Ability to sense wireless network - paranormal claim?

For some time when I was a child, I believed that I could feel electricity with my fingers. When I stroked the metal stand of a lamp, there was a vibrational sensation when it was on, that was not there when it was not.

Even today, I am not entirely sure of the physics, but I gather that the metal really vibrates with the 50Hz frequency of the current.
I can feel that too! That's why I don't do it anymore :eek:
 
I approached this with an open mind (as I do most things :) ) but when I read the article I was very disappointed. According to her account, the only relationship between the wifi and her "illness" was the her illness started when they got wifi and stopped when they got rid of it. This barely even qualifies as anecdotal evidence.

I had the sh*ts on Tuesday. There was a silver car parked outside my house all day. When it left I felt better. So beware silver cars, they interfere with your bowels.


hahahaha thats a great analogy
 
Might be the flyback transformer in your TV that causes the whine, right around 17-20kHz. Most people can't detect it. They might even insist it isn't there.

;)
Quite right. Other people said they heard nothing, which surprised me, because it was very irritating. Even my 21" CRT monitor at 85hz, although it doesn't emit any trill, I power off when going to sleep or reading. There is a slight intensity that is barely noticeable - I have to wonder if it's just habit, though. Just seems "quieter" with it off.
 
If it were remotely paranormal, I'd have the million in the bag. Unfortunately, it's none too unprecedented or controversial. I suspect it's either the flyback transformer or the deflection yoke.

Claimant: "Psst."
Randi: "Hello.."
Claimant: "I want to try for the million. I can telepathically communicate with my old television. Just not through lead walls."
Randi (crossing arms and sighing): "Well that's a new one, and refreshing to boot. Someone feeding their television b-llshit instead.."
 
Nothing to report yet - but I've only recently sent her the letter.

However there was another piece about 'wifi woo woo' in the UK press yesterday. This time on the bbc! (http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/magazine/6172257.stm. Theres a form for comments here too - and I'm pretty confident the bbc will publish any (non offensive) comments.

Again someone makes the claim -

It seems theres a growing hysteria about 'the dangers of wi-fi' in the UK that is starting to have real impacts (eg "some schools are removing wifi networks"). It would be great if JREF can help nudge things back to rationality by arranging a proper test. The woman in the article from the opening post might apply (however that was always a long shot). If not I'll try to contact the guy from the bbc article who makes the same claim.

- Drelda

Have you had a response, drelda?

(Still no comments published here: http://www.thisislondon.co.uk/news/a...ick/article.do
Quelle surprise.)
 
If she actually can, I doubt it is anything near a paranormal claim. I often power the television off when reading on the couch because of the almost imperceptibly high pitched trill it makes. Although Wi-Fi is another thing entirely. Can't imagine the signal would be strong enough to have any effect on the auditory cortex or the ear. I'm surprised she doesn't complain about cell phones.

I complain about cell phones all the time.
































OK really it is just the morons talking on them.
 
I can feel that too! That's why I don't do it anymore :eek:
Lamps that turn on and off when you touch them have metal bases that are electrically connected to the internal circuitry. They use electricity to sense the capacitance of your body when you touch the lamp. If you run you finger along the metal you can feel the 50 or 60 Hz pulses of electricity.

These lamps somtimes turn on and off seemingly by them selves. I seen an older lamp switch on and/or flicker when a phone rang and when lighting flashed.

This would seem to be a woo thing if you didn't understand why it happens.
 
Hi,

There was an item on the BBC news last night about the 'dangers of wifi'. It features a couple of the people referenced in other press earlier in this thread.

Again the claim is made that one of them can 'sense' a wifi network.

I've uploaded the clip to : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qX9uTzuM__A

As a result of all this press in recent months theres now a growing belief in the UK that wifi networks are dangerous. Schools are removing them, companies are finding it more difficult to setup hotspots etc. There doesn't seem to be any real evidence of a problem - but as ever this doesn't count for much.

I wrote to the woman in the clip a few months ago inviting her to apply for the MDC if she really does claim to be able to sense a wifi network. I didn't get any response - but the claim is still being reported.

- Drelda
 
As a result of all this press in recent months theres now a growing belief in the UK that wifi networks are dangerous. Schools are removing them, companies are finding it more difficult to setup hotspots etc. There doesn't seem to be any real evidence of a problem - but as ever this doesn't count for

While it doesn't seem to be a popular belief, I think technology that is questioned, should have to bear the burden of proof, not the other way around.

In simple terms, if you want to start broadcasting radiation, you have to prove it can't cause harm first, not the other way around. I know, I know, that sounds silly when talking about technology. What we see, is that somebody invents something, starts using it, then when it might have a harmful effect, the people using the technology want YOU to prove it is harmful. Or they claim there is no evidence that it causes harm. All the while, it is being used. Often in a manner that gives you no option to avoid it.

While most new technologies are no danger, (ignoring the human factor), some have been. Some have caused a lot of death and disease before it was shown that they were indeed dangerous. In most cases, it is just as I stated. The substance or radiation is used until overwhelming proof is found, that it is indeed causing harm.
 
I'm not saying a Wifi can cause harm, (I sure hope it can't), just that the view on technologies is skewed. If it were a woo claim, it would get shredded, quickly and without end. But modern technology seems to enjoy the opposite effect. Use it, then when it might be harmful, ignore any evidence, until it is overwhelming, then do something about it.

That is backasswards.
 
I don't really agree with your view of technology, but that is irrelevant since this has nothing to do with technology. Wifi and the various other things that use radio waves do nothing that the Sun, and other natural sources, haven't been doing for millions of years at much higher intensities. And of course more recently we have been drowned in radio waves from radio (duh), TV, and phone antenna, yet no-one has ever complained about them, even though the power from one is orders of magnitude higher than that from a router. Maybe technology should have tighter safety controls on it, but that doesn't change the fact that everything about this claim is utter cow poo.
 
Wifi and the various other things that use radio waves do nothing that the Sun, and other natural sources, haven't been doing for millions of years at much higher intensities.

Nonsense. If the Sun was bathing us in high doses of the frequencies that Wifi or other com devices use, we couldn't use them at all. Too much noise, interference, static, whatever. That is a nonsense statement. It made me think of the claim by an X-ray tech who wanted to put me at ease about the radiation dose from oral x-rays. She claimed it would be the same as a day on the sun. I pointed out that a day in the sun would result in serious burns, immune system damage, and an increase in skin cancer risk. She didn't look happy, because she realized that was true.

The next time I got X-rays she had modified it to an hour in the sun.

And of course more recently we have been drowned in radio waves from radio (duh), TV, and phone antenna, yet no-one has ever complained about them, even though the power from one is orders of magnitude higher than that from a router.

While some locations may be "drowned" with radiation, not everywhere is. Even so, there are many many complaints about exposure to radiation. The history of broadcasting radiation is filled with finding out the hard way about the dangers of this. Today the worst offenders are mostly known, and protection from radiation is very important to workers around high doses of radiation.

Maybe technology should have tighter safety controls on it, but that doesn't change the fact that everything about this claim is utter cow poo.

That may be so. A claim like this is easy to test, as was pointed out early on.
 
This reminds me of something I once read on alt.folklore.urban. A utility man drove out to a large broadcasting antenna. A local resident approached the utility man, complaining that ever since they had built the antenna everyone in the area had all sorts of health problems. The utility man replied, "well, then this is really going to bother you: I'm here to turn the antenna on."
 
Nonsense. If the Sun was bathing us in high doses of the frequencies that Wifi or other com devices use, we couldn't use them at all. Too much noise, interference, static, whatever. That is a nonsense statement. It made me think of the claim by an X-ray tech who wanted to put me at ease about the radiation dose from oral x-rays. She claimed it would be the same as a day on the sun. I pointed out that a day in the sun would result in serious burns, immune system damage, and an increase in skin cancer risk. She didn't look happy, because she realized that was true.

The next time I got X-rays she had modified it to an hour in the sun.

Are you seriously suggesting that x-rays from the Sun are responsible for sun burn? You have no idea what you are talking about. UV gives you a burn, the x-rays don't do anything, but they are there. Considering that the Sun gives out very little high energy radiation since it's peak is in the visible, a day in the Sun sounds perfectly reasonable for an x-ray machine.

In fact, the Sun really is putting out lots of radio waves. It doesn't drown out the signals we use because it is broadband radiation, meaning the power is spread over a wide range of frequencies, whereas communications use a small amount of power focussed on one frequency. In addition, most communications are either directional or fairly short range. If you're really trying to claim the Sun can't effect radio waves I suggest you ask yourself why long range communication is so much easier at night. You can pick up amature radio signals from halfway around the world, but during the day you have no chance.

While some locations may be "drowned" with radiation, not everywhere is. Even so, there are many many complaints about exposure to radiation. The history of broadcasting radiation is filled with finding out the hard way about the dangers of this. Today the worst offenders are mostly known, and protection from radiation is very important to workers around high doses of radiation.

We're not talking about "radiation", we're talking about radio waves. The radiation you are talking about is ionising radiation, which incldues hard x-rays, gamma rays and particle radiation. The broadcasting has no history of finding out about the dangers of radiation because it doesn't use dangerous radiation.

That may be so. A claim like this is easy to test, as was pointed out early on.

Great, go and test it then. The people who are actually involved with this kind of work know exactly how sensible this claim is and give it all the time it deserves. If you want to waste your time with it, feel free.
 
Conflicting sources

Are you seriously suggesting that x-rays from the Sun are responsible for sun burn?

Of course not. If you actually read what I said, somebody giving me a series of X-rays said that the radiation from the X-ray was equal to a day in the sun. Then changed it to an hour.

You have no idea what you are talking about. UV gives you a burn, the x-rays don't do anything, but they are there.

While it might be considered rude to suggest I don't know what I am talking about, it is understandable, when you can'tunderstand what I said. :i: X-rays are coming from the sun, however, and the amount is known. Doing a quick check of the data, the amount of radiation from an X-ray machine can be compared to the amount we get from background radiation. This method of explaining radiation is called Background Equivalent Radiation Time or BERT.

Considering that the Sun gives out very little high energy radiation since it's peak is in the visible, a day in the Sun sounds perfectly reasonable for an x-ray machine..

No, it is complete BS actually. Using BERT, values can be given for the amount of radiation we get from an X-ray machine. Or from other sources. I find great variation in what these amounts are reported to be, however. On the one hand,

To put the risks of radiation from X-rays into perspective: a four-hour airline flight will expose you to the same amount of radiation (from cosmic rays) as from a simple chest X-ray. This is the same as the amount of radiation we would be exposed to naturally (from background radiation) over 10 days.
--British United Provident Association

and then there is
The effective dose from common diagnostic x-ray procedures is typically less than the amount of radiation you receive from nature in 2 years.
--eMedicine

See? So depending on who you believe, my Dental X-rays either gave me the amount of radiation I would naturally get in 40 days, or less than I would get in 8 years. Not the same as a day, or hour, in the sun. So the X-ray tech didn't know crap about what she was actually doing, when it came to explaining the dose.

In fact, it is known that X-rays increase risk of cancer, or mutation in a fetus. What is done, is a risk trade off, in that the benefits of diagnosis is great enough to justify the risk. Nobody claims that X-rays are safe, they are considered a good trade off in diagnosis VS increased risk.

But the amount of radiation you're exposed to during an X-ray is so small that the risk of any damage to cells in your body is extremely low.

So for most X-ray examinations, the benefits of a medically indicated examination are thought to greatly outweigh the small risk.
-- Mayo Clinic

How we found out X-rays can hurt you is interesting history. Same for all kinds of radiation. While some have insisted that only ionizing radiation can hurt you, this is nonsense. All kinds of frequencies can harm, it depends on the level of exposure.
 
Last edited:
In fact, the Sun really is putting out lots of radio waves. .... You can pick up amature[sic] radio signals from halfway around the world, but during the day you have no chance.

This is a common misunderstanding. Only AM radio is effected by changes in the ionosphere, which is due to solar radiation. Your Wifi and cell phone is not effected.

We're not talking about "radiation", we're talking about radio waves. The radiation you are talking about is ionising[sic] radiation, which incldues[sic] hard x-rays, gamma rays and particle radiation.

No, I am talking about all radiation. Obviously the effects of ionizing radiation is well understood, due to the horrible tragedies that occurred in the past. Radio/Microwave radiation can kill you in real quick in high doses. Especially certain frequencies.

The broadcasting has no history of finding out about the dangers of radiation because it doesn't use dangerous radiation.

Another myth. The FCC has strict guidelines about radiation exposure from microwaves and radio frequencies. Radar as well. A lot is known about the dangers from these frequencies. It is scientific.

... The people who are actually involved with this kind of work know exactly how sensible this claim is and give it all the time it deserves.

I have to agree. A claim like this should be easy to test, and important to test, because of peoples fears. A scientific test would do much to advance knowledge about this. The lack of scientific study on the matter, leads to irrational conclusions.
 
In fact, the Sun really is putting out lots of radio waves. It doesn't drown out the signals we use because it is broadband radiation, meaning the power is spread over a wide range of frequencies, whereas communications use a small amount of power focussed on one frequency.
Sure, but that the power of the broad spectrum radiation from Sun is greater than the narrow band radiation of a particular source is not, in itself, evidence that the narrow band radiation is not harmful.

In addition, most communications are either directional or fairly short range.
How is this relevant to the non-directional localized behaviour of sitting next to a wifi device?

we're talking about radio waves. The radiation you are talking about is ionising radiation, which incldues hard x-rays, gamma rays and particle radiation. The broadcasting has no history of finding out about the dangers of radiation because it doesn't use dangerous radiation.
Are microwaves ionizing? I don't think so, but I still wouldn't want to sit in a microwave beam.

[For the record, I suspect wifi devices are harmless]
 
Are microwaves ionizing? I don't think so, but I still wouldn't want to sit in a microwave beam.

[For the record, I suspect wifi devices are harmless]

Nope, no ionization at all, even at high power levels. I spend a a fair amount of time in the beam of microwaves during ham radio contests. But the power levels are relatively low (5 watts at 10GHz for example. I'm not about to put my eyeball over a waveguide at that power level...although for short exposures the risks of damage are pretty low. But several feet away from a half meter dish being fed with 5 watts? Do the math and you'll see the power levels per square cm are really low.

Apply the inverse square law to someone standing a few meters from 100mw into Wi-Fi omni antenna and the RF exposure becomes trivial.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom