A coherent definition of God

(...)

Trakar, does your Faith lead you to experience a God?

(I would not consider your translations accurate, but I can accept that to some perspectives those would be the closest kernels to any that they might generally be capable of accepting/understanding.)

If I had experience of God, what need would I have for Faith?
 
(I would not consider your translations accurate, but I can accept that to some perspectives those would be the closest kernels to any that they might generally be capable of accepting/understanding.)

If I had experience of God, what need would I have for Faith?

A simple yes or no was called for.
 
As tsig said earlier . . .



By what method is this possible? Even dreams, delusions and fantasies are formed by "outside information". If you mean some mystical, spiritual experience from "the other side" please fess-up and just say that.

As I explained, I use the term "empirical evidence" in the scientific application sense of the term not the philosophical, or more importantly the older "medical" application of the sense. If you wish to have a discussion of philosophical Empiricism and its comparison to say Realism, or Theism, I would be happy to enjoin that discussion, but it is not much relevent to the discussions of this thread.
 
I will attempt a translation . . .

(I would not consider your translations accurate, but I can accept that to some perspectives those would be the closest kernels to any that they might generally be capable of accepting/understanding.)
You're wrong and I'm smarter (more capable) than you and others that don't accept or understand what I say.

If I had experience of God, what need would I have for Faith?
No.
 
Would have had to have interacted with it to have created it.

Possibly, I am not privy to the methodologies of creation, and without recognizable evidences to examine it is beyond my ability to state one way or the other. As stated, this is simply a speculation.
 
Possibly, I am not privy to the methodologies of creation, and without recognizable evidences to examine it is beyond my ability to state one way or the other. As stated, this is simply a speculation.
Why you can't dip into your supply of "subjective considerations"?
 
@ Trakar - By whatever method/non-method you choose/decide to believe the Universe was created by a creator, do you equally choose/decide to believe this creator was also created by a creator and so on ad infinitum? If not why not.
 
Last edited:
So your search for evidence of a creation and a creator by way if credible means was a total failure (conclusive) but you have trouble accepting it as such. Would you describe the results of a similar search for Santa, The Easter Bunny or Tooth Fairy as being “inconclusive“.

You missed the “always existed” option for the Universe.

No, there is plenty of evidence to consider with regards to the creation of the visible universe, simply no way to conclusively determine (that I have found) whether or not there are any Divine fingerprints involved in that event. Of course, there is very little we can say about the universe beyond our perceptions and understandings.

As for Santa, the tooth fairy and the Easter bunny, there are evidences a plenty that confirm both the fictitious nature of their existence and the absence of their presence in the events oft attributed to them. Now if you had compared the Creator to the Flying Spaghetti Monster, you might have actually connected with a more salient analogy.
 
No, there is plenty of evidence to consider with regards to the creation of the visible universe, simply no way to conclusively determine (that I have found) whether or not there are any Divine fingerprints involved in that event. Of course, there is very little we can say about the universe beyond our perceptions and understandings.
Is all that saying you completely reject an "always existed" Universe option?

As for Santa, the tooth fairy and the Easter bunny, there are evidences a plenty that confirm both the fictitious nature of their existence and the absence of their presence in the events oft attributed to them. Now if you had compared the Creator to the Flying Spaghetti Monster, you might have actually connected with a more salient analogy.
Equally - As for god, there are evidences a plenty that confirm both the fictitious nature of "his" existence and the absence of "his" presence in the events oft attributed to "him".
 
Is all that saying you completely reject an "always existed" Universe option?

I don't reject it, there would have to be contraindicative evidences to a pre-existing eternal universe to reject the proposal, I know of no compelling grounds to reject the concept, likewise, I know of no compelling support for the concept. Lack of evidence does not reject a concept, it merely leaves the concept without compelling evidentiary support.

Equally - As for god, there are evidences a plenty that confirm both the fictitious nature of "his" existence and the absence of "his" presence in the events oft attributed to "him".

Not at all, you may be able to argue with some success, that there are evidences indicative that some beliefs and stories about God are fictitous, and others fictions or myths. If you know of compelling evidences against there being a Creator, however, you have something that seems to have eluded many very intelligent searchers, theist and atheist alike for many millenia, at the least. Please share this evidence.
 
Depends on what attributes you look at. All gods are mythical beings. That's a factual definition supported by the evidence. To define each one of those myths individually makes less sense but even then you can list attribute themes like, "justifies behavior", and, creation and magical intervention themes are common.

All gods are not mythical beings. The gods addressed by philosophers and mystics are gods which may exist irrespective of what humanity thinks(mythologises).

Either you accept that there may be aspects of existence(including creators) beyond our tiny existence. Or you are impelled to go down Piggy's road that nothing exists unless a human can think about it and if it does exist we would be aware of it.
 
(I would not consider your translations accurate, but I can accept that to some perspectives those would be the closest kernels to any that they might generally be capable of accepting/understanding.)

Who are you? Yoda?

Further questions asked would have; see way wind is blowing, I do.
 
Skeptic Ginger said:
All gods are mythical beings.
All gods are not mythical beings.

They are all mythical. It a pragmatic call. Also, it's the null hypothesis.

Either you accept that there may be aspects of existence(including creators) beyond our tiny existence.
There may indeed.

Here's a thought. You may have wings! They may unfold in case of emergency. Go jump off a tall building. Test jump off a short ladder.
Such wings are more likely than the "maybe" of your creators*. Why are you not trying it? Get a good run-up, push off for height. Go go go.
(Tweet on the way down.)
Try it and let us know how it goes by twitter.

* Unless you mean other sentients that create stuff. That's groovy. There's a thread for that.
 
Last edited:
They are all mythical. It a pragmatic call. Also, it's the null hypothesis.

There may indeed.

Here's a thought. You may have wings! They may unfold in case of emergency. Go jump off a tall building.
Such wings are more likely than the "maybe" of your creators*. Why are you not trying it? Get a good run-up, push off for height. Go go go.
(Tweet on the way down.)

* Unless you mean other sentients that create stuff. That's groovy. There's a thread for that.

awwww, shame. Expect a nice pm from a mod :)
 
Either the things that make up the universe always existed or they did not.

I think of God as the Origin, spirit and intent, separated from time.
 
Either the things that make up the universe always existed or they did not.

I think of God as the Origin, spirit and intent, separated from time.

Woospeak. Meaningless waffle. Even if the things that make up the universe have always existed why does that prove the existence of a god? Which one of the many gods that mankind has invented are you referring to?
 
Last edited:
Depends on what attributes you look at. All gods are mythical beings. That's a factual definition supported by the evidence. To define each one of those myths individually makes less sense but even then you can list attribute themes like, "justifies behavior", and, creation and magical intervention themes are common.


Still seeing that one can use any attributes for said god, still defining something that can be anything is anything but possible.

This thread can go on forever and still not come to any conclustion.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
I don't reject it, there would have to be contraindicative evidences to a pre-existing eternal universe to reject the proposal, I know of no compelling grounds to reject the concept, likewise, I know of no compelling support for the concept. Lack of evidence does not reject a concept, it merely leaves the concept without compelling evidentiary support.



Not at all, you may be able to argue with some success, that there are evidences indicative that some beliefs and stories about God are fictitous, and others fictions or myths. If you know of compelling evidences against there being a Creator, however, you have something that seems to have eluded many very intelligent searchers, theist and atheist alike for many millenia, at the least. Please share this evidence.

No difference there.
 
(I would not consider your translations accurate, but I can accept that to some perspectives those would be the closest kernels to any that they might generally be capable of accepting/understanding.)

If I had experience of God, what need would I have for Faith?

You're believing in something you don't have any reason to believe exists?

I've got a real old book here and it has your name in it and it says you owe me $100, do you believe it?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom