A coherent definition of God

 
Trakar - I would appreciate your explanation how faith can also be a considered decision.

Consideration is the process of thoughtful (internal and external) examination of an issue. The weighted evaluation of a subject merely according to objective observations and standards (empiric evidences) is certainly one often valuable form of consideration.

Not that I have never tried to apply objective empirical examinations to the issue of a Creator, merely that the end result of my empiric considerations have always proven to be inconclusive, indicating no distinguishable differences between a created universe and a spontaneous universe.

Given that, and with the guidance of more subjective considerations, I choose to believe that the universe (all that is) was created.

That is the core element of my faith.
 
Consideration is the process of thoughtful (internal and external) examination of an issue. The weighted evaluation of a subject merely according to objective observations and standards (empiric evidences) is certainly one often valuable form of consideration.

Not that I have never tried to apply objective empirical examinations to the issue of a Creator, merely that the end result of my empiric considerations have always proven to be inconclusive, indicating no distinguishable differences between a created universe and a spontaneous universe.

Given that, and with the guidance of more subjective considerations, I choose to believe that the universe (all that is) was created.

That is the core element of my faith.
Thanks for the answer. I will give it some consideration before offering a response if I think one is required.
 
Consideration is the process of thoughtful (internal and external) examination of an issue. The weighted evaluation of a subject merely according to objective observations and standards (empiric evidences) is certainly one often valuable form of consideration.

Not that I have never tried to apply objective empirical examinations to the issue of a Creator, merely that the end result of my empiric considerations have always proven to be inconclusive, indicating no distinguishable differences between a created universe and a spontaneous universe.

Given that, and with the guidance of more subjective considerations, I choose to believe that the universe (all that is) was created.

That is the core element of my faith.

God manifested to you?
 
Consideration is the process of thoughtful (internal and external) examination of an issue. The weighted evaluation of a subject merely according to objective observations and standards (empiric evidences) is certainly one often valuable form of consideration.

Not that I have never tried to apply objective empirical examinations to the issue of a Creator, merely that the end result of my empiric considerations have always proven to be inconclusive, indicating no distinguishable differences between a created universe and a spontaneous universe.

Given that, and with the guidance of more subjective considerations, I choose to believe that the universe (all that is) was created.

That is the core element of my faith.

I don't understand what you mean by - "subjective considerations".

What non-empiric "things" (non- things) did/can you consider to choose your belief that you have faith in?

I can understand (whatever) considerations being the core element of your belief, but not faith (at least by your definition of faith).
 
Last edited:
I don't understand what you mean by - "subjective considerations".

Subjective - judgment based on individual personal impressions and feelings and opinions rather than external facts

Consideration -the process of thoughtful (internal and external) examination of an issue.

What non-empiric "things" (non- things) did/can you consider to choose your belief that you have faith in?

Feelings, intuition, emotional draw, esthetics, past experience and other individual and community opinions and impressions, etc., but these are influences not independent or consistently valued items that can be tabulated and totalled. The only value they contain is in my particular considered perception of them in relation to what I am considering.
 
Subjective - judgment based on individual personal impressions and feelings and opinions rather than external facts

Consideration -the process of thoughtful (internal and external) examination of an issue.

Feelings, intuition, emotional draw, esthetics, past experience and other individual and community opinions and impressions, etc., but these are influences not independent or consistently valued items that can be tabulated and totalled. The only value they contain is in my particular considered perception of them in relation to what I am considering.
I don’t agree. As I mentioned earlier beliefs (and impressions, feelings, intuition and the like) don’t just pop into peoples heads and they aren’t randomly drawn from a hat. They’re developed and formed by interaction and experiences with what you call “empiric evidences”. As such beliefs are no less related to “empiric evidences” than knowledge. Essentially beliefs are “empiric evidences” interpreted by emotions and knowledge is “empiric evidences” interpreted by intelligence.
 
Last edited:
I don't believe that God interacts with the physical universe.
This is an issue of personal speculation not an issue of faith.

So your god is totally within your mind?
 
Defining something that can be anything is anything but possible.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
I don't believe that God interacts with the physical universe.This is an issue of personal speculation not an issue of faith.



So basically he does not exist...if he does not interact with our reality then in what way does that differ from not existing?
 
Although it's like squinting at those 3D stereograms, I will attempt a translation into simple English.

Consideration is the process of thoughtful (internal and external) examination of an issue.

Consideration is thinking carefully about an issue.

The weighted evaluation of a subject merely according to objective observations and standards (empiric evidences) is certainly one often valuable form of consideration.
One kind of consideration is evaluation of stuff by evidence.

Not that I have never tried to apply objective empirical examinations to the issue of a Creator, merely that the end result of my empiric considerations have always proven to be inconclusive, indicating no distinguishable differences between a created universe and a spontaneous universe.
He tried evaluating the evidence, but failed to conclude anything.

Given that, and with the guidance of more subjective considerations, I choose to believe that the universe (all that is) was created.
Without a decision, he reached for emotions and experience* and chose a conclusion he liked.

* Some would argue that these are too evidence, of a degraded kind.

That is the core element of my faith.
His faith is "just because" and without conscious reason.

Trakar, does your Faith lead you to experience a God?
 
I don’t agree. As I mentioned earlier beliefs (and impressions, feelings, intuition and the like) don’t just pop into peoples heads and they aren’t randomly drawn from a hat. They’re developed and formed by interaction and experiences with what you call “empiric evidences”. As such beliefs are no less related to “empiric evidences” than knowledge. Essentially beliefs are “empiric evidences” interpreted by emotions and knowledge is “empiric evidences” interpreted by intelligence.

It is easy to confuse the term empiric, as it can have opposite meanings depending upon context. In reference to philosophy, empiricism refers to subjective knowledge gained only by direct personal experience without the use of outside information or understanding, whereas in science, empirical evidences are objective, quantifiable results provable by experiment. My use of the term "emipiric evidences" generally refers more to the scientific application to evidences that are of an objective physical nature and readily quantifiable. If it makes it easier for your considerations we can use terms that you are more comfortable with.

As to your content, it matters little if you disagree, that is simply your preference in an issue of subjective understandings. That we have different perspectives and understandings was an a priori given.
 
It is easy to confuse the term empiric, as it can have opposite meanings depending upon context.
As tsig said earlier . . .
If you redefine words to have your own idiosyncratic meanings soon you'll be talking to yourself because no one else will understand you.

In reference to philosophy, empiricism refers to subjective knowledge gained only by direct personal experience without the use of outside information or understanding,
By what method is this possible? Even dreams, delusions and fantasies are formed by "outside information". If you mean some mystical, spiritual experience from "the other side" please fess-up and just say that.

whereas in science, empirical evidences are objective, quantifiable results provable by experiment. My use of the term "emipiric evidences" generally refers more to the scientific application to evidences that are of an objective physical nature and readily quantifiable. If it makes it easier for your considerations we can use terms that you are more comfortable with.
“Scientific application” is the only meaningful way I can use and accept the term.

As to your content, it matters little if you disagree, that is simply your preference in an issue of subjective understandings. That we have different perspectives and understandings was an a priori given.
Agreed (Yay!).
 
Last edited:
Not that I have never tried to apply objective empirical examinations to the issue of a Creator, merely that the end result of my empiric considerations have always proven to be inconclusive, indicating no distinguishable differences between a created universe and a spontaneous universe.
So your search for evidence of a creation and a creator by way if credible means was a total failure (conclusive) but you have trouble accepting it as such. Would you describe the results of a similar search for Santa, The Easter Bunny or Tooth Fairy as being “inconclusive“.

You missed the “always existed” option for the Universe.
 
Last edited:
I don't believe that God interacts with the physical universe.
This is an issue of personal speculation not an issue of faith.
Would have had to have interacted with it to have created it.
 
Last edited:
Defining something that can be anything is anything but possible.

Paul

:) :) :)
Depends on what attributes you look at. All gods are mythical beings. That's a factual definition supported by the evidence. To define each one of those myths individually makes less sense but even then you can list attribute themes like, "justifies behavior", and, creation and magical intervention themes are common.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom