Ability to sense wireless network - paranormal claim?

The mythbusters did a segment where they busted the myth that you could listen to a radio station via your fillings.

I don't even have to read that article to know that it's impossible. If you could simply pickup, AND LISTEN to a radio signal via metal... I could've saved myself a lot of money at RadioShack and attach bits of tinfoil to myself or teeth instead.

Because we all know that random pieces of fillings and metal can accuratly translate the frequency of something exactly like a radio does...
 
I think if you were sensitive to radio-waves you'd be in a pretty bad way in the modern world, dont you think? Never mind very short range stuff like Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, what about mobile-phone masts, PCM personal radios and the big stuff like radio and television transmitters? If she were genuinely disturbed by EM she'd have exploded long ago.
 
I think if you were sensitive to radio-waves you'd be in a pretty bad way in the modern world, dont you think? Never mind very short range stuff like Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, what about mobile-phone masts, PCM personal radios and the big stuff like radio and television transmitters? If she were genuinely disturbed by EM she'd have exploded long ago.

The argument will be that the frequency and coding specific to things like Wi-Fi are quite different than that of radio and cellphone signals.
 
I personally don't believe the ability to sense "Wi-Fi" signals, radio signals, etc... Counts as something paranormal. These signals are something physical, and they CAN sometimes conflict with people, and in some cases, make them sick. Even they should know that it's all scientific, and they should go to a scientist or a doctor for advice on it.

For example, I have the "Ability" to sense when a Television is on while closing my eyes. This isn't a "paranormal" ability, it's nothing more than pure science of the fact that televisions radiate a high pitched frequency, and I just apparently can notice it when others can't. If being sensitive to electronic sounds, and signals that are actually THERE and conflict with human sense is paranormal, then maybe I should apply for such a challenge. However, I don't see how it can be "paranormal."

But there is no way for the human body to detect radio signals. Being able to hear high frequency sound is nothing special. Assuming you are under about 30 you would be quite unusual if you couldn't hear the noise from a TV. It doesn't matter that radio signals are somthing physical. So are electric signals in our brains, but claiming to read minds is most definately paranormal.

I would be very interested to know why you think that "These signals are something physical, and they CAN sometimes conflict with people, and in some cases, make them sick.". As far as I know, every study into the effects of radio signals has either been negative or inconlusive, despite all the hysterical claims about them.
 
I think if you were sensitive to radio-waves you'd be in a pretty bad way in the modern world, dont you think? Never mind very short range stuff like Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, what about mobile-phone masts, PCM personal radios and the big stuff like radio and television transmitters? If she were genuinely disturbed by EM she'd have exploded long ago.

And that would make for another great Mythbusters episode. :D




Still no comments published by thisislondon.co.uk. From their page:

"(...)Thank you for submitting your comment to This is London.

Your views are important to us and you will shortly receive an email when your comment is published if you selected this option.

Please note that all comments are moderated and published at the editors' discretion.(...)"
 
In the process of installing wireless access points, which may have been mounted to walls or put in attic or crawl spaces; it's more likely that mold spores were stirred up causing her to feel sick.

However, because "... all comments are moderated and published at the editors' discretion.(...) " alternative solutions aren't likely to be published.
:boggled:
 
Last edited:
Interesting article. The title and first three words sum it up quite nicely.
Is there any proof that Wi-Fi networks can make you sick? Strictly speaking, no.
The rest is basically just saying "But, but, but, I heard from my girlfriend's, father's, boyfriend's, uncle's pet jellyfish that it was true, so scientists must be wrong.". The fact that they focus on Wi-Fi networks and ignore all the work that has been done with similar frequencies, such as mobile phones, says an awful lot about the standard of reporting.

Edit : It's also worth noticing that while the headline is about getting sick, and the article is designed to stir up emotions about people becoming ill from technology, the actual substance of both the claim and the article is that radio signals can be detected by people, not make them ill. Interesting, no?
 
For example, I have the "Ability" to sense when a Television is on while closing my eyes. This isn't a "paranormal" ability, it's nothing more than pure science of the fact that televisions radiate a high pitched frequency, and I just apparently can notice it when others can't. If being sensitive to electronic sounds, and signals that are actually THERE and conflict with human sense is paranormal, then maybe I should apply for such a challenge. However, I don't see how it can be "paranormal."

Yes, that's the linescan frequency, IceSage. I can hear it, too, although many people can't. However, it's an acoustic wave and we have dedicated acoustic wave detectors either side of our heads. The frequency is not so high that it's freakish to be able to hear it.*

Our EM wave detection organs only work over a very narrow band, way, way below RF regions. Rhodopsin won't react to RF, so the lady would need a hitherto undocumented sense. I'd say that was a pretty paranormal claim.

*PS, it doesn't work for plasma TVs.
 
In the old days of broadcast TV, (I know, I know, some people still actually get television this way), it was obvious that a human body could influence the signal. In fact, sometimes you had to actually hold the rabbit ears to get a signal. Radio is the same. If the human body can influence radio and television frequencies. then they can influence the human body.

The question I am pondering, is could anyone be aware of it? What level of energy are we talking about here? While it must be very faint, is it possible some people can detect, through some unknown way, when certain electromagnetic waves are passing through them? Or being absorbed by them?

It seems doubtful. Impossible.
 
I just took a shot at registering a comment. Will probably be rejected by the editor(s). This network obviously doesn't appreciate negative comment. Maybe I'll try a positive "gosh yes I can sense wireless networks too" approach: then we'll KNOW if the site is totally biased.
 
In the old days of broadcast TV, (I know, I know, some people still actually get television this way), it was obvious that a human body could influence the signal. In fact, sometimes you had to actually hold the rabbit ears to get a signal. Radio is the same. If the human body can influence radio and television frequencies. then they can influence the human body.

Careful, robinson - that's not necessarily so. The presence of a water-filled human changes the impedance of the radio circuit, but isn't necessarily doing anything to the EM waves themselves.

The question I am pondering, is could anyone be aware of it? What level of energy are we talking about here? While it must be very faint, is it possible some people can detect, through some unknown way, when certain electromagnetic waves are passing through them? Or being absorbed by them?

It seems doubtful. Impossible.

I'm with you there. Why would natural selection adapt us to detect radio-frequency waves?
 
I just took a shot at registering a comment. Will probably be rejected by the editor(s). This network obviously doesn't appreciate negative comment. Maybe I'll try a positive "gosh yes I can sense wireless networks too" approach: then we'll KNOW if the site is totally biased.

Well, go ahead, Spiro. Can you?
 
But there is no way for the human body to detect radio signals.

That is true that there is no recognizable human sense that can detect radio waves, but according to Wikipedia some animals can detect electric fields. Some fish actually use electric fields to communicate, pretty close to telepathy.

There is of course the fact that humans can detect static electricity, as you feel the hair on your arm stand up when you rub a balloon against it, though this is a secondary effect and not a direct sense.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sense:

"Electroception (or "electroreception"), the most significant of the non-human senses, is the ability to detect electric fields. Several species of fish, sharks and rays have evolved the capacity to sense changes in electric fields in their immediate vicinity. Some fish passively sense changing nearby electric fields; some generate their own weak electric fields, and sense the pattern of field potentials over their body surface; and some use these electric field generating and sensing capacities for social communication. The mechanisms by which electroceptive fishes construct a spatial representation from very small differences in field potentials involve comparisons of spike latencies from different parts of the fish's body.

The only order of mammals that is known to demonstrate electroception is the monotreme order. Among these mammals, the platypus (see [2]) has the most acute sense of electroception.

Humans (and probably other mammals) can detect electric fields indirectly by detecting the effect they have on hairs. An electrically charged balloon, for instance, will exert a force on human arm hairs, which can be felt through tactition and identified as coming from a static charge (and not from wind or the like). This is however not Electroception since there is no separate sense for it. The presence of an electrical field is merely concluded from a side-effect of another sense."
 
You must also remember that wikipedia has not the best rep when it comes to accuracy.



Let's keep this thread about wi-fi and Ms. Figes' alleged ability.
 
That is true that there is no recognizable human sense that can detect radio waves, but according to Wikipedia some animals can detect electric fields. Some fish actually use electric fields to communicate, pretty close to telepathy.

Electric fields are not radio waves and humans are not fish.

Edit : Also, there is nothing telepathic about using known organs to communicate using known forces in a known way.
 
Last edited:
She's had a short article published on the Grauniad's website: http://commentisfree.guardian.co.uk/kate_figes/2006/12/wifi_worries.html

It seems to be being given a good kicking.

The very first comment posted says:
the Guardian technology blog has put up a post that says you can't probably can't pass a double blind test as to whether or not wi-fi is in a particular room. Arrange a test, take it and pass it. then we can take this seriously.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom