Puppycow
Penultimate Amazing
As a 'wrap' on the original Abenomics. Many sources have declared that original Abenomic a failure in the past 4 months or so and my interpretation of the new negative interest rate is that the Japanese government agrees. Particularly the attempt to increase workforce by gaining more female employment have failed. I personally don't think the other two "arrows" had a chance.
~2.7 years ago I suggested to lomiller that this policy would not create the growth he expected, and I predicted the obvious - that the yen would devalue.
The nikkae went from 13316 to 17518 yen ($136.40->$144.57) up 31.56% in nominal yen terms [+6% in dollar terms] . The YCS went from $65.35 to $88.66 which converts to(6380 -> 10743 yen) or a gain of 68.4% as yen [35.7% as dollars] by betting against the yen. This *suggests* that growth not real.
---
That 37% delta result is no doubt exaggerated (the yen/$ shifted 24%), but it appears that REAL growth in Japan was nearly nil, and inflation had a nice bump in 2014, but has evaporated - not close to the 2% target.
[qimg]http://www.alhambrapartners.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/ABOOK-Nov-2015-Japan-GDP-HH-Cons-less-Rent.jpg[/qimg]
I'd take a victory lap, but there is nothing plesant about this outcome.
--
Negative interest rate is will certainly assist the currency decline but other policy will be needed to generate growth. What is the qty of commercial lending in Japan ? What are commercial rates like ?
Well, I don't know that much about commercial lending rates. I do know what I pay on my mortgage, about 1.9% although that was a few years ago. Could have been lower if I'd taken an adjustable rate. I'm probably overpaying for the certainty of a fixed rate at that. Of course this is with the benefit of hindsight. Yield on a 10-year government bond right now is 0.06%. Read that again. There's an extra zero there. Even the 30 year is barely above 1%. Might be a good time for me to explore refinancing options.
Eta: as far as "real" growth goes, we probably should ignore exchange rates because even if the yen lost a lot against the dollar, it's partly just payback for the rise of the yen when the fed did their QE. The yen is now back to where it was in 2007 before the financial crisis and the fed's QE. Inflation continues to be basically nil here. So you can basically look at nominal GDP.
If you don't convert to US dollars, per capita GDP on a PPP basis has stayed pretty steady. Japan's population is in decline and the working age population is in even faster decline. So expecting absolute growth of the economy is not realistic. So I like to look at it per capita.
Last edited: