Alcoholism, are there varying degrees?

NEEDING a drink I'd say is the full diagnosis: you, sir or madam, are an alcoholic, irrespective of cultural mores.

As to the 5 way split you cited, note that alcoholic=alcoholic=etc.

My citing it in no way implies I agree with it. I asked if that's what's meant.
I'm waiting for the answer.

If it's simply a matter of a how much a person drinks, then how much drinking makes one an alcoholic? What kind of alcohol? Can you be a wine spritzers-only alkie? a beer-only alkie? What if you only drink once a month?

I gave my definition, and it's workable.

Where are the rest of them? I'm *********** tired of guessing what they might be.
 
I'd agree that's an NA description, and an addiction.

For most alcoholics (not skid-row denizens) not being classical "addicts":
-wanting alcohol to cope with everyday life
-needing alcohol to socialize

-the primary relationship is with your substance, alcohol

We appear to both be well aware of NA attendees vs AA attendees.

ymmv.

I think of alcoholics as addicts, but that is just me, I would rather attended an AA meeting any day over an NA meeting.

My mileage comes from working in social services for 15 years. I worked out reach mental health which is a mixed bag of substance problems, got into group therapy for my family history issues and realized I was a drug addict, went to two NA meetings and found I preferred the less drama at AA. I then got into recovery and did the usual but my mental health improved, so it stuck.

As part of my outreach case management (~9 years) I did weekly intakes and cofacillitated a relapse prevention group for MISA clients, I did a year of PSR, no intakes, I did domestic violence work for three years, actively screening and doing screenings on a daily basis. Then I was a crisis intervention person for ~1.5 years, where I did as many as 20 assessments a week (intake) and also crisis assessments and hospital interventions.

I found that those three criteria applied to people regardless of their addiction. It did not apply directly to the victims of DV but some of them were addicts as were their perps. I sure saw alot of drunk and drugged people at the ER.

But it is my own personal experience, I found some AA groups that did not mind me attending "Hello I am David, I am a drug addict", besides 5 years of group therapy I also attended Coda for a while.
 
Sorry, but that is a rather typical pattern that most imo would classify as alcoholism.

The reason I never used the alcoholic label was because I could go for long periods without a drink, with much willpower I could stop myself reaching for a bottle but I would always convince myself that I could get tipsy then stop, I eventually lost count of how much I had and blacked out. My binges would only last for a day or 2 per week but nearly killed me.

The thing was I could never understand how people liked drink and could stop. I actually hated the taste of the stuff, I used it solely for effect. For example, here we are recommended to drink no more than 3 units a day, I cannot see the point in that as people do by and large drink for some degree of inebriation, unless its for the supposed slight health benefit. By these standards almost every drinker seeking some level of intoxication, albeit probably mild (vast majority of drinkers do) would be at least a problem drinker if not an alcoholic. Yes, red wine can taste nice in cooking but other than that alcohol is a drug and I can't see why anyone would want to use it in ineffective doses just for the vile taste.
 
My citing it in no way implies I agree with it. I asked if that's what's meant.
I'm waiting for the answer.
I gave you my answer.

If it's simply a matter of a how much a person drinks, then how much drinking makes one an alcoholic?
I think we both know that isn't the criteria; it's the behaviors associated with drinking.

What kind of alcohol? Can you be a wine spritzers-only alkie?
Sure, although many ladies seemed be into cooking sherry!

a beer-only alkie?
Of course, in fact that's my drug of choice.

What if you only drink once a month?
More facts needed to assess.

I gave my definition, and it's workable.
Causes problems that don't occur when sober iirc. We agree.

Where are the rest of them? I'm *********** tired of guessing what they might be.
What more do you want? Nothing else is needed imo.
 
The reason I never used the alcoholic label was because I could go for long periods without a drink, with much willpower I could stop myself reaching for a bottle but I would always convince myself that I could get tipsy then stop, I eventually lost count of how much I had and blacked out. My binges would only last for a day or 2 per week but nearly killed me.

The thing was I could never understand how people liked drink and could stop. I actually hated the taste of the stuff, I used it solely for effect. For example, here we are recommended to drink no more than 3 units a day, I cannot see the point in that as people do by and large drink for some degree of inebriation, unless its for the supposed slight health benefit. By these standards almost every drinker seeking some level of intoxication, albeit probably mild (vast majority of drinkers do) would be at least a problem drinker if not an alcoholic. Yes, red wine can taste nice in cooking but other than that alcohol is a drug and I can't see why anyone would want to use it in ineffective doses just for the vile taste.

We have much in common and our views are pretty much the same. :)
 
My citing it in no way implies I agree with it. I asked if that's what's meant.
I'm waiting for the answer.

If it's simply a matter of a how much a person drinks, then how much drinking makes one an alcoholic? What kind of alcohol? Can you be a wine spritzers-only alkie? a beer-only alkie? What if you only drink once a month?

I gave my definition, and it's workable.

Where are the rest of them? I'm *********** tired of guessing what they might be.

I found this:

http://alcoholism.about.com/gi/o.ht...s=0&zu=http://www.ncadd.org/facts/defalc.html


"Alcoholism is a primary, chronic disease with genetic, psychosocial, and environmental factors influencing its development and manifestations. The disease is often progressive and fatal. It is characterized by continuous or periodic: impaired control over drinking, preoccupation with the drug alcohol, use of alcohol despite adverse consequences, and distortions in thinking, most notably denial."
 
Is this crackpot science and a money making scheme? She claims to be a biochemist and holistic healer:





ETA- Never mind Genita Petralli H.H.P., N.C., M.H., Medical Director and author of the book in the video is a believer in pseudo science. Her site below is full of quackery.



http://biosanctuary.com/
 
Last edited:
I found this:

http://alcoholism.about.com/gi/o.ht...s=0&zu=http://www.ncadd.org/facts/defalc.html


"Alcoholism is a primary, chronic disease with genetic, psychosocial, and environmental factors influencing its development and manifestations. The disease is often progressive and fatal. It is characterized by continuous or periodic: impaired control over drinking, preoccupation with the drug alcohol, use of alcohol despite adverse consequences, and distortions in thinking, most notably denial."

Pretty much says what I've been saying. If it causes you "adverse consequences," and it occurs over time, whether continuous or periodic, then you might be alcoholic. Nothing in what you quote negates my definition.

If you were genetically an alcoholic, but you never took a drink...would you still be an alcoholic? Yes, I know there are other factors, but the notion interested me.
 
im a functional alcoholic and i have varying degrees..

monday
teusday
wednesday
thursday
friday
saturday
sunday
 
Could you explain this part. Do you mean shyness?
No*.I mean family or workplace induced stress. Instead of dealing with it head-on (perhaps because doing so causes conflict in the family, or because he just doen't know how, a person has a glass of wine instead. We all do this. It's nicer to sit down with a glass than actually do that tax return. And so long as the return gets done in time, it doesn't matter much.
But if it doesn't get done at all, becuse the response to facing the task is the same avoidance every time, then there's a problem.
Note that alcohol is not necessary in this simple case. Simply sticking one's nose in a book is just as bad as sticking it in a bottle- the task does not get done. The specific problem with alcohol as an avoidance tool is that in each instance, it makes it very hard to change your mind- as the mind is what you just deadened. The person who picks up a novel is apt to feel pangs of conscience and worry over the neglected task. Sooner or later, he gets on with it. The drinker does not. Or does it badly if he tries.

The knowledge of failure on that occasion adds to the stress load. Next time he thinks about that task, there's an easy option in the fridge.
At that point, willpower or discipline or push from a friend or family member may be enough to get most people focussed on the job. But if that's absent, or the (perhaps spousely) "push" is itself a stressor (nagging?), some folk reach for the bottle.
If there's no bottle there, he either gets on with it, avoids it in some other way, or just gets more stressed while achieving nothing- alcohol free functional alcoholism. Not a drunk, just uselessly ineffectual, which looks (if we see alcoholism as an illness) like a different thing entirely. But functionally it isn't.
Of course there are other symptoms of alcohol abuse, such as violence, but in my experience- both of how I use alcohol myself and what I've observed in people with varying degrees of behavioural problems involving alcohol, simple stress avoidance is consistently the start- and so long as there's a social mechanism for knowing when and how to stop, that's fine. It's when no such mechanism exists that a pleasant relaxer turns into a mind blocker.
I don't at all doubt there can be a genetic component here, but I doubt it's anything to do with ability to handle drink. It concerns ability to handle life, which is a very complex issue.
Example- a young man drinks with his mates once a week. He then gets a sales job. He's on the road, staying in motels, alone. Now he drinks in the bar, alone or with strangers. The friend who would normally see he gets home is not there. He drinks too much. Next day he misses a call or shows up hungover at a meeting. I don't know whether calling him an alcoholic makes sense, but he undeniably has an alcohol related problem.
Some people- some US Native Americans for instance, genuinely do have genetic / enzyme problems metabolising ethanol and that likely does contribute towards social problems with alcohol, but most Europeans don't have such problems, The genetic ability to digest lactose and casein in adults bears comparison, I reckon.
*ETA Not shyness specifically. It could well be an example of stress and stress response.
 
Last edited:
If by "tolerant," you mean your society as a whole is willing to overlook spouse abuse (mental, verbal, emotional, and/or physical), spotty job history or performance, physical illness such as liver disease; drunk driving arrests; jail time; and so forth, you might have a point.

I guess now one must define, exactly, what constitutes a "problem?" :rolleyes:

I muck around with what I call the "four-L's of pain":

Livelihood: eg. I feed my addiction before I feed the kids, I lose jobs, become unemplyable, spend inappropriately etc.
Lovelife: eg. Spouse/partner, family, friends, colleagues, spirituality, self - the self stuff is what I call the "head frigs" (and I cleaned that up) being guilt, remorse, self loathing, etc.
Liver (health): Liver problems, pancreas, brain damage/korsakoffs, peripheral neuropathy, esophageal varices, blood disorders, mental health issues, death, PAFOs etc.
Legal: Gaol, lockups, assaults, fines, courts, Human services, divorce etc.

These things kick in a varying degrees causing various problems. What one person is prepared to accept will be different to the next.

Another anecdote.
I have clients who are quite happy to keep drinking and accept the ultimate consequence. They know they will die if they continue, yet choose to do so - I have buried many.
On the other hand, another will stop simply because they have had one drink drive offence.

I go with that:
-needing a drug to cope with everyday life
-needing a drug to socialize

and the clincher

-your primary relationship is with your substance

I like this in a general way too.


im a functional alcoholic and i have varying degrees..

monday
teusday
wednesday
thursday
friday
saturday
sunday

Teusdays are a problem for me to. So is tpying. :);)

I also muck around with people around triggers for drinking; clients find it generally beneficial discovering what gets them started on any given day. Many times it is an inability to handle emotions well. Many times too it ends up (for the daily drinker especially) simply being the habit/addiction coupled with the fear/pain of withdrawal, as well as emotional problems.

Two of the things I tell them:

"Alcoholics don't need an excuse to drink; they just need an excuse to drink."

"My personal triggers were any day ending in Y".
 
Last edited:
Hmmm,
I don't know usually when alcohol causes problems at work it is because people miss work or can not preform, or come in very drunk.

Now relationships it is a little less clear cut but usually not making dates, taking responsibility to be where needed, acting appropriately, lost weekends, blowing paychecks and the like are why people end relationships with someone using alcohol.

So if an individual has a relationship with someone who does not mind them never being where they agree to be, not doing the things they say they will do (like pay bills), getting into strange situations in social settings (like always fighting), spending the whole weekend in a stupor and never paying their share of the bills, I would say this:

that 'tolerant' individual has a :
higher tolerance for chaos than most
does not have very good boundaries
does not mind being homeless or being hounded by creditors
does not mind loosing their friends

I would say that goes past 'tolerance'.
How about this:

A person needs two or three drinks during lunch in order to get him through the rest of workday. If he does not get these drinks and is completely sober he becomes cranky and irritable, and his work performance is WORSE than if got them. Is he an alcoholic?

This is not hypothetical -- what I just described is a completely normal Russia behavior. And Russian people certainly make a distinction between the above and "drinking to the point you cannot perform your work". One is tolerated. The other is not.
 
No*.I mean family or workplace induced stress. Instead of dealing with it head-on (perhaps because doing so causes conflict in the family, or because he just doen't know how, a person has a glass of wine instead.

Snipped for brevity>>>>>

*ETA Not shyness specifically. It could well be an example of stress and stress response.

That makes sense, on the other hand I remember times where I planned to get drunk and knew things wouldn't get down, so I made sure to complete all my tasks beforehand.
 
I also muck around with people around triggers for drinking; clients find it generally beneficial discovering what gets them started on any given day. Many times it is an inability to handle emotions well. Many times too it ends up (for the daily drinker especially) simply being the habit/addiction coupled with the fear/pain of withdrawal, as well as emotional problems.

Two of the things I tell them:

"Alcoholics don't need an excuse to drink; they just need an excuse to drink."

"My personal triggers were any day ending in Y".

I attended group therapy and personal counselling where "indentifying triggers" was taught and we were told if we learned everything about them we could combat our drinking. Didn't work for me, maybe it does for others.
 
How about this:

A person needs two or three drinks during lunch in order to get him through the rest of workday. If he does not get these drinks and is completely sober he becomes cranky and irritable, and his work performance is WORSE than if got them. Is he an alcoholic?

This is not hypothetical -- what I just described is a completely normal Russia behavior. And Russian people certainly make a distinction between the above and "drinking to the point you cannot perform your work". One is tolerated. The other is not.

Personally I would say that from my experience that sort of crosses the line, but cultures do vary. There is also a very high tolerance for violence against women in Russia, that does not mean I would rewrite my personal criteria for what I consider domestic violence.

As I stated if someone needs or feels that they need or depends upon a substance to deal with everyday life, that is one of the clues I used to look for in determining if there was a substance issue.

So I personally would not change my criteria just because a culture considers substance abuse to be normal. I would ask the person
"How often do you not have a drink at lunch?"
"How would you feel if you did not have a drink at lunch?"
"Are there days that you have missed your drink and not noticed."

But making an assessment depends upon the convergence of factors as well, not a single criteria.

It also really depends upon those answers and other factors, like, what is the availability of safe alternatives to alcohol?

Yet just because everyone in a neighborhood thinks it is okay to beat their kids and leave bruises on them, I would not suddenly change my opinion on the criteria for domestic violence. I would not suddenly say "Well it is physical violence only if they break bones."

It is physical violence.

Just so if an individual says they need to drink on a regular basis to cope with everyday life, I would consider that as one check mark.
 
I attended group therapy and personal counselling where "indentifying triggers" was taught and we were told if we learned everything about them we could combat our drinking. Didn't work for me, maybe it does for others.

In the relapse prevention models those are the times that you focus your plan on, how to cope without using.

:)
 
I think what I'm trying to get at is in all my years of drinking (and yes they're anecdotes, but thousands of them) I don't recall there ever being a person who had for example 8 drinks/night, three times a week.

I take it you've never met any students? That sort of behaviour is actually quite common. In fact, it's so common that such binge drinking is frequently targeted by the police and government over here (UK).

I'm just wondering if there's a happy medium somewhere.

For many people, yes. For others, it seems that unfortunately there's not.

That doesn't strike me as problematic at all. (I mean, the idea that two people can have identical intake levels but be classified differently.)

I wasn't just referring to intake levels, but the actual effects on lives. Two people who don't just drink the same amount, but have that drink affect their lives in the same way, can still end up being perceived very differently. A millionaire who doesn't need to work and is friends with other people who drink the same amount and think getting wasted and arrested is funny will not suffer the same consequences as an office worker who does everything exactly the same, but has a family relying on the income he no longer has after being arrested one too many times. The latter has an obvious alcohol problem, while the former, aside from possible future health problems, could potentially be worse off if he stopped drinking due to the way his part of society might view that.

It's still not necessarily a big problem. After all, life isn't fair and a lot of other medical problems don't affect people the same way either. But for something like a broken leg, you can be pretty clear whether someone has one or not. It may have a different affect on their lives, but that doesn't change the status of their leg. With alcoholism, and many other psychological illnesses, it's a lot more messy and the effects on your life are actually the primary factors in determining if you have a disease or not, rather than simply being the unfortunate consequences of having one.

If by "tolerant," you mean your society as a whole is willing to overlook spouse abuse (mental, verbal, emotional, and/or physical), spotty job history or performance, physical illness such as liver disease; drunk driving arrests; jail time; and so forth, you might have a point.

I guess now one must define, exactly, what constitutes a "problem?"

Of course. How can you possibly have a discussion about drinking causing problems without first defining what a problem actually is? I already gave one example where two people can have similar behaviour with similar effects on their lives, but where only one would generally be said to have a problem. Or look at Mark6's example of Russia, where behaviour that would be considered a serious problem drinking in many places is perfectly normal and actually expected.

The problem is NEEDING a drink during work hours. Culture be damned, that is a problem behavior in and of itself.

In your culture. That would be the same culture where needing a drink of highly addictive stimulant during work hours is actually perfectly normal, to the point where not needing one is often remarked on as being weird. As is needing to smoke highly addictive drugs, although now to a lesser extent. In fact, not drinking coffee and not smoking really can have an impact on your work and social life, due to missing out on networking during coffee and smoke breaks.

So why is that all fine, but if a different culture happens to tend towards alcohol as their drug of choice, they must be objectively wrong? Bear in mind that most of the effects of caffeine in regular drinkers are actually just from countering withdrawal symptoms not a real boost in alertness, so it's not as though you can argue it's any more beneficial.
 
Well, from my perspective, the definition of an alcoholic is someone who goes to meetings.

I have a kind and loving relationship with booze. I genuinely like the taste of beer & wine (and consider myself a bit of a wine snob). I'm really not a huge fan of spirits - I could have a mixed drink, or not. Maybe a cognac after an especially nice meal. But I definitely am not the type of person to open a bottle of whisky and drink it 'til its gone.

I probably have a drink or two on most days. Usually after work / with dinner. Generally a couple of beers, or a couple of glasses of wine. Some days, I feel like having more, so I do. Some days, I have none.

At parties, I do indulge, and can easily be swept away and get more than slightly inebriated. However, I do not:

- Drive drunk (I may have once or twice in my youth and gotten away with it, but am very conscious about minding my p's and q's now)
- Get violent when drinking (I ONCE was in a fight that I would describe as alcohol induced. I've been drinking for 25 years, so I hardly think that was a pattern established)

Now - I've been cautioned that I have a 'fatty' liver, which is I gather, a pre-cirrhotic condition, brought on both by diet and booze. I have curtailed my drinking accordingly, without experiencing withdrawal symptoms. I would rather be able to continue to have a healthy relationship with booze rather than be forced to go cold turkey because my liver becomes pate.

So - by some people's definition, maybe I am an alcoholic. Presumably some sort of low-grade 'not stuck on the street and completely dysfunctional homeless person' boozehound.

By my definition, since I a) have control over my situation and b) am able to control my intake through willpower / common sense, I'm not an alcoholic - I'm just a drinker.
 
I take it you've never met any students? That sort of behaviour is actually quite common. In fact, it's so common that such binge drinking is frequently targeted by the police and government over here (UK).

I'm sorry I shouldn't be using quantity to describe different forms of drinking. What I meant to describe was someone who could get adequately inebriated to enjoy the drug and then stop at the appropraite time before he was completely drunk. My apologies if that doesn't make thungs clearer, I hope you understand what I'm getting at.





I wasn't just referring to intake levels, but the actual effects on lives. Two people who don't just drink the same amount, but have that drink affect their lives in the same way, can still end up being perceived very differently. A millionaire who doesn't need to work and is friends with other people who drink the same amount and think getting wasted and arrested is funny will not suffer the same consequences as an office worker who does everything exactly the same, but has a family relying on the income he no longer has after being arrested one too many times. The latter has an obvious alcohol problem, while the former, aside from possible future health problems, could potentially be worse off if he stopped drinking due to the way his part of society might view that.

It's still not necessarily a big problem. After all, life isn't fair and a lot of other medical problems don't affect people the same way either. But for something like a broken leg, you can be pretty clear whether someone has one or not. It may have a different affect on their lives, but that doesn't change the status of their leg. With alcoholism, and many other psychological illnesses, it's a lot more messy and the effects on your life are actually the primary factors in determining if you have a disease or not, rather than simply being the unfortunate consequences of having one.

Thanks for that, you said it much better than I could've.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom