Ability to sense wireless network - paranormal claim?

I wonder if a test must be conducted in the countryside or in a radio-shielded room. I live in a big city, and there is nowhere I can go where there is not a wireless LAN present.

Or does she claim that the transmitter is in the same room? Is she doing a visual identification?

Is her ability limited to certain frequencies? There are radio waves everywhere on Earth, most of them man-made. It must be difficult to pick out certain signals among that noise.
 
I wonder if a test must be conducted in the countryside or in a radio-shielded room. I live in a big city, and there is nowhere I can go where there is not a wireless LAN present.

Or does she claim that the transmitter is in the same room? Is she doing a visual identification?

Is her ability limited to certain frequencies? There are radio waves everywhere on Earth, most of them man-made. It must be difficult to pick out certain signals among that noise.

From the article: http://www.thisislondon.co.uk/news/...s/Wireless technology made me sick/article.do

"(...) Ms Figes, 49, claims she is so sensitive to wi-fi's electro-magnetic waves she can instantly tell whether it is installed in a particular room. (...)"


It'd help if we could a statement directly from her. Perhaps she is on to something.

I'd like to see her claim tested - not necessarily for the JREF Challenge. By an organisation with proper knowledge which produces a valid result.
 
From the article: http://www.thisislondon.co.uk/news/...s/Wireless technology made me sick/article.do

"(...) Ms Figes, 49, claims she is so sensitive to wi-fi's electro-magnetic waves she can instantly tell whether it is installed in a particular room. (...)"


It'd help if we could a statement directly from her. Perhaps she is on to something.
I presume it could be tested by switching the access point on and off - unless she can detect a WLAN with the access point switched off.
 
I approached this with an open mind (as I do most things :) ) but when I read the article I was very disappointed. According to her account, the only relationship between the wifi and her "illness" was the her illness started when they got wifi and stopped when they got rid of it. This barely even qualifies as anecdotal evidence.

I had the sh*ts on Tuesday. There was a silver car parked outside my house all day. When it left I felt better. So beware silver cars, they interfere with your bowels.
 
Hi,

We need to be careful not to mix up the general idea of electro-sensitivity (ie health impacts etc) and the specific claim that someone can sense wifi.

I don't think the idea of health impacts from EM waves is a paranormal claim. Seems unlikely to me - but I guess its possible they will be proved right on that.

However being able to 'sense' the presence of a wireless network with no external equipment seems to require some entirely new biology or physics - so that seems like a hardcore paranormal claim.

I've managed to get a contact address for the woman in the article - given that the opinion here seems to be that the claim would be challenge worthy I'll send her a letter telling her about the prize and inviting her to apply.

- Drelda

Any results on your - commendable - efforts yet, drelda?
 
Any results on your - commendable - efforts yet, drelda?
Nothing to report yet - but I've only recently sent her the letter.

However there was another piece about 'wifi woo woo' in the UK press yesterday. This time on the bbc! (http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/magazine/6172257.stm. Theres a form for comments here too - and I'm pretty confident the bbc will publish any (non offensive) comments.

Again someone makes the claim -
...and he could tell if the wi-fi transmitters were on or off.

It seems theres a growing hysteria about 'the dangers of wi-fi' in the UK that is starting to have real impacts (eg "some schools are removing wifi networks"). It would be great if JREF can help nudge things back to rationality by arranging a proper test. The woman in the article from the opening post might apply (however that was always a long shot). If not I'll try to contact the guy from the bbc article who makes the same claim.

- Drelda
 
Last edited:
Drelda, the link does not work properly.

How about a few of us trying to contact those people - Ms. Figes, the guys who wrote the articles, etc. - and referring them to the JREF Challenge?
 
The comments on the BBC site (link above) are being published. All (except one) say the claim is rubbish. If you want you can mention JREF Challenge there.

At least in the other site they have not published ANY comments, rather than just one side.
 
I visited my friend's university once and had dinner with them in the dorm cafeteria. It had wireless internet and I knew that because I could see the router.
I went ahead and tilted my head and said there is wireless in this room. And the freaked out.
And then I pointed out that the router was right there.
And now I have no friends. j/k
I love pranks.
 
whoa

..... A special role is played by the electrophonic effect of microwave hearing. Humans can perceive a buzzing or clicking sound in the back of their heads at exposure to power densities as low as 0.1 mW/cm² of pulsed microwave radiation (200-3000 MHz) , depending on the pulse repetition frequency and the peak power density (around 300 mW/cm²). The absorbed energy produces a thermoelastic expansion of the brain tissue causing an acoustic pressure wave which is detected in the cochlea by the hair cells of the organ of Corti. The energy needed to produce this effect is so small that it does not actually increase the mean temperature of the brain, yet the acoustic sensation is strong enough to be clearly perceived in an ambient noise level of circa 65 dB.

Biological Effects of Radiofrequency Radiation by Wolfgang W. Scherer ( 25. March 1994 )
 
Biological Effects of Radiofrequency Radiation by Wolfgang W. Scherer ( 25. March 1994 )
I agree it is very interesting. However, I am not surprised that humans can sense a radiation that is able to heat fat molecules in the body, but that a pulsed radiation would end up producing a sensation of sound is very surprising. Will this mean that since I can only hear the fan of my microwave oven, it is adequately isolated?
 
Hi,

Theres a story in the London papers today about a woman who claims that wireless networks made her sick - and particularly claims that : "she is so sensitive to wi-fi's electro-magnetic waves she can instantly tell whether it is installed in a particular room. " The details are here - tinyurl.com/yagmnw. This sounds like a paranormal claim to me - but I'm not an expert. If people agree its likely to be challenge worthy I'll try to contact her to tell her about the $1m. thanks - Drelda
If she actually can, I doubt it is anything near a paranormal claim. I often power the television off when reading on the couch because of the almost imperceptibly high pitched trill it makes. Although Wi-Fi is another thing entirely. Can't imagine the signal would be strong enough to have any effect on the auditory cortex or the ear. I'm surprised she doesn't complain about cell phones.
 
If she actually can, I doubt it is anything near a paranormal claim. I often power the television off when reading on the couch because of the almost imperceptibly high pitched trill it makes.
Quite likely, this is an actual sound produced by vibrations of some part within the television. I guess you knew that: I just wanted to clarify ...
 
Might be the flyback transformer in your TV that causes the whine, right around 17-20kHz. Most people can't detect it. They might even insist it isn't there.

;)
 
For some time when I was a child, I believed that I could feel electricity with my fingers. When I stroked the metal stand of a lamp, there was a vibrational sensation when it was on, that was not there when it was not.

Even today, I am not entirely sure of the physics, but I gather that the metal really vibrates with the 50Hz frequency of the current.
 
Might be the flyback transformer in your TV that causes the whine, right around 17-20kHz. Most people can't detect it. They might even insist it isn't there.

;)

If it were remotely paranormal, I'd have the million in the bag. Unfortunately, it's none too unprecedented or controversial.

I suspect it's either the flyback transformer or the deflection yoke.
 
Might be the flyback transformer in your TV that causes the whine, right around 17-20kHz. Most people can't detect it. They might even insist it isn't there.

Most people under 30 can, and it all goes downhill from there. I hadn't really thought of this as an explanation, since I assumed this woman was simply fooling herself as is normally the case. However, my router (not wiresless) makes quite a loud buzzing noise that can get really annoying if I leave it turned on at the mains (it's the transformer, not the actual router). Older people generally have worse hearing, as is evident from not hearing the TV noise, so it would not surprise me if she was simply hearing a sound from her router but not conciously registering it. Tinitus can have real health effects due to lack of sleep and concentration, so I wouldn't be surprised if this sort of thing could have an effect as well, even if the effect is simply making her feel uncomfortable.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom