Ability to sense wireless network - paranormal claim?

drelda

Critical Thinker
Joined
Jan 20, 2005
Messages
364
Hi,

Theres a story in the London papers today about a woman who claims that wireless networks made her sick - and particularly claims that :

"she is so sensitive to wi-fi's electro-magnetic waves she can instantly tell whether it is installed in a particular room. "

The details are here - tinyurl.com/yagmnw.

This sounds like a paranormal claim to me - but I'm not an expert. If people agree its likely to be challenge worthy I'll try to contact her to tell her about the $1m.

thanks - Drelda
 
Does she have the same reaction to cordless phones?
Some use the same frequency range.
 
There's really only one sure-fire way to know if this would qualify. Tell her about the challenge and have her apply. It's simple and inexpensive. It should only cost her the amount of postage necessary to mail to Randi in Florida.

Go for it, drelda.



However, I would bet good money that this story got way overblown. Just a little gas. Chinese whispers. I look forward to being wrong.
 
Go for it, drelda.



However, I would bet good money that this story got way overblown. Just a little gas. Chinese whispers. I look forward to being wrong.

I suspect it is much like a story here in Toronto. It was discovered that as many as 10% of the units in a high-rise apartment building (block of flats) were being used as a marijuana grow-op. Since the discovery, many of the tenants in the building have been complaining of health problems. I'm not aware of any evidence that they were complaining of these health problems while the grow-op was in operation, but was not yet discovered.
 
I tried to post a comment, but the page timed out on me (consigning my witty and incisive words into the etheric deeps).
No - don't mention the Challenge. That's for paranormal claims, and the electro-sensitivity people say there's a scientific basis for their claims that wi-fi waves are harmful.
Point out the wide range of wi-fi - about 100 yards normally - which would mean that whole areas of modern cities would be full of very sick people; also, throw in the fact that many cordless telephones operate on the same frequencies.
Point out also that it's not up to the telecommunications companies to prove that wi-fi does not make people sick (the "prove a negative" fallacy), but for the electro-sensitives to provide medical evidence that it does.
Say that any claim that "electro-sensitives" can "feel" wi-fi waves can be proved very simply with double-blind testing.
Finally mention that the concept of "electro-sensitivity" goes back for decades. I remember it from the 60s and 70s, with people claiming then that being around ordinary electric wiring made them ill. That so-called sensitivity was closely related to the "allergic to the twentieth-century" syndrome, where some people claimed that being around anything plastic, electric, artificial etc made them ill. Neither claim has ever been proven.
 
Last edited:
No - don't mention the Challenge. That's for paranormal claims, and the electro-sensitivity people say there's a scientific basis for their claims that wi-fi waves are harmful.

So do the proponents of homeopathy, perpetual motion and plenty of other rubbish. What she claims is paranormal, and even if you somehow argue that it is not, I would bet quite a lot that the JREF would consider it so and deem it elligible for the challenge anyway.
 
So do the proponents of homeopathy, perpetual motion and plenty of other rubbish. What she claims is paranormal, and even if you somehow argue that it is not, I would bet quite a lot that the JREF would consider it so and deem it elligible for the challenge anyway.
No - these people do believe their sensitivity has a scientific basis. They are not making any paranormal claims and would feel insulted if you suggested that.
What I should have explained was that simply saying "Take the Challenge" will be dismissed; people either won't ever have heard of it, or won't think it's applicable. You should instead list the facts against electro-sensitivity - there's no shortage of them.
 
Last edited:
No - these people do believe their sensitivity has a scientific basis.

Of course they do. As I said, so do the proponents of lots of other woo. That doesn't mean it actually does have a scientific basis.

They are not making any paranormal claims and would feel insulted if you suggested that.

They are claiming that humans can detect something that all known science says they cannot detect. This is a paranormal claim. If they get insulted over having this pointed out it says an awful lot about them.

What I should have explained was that simply saying "Take the Challenge" will be dismissed; people either won't ever have heard of it, or won't think it's applicable. You should instead list the facts against electro-sensitivity - there's no shortage of them.

Of course they will dismiss it because they don't think it's applicable. That's the oldest excuse in the book. As has been discussed in other threads, the challenge isn't just a tool for examining paranormal claims, it is also a tool for arguing against paranormal claims. If someone claims to be able to do something that the JREF would accept as paranormal (and I see no reason why this wouldn't be), then any refusal to take the challenge is effectively admitting that the claim is false. Of course, I am not suggesting that you should not point out the many problems with the claim, but the challenge is another useful argument that allows us to say "If this is true, then why won't anyone test it?".
 
They are claiming that humans can detect something that all known science says they cannot detect. This is a paranormal claim.
I agree with Cuddles. To put too fine a point on it, how to characterize their claim is separate from the claim. They may claim that their claim is not paranormal, but that is a separate issue from the claim itself about electricity. We can claim that their claim is paranormal and that's a whole 'nother discussion than whether the claim about electricity is true or not.
 
OK. I'll try just one more time to get my specific point across:
1) These people have probably not heard of the MDC, so unless you include a lengthy explanation, they'll dismiss it;
2) If they have heard of the MDC, they'll think it doesn't apply to them, only to people like Uri Geller;
3) Banging on about the MDC simply gets you labelled, for them, as wackos on the same level as JWs and Scientologists, so they have an excuse to ignore you.
4)These people aren't claiming any special powers - they just say that wi-fi is the cause of their illnesses and that medical science and Big Tech is ignoring/covering up this 'fact'. Telling them to take the MDC is like telling the Loose Changers to take the Challenge.

Now I'm abandoning this thread.
 
Last edited:
If there'd be an easy mil in for me by showing something I firmly believe in/consider true/have no doubt about, I'd be all ears.

I'd certainly not ignore or dismiss it but try to collect the mil and give a [result of defecation] about any comments from anyone.

What is to misunderstand about: "Prove your claim and get a Million Dollars"? (I.e.: Very likely no more material worries for me and my children.)
 
If there'd be an easy mil in for me by showing something I firmly believe in/consider true/have no doubt about, I'd be all ears.

I'd certainly not ignore or dismiss it but try to collect the mil and give a [result of defecation] about any comments from anyone.

What is to misunderstand about: "Prove your claim and get a Million Dollars"? (I.e.: Very likely no more material worries for me and my children.)


Gzuzkryst, that is an excellent piece of rational thinking on the matter. And that's the problem.

You see, despite the MDC and its promotion, the True believers still believe. How? I think Sofia has done a very good job of looking into the motivations and thoughts of the True believers to explain it.

The smarter/con woos detect the MDC as a threat and start exercising pressure on the others to consider it A Bad Thing. Eventually peer pressure triumphs and the woos rationalize that the MDC has nothing to do with reason or transparacy but is nothing but a con. Sofia appears to suggest a softer, side stepping approach to try to overcome that and try and coax the True believers to discover the MDC for themselves, rather than push it in their face like a Jehovah's witness.
 
Gzuzkryst, that is an excellent piece of rational thinking on the matter. And that's the problem.

You see, despite the MDC and its promotion, the True believers still believe. How? I think Sofia has done a very good job of looking into the motivations and thoughts of the True believers to explain it.

The smarter/con woos detect the MDC as a threat and start exercising pressure on the others to consider it A Bad Thing. Eventually peer pressure triumphs and the woos rationalize that the MDC has nothing to do with reason or transparacy but is nothing but a con. Sofia appears to suggest a softer, side stepping approach to try to overcome that and try and coax the True believers to discover the MDC for themselves, rather than push it in their face like a Jehovah's witness.

In this case, I would not suggest the Kimpatsu Browbeat Approach. Also no steamhammer or knee-jerking. Something like this:

Drelda: You really claim this happens to you?
Woman: Of course.
Drelda: Would you be willing to show this to others?
Woman: Well, I already have.
Drelda: Would you show it again and get a million US Dollars for it?
Woman: ___.



Only a very small number of people do not need to collect the mil to satisfy our most basic drive, survival. Most blue collar people do.

If you could spare yourself 30-40 years of work by simply proving what you claim, no reasonable person would decline this, would she?
 
Hi,

We need to be careful not to mix up the general idea of electro-sensitivity (ie health impacts etc) and the specific claim that someone can sense wifi.

I don't think the idea of health impacts from EM waves is a paranormal claim. Seems unlikely to me - but I guess its possible they will be proved right on that.

However being able to 'sense' the presence of a wireless network with no external equipment seems to require some entirely new biology or physics - so that seems like a hardcore paranormal claim.

I've managed to get a contact address for the woman in the article - given that the opinion here seems to be that the claim would be challenge worthy I'll send her a letter telling her about the prize and inviting her to apply.

- Drelda
 
Hi,

We need to be careful not to mix up the general idea of electro-sensitivity (ie health impacts etc) and the specific claim that someone can sense wifi.

I don't think the idea of health impacts from EM waves is a paranormal claim. Seems unlikely to me - but I guess its possible they will be proved right on that.

However being able to 'sense' the presence of a wireless network with no external equipment seems to require some entirely new biology or physics - so that seems like a hardcore paranormal claim.

I've managed to get a contact address for the woman in the article - given that the opinion here seems to be that the claim would be challenge worthy I'll send her a letter telling her about the prize and inviting her to apply.

- Drelda

Drelda, if you can pinpoint the issue at hand to a specific question (E.g.: "Would abc qualify for the Challenge?") concerning its applicability to the JREF Challenge, I suggest you e-mail Jeff Wagg at [email protected]

He is an official JREF Representative and his word counts.

The Forum Members only give their opinions.
 
I personally don't believe the ability to sense "Wi-Fi" signals, radio signals, etc... Counts as something paranormal. These signals are something physical, and they CAN sometimes conflict with people, and in some cases, make them sick. Even they should know that it's all scientific, and they should go to a scientist or a doctor for advice on it.

For example, I have the "Ability" to sense when a Television is on while closing my eyes. This isn't a "paranormal" ability, it's nothing more than pure science of the fact that televisions radiate a high pitched frequency, and I just apparently can notice it when others can't. If being sensitive to electronic sounds, and signals that are actually THERE and conflict with human sense is paranormal, then maybe I should apply for such a challenge. However, I don't see how it can be "paranormal."
 
I suppose there could be some kind of galvanic response going on. I wonder if she has any metal in her body besides fillings. I imagine that if she had some fillings made from different metals, like silver and gold, at the right distances and angles, it could set up some kind of galvanic feedback that could create the feeling of her illness.

- - -

The Texas A&M University System Health Science Center:

Question: "The best way I can describe my problem is this. Have you ever put a fork (or metallic item) against a silver type filling in your mouth? Well that is the feeling I have almost all the time. It gets worse with certain load frequencies. I think it may be related to the metal filling. Any ideas about this?"

Answer: "Some patients actually report being able to pick up radio stations on their fillings. Sounds like you have a similar problem. The situation stems from the fact that metals are conductive and saliva can act like a wire to connect the two metals or in your case the two or more fillings. This phenomenon is know as a "galvanic reaction" and is more pronounced in some people. It simply means that there is a "connection" between two metals. Since silver fillings contain several different metals, you only need one filling to create the connection. The "current" that flows is stronger when two very different metals are in contact, hence a spoon against a filling causes a strong sensation.

This information may be more than you wanted to know but the phenomena of galvanic reaction is not harmful to the patient but may accelerate the corrosion of your silver restorations. Foods that lower the pH of your saliva will "enhance" the galvanic reactions. You don't mention what occurred recently to make it more pronounced. Sometimes sealing over the silver fillings can help eliminate the occurrence for a while but the sealant doesn't last and so you would be back to square one. Hope this helps. And thanks you for your question."

http://www.tambcd.edu/DentalCE/askdoc/html/antenna_teeth_.html

- - - - - - -

Work like you don't need the money. Love like you've never been hurt. Dance like nobody's watching. ~ Satchel Paige
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom