How do I know what? Whether or not their motivation is to deliberately deceive others or the result of simple ignorances and misunderstandings (as I stated)? I believe my words were: "it is, in my experience, most often simply matters of ignorance and/or misunderstanding." This experience is derived from engaging people in discussion and assessing their responses and considerations. It is definitely a subjective process, and I undoutably have made some mistakes or been deceived upon occassion.
One case is this distinguishing of honest faith from self-serving deception dressed as faith.
The two primary categories of division, to my considerations, are faith (based upon my earlier description) and beliefs based upon a lack of knowledge and understandings (ignorances) and/or confusions regarding basic knowledges and understandings (misunderstandings) being represented as faith. Purposeful self-serving deception is extremely rare among individuals, however, if I am reading the direction of your inquiry correctly, I would probably agree that this self-serving deception motivation is more prevelant among public figure proponents of their personal faith (religious leaders, politicians, etc.,).
Another case is the further interaction with the faithful wanting to continue <something> while we grow aware that such a course is not a good one.
I really don't grok this. If you can try to expand upon and explain this I would be happy to respond more appropriately to your comment.
Let's say you spoke to a psychic who believes that Angels are guiding her. She charges a lot of money to do her thing, but she appears genuine. She has a path that led her here, and so forth.
once it becomes a commercial venture, we aren't so much talking about only faith as we are about marketing, services and compensations, or at the least the issues become so complexly tangled that they are not easily isolated. This isn't to say that all such individuals are without faith, but merely that my assessment process isn't designed or experienced at trying to deal with those particular situations, and generally aren't something I regularly deal with or often contemplate.
Let's say that her clients are poor and cannot afford her ministrations. Let's say that her work hurts them financially. Let's say that they do not care and continue to employ her.
Much would depend upon local laws, but her actions would definitely conflict with my personal moral bearing. Probably not much differently than I would react to doctors, lawyers, or other merchants who acted similarly.
Her clients claim faith in her services...
I think we are starting to stretch fairly far away from my definition of faith and into the more generalized common (mis)usages and over applications of the term. Not that mine is right and all others are wrong, it is just that these others are not what I mean when I use the term.
— when pressed they can't find any evidence, they just feel <stuff> about the Angels, or her <spiritual stuff>.
"Feelings" are a type of evidence and/or the result of physical experiences and considerations, conscious and unconscious. As stated this is actually beyond the types of personal assessments I generally concern myself with and I've never run into such a situation. I'm not saying that the hypothetical you present is unrealistic or circular, but, I would not be satisfied with the result that they are unaware of making any evidence-based decisions regarding psychic abilities, Angels or this particular psychic's <spiritual stuff>.
What now? How do you judge her Faith? Her clients'?
If she is breaking laws: she is a criminal.
If she is acting in a manner I would consider immoral: I would consider her immoral.
Your hypothetical does not include me discussing her faith with her, so I really am not given the information I would need to assess her faith.
If her clients are behaving in a manner that is causing themselves and those dependent upon them serious harm: then what is there to judge or assess, their actions speak pretty much for themselves.
I don't consider life-coaches to be any more reputable than psychics. In fact I generally don't consider them to be as reputable, merely because I've met plenty of self-claimed psychics who aren't interested in compensation for their "gift," but I've never met a life-coach who wasn't interested in their fee.
I really don't see that this example fits your criteria (ie., interviewed and they didn't find any evidence, they just feel <stuff> about the Angels, or her <spiritual stuff>)
Your highlighted words are spot-on.
When someone claims Faith in <x> and performs deeds in the world according to <x> that affect people who do not believe <x> then we have a situation.
At that point Faith in <x> has to be asked for evidence. That's the point at which Faith — "it requires no evidence" — becomes a tyranny. You are essentially saying "just because," when someone else is asking you, "why are you hurting me?"
again not real clear in this section, but perhaps I am getting lost in your attempts to create what looks to me like a generic over-simplification. Please expand and clarify and I will try to give you a better response.
To come back to the OP. The route from a nebulous "God" down to a personal faith in <something> to do with that "God" is the road of tyranny.
Tyranny is an issue of the human condition, and it can express itself in many forms and through many faces to include religion, politics, economics, nationalism, racism, or virtually any belief system that incorporates exclusionary or exceptionalist precepts, but its root is in the personal perception that their individual preferences are inherently superior to all others.
You end up in a isolated echo chamber of thoughtlessness which cannot be penetrated (worst affliction) and you impose yourself upon others; for what faith lacks tenets?
attempting to avoid confusing personal issues of faith with religion, is one of the reasons I offered the previous definition of "faith."
I think you are saying no reason or system of reason should be applied to Faith. If so, and as above, the question is "how do you reasonably deal with the faithful?"
I don't know that I would agree with this characterization, and I feel that your use of the term "faithful" in this context, is not in accord with my description of "faith." But even if I make the adjustments in terminology to bring your question more into line with my understandings, I would have to understand how and why I must "reasonably deal with" these people, before I could provide you with any kind of seriously considered response. I don't seek to understand other's perspectives to manipulate those with those perspectives.