Alcoholism, are there varying degrees?

ProBonoShill

Master Poster
Joined
May 17, 2010
Messages
2,329
As a person who started drinking at the age of fourteen, became a heavy drinker two years later and continued this practice until a few years ago I've always held the notion that you're either a problem drinker or a normal drinker/abstainer.

I'll explain what I mean.

The normal drinkers are people who have a one or two drinks and stop, they could really care less about alcohol and if it were removed from the planet forever wouldn't miss it all.

Then there are the problem drinkers, people who once they start drinking don't want to stop. They have 8 drinks and want 8 more. If you held a party and told them it was alcohol free they probably wouldn't attend.

Probably an oversimplification but hopefully you'll get what I mean.

I'm not sure if they are varying degrees of alcoholism, you're either an alcoholic or you're not. I'm most likely wrong about this, but thought the discussion might be interesting and hope to learn a lot from it.
 
The definition I've always used, and which I actually learned while my ex was in AA and I in Al-Anon, was this:

If your drinking is causing problems in your life and relationships, and you are unable or unwilling to stop, you are probably alcoholic.

Amount, type and frequency don't matter as much as "causes you problems, but you keep drinking anyway."


Surely you know folks, or have heard of folks, who smoke a joint once in a while, and no problems result from it.
Are they addicted?
 
Last edited:
The definition I've always used, and which I actually learned while my ex was in AA and I in Al-Anon, was this:

If your drinking is causing problems in your life and relationships, and you are unable or unwilling to stop, you are probably alcoholic.

Amount, type and frequency don't matter as much as "causes you problems, but you keep drinking anyway."


Surely you know folks, or have heard of folks, who smoke a joint once in a while, and no problems result from it.
Are they addicted?

That's an interesting definition, I like it, but I know people who drink far above recommended levels who don't appear to have any glaring problems.



For example most people I drank with, consumed far above the levels stated here:

http://healthland.time.com/2009/08/20/when-does-social-drinking-become-at-risk-drinking/


The broad strokes about alcohol consumption, Willenbring says, are fairly simple. Low risk drinking, "according to the NIAAA, for men, is no more than four drinks in one day, and no more than 14 drinks in a week." For women, he says, "it's no more than three drinks in any day and no more than seven drinks in any week."

Those figures may seem to contradict recommendations made by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, which call for no more than one drink per day for women, and no more than two drinks per day for men, but Willenbring says it's just that the other guidelines present the number of drinks as a daily average, as opposed to offering two sets of guidelines—by both day and week. "It's important that both the daily and the weekly limits be considered, because, for example, if a man has four drinks in one day, or has four drinks every day then he's going to violate the weekly [total for low risk drinking]."


As for those smoking the "chronic" I know many :)

No I wouldn't say they are addicted, in fact I'm not sure if marijuana use can become addictive. Maybe psychologically but not physically like alcohol, though once again, I could be mistaken.
 
We evolved a reward system. We evolved a tendency to seek and enjoy alerted states. We probably have thousands of psychological modules in the mind and incalculable genetic and biological factors affecting all of this.

Some people don't enjoy altered states, some people want to always be in an altered state, which doesn't have to be drugs. This is a natural variation, it doesn't have to be an illness. We have all kinds of natural variations throughout the species, it's a kind of evolutionary spectrum that leads to more ideal outcomes over time. For example, it's a good thing to have some people with low-metabolisms, in case there is an extended famine.

Lots of mammals are evolved to use mind-altering substances, like primates who rub millepede's on their back for a 30-minute high. (bbc youtube) These kind of things convey some benefit to us in the evolutionary landscape. The problem is when these tendencies run out of control. Some people have a reward system that isn't connected well with their pain avoidance system, and these are all just modules in the brain.

It's like, why everyone (else) is a hypocrite. The module you use to enact social enforcement is not the same module you use to take care of yourself, and this is just an accident of evolution. Sometimes this gets really bad and the person cannot possibly rewire their brain to manage alcohol safely so abstaining is the most intelligent choice. What I mean is that they are pickled in a way that neuroplasticity or epigenetics or whatever you imagine cannot correct for.

A good example of this is how vervet monkeys who steal booze from resorts have been shown to use and abuse alcohol in much the same rates as us! Equal amounts social drinkers, alcoholics and abstainers. Funny BBC video

Those problem drinkers can either learn to use safely or not. There is no way to diagnose a "disease of alcoholism", there are only varying degrees of problem drinkers, which is obvious when you look at the greater evolutionary picture here. How do you know if you can get it under control? Unfortunately there is no test, and "experimentation" is notoriously dangerous and unwise. I don't think people should freak out and think "I must abstain! I must have the disease!" But I don't think people should play around with it either. If you can't figure it out, you need to abstain.

So yes I think there are infinite kinds of drinkers. And I also think that these factors can change throughout your life.
 
Last edited:
That's an interesting definition, I like it, but I know people who drink far above recommended levels who don't appear to have any glaring problems.



For example most people I drank with, consumed far above the levels stated here:

http://healthland.time.com/2009/08/20/when-does-social-drinking-become-at-risk-drinking/

Right, but regardless of amount, did they have problems as a result of drinking, and continued anyway? If the only problem arising from their over-indulgence was that it affected their health--as it would--and they wouldn't or felt they couldn't stop, that's alcoholism, IMO.

When you continue any behavior in spite of negative impact from it, then it's a problem behavior.

If preferred, one could label them as "problem drinkers." Is that the same as being alcoholic? I dunno.


As for those smoking the "chronic" I know many :)

No I wouldn't say they are addicted, in fact I'm not sure if marijuana use can become addictive. Maybe psychologically but not physically like alcohol, though once again, I could be mistaken.

Agree. I've always heard it isn't physically addictive. The body and brain show no withdrawal signs when marijuana intake is ceased. But one can develop a psychological dependence on it.
 
Last edited:
The definition I've always used, and which I actually learned while my ex was in AA and I in Al-Anon, was this:

If your drinking is causing problems in your life and relationships, and you are unable or unwilling to stop, you are probably alcoholic.

Amount, type and frequency don't matter as much as "causes you problems, but you keep drinking anyway."


Surely you know folks, or have heard of folks, who smoke a joint once in a while, and no problems result from it.
Are they addicted?

I do not really like this definition. If a person eats sugar, they will weigh a bit more, plus risk tooth decay. They will know this, but keep on eating it. Does this mean they are addicted to the sugar? The benefit of eating the sugar would be an increase in pleasure, which would be greater than the problems.

When I mention sugar above, it includes everything that contains sugar. You can also include salt, as we only need a fraction of the salt we actually consume.
 
I do not really like this definition. If a person eats sugar, they will weigh a bit more, plus risk tooth decay. They will know this, but keep on eating it. Does this mean they are addicted to the sugar? The benefit of eating the sugar would be an increase in pleasure, which would be greater than the problems.

When I mention sugar above, it includes everything that contains sugar. You can also include salt, as we only need a fraction of the salt we actually consume.

If you engage in a behavior that causes you problems in your life or relationships, yet you will not or find you cannot quit or reduce this behavior to a level that reduces or eliminates said problems, you likely are engaging in an unhealthy dependency. The particular name for said dependency will vary, according to its nature.
 
What we call it seems to be a social convention.
I'd summarise the OP by saying there are drinkers and there are drunks.
Whether there's an "ism" at all is a matter of definition.
 
That's an interesting definition, I like it, but I know people who drink far above recommended levels who don't appear to have any glaring problems.

I don't like labelling my clients and avoid doing so in most instances. That said, I do have a bit of a grading scale that I use for my own purposes when considering a treatment program with and for the client. This is by no means meant to be comprehensive, but I rank them a biit like this:

Alcoholic - total dependance, huge problems, inability to stop.
Problem drinkers - can stop, but have problems when they do drink
Heavy drinkers - no major problems, and have the potential to drink as much as the above two categories.
I have no name for this category but it's people like (say) my sister. Gets pretty pissed about twice a year, drinks safely the rest of the time.
Social drinkers - drink safely.
Tea total

Is is possible for people to move up or down the scale in some instances.

No I wouldn't say they are addicted, in fact I'm not sure if marijuana use can become addictive. Maybe psychologically but not physically like alcohol, though once again, I could be mistaken.

Cannabis is most certainly addictive and can bring just as many problems for the individual as alcohol.

http://ncpic.org.au/workforce/alcoh...on/factsheets/article/cannabis-and-dependence

Agree. I've always heard it isn't physically addictive. The body and brain show no withdrawal signs when marijuana intake is ceased. But one can develop a psychological dependence on it.

Wrong: There can be very uncomfortable withdrawal symptoms. The addiction is physical as well as psychological. (same link as above).

What are the symptoms of cannabis withdrawal?

One of the most common symptoms of cannabis dependence is the experience of discomfort when ceasing use known as withdrawal. Studies with cannabis users who have recently quit report that withdrawal symptoms start on the first day, usually peak in the first two to three days, and with the exception of sleep disturbance, are usually very mild by the sixth day.

The most common symptoms include:
anxiety/nervousness
reduced appetite
irritability/restlessness
sleep difficulties including strange dream

Even though these symptoms are not life threatening, they can be distressing enough for the person trying to stop smoking cannabis, to start using again.


Very distressing.
From someone who has withdrawn independantly from each of the following, I can tell you that while withdrawal from Alcohol was difficult, Cannabis was worse and stopping cigarettes was a piece of cake by comparison.
 
Then I stand corrected. How you experienced withdrawal from each of these seems rather...unimportant, as such things affect each of us differently.

Myself, I only ever drank socially, so not drinking was just as easy as not holding my breath.
Not smoking pot was the same.
Cigarettes are impossible.
 
I'm not sure if they are varying degrees of alcoholism, you're either an alcoholic or you're not.

Either you're overweight or you're not. Either you're tall or you're not. Either you're rich or you're not. Just because the broad categories exist does not mean there is no variation within them. Someone who weighs 20 stone is overweight, but they're nowhere near as overweight as someone who weighs 40 stone. Someone 6'5" is tall, but not as tall as someone who is 7'. A millionaire is not as rich as a billionaire. Similarly, just because you're an alcoholic does not mean all alcoholics must be the same.

So of course there are varying degrees. Some alcoholics can have few problems resulting from their condition, while others end up ruining their entire lives. Just because they can all be described as alcoholics does not mean they have exactly the same problems or need exactly the same help.

The normal drinkers are people who have a one or two drinks and stop, they could really care less about alcohol and if it were removed from the planet forever wouldn't miss it all.

Then there are the problem drinkers, people who once they start drinking don't want to stop. They have 8 drinks and want 8 more. If you held a party and told them it was alcohol free they probably wouldn't attend.

Again, this is a huge simplification. There are a lot of what you term normal drinkers who still enjoy alcohol quite a bit and would miss it if it were gone (I'd go so far as to say that applies to the vast majority of social drinkers). There's a wide continuum between being addicted to something and not caring at all if you can never have it again. Similarly, just because someone is an alcoholic does not mean alcohol is all they ever care about. Maybe they'd actually prefer an alcohol-free party because then they could enjoy the party itself rather than being tempted by their addiction.

It's just not as simple a situation as you seem to want to make it. Not only is there a continuum that happens to have one end labelled "alcoholic", it's not at all easy to point at where a person lies on it. For example, if you go with Slingblade's definition which, similar to medical definitions for many mental illnesses, emphasises actually causing problems with your life, that means that two different people with identical behaviour could be classified differently. A millionaire playboy who drinks himself stupid every night may not cause himself any problems at all, while an office worker working 9-5 and looking after a family probably will. Is one an alcoholic and one not, even though the only difference is external circumstance?

It's like asking if there are varying degrees of cancer. Sure, any given person either has cancer or they don't, but there are huge differences between different cancers, different stages in cancer, different peoples' ability to cope physically and mentally, different responses to treatment, and so on.
 
I found it easy to give up cigarettes, once I had found the appropriate formula. Alcohol is proving to be a much harder nut to crack.
 
The subject of alcohol is a difficult one I think. In a country/culture where substance abuse is pretty much a given and acceptable social behaviour, then the lines can get blurred. I have drank, and continue to do so despite trying to stop multiple times. I wouldn't class myself as an alcoholic purely because the reason I can't stop isn't necesserily addiction. If I woke up and drank, or drank every day and couldn't stop myself that would (in my opinion) make me an alcholic. Whether I have a drink problem is a different question; when i do drink i drink too much. way too much sometimes. And I often do it when I don't plan to. But it doesn't affect my life, doesn't affect my health (too much), and hasn't as yet caused any other serious problems.

I do think it is somewhat of a problem and would like to slow down with it as I'm getting older. Anything you can't stop doing, you probably should for a while to at least make sure you can! I find though that drinking is so engrained in my life, and all my friend's lives that it is difficult just to quit. I wouldn't class that as addiction, but I would class it as alcoholism. I think the "ism" is important as it separates cultural/social/personal choice based behaviour from addictive.

Maybe if the health concerns were more of a question I would try harder.
 
Last edited:
Like everything else in life, alcoholism is just a word that describes a broad spectrum of human behaviors:

You can be dependent on alcohol but otherwise healthy and high-fuctioning with few problems other than the slow damage you are doing to your liver.

You can NOT be dependent on alcohol but engage in occasional binge drinking episodes where you end up with DUIs, losing your job, cheating on your spouse, etc.

Which of those is the alcoholic?
 
We evolved a reward system. We evolved a tendency to seek and enjoy alerted states. We probably have thousands of psychological modules in the mind and incalculable genetic and biological factors affecting all of this.

Some people don't enjoy altered states, some people want to always be in an altered state, which doesn't have to be drugs. This is a natural variation, it doesn't have to be an illness. We have all kinds of natural variations throughout the species, it's a kind of evolutionary spectrum that leads to more ideal outcomes over time. For example, it's a good thing to have some people with low-metabolisms, in case there is an extended famine.

Lots of mammals are evolved to use mind-altering substances, like primates who rub millepede's on their back for a 30-minute high. (bbc youtube) These kind of things convey some benefit to us in the evolutionary landscape. The problem is when these tendencies run out of control. Some people have a reward system that isn't connected well with their pain avoidance system, and these are all just modules in the brain.

It's like, why everyone (else) is a hypocrite. The module you use to enact social enforcement is not the same module you use to take care of yourself, and this is just an accident of evolution. Sometimes this gets really bad and the person cannot possibly rewire their brain to manage alcohol safely so abstaining is the most intelligent choice. What I mean is that they are pickled in a way that neuroplasticity or epigenetics or whatever you imagine cannot correct for.

A good example of this is how vervet monkeys who steal booze from resorts have been shown to use and abuse alcohol in much the same rates as us! Equal amounts social drinkers, alcoholics and abstainers. Funny BBC video

Those problem drinkers can either learn to use safely or not. There is no way to diagnose a "disease of alcoholism", there are only varying degrees of problem drinkers, which is obvious when you look at the greater evolutionary picture here. How do you know if you can get it under control? Unfortunately there is no test, and "experimentation" is notoriously dangerous and unwise. I don't think people should freak out and think "I must abstain! I must have the disease!" But I don't think people should play around with it either. If you can't figure it out, you need to abstain.

So yes I think there are infinite kinds of drinkers. And I also think that these factors can change throughout your life.

That is very interesting Joey and is what I've always suspected separates the "normal" drinker from the alcoholic. It's a physical difference in our brains.

It could also be hereditary, though I've encountered people who claim their parents and grandparents had no problems with alcohol.
 
Like everything else in life, alcoholism is just a word that describes a broad spectrum of human behaviors:

You can be dependent on alcohol but otherwise healthy and high-fuctioning with few problems other than the slow damage you are doing to your liver.

You can NOT be dependent on alcohol but engage in occasional binge drinking episodes where you end up with DUIs, losing your job, cheating on your spouse, etc.

Which of those is the alcoholic?

The one who won't quit or cut back, in spite of these problems.

No one seems to be getting that the key to it is the problems it causes combined with an unwillingness to change.

If it causes you no problems, you have no problem.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom