Abenomics: medicine or poison for Japan?

Medicine or poison?

  • Medicine

    Votes: 12 27.3%
  • Poison

    Votes: 3 6.8%
  • Don't know

    Votes: 18 40.9%
  • Planet X

    Votes: 11 25.0%

  • Total voters
    44


OK, the effect of the tax hike on the second quarter was anticipated. I want to see what happens in Q3 and Q4 before pronouncing judgment. I think it is a necessary evil because the debt cannot keep spiraling higher forever.
 
They are now considering a second tax hike, from 8% to 10% (the previous one was from 5% to 8%), to go into effect next October. No decision will be taken until December though.

http://the-japan-news.com/news/article/0001567961

Prime Minister Shinzo Abe on Sunday underscored his intention to consider carefully from a neutral standpoint whether to go ahead with the planned second-stage consumption tax hike to 10 percent in October 2015.

“The economy has a life of its own, so I will look at it [tax hike] neutrally,” Abe said on an NHK program.

He is believed to be looking mainly at economic data for July-September after the government raised the consumption tax rate from 5 percent to 8 percent on April 1.

“If the economy takes a rapid downturn [due to the additional tax hike], tax revenue will not increase as we wish,” Abe said, indicating his priority of pulling the economy out of deflation.

“We have to pursue the dual goals of achieving economic growth and fiscal reconstruction,” he added.

Abe is expected to decide later this year whether to go ahead with the additional tax increase.

He revealed that before making the decision, he plans to bring together experts for intensive meetings to hear their opinions on the tax hike from a macroeconomic standpoint.

Meanwhile, the Nikkei is once again above 16,000 (barely) at this moment and the yen has weakened to 108.5 to the dollar.
 
Well this morning the initial estimate for Q3 GDP was announced, and it wasn't good. The figure is only a first estimate and will be revised eventually, but no telling which direction it will be revised, and it will be at least another month before that happens.

A survey of economists had predicted a modest rebound, but instead the economy contracted again, making for two consecutive quarters of negative growth, which is a recession according to one popular definition. It seems likely that Abe will now dissolve the Diet and call a snap election, and that a second planned hike in the consumption tax next year will be delayed.

(Reuters) - Japan's economy shrank an annualised 1.6 percent in July-September, confounding expectations for a modest rebound after a severe contraction in the previous quarter and solidifying the view premier Shinzo Abe will delay a second sales tax hike next year.

Abe has said Monday's GDP data would be key to his decision on whether to proceed with the increase to 10 percent in October next year. That decision had been expected by year-end.

The second straight quarter of contraction, which compared with a 2.1 percent increase forecast in a Reuters poll, added to signs the world's third-largest economy has been slow in healing from the blow to consumption from the first tax increase in April.

The April tax hike to 8 percent from 5 percent led to a revised 7.3 percent economic contraction in the second quarter, which was the biggest decline since the global financial crisis.

Given the prolonged pain from the April hike, an official close to the premier has told Reuters that Abe would postpone the second increase and call a general election in an effort to lock in his grip on power.

Abe, who is returning on Monday from a week-long tour to attend a host of global meetings in Beijing to Australia, is set to make a decision this week, Japanese media have said.

On a quarter-on-quarter basis, the economy fell 0.4 percent in the third quarter after a revised 1.9 percent decrease in April-June. Economists had expected growth of 0.5 percent.
 
Why do they keep repeating the same kind of mistakes? Easing at the monetary end and tightening at the fiscal (just like in 1997). Stupid policy.

When aggregate demand is lacking, fiscal policy wins hands down.
 
Last edited:
Why do they keep repeating the same kind of mistakes? Easing at the monetary end and tightening at the fiscal (just like in 1997). Stupid policy.

When aggregate demand is lacking, fiscal policy wins hands down.

Well I would assume that they are worried about the debt levels.

The fiscal end has been loose for a long time to build up so much debt.

Government outlays have exceeded revenues by a large amount for a long time.

Maybe if they had done it right in the first place, like back in the 1990s or early 2000s, they wouldn't be in such a fix now.

There are other issues too, like the demographics and, since 2011, the lack of output from nuclear power. (It has become very unpopular politically, despite the fact that it would help reduce energy imports.)
 
Well I would assume that they are worried about the debt levels.

The fiscal end has been loose for a long time to build up so much debt.

Government outlays have exceeded revenues by a large amount for a long time.

Maybe if they had done it right in the first place, like back in the 1990s or early 2000s, they wouldn't be in such a fix now.

There are other issues too, like the demographics and, since 2011, the lack of output from nuclear power. (It has become very unpopular politically, despite the fact that it would help reduce energy imports.)

Sure, but when the government tightens its fiscal stance (when AD is already lackluster), what results is not necessarily a smaller deficit. It may grow larger as private consumption decreases even further. I agree with the timing thou: I guess they would have needed some kind of private sector debt write-down in the 1990s; followed by a larger share of government spending touching households rather than the financial sector.
 
When aggregate demand is lacking, fiscal policy wins hands down.
Japan has had a general government deficit in excess of -8% of GDP every year since 2009 (will include this year). Not exactly a ringing endorsement of fiscal policy (nor is the record much of one for monetary policy either) . . . unless one's perennial response to this suggestion is "Well it clearly was not enough (stimulus)"
 
Japan has had a general government deficit in excess of -8% of GDP every year since 2009 (will include this year). Not exactly a ringing endorsement of fiscal policy (nor is the record much of one for monetary policy either) . . . unless one's perennial response to this suggestion is "Well it clearly was not enough (stimulus)"

The deficit by itself doesn't tell that much about fiscal policy or "stimulus". It does, however, tell us that the private sector has been running quit a surplus (saving). In regards to GDP growth, they should have done away with a great deal of private debt in the 1990s. Maybe the government could also have taken over a larger role in terms of fixed income, so as to de-incentivize extreme private sector saving?
 
Well I would assume that they are worried about the debt levels.

The fiscal end has been loose for a long time to build up so much debt.

Government outlays have exceeded revenues by a large amount for a long time.

Maybe if they had done it right in the first place, like back in the 1990s or early 2000s, they wouldn't be in such a fix now.

Japan's NET debt falls between Portugal & Greece - bad but not off the charts as the public debt figures imply.

I don't understand that - why would a bad policy implemented earlier do anything but hasten the current status ?


There are other issues too, like the demographics and, since 2011, the lack of output from nuclear power. (It has become very unpopular politically, despite the fact that it would help reduce energy imports.)

+1, and nuclear was a big part (~30%) of their national elec supply. I understand they are restarting a few plants.

Sure, but when the government tightens its fiscal stance (when AD is already lackluster), what results is not necessarily a smaller deficit. It may grow larger as private consumption decreases even further.

Agreed, but Abenomics seemed like a poor idea to start with. They are now running the ~2% avg (or better) inflation rate they wanted, their currency dropped as expected. This effectively robs savers (most of Japanese individual investment is in Jbonds) and consumers . The 2% per annum loss in LT savings is certain to have a negative wealth effect, but perhaps not enough to cause a dramatic decline in Jbond holding behavior/tradition/market-inefficiency. You can't improve real GDP by accounting tricks, but the tricks have secondary effects.

Yes tax increases add the the negative wealth effect, and is likely a major driver of the big negative GDP changes, but so are their slowing exports. It's a brilliant way to hollow-out retail consumption.


I agree with the timing thou: I guess they would have needed some kind of private sector debt write-down in the 1990s; followed by a larger share of government spending touching households rather than the financial sector.

We can speculate about counterfactuals all day - none of this represents a convincing argument.


Keynes was a brilliant guy, and IMO accurately assessed that the consumer fears, or the 'negative wealth effect' can lead to reduced retail consumption, therefore forcing a decline in production and ... a vicious circle (tho' at some point a self-limiting one). His proposed solution, to have government make up the shortfall in consumption, on a short term basis seems to be quite problematic in practice. Government can stimulate either by additional deficit spending or by tax reductions. Tax reductions on a short term basis seem likely to be ineffective in overcoming the consumer reluctance to spend. It would require a long term reliable reduction to convince someone to buy a house or car. Added deficit spending by government is likely inefficient with a low multiplier, but also it stimulates different market sectors - the government buys tanks, roads and bridges, not iphones and pay-per-view events. So the wrong sectors are stimulated/over-stimulated. Of course Keynes allowed for the government stimulating by reducing interest rates - TO BORROWERS - but that doesn't effectively happen in the US where Government crowds-out private borrowing, and sets very high bars for bank lending I don't know the internals of Japan lending, but the GDP figures include negative investment growth, implying a comparable problem. Maybe government taking up the slack isn't the right solution.

Japan has a different problem tho' - they had a working population inversion before we did, and their only export (manufacturing value add) has heavy competition. A stagnant or declining GDP is not unforeseeable.
 
Last edited:
What does "fiscal policy wins hands down" mean, or imply? Ever increasing deficits?

It basically means money transferred from the government to households. You could think of infrastructure investments as well, but for Japan that does not seem fruitful (unless the energy sector is in for an overhaul; unemployment rate is already quite low).

The government deficit is a reaction to private sector saving. So why does the private sector need to save so much?

Japan's sectoral balances:
 
Last edited:
You have lost me with what this has to do with "fiscal policy wins hands down" in respect of Japan. Japan hardly advertises that it does.
 
You have lost me with what this has to do with "fiscal policy wins hands down" in respect of Japan. Japan hardly advertises that it does.

Well, if the problem is insufficient aggregate demand, monetary policy is not going to raise it as much as fiscal policy. And in Japan's case, you might need to do a kind of sustained money transfer straight to households (as the specific kind of fiscal mechanism).
 
Last edited:
Which is back to what I said had to be your conclusion in the first post I made. The most expansionary fiscal policy the world has ever seen is merely not enough. But it still "wins hands down" as a policy lever.

Colour me sceptical. I think the case is tenuous, to say the least.
 
In the past Japan was famous for lavish government spending on infrastructure projects that continued for most of the "lost decade" iirc. They may have dialed that back although perhaps Abe has revived it.

I think demographics s the main thing. There's never going to be strong economic growth. What we should hope for is to have some growth or at least not contraction on a per capita basis. The news never mentions per capita figures when GDP is reported.

The good news in Japan is that, despite everything, unemployment is still low, and it's still a very livable country without major social unrest.
 
Last edited:
Which is back to what I said had to be your conclusion in the first post I made. The most expansionary fiscal policy the world has ever seen is merely not enough. But it still "wins hands down" as a policy lever.

Colour me sceptical. I think the case is tenuous, to say the least.

First, government expenditure and revenue grew pretty much in tandem between 1975 and 1990 (expenditure rose by 48.4 T ¥ and revenue by 46.3 T ¥). Since 1990 the expenditure trend has been rising at a slower pace (1990-2014 = +26.6 T ¥). However, revenue during the same period has been declining – not rising – so that we are, for example, looking at -10.1 T ¥ in revenue in 2014 compared to 1990.

So what we have here is a growing gap between expenditure and revenue since 1990, not because explosive growth in government expenditure but, to an important degree, because a sequential decline in government revenue, and that gap has been financed by bond issuance (i.e. accumulation of government debt). Yet somehow you assume mere financing of that gap through bond issuance indicates the most expansionary fiscal policy the world has ever seen. Well, if you simply compare debt to GDP you could say that, but is that a meaningful assessment? Not in my view.

Second, looking at OECD statistics about government spending in terms of (A) percentage of GDP; (B) expenditure per person; (C) annual percentage change of government expenditures per person (2000-2009) … will have Japan scoring below OECD average.

Simply looking at government debt/GDP will not give you a meaningful picture here.
 
Last edited:
In the past Japan was famous for lavish government spending on infrastructure projects that continued for most of the "lost decade" iirc. They may have dialed that back although perhaps Abe has revived it.

I think demographics s the main thing. There's never going to be strong economic growth. What we should hope for is to have some growth or at least not contraction on a per capita basis. The news never mentions per capita figures when GDP is reported.

The good news in Japan is that, despite everything, unemployment is still low, and it's still a very livable country without major social unrest.

That could be entirely correct: they may not really need high growth anymore? Kind of like how F. Coppola ended her latest piece on Japan at Pieria:
F. Coppola said:
For countries with ageing populations, stagnation and low inflation are benign forces that should not be resisted. The countries of the old are places of calm and stability, not frenetic activity and fast growth. And in the sunset of a civilization, debt monetization may be a friend.


Looking at Japan's bond issuance, we can see how Construction bonds were the dominant issues until 1997 (and then a few bursts here and there afterwards) only to be overtaken by Special Deficit-Financing bonds after that.
 
Last edited:
We're about to find out what japan thinks of it

Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe said on Tuesday he would delay a planned rise in the nation's sales tax to 10 per cent till April 2017 and call a snap election to seek a fresh mandate, just two years after taking office.

The economy unexpectedly slipped into recession in the third quarter, data released on Monday showed, a sign the pain from an initial rise in the sales tax to 8 per cent from 5 per cent in April was lasting longer than expected.

Mr Abe said he would dissolve parliament on November 21.

http://www.theage.com.au/world/japanese-pm-shinzo-abe-calls-snap-election-20141118-11pc1m.html
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom