A coherent definition of God

God: An imagined something with testicles that made all the atoms in the Universe before there was time.

After He made the Universe, God proclaimed that He loved you, but if you didn't love him, He would torture you until the end of time.
 
A silly word invented for a silly book. I wonder how many of the woos know its origin?

I'll bet you've never participated in a water sharing ritual*.


*(pissing on the first one that passes out around the campfire.)
 
God: An imagined something with testicles that made all the atoms in the Universe before there was time.

After He made the Universe, God proclaimed that He loved you, but if you didn't love him, He would torture you until the end of time.

See, after making time, he found he needed some way to fill it, so he made us; he knew we'd be more than a handful so he made eternity with which to punish us.

At least that's how I understand the story so far.
 
God: An imagined something with testicles that made all the atoms in the Universe before there was time.

After He made the Universe, God proclaimed that He loved you, but if you didn't love him, He would torture you until the end of time.

The whole universe is just god's wet dream?
 
...That's part of the problem with words like 'faith', isn't it? We can't tell who's deceiving us and who's practicing the real thing...

Well, for the most part, such is irrelevent,...unless someone is trying to assert superiority, or exclude another's participation, rights or freedoms.

(I can accept 'faith' as being a purely contemplative, inner, meditative kind of thing. If it influences emotions and/or deeds that's evidence and so BZZZ! Problem! Loop. It polices itself and turns ever inwards; very Zen.)

no problem, to my consideration, with faith influencing thoughts, emotions, or deeds, so long as these influences do not result in substantive harm of self or others.

I still have to say I don't know what Faith (your kind) starts with.

for me, it was a well considered, but simple, decision.

What is the seed? Would that be a religion, some concept of God? What is the process that begins Faith?

I chose/decided on religion when young. When I was a little older, I became inconvenienced by and disbelieving of my religion, so I tried some other variations of religion. As an adult, I chose agnostic atheism, and then after a decade or so I chose agnostic theism. Occassional bouts of liberal, generalist, Catholicism or passive, vague atheism gain sway in my thoughts and considerations. I am intellectually comfortable with my faith and the flux of perspective. Faith like mine must be a considered decison.

I meant deal-with as in day to day inter-human stuff. Laws, economics, rights, privacy, health, the whole ball of wax. Reasonably as in reason, logic, clarity, agreed norms of decision making, etc.

Presumably, you mean how do I, with my faith, beliefs, understandings and considerations, interact with those who have different faith, beliefs, understandings and considerations. For me, this is of neccesity a case-by-case situation, requiring and involving understanding of the individual's faith, beliefs, and self-considerations of those faiths and beliefs.

If you are asking me how I feel society in general should deal with issues of individual faith and religion, the most simple responses probably revolve around understanding and maintaining the distinctions between individual rights, freedoms and responsibilities, group rights, freedoms and responsibilities and the role of government, groups and individuals in protecting and enforcing those rights, freedoms and responsibilities.

Or, if you approach this to address a "christian nation" perspective I would urge discussion and consideration of these four scriptural guidelines: "Therefore all things whatsoever ye would that men should do to you, do ye even so to them," "Judge not, that ye be not judged. For with what judgment ye judge, ye shall be judged: and with what measure ye mete, it shall be measured to you again." "Render therefore unto Caesar the things which are Caesar's; and unto God the things that are God's."

So, how to reason with a person about <something> when they are blocked from hearing you by their 'faith'.

why would it matter? Regardless of their faiths (or asserted lack thereof) if people close themselves off to discussion and the intellectual contemplations of ideas different than those already renting space in their mind, that is their loss. So long as they abide by the law and don't commit substantive harms against themselves or others, let them suffer the consequences of their own choices.

I think you have answered that ok. You'd go by the fruits (so-to-speak) of their faith and decide as best you can.


You can tell by my other responses that I am skeptical about this faith thing, but I have found the conversation enlightening thus far.

I, as well, with regards to both "faith thing," and "no faith thing." But skepticism is a valuable tool so long as it is kept sharp and properly applied. I always enjoy civil discussion and considerations, they are unfortunately uncommon.
 
Last edited:
Awww. I like grok. Heinlein not so much, but grok?... :( Just pretend you are hearing a Klingon say it. :)

For a long time, every time I heard one of my programmers sling out "grok" my first association was with Groo the Wanderer and I'd start craving cheese-whiz. I guess, with time we all pick up little bad linguistic practices from those around us.
 
for me, it (faith) was a well considered, but simple, decision.
Faith like mine must be a considered decison.
If your faith is a “considered decision” how can it be faith?

"Proofs" are the fodder of logic and logicisms, while that is one path to take, I rarely see much rigor in its application by either camp.

When it comes to faith, "proofs" are largely irrelevent. If you have faith and you run into compelling empiric evidences that support your faith, you no longer have faith, you have an evidence-based understanding that is as good and reliable as the empiric evidence supporting it. Likewise if you lack faith, empiric evidences aren't going to give you faith, they are merely going to present an evidence-based understanding that you will accept or attempt to refute.

Faith is not an empiric evidence-based state, it is a state of acceptance in the absence of empiric evidences. Note, not in the spite of empiric evidences, but in the absence of such evidences.
Isn’t all that essentially saying that faith is a non-considered, non-decision as in a blind confidence, trust or acceptance?
 
Last edited:
For a long time, every time I heard one of my programmers sling out "grok" my first association was with Groo the Wanderer and I'd start craving cheese-whiz. I guess, with time we all pick up little bad linguistic practices from those around us.

Were you aware of the origin of the word and it's association with Californian woospeak psychobabble?
 
Were you aware of the origin of the word and it's association with Californian woospeak psychobabble?

You mean Heinlein's "Stranger in a Strange Land" martian's were Californian woosters?
 
Okay so give it your best shot.

I can give a coherent definition, but "God" might not be what I'm describing as "God" is a human subjective concept.

However if I generalise God is;

The originator of the known universe in the form it takes.


This does not mean God is the originator of existence, or other forms of universes.

Also I have not included intelligence in the definition as intelligence is a phenomena exhibited by humans and may not be applicable to God.


As the prevalent philosophy on these boards seems to be materialism, in reality God is the Sun. In which case they are in agreement with occultists.
 
Last edited:
I can give a coherent definition, but "God" might not be what I'm describing as "God" is a human subjective concept.

However if I generalise God is;

The originator of the known universe in the form it takes. This does not mean God is the originator of existence, or other forms of universes.
Also I have not included intelligence in the definition as intelligence is a phenomena exhibited by humans and may not be applicable to God.


As the prevalent philosophy on these boards seems to be materialism, in reality God is the Sun. In which case they are in agreement with occultists.

I've missed your gibberish. God is the Sun, That's a good one. As for the highlighted part, coherent is not the word that springs to mind. God has no intelligence? I can believe that.
 
Last edited:
for me, it (faith) was a well considered, but simple, decision.
Faith like mine must be a considered decison.
If your faith is a “considered decision” how can it be faith?
"Proofs" are the fodder of logic and logicisms, while that is one path to take, I rarely see much rigor in its application by either camp.
When it comes to faith, "proofs" are largely irrelevent. If you have faith and you run into compelling empiric evidences that support your faith, you no longer have faith, you have an evidence-based understanding that is as good and reliable as the empiric evidence supporting it. Likewise if you lack faith, empiric evidences aren't going to give you faith, they are merely going to present an evidence-based understanding that you will accept or attempt to refute.
Faith is not an empiric evidence-based state, it is a state of acceptance in the absence of empiric evidences. Note, not in the spite of empiric evidences, but in the absence of such evidences.
Isn’t all that essentially saying that faith is a non-considered, non-decision as in a blind confidence, trust or acceptance?
 
Trakar - I would appreciate your explanation how faith can also be a considered decision.
 
No. The book was treated as a holy tract by the hippies.

And it was treated as classic Heinlein by geeks, nerds and assorted sci-fi fans for much of the last 50 years. I noted that I became familiar with the popular usage of the term from its (over)usage by many of the programmers I had working on my staff in the '80s. If you are only familiar with its usage from Hippies that used the term, I guess those are association issues you need to work through on your own, they aren't my problem or concern.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom