Abenomics: medicine or poison for Japan?

Medicine or poison?

  • Medicine

    Votes: 12 27.3%
  • Poison

    Votes: 3 6.8%
  • Don't know

    Votes: 18 40.9%
  • Planet X

    Votes: 11 25.0%

  • Total voters
    44
As a 'wrap' on the original Abenomics. Many sources have declared that original Abenomic a failure in the past 4 months or so and my interpretation of the new negative interest rate is that the Japanese government agrees. Particularly the attempt to increase workforce by gaining more female employment have failed. I personally don't think the other two "arrows" had a chance.

~2.7 years ago I suggested to lomiller that this policy would not create the growth he expected, and I predicted the obvious - that the yen would devalue.



The nikkae went from 13316 to 17518 yen ($136.40->$144.57) up 31.56% in nominal yen terms [+6% in dollar terms] . The YCS went from $65.35 to $88.66 which converts to(6380 -> 10743 yen) or a gain of 68.4% as yen [35.7% as dollars] by betting against the yen. This *suggests* that growth not real.
---

That 37% delta result is no doubt exaggerated (the yen/$ shifted 24%), but it appears that REAL growth in Japan was nearly nil, and inflation had a nice bump in 2014, but has evaporated - not close to the 2% target.

[qimg]http://www.alhambrapartners.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/ABOOK-Nov-2015-Japan-GDP-HH-Cons-less-Rent.jpg[/qimg]

I'd take a victory lap, but there is nothing plesant about this outcome.
--

Negative interest rate is will certainly assist the currency decline but other policy will be needed to generate growth. What is the qty of commercial lending in Japan ? What are commercial rates like ?

Well, I don't know that much about commercial lending rates. I do know what I pay on my mortgage, about 1.9% although that was a few years ago. Could have been lower if I'd taken an adjustable rate. I'm probably overpaying for the certainty of a fixed rate at that. Of course this is with the benefit of hindsight. Yield on a 10-year government bond right now is 0.06%. Read that again. There's an extra zero there. Even the 30 year is barely above 1%. Might be a good time for me to explore refinancing options.

Eta: as far as "real" growth goes, we probably should ignore exchange rates because even if the yen lost a lot against the dollar, it's partly just payback for the rise of the yen when the fed did their QE. The yen is now back to where it was in 2007 before the financial crisis and the fed's QE. Inflation continues to be basically nil here. So you can basically look at nominal GDP.

If you don't convert to US dollars, per capita GDP on a PPP basis has stayed pretty steady. Japan's population is in decline and the working age population is in even faster decline. So expecting absolute growth of the economy is not realistic. So I like to look at it per capita.
 
Last edited:
Well, I don't know that much about commercial lending rates. I do know what I pay on my mortgage, about 1.9% although that was a few years ago. Could have been lower if I'd taken an adjustable rate. I'm probably overpaying for the certainty of a fixed rate at that. Of course this is with the benefit of hindsight. Yield on a 10-year government bond right now is 0.06%. Read that again. There's an extra zero there. Even the 30 year is barely above 1%. Might be a good time for me to explore refinancing options.

The Japanese 10yr went negative a couple days ago - sheesh!

Eta: as far as "real" growth goes, we probably should ignore exchange rates

It's still a ~35-37% delta no matter which currency we measure in. The wager I offered was between whether Abenomics would result in increased growth or decreased yen value. I did not anticipate any significant change in Japan's very modest growth while lomiller did. I did anticipate a lower yen as a result of ABenomics. My 3yr expectation might be a 5-10% lower yen, the 24% drop was unanticipated.

because even if the yen lost a lot against the dollar, it's partly just payback for the rise of the yen when the fed did their QE. The yen is now back to where it was in 2007 before the financial crisis and the fed's QE. Inflation continues to be basically nil here. So you can basically look at nominal GDP.

I don't think we can hand-wave away ~24% currency devaluation as mere reversion to the mean unrelated to the Abenomic BoJ policy to intentionally weaken the yen.

If you don't convert to US dollars, per capita GDP on a PPP basis has stayed pretty steady. Japan's population is in decline and the working age population is in even faster decline. So expecting absolute growth of the economy is not realistic. So I like to look at it per capita.

That doesn't surprise me at all. I expected Japan to continue w/ it's 3rd decade of poor but positive growth regardless of Abenomics. The only part of Abenomics that I thought had a chance of creating real growth was the attempt to increase the working population - but that part seems to have failed. So the intention to create 2% internal inflation failed also, but the loose money policy was part of the cause of the currency shift.

Aside from increasing workforce Abenomics seemed to me like a numerical game with currency - not a means of addressing fundamentals.
 
Last edited:
The Japanese 10yr went negative a couple days ago - sheesh!

Interesting! I just took a look. Currently the 10yr is positive again, although just barely, but the 2yr and 5yr maturities both have negative yields.
Not quite sure why someone would buy a bond with a negative yield. Seems like cash would be a better investment in that case.
http://www.bloomberg.com/markets/rates-bonds/government-bonds/japan


It's still a ~35-37% delta no matter which currency we measure in. The wager I offered was between whether Abenomics would result in increased growth or decreased yen value. I did not anticipate any significant change in Japan's very modest growth while lomiller did. I did anticipate a lower yen as a result of ABenomics. My 3yr expectation might be a 5-10% lower yen, the 24% drop was unanticipated.

Ah, well clearly you were right about that. What the weaker yen did do was to pump up the Nikkei though. Japanese companies get more profitable when the yen is weak. It was hoped that some of these profits would get passed on to workers and that could boost consumption but that doesn't appear to be materializing.

I don't think we can hand-wave away ~24% currency devaluation as mere reversion to the mean unrelated to the Abenomic BoJ policy to intentionally weaken the yen.

Not sure what your point is here though. It's true: just look up where the yen exchange rate was in 2007 vs. today. 2007 was the last full year before the global financial turmoil began in earnest although warning signs may have started blinking in 2007. Yes, the yen has been devalued a lot since abenomics started, but that's following an equal spike in the exchange rate that preceded it. Meanwhile, the prices of consumer goods here have stayed pretty flat the whole time. (I've lived here the whole time, btw). I bet if you went to a supermarket in 2007 or 2012 and today, you would not see much difference in the average prices at any of those times.

That doesn't surprise me at all. I expected Japan to continue w/ it's 3rd decade of poor but positive growth regardless of Abenomics. The only part of Abenomics that I thought had a chance of creating real growth was the attempt to increase the working population - but that part seems to have failed. So the intention to create 2% internal inflation failed also, but the loose money policy was part of the cause of the currency shift.

Aside from increasing workforce Abenomics seemed to me like a numerical game with currency - not a means of addressing fundamentals.

Well, the demographics and Japanese culture make it very hard to increase the size of the workforce. All these stay-at-home moms already have full-time jobs really. The men are not equipped to take on a greater share of domestic duties, being pampered by their mothers from an early age. You can't teach an old dog new tricks as they say. You can either have children and a family or you can have a career if you are a woman, unless you are some kind of superwoman.
 
Time for another update I suppose:

Consumer prices fall for 5th straight month

TOKYO —

Japanese inflation continued to disappoint in July, according to data released on Friday, with consumer prices dropping for a fifth straight month in the latest blow to Tokyo’s faltering war on deflation.

The 0.5% decline in July was worse than the 0.4% average fall expected by economists.

Friday’s data come ahead of household spending numbers next week, which are also expected to be disappointing, and after Japan’s July exports suffered their sharpest monthly fall in seven years.

Japanese officials are under intense pressure to deliver, as many economists increasingly write off Prime Minister Shinzo Abe’s faltering bid to fire up the world’s number three economy, dubbed Abenomics.

Last week, official figures showed the economy registered zero growth on-quarter, falling below economists’ expectations for a modest 0.2% expansion, as weak exports and a fall in business spending dented activity.

There's more in the article.

Prices remain deflationary. The yen is back to around 100 to the USD. The BoJ disappointed markets by not expanding QE. The government recently passed a 28-trillion-yen spending bill in hopes of sparking growth, and consumption tax hikes have been postponed.
 
I don't know if this subject interests anyone because it involves central banks and monetary policy. It's something a lot of people have difficulty in understanding, including myself. But I read this article about the latest statement from the Bank of Japan, and it got me thinking and looking for more information about what is really going on here.

First this:

BOJ Shifts Policy Framework to Targeting Japan’s Yield Curve

Some of the interesting sentences:

The Bank of Japan shifted the focus of its monetary stimulus Wednesday from expanding the money supply to controlling interest rates, which some economists deemed as further evidence that BOJ policy had reached the limits of its effectiveness.

The central bank said it would adjust the volume of its asset purchases, the core of its framework until now, as necessary in the short term to control bond yields, while keeping it at about 80 trillion yen ($780 billion) annually over the long term. The BOJ also scrapped a target for the average maturity of its holdings of government bonds.

"Annually over the long term". What exactly does "the long term" mean? Like all central bank speak, it's sort of a vague open-ended term. But I sense what it means is, indefinitely. As long as there are bonds to buy, and inflation remains low, they will keep buying 80 trillion yen in government debt every month.

So what does that mean?

Yuichi Kodama, chief economist at Meiji Yasuda Life Insurance Co. in Tokyo, saw the shift as a tacit admission by the BOJ that it has reached the limits of its JGBs purchases. The BOJ now owns more than a third of outstanding JGBs, with the pace of its buying draining the market of supply.

"If it takes additional easing in the future, it will probably deepen the negative rate," he said.

So that means that over one third of Japanese government debt is held by the bank of Japan. And that ratio is rising every month which effectively means:

Japan’s Debt Burden Is Quietly Falling the Most in the World

Japan for years has been renowned for having the world’s largest government debt load. No longer.
That’s if you consider how the effective public borrowing burden is plunging -- by one estimate as much as the equivalent of 15 percentage points of gross domestic product a year, putting it on track toward a more manageable level.
Accounting for the Bank of Japan’s unprecedented government bond buying from private investors, which some economists call "monetization" of the debt, alters the picture. Though the bond liabilities remain on the government’s balance sheet, because they aren’t held by the private sector any more they’re effectively irrelevant, according to a number of analysts looking at the shift.

“Japan is the country where public debt in private hands is falling the fastest anywhere,” said Martin Schulz, a senior economist at Fujitsu Research Institute in Tokyo.

So Japan has figured out how to magically pay down its debt by printing money, and without causing inflation or high interest rates. Both are lower than just about anywhere else. Interest rates are even negative in some cases and very close to zero in others. Inflation likewise ranges from negative to very low.

So, that's why it is nice to have a central bank.
What is the downside? Well if you are saving for retirement, you'll need to find something other than government bonds to invest in if you want any kind of yield.
 
I also think it's projected that pretty soon the government of Japan (one of the world's largest creditors) will be receiving more interest on its assets than it pays on its debt.
 
Well, I don't know that much about commercial lending rates. I do know what I pay on my mortgage, about 1.9% although that was a few years ago. Could have been lower if I'd taken an adjustable rate. I'm probably overpaying for the certainty of a fixed rate at that. Of course this is with the benefit of hindsight. Yield on a 10-year government bond right now is 0.06%. Read that again. There's an extra zero there. Even the 30 year is barely above 1%. Might be a good time for me to explore refinancing options.

Basically, this means that households are so broke that they can't borrow money. Not a good thing. This also happened in Japan in the early 2000's and was a result not necessarily of people being broke, but having pretty-much no disposable income at hand to spend. Because...during the late 1980's and early 1990's, households lost a fortune in the Japanese Stock markets and also paid waaaaaay too much for their over-priced homes. The situation has impacted the Japanese economy for over 20 years.

http://www.global-rates.com/interest-rates/central-banks/central-bank-japan/boj-interest-rate.aspx
 
Last edited:
Well, the 10-y government bond yield is currently negative in Switzerland, Germany, Netherlands and Finland, including Japan (and in Denmark it's just about zero)… so no, I would not say these yields are an indication of households being broke.
 
The ratio of household debt to GDP in Japan is around 66%. For comparison, in the USA it's around 80%.

I don't think the problem is that Japanese households are unable to borrow money.
 
The ratio of household debt to GDP in Japan is around 66%. For comparison, in the USA it's around 80%.

I don't think the problem is that Japanese households are unable to borrow money.

But...the Japanese are relatively high savers who WON'T borrow money when they have a lot of debt. Yeah...they could borrow a bit more, but they won't.

Also, there is Japan's funky corporate debt that was accrued in the late 1980's and early 1990's. When I say "Funky", I mean it was non-capital debt (like real-estate) that did not nessessarily add to the productive capacities of the companies. Hence, it was more difficult for these companies to work themselves out of debt.

In the other hand, China has low household debt and huge Corporate Debt. And the Corporate Debt is capital debt. So there really is no problem.
 
Why not make a Japanese Government Program designed to destroy property values throughout Japan? As property values are destroyed, more people can afford cheaper homes and have a lot more income left over to spend.

The Japanese government could form a Corporation whose main job is to build homes and sell them as cheap as possible. This will put people to work building homes and the infrastructure that supports them. As home prices fall, and people start borrowing more money to buy them, interest rates will eventually rise until the level of new homes built reaches natural saturation...and new construction slows.

Eventually, a similar program could be considered for industrial property.

In short, introduce the non-profit real-estate developer in Japan, and that will fix the problem.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom