Ability to sense wireless network - paranormal claim?

Of course not. If you actually read what I said, somebody giving me a series of X-rays said that the radiation from the X-ray was equal to a day in the sun. Then changed it to an hour.

Don't worry, I read exactly what you said. You were talking about x-ray dose and were told it was equivalent to a day in the Sun. The x-rays. You then went off on a completely irrelvant tangent about sun-burn, which has nothing to do with x-rays. The dose from an x-ray machine could be the same as a day, hour or year from the Sun for all I care, the fact is you were talking about x-rays, not UV and therefore your comments about sun-burn were completely irrelevant and strongly suggest you are talking utter crap.

While it might be considered rude to suggest I don't know what I am talking about, it is understandable, when you can'tunderstand what I said. :i: X-rays are coming from the sun, however, and the amount is known. Doing a quick check of the data, the amount of radiation from an X-ray machine can be compared to the amount we get from background radiation. This method of explaining radiation is called Background Equivalent Radiation Time or BERT.

X-rays. I'll say that again. X-rays. No matter what the dose, the effects from other radition from the Sun is irrelevant, since that was not under discussion. The rest of your post is utterly pointless. You said that the dose of x-rays from an x-ray machine could not be equivalent to that from the Sun because it didn't give you a sunburn. This argument is just plain wrong. Whether the does actually is that much or not is completely irrelevant to your point.
 
This is a common misunderstanding. Only AM radio is effected by changes in the ionosphere, which is due to solar radiation. Your Wifi and cell phone is not effected.

You said
If the Sun was bathing us in high doses of the frequencies that Wifi or other com devices use, we couldn't use them at all. Too much noise, interference, static, whatever.
Bolding mine. I gave an example of exactly this, proving my point. Just because it doesn't have the same effect on all devices in no way makes me either wrong or suggest any misunderstanding on anyone's part other than yours. In any case, your argument that we wouldn't be able to use them due to noise is completely wrong simply because we can filter out noise. This is exactly why most things don't have problems with interference.

No, I am talking about all radiation. Obviously the effects of ionizing radiation is well understood, due to the horrible tragedies that occurred in the past. Radio/Microwave radiation can kill you in real quick in high doses. Especially certain frequencies.

Why would you be talking about all radiation? Do I smell a straw man? Communication is achieved with radio waves. Therefore we talk about radio waves when talking about the possible dangers. The fact that x-rays or electron beams can hurt people is completely beside the point. Radio waves are non-ionising. Yes, we know some frequencies can be dangerous and we know why they are dangerous. Wifi does not use these frequencies.

Another myth. The FCC has strict guidelines about radiation exposure from microwaves and radio frequencies. Radar as well. A lot is known about the dangers from these frequencies. It is scientific.

Yes, lots is known and it is scientific. You said that the communication industry had a history of finding out the dangers due to their own mistakes. As far as I'm aware this is not the case, the dangers have been found out by scientific means and not by nasty accidents. I am not completely sure of this however, so any sources you have on all these nasty accidents would be welcome.

I have to agree. A claim like this should be easy to test, and important to test, because of peoples fears. A scientific test would do much to advance knowledge about this. The lack of scientific study on the matter, leads to irrational conclusions.

Easy to test and has been tested. Wifi is not dangerous.

Sure, but that the power of the broad spectrum radiation from Sun is greater than the narrow band radiation of a particular source is not, in itself, evidence that the narrow band radiation is not harmful.

Because all the things people complain about do not operate on the same frequencies, they are spread out over a range, even though each one will operate on a narrow frequency at any given time. We know things like microwaves can be dangerous because certain specific frequencies are absorbed. It is concievable that there are other frequencies that could also be absobed that we don't know about, but this is not what people claim. They say all wifi devices, or whatever, cause problems, and since we know that all wifi frequencies aren't the same we know that it cannot be a specific absorption line and their claims simply don't make sense.

How is this relevant to the non-directional localized behaviour of sitting next to a wifi device?

It is relevant because people do not claim to have problems when they stick a wireless router to their head, they claim to have them when they are in the same building as a wifi network. It is relevant because the radiation level from wifi any further than actually sitting on it is far less than TV, radio and mobile phone signals. If massively powerful TV transmitters don't cause problems, why should we believe people when they suddenly claim much lower power raditiation does?

Are microwaves ionizing? I don't think so, but I still wouldn't want to sit in a microwave beam.[/QUOTE]

No, they're not even close to being ionising. If you don't want to sit in a microwave beam I suggest you move somewhere with no TV, radio of telephone service and never use any kind of wireless device. And no electricity.
 
You'd think with all the millions of cellphones around the world, there would be a clear "phone disease" or "WiFi disease" that nobody could deny. After all, it didn't take long to flush out Thalidomide, and I suspect there are far more people with mobile phones than ever took it.

However, people claim mobile phones cause leukemia, brain cancer, bowel cancer, brittle bones, Alzheimer's disease, Osgood's Knee, tennis elbow, genital warts and who knows how many other ailments. You would think that a single cause (use of cellphones) would have a single, characteristic effect, and that it's be epidemic and on the front pages of newspapers everywhere.

A fortiori for power line EM radiation.
 
Don't worry, I read exactly what you said. You were talking about x-ray dose and were told it was equivalent to a day in the Sun. The x-rays. You then went off on a completely irrelvant tangent about sun-burn, which has nothing to do with x-rays. The dose from an x-ray machine could be the same as a day, hour or year from the Sun for all I care, the fact is you were talking about x-rays, not UV and therefore your comments about sun-burn were completely irrelevant and strongly suggest you are talking utter crap.



X-rays. I'll say that again. X-rays. No matter what the dose, the effects from other radition from the Sun is irrelevant, since that was not under discussion. The rest of your post is utterly pointless. You said that the dose of x-rays from an x-ray machine could not be equivalent to that from the Sun because it didn't give you a sunburn. This argument is just plain wrong. Whether the does actually is that much or not is completely irrelevant to your point.

Perhaps there will be less arguement if one adopts the notion that robinson intended only to dispute the direct arguement being made (that no harm was likely to result from the x-ray since it was equivalent in risk to a day of exposure to the sun) rather than dispute the underlying point (that no harm was likely to result from his single x-ray). His choice was to note that the stated equivalent event could indeed cause significant harm, which was a point granted by the person making the claim. The response to this was to simply alter the claimed equivalent event, which he noted was an indication that the other person was seemingly more interested in making a point rather than providing correct information.

It is true, though, that his arguement in this case does nothing to further his earlier point that high-energy radiation from man-made sources can far exceed the amount that reaches Earth's surface from the sun (which I'd advise against disputing, as it is demonstrably true). His purpose seems to have been only to relate another time when he encountered someone making such a claim.

And to take yet another step back, his point that high-energy radiation on earth is nearly all man-made as a result of its absorption by our atmosphere is not a complete rebuke of the claim that exposure to particular levels or types of high-energy radiation is not significantly more harmful than typical exposure to radiation in general, and certainly is no arguement of the converse. I do not believe that the risks in both cases have been measured to a precision that allows for adequate comparison (though at this point it is quite possible some rational parties would disagree with me here).

If one were to take the position that a very high standard of evidence be required when the matter involves real potential harm to humans AND there is an expected predisposition to bias on the part of those most likely to do the research, one could certainly make the claim that sufficient evidence has not yet been provided to prove the case.
 
If one were to take the position that a very high standard of evidence be required when the matter involves real potential harm to humans AND there is an expected predisposition to bias on the part of those most likely to do the research, one could certainly make the claim that sufficient evidence has not yet been provided to prove the case.

I'm not sure I understand everything you just wrote, but some of it seems to point to my being correct, so it sounds good to me.:wackylaugh:

It seems sometimes that what is considered true and verified depends on who is doing the judging. Nothing is more obvious than research that involves both possible harm, and massive amounts of money, is subject to fraud, trickery, deception and bad experiments.

Or as James Randi says:

"Authority does not rest with scientists, when emotion, need, and desperation are involved. Scientists are human beings, too; they can be deceived and self-deceived. ...Scientists can be wrong — sometimes, very wrong. The history of science is replete with serious errors of judgment, bad research, faked results, and simple mistakes, made by scientists in every field."

I like to see the data, not have someone tell me what it meant. It is often very difficult to actually get all the data on experiments that threaten vested interest. Especially when that vested interest funded the research.

This is obvious in the fields of electromagnetic radiation, especially so when it involves children. You might think research into EF is over and done, all the results known, everything is AOK, no problems found at all.

Nothing is further from the truth.
 
I suspect it is much like a story here in Toronto. It was discovered that as many as 10% of the units in a high-rise apartment building (block of flats) were being used as a marijuana grow-op. Since the discovery, many of the tenants in the building have been complaining of health problems. I'm not aware of any evidence that they were complaining of these health problems while the grow-op was in operation, but was not yet discovered.

:shocked:

You doubt the ill-effects of all that unhealthy oxygen produced by fast growing plants?

Or maybe it's the UV light that penetrates their floors and ceilings and walls.
 
Fascinating story. I'd like to know who the 35 year old doctor was and who were the scientists who conducted the tests with her.

Ward
 

From the article:

She was seated on a wooden chair while voltage was applied to metal plates for pulses of 90 seconds to create a series of magnetic fields. The woman was asked to describe her symptoms after each exposure and after random sham exposures when, unknown to her, there was no voltage.

She reported headaches, pain and muscle twitching during the genuine exposures and no symptoms for the majority of the sham exposures.

The scientists concluded that such consistency could not be attributed to chance.

Assuming that the experiment was properly controlled (an unknown variable, right now), would that qualify for the million dollar challenge? Or would it have qualified if this lady hadn't just blown it and shown it was scientifically verifiable?
 
...snip...

Assuming that the experiment was properly controlled (an unknown variable, right now), would that qualify for the million dollar challenge? Or would it have qualified if this lady hadn't just blown it and shown it was scientifically verifiable?

Wouldn't have thought so as there is nothing "paranormal" about magnetism, radio waves, electricity and the like and they can have discernible effects on people.

Randi was involved in testing a non-paranormal claim for being able to identify the music recorded on a LP simply by looking at the grooves so he might get involved in an "electrical sensitivity" test (youngsters ask your grandparents to explain what a LP was)?
 
Wouldn't have thought so as there is nothing "paranormal" about magnetism, radio waves, electricity and the like and they can have discernible effects on people.
Hi,

The question isn't whether sufficiently strong EM fields can have discernible effects on people - clearly they can. Whats not so clear is how the low levels used in a wireless networks could be detected by a person (who doesn't have any special metal or equipment in their body).

As far as I know there is no known mechanism in biology or physics which would allow a person to 'sense' the existence of a wifi network. If this is the case then I think it counts as a paranormal claim. I could be wrong about the biology/physics of course (I'm not an expert).

I don't think the claims of health impacts from long term exposure to weak EM are a paranormal claim - I suspect these claims may not be true - but its completely conceivable that long term exposure could have impacts. However I can't imagine how someone could tell if a wifi access point was switched on or off based on 30 seconds of exposure.

I find this question interesting because (unlike telepathy or telekinesis or other hard-core woo) its not so 100% clear. I'll admit its just about possible that the people making the claims about sensing wifi are right - and there is a scientific explanation for it - and if so they may well be right about the wider health concerns also (in which case we all need to know about it urgently!).

On the other hand if (as I suspect) they are fooling themself (in the usual ways people fool themselves about so many topics discussed here) then if we could demonstrate that to them we might do them a big favour - ie if there are thousands of people out there torturing themselves with placebo discomforts every time electricity is used around them then shouldn't we try to help them?

I found the website of Dr Andrew Marino who did the study mentioned in the bbc piece. http://www.andrewamarino.com/ . He is obviously something of a specialist on EM field impacts. I didn't notice anything specifically about the study mentioned - it would be interesting to know the strength of the fields in question for instance (ie were they many times stronger than those in wifi networks).

So is there woo here? It smells like woo...

- Drelda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom