A coherent definition of God

You're believing in something you don't have any reason to believe exists?

I've got a real old book here and it has your name in it and it says you owe me $100, do you believe it?



You are not very good at shystering are you?
 
Not at all, you may be able to argue with some success, that there are evidences indicative that some beliefs and stories about God are fictitous, and others fictions or myths. If you know of compelling evidences against there being a Creator, however, you have something that seems to have eluded many very intelligent searchers, theist and atheist alike for many millenia, at the least. Please share this evidence.
I was mimicking your claim to mock it. I don’t believe you can disprove (or prove) the existence of a Santa, Tooth Fairy or Easter Bunny any more than I can of a god.

You give an example of “evidences a plenty that confirm both the fictitious nature of their existence and the absence of their presence in the events oft attributed to them” regarding Santa, Tooth Fairy and Easter Bunny.

In plain English - You provide a piece of credible evidence that proves Santa, Tooth Fairy and Easter Bunny don’t exist as you claim you can. You share your "evidences a plenty".
 
Last edited:
To keep this thread on topic . . .

God = A myth that isn’t any more credible than Santa, Tooth Fairy and Easter Bunny myths.
 
Still seeing that one can use any attributes for said god, still defining something that can be anything is anything but possible.

This thread can go on forever and still not come to any conclustion.

Paul

:) :) :)
The thread is not my measure of the validity of my definition. The evidence is. :)
 
I was mimicking your claim to mock it. I don’t believe you can disprove (or prove) the existence of a Santa, Tooth Fairy or Easter Bunny any more than I can of a god.

You give an example of “evidences a plenty that confirm both the fictitious nature of their existence and the absence of their presence in the events oft attributed to them” regarding Santa, Tooth Fairy and Easter Bunny.

In plain English - You provide a piece of credible evidence that proves Santa, Tooth Fairy and Easter Bunny don’t exist as you claim you can. You share your "evidences a plenty".

The several are not conditionally linked, my abilities to refute Santa, Easterbunny, or Tooth fairy are independent of your abilities or inabilities to support your assertions.

That said, beyond the historic progenitor of the Santa myth (Bishop Saint Nicholas), there has never been any serious proposal of the reality of these characters beyond their fairy tale existence. There is no role or place outside of the human mythos and we have the testimonies of millions of individuals who acknowledge having acted the part these characters. Additionally, the absence of these actors or the resultant indicators of existence beyond populations where the mythos exist would seem to indicate that understandings and exposure to the myths are necessary to spur individuals to act in accordance with the myths.

Neither creation, nor creator are dependent upon the mythos of creation for their existence. Please present your claimed evidences of non-existence.
 
Starting a response with a personal insult, is not conducive to further discussion.

He was just suggesting that you tone down the thesaurus a bit and stop using four polysyllabic words when one simple word. will do.
 
You're believing in something you don't have any reason to believe exists?

I have faith in the existence of a Creator. I know of no scientific evidences that compellingly support or reject the existence of that Creator.

I've got a real old book here and it has your name in it and it says you owe me $100, do you believe it?

You are claiming the physical existence of an object within the physical universe. Demonstrate the evidences and I will decide whether or not they amount to the compelling qualification. I have no faith in the accuracy of your assertion, but will yeild to the evidence if such is compelling.
 
He was just suggesting that you tone down the thesaurus a bit and stop using four polysyllabic words when one simple word. will do.

Your explanation does not excuse or negate the behavior.
 
No greater what?
of what can be thought.

You wanted a coherent definition of God.
"God is that which no greater can be thought."
is a coherent definition of God.

By the way, google is your friend. Try googling:
"God is that which no greater can be thought."

Don't blame me if you never hears of Anselm's ontological argument for the existence of God or Spinoza's definition of God.

If you are talking about the biblical God, that is different story and I am sorry I have overestimated you.
 
Last edited:
Your explanation does not excuse or negate the behavior.

I was not endeavoring to excuse or enucleate the comportment of the esteemed member. Rather, I was attempting to elucidate to you that the member referred to was merely enunciating that your missives are redolent of the Star Wars character Yoda.
 
of what can be thought.

You wanted a coherent definition of God.
"God is that which no greater can be thought." is a coherent definition of God.

By the way, google is your friend. Try googling:
"God is that which no greater can be thought."

Don't blame me if you never hears of Anselm's ontological argument for the existence of God or Spinoza's definition of God.

If you are talking about the biblical God, that is different story and I am sorry I have overestimated you.

Coherent is not the word that comes to mind. Greater disdain, laughter and derision fill in the space for me.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom