. But how many people have kicked the physical dependence and then regressed? It's quite common. So what gets them started in the first place? It's those genetic/personality factors that predispose people to alcoholism (and every other addiction for that matter).
 
Okay, but can it be modified.

I don't think I could ever learn to drink "normally" and am curious if it's possible for heavy drinkers with serious problems to drink in a reasonable fashion.

I've always believed it to be a physical problem, kinda like you can't be half-pregnant. You either have the gene or you don't.

I personally believe that with my issues it is best to never expose myself to my drug of choice. I don't want to know.

The genes may also not be specific for addiction, I also have major depression with OCD, my addiction to serotonergic hallucinogens may have been partly related. My secondary addictions don't have a glamour for me, I can smoke mj if I want and not crave it later, I don't like the after effects. I can use pseudoephedrine in small doses, but it still makes me crazy.

But no more hallucinogens for me.
 
Last edited:
I think it's a complicating factor for sure, but not the actual problem itself. Dependence is simply a physical condition that develops after long-term use of alcohol. Dependence can be fixed by stopping the use for a long enough period of time. But how many people have kicked the physical dependence and then regressed? It's quite common. So what gets them started in the first place? It's those genetic/personality factors that predispose people to alcoholism (and every other addiction for that matter).

Um not under the definition used in the DSM or the ICD, dependence is a cluster of behaviors that may or may not involve physical withdrawal syndromes.

:)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom