A coherent definition of God

What is “proper faith”? Is it possible for a person to be so brain-dead they believe something utterly and completely without any thought other than their belief is correct?
Isn't claiming to have "proper" or "pure" faith essentially claiming you have reached a final conclusion that requires no further thought? Are people really capable of doing that (not thinking)?

In the choosing of a belief there is a non-faith evaluation process involved. Obviously faith in a belief can't predate the belief. Whatever factors were involved in choosing a belief still exist in the mind of the believer after the belief is chosen, and they remain active in the retention of the belief. Beliefs are therefore not the product of either "proper" or "pure" faith. Beliefs are the product of the factors that were used to chose them.
 
Last edited:
Your fixes vouch for another speedy detachment from reality; your fixes are decidedly not what His Serene Knowledge of Oxford Richard Dawkins preaches. Just get in touch with the high clergy of atheism to get a clear view of what atheism can really look like.
Richard who?

I realise this will fall on deaf ears . . . but . . . There is no "atheist scriptures" or "high clergy of atheism". Atheism isn't a relgion regardless of how desperately you want it to be and claim it is.

Claiming atheists are stupid because they are as stupid as theists just doesn't work (although there's a half-truth there).
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by epix
According to the atheist scriptures, God is a sadomasochistic being that doesn't exist.
If a god (as described in The Bible) existed it would be a sadomasochistic being
Had to fix that for you because you still don't understand atheism correctly.
Let's take a look at this molestation of reason: The stricken part includes a statement saying that God doesn't exist. That strike was done by an atheist who is saying that I still don't understand atheism correctly. And who does, when an atheists regards God's non-existence as a wrong statement and runs a line over it? :confused: :rolleyes:

Christianity is heavily inspired in its conduct by God through the Bible. The High Priest of Atheism, His Serene Knowledge Richard Dawkins maintains that Christianity is "sadomasochistic." And who inspired Christians to be as such? The Snow White?

The statement that God is a sadomasochistic being that doesn't exist is exactly a taylormade definition every radical atheist should have on his/her T-shirt.

If God doesn't exist, then the probability that he does is zero. In other words, there is no chance whatsoever that he exists. How do you reconcile that with the following statement made by the atheists?

ATHEIST-BUS-2_1217539c.jpg


Oh, God probably doesn't exist. Aha.

I wonder what it is that prevents the radical atheists to set all parameters in the exists-doesn't-exist formula to zero, do the multiplication and let God disappear entirely. Yes, God existed a tiny bit but now he's no more. Hallelujah! Praise the Ford - or whatever.
 
Isn't claiming to have "proper" or "pure" faith essentially claiming you have reached a final conclusion that requires no further thought?

Yes. With a caveat*

My recent terms proper, true and pure were all in reference to the rather good definition of faith that Traken gave a page back:
Trakar said:
If you have faith and you run into compelling empiric evidences that support your faith, you no longer have faith .. Faith is .. a state of acceptance in the absence of empiric evidences. Note, not in the spite of empiric evidences, but in the absence of such evidences.

* Caveat being a)it's my take, b)I gather that doubt forms part of the voodoo: when a doubt is felt, it is used to burn the faith hotter. Doubt is the only proof required that faith is working. Something weird like that.

Are people really capable of doing that (not thinking)?

Scary, and yes.

My hypothesis is that mind-control happens. Whether is subtle and almost self-done as in Christianity/Islam (mainstreams) or blatant and blunt like the CO$, the result is people who are literally operating in another mind. They have all their faculties of speech and intelligence, but their reality has been mutated 180 degrees towards a faith.

For example, suicide bombers are mostly* children who have been taken away from a young age and have been systematically (by the book, and there are such books) brain washed.

(* Evidence.. I could google, but I read this recently and have seen at least two BBC doccies on the subject.)

I recommend Xenu.net and the books found there for some chilling insights into this flowers and love stuff we call religion. Also, youtube.

In the choosing of a belief there is a non-faith evaluation process involved.

If there is choice. Children of religious parents don't get that choice.
For others, it can be a bait-and-switch system like CO$ or they may have pre-set themselves to want faith, so they seek it out. The latter usually from childhood religious circs.

Beliefs are therefore not the product of either "proper" or "pure" faith. Beliefs are the product of the factors that were used to chose them.

Yes, it's a compex subject. Neuroscience, really. My own experience has been that Faith sits like a fuse within a mind.

Anecdote:
I talked to my friend and began to press rather hard on the hypocrisy of his various Catholic/Mystic positions. It came down to the wire and I saw his fuse blow. After that it was hopeless. All I got were hurtful insults (a 20 year long friendship, mind you!) and bible verses.
 
According to the atheist scriptures, God is a sadomasochistic being that doesn't exist.

First, there are not atheist scriptures.

Second, some atheists think that, if a "god", existed, which acted as the one described in the bible, it would be logical to conclude that it is a sadomasochistic being (that is plain simply the behavior the character displays in the book)
 
Originally Posted by epix
According to the atheist scriptures, God is a sadomasochistic being that doesn't exist.
If a god (as described in The Bible) existed it would be a sadomasochistic being

Let's take a look at this molestation of reason: The stricken part includes a statement saying that God doesn't exist. That strike was done by an atheist who is saying that I still don't understand atheism correctly. And who does, when an atheists regards God's non-existence as a wrong statement and runs a line over it? :confused: :rolleyes:


Atheists just do not believe in god. They do not say "god does not exists". They say "the belief that god exists, we do not have it". What is so hard to understand about that?

John has an apple.

Peter doesn't have a apple.

It is not that Peter thinks the apple that John has doesn't exist, Peter just doesn't have it.

Now:

John has a belief in a god, he is a theist

Peter doesn't have a belief in any god, he is atheist.

It is not that Peter thinks the god that John has doesn't exist, Peter just doesn't have a belief in it.

Easy! Get it now?


Christianity is heavily inspired in its conduct by God through the Bible.

1) And that god sometimes does horrible things in the Bible. And Christianity has done horrible things.

2) And that god sometimes does nice things in the Bible. And Christianity has done nice things.

But some Christians just say 1 is true, 2 is false, even in front of hard evidence!

The High Priest of Atheism, His Serene Knowledge Richard Dawkins maintains that Christianity is "sadomasochistic." And who inspired Christians to be as such? The Snow White?

The human guys that invented Christiany. If we ever found evidence that god of Christiany ever exists, at that it did what the Bible says it did, then it inspired them.

The statement that God is a sadomasochistic being that doesn't exist is exactly a taylormade definition every radical atheist should have on his/her T-shirt.

But, it wouldn't be accurate. The accurate thing to have in the T-shirt is:

if a "god", existed, which acted as the one described in the bible, it would be logical to conclude that it is a sadomasochistic being.

If God doesn't exist, then the probability that he does is zero. In other words, there is no chance whatsoever that he exists. How do you reconcile that with the following statement made by the atheists?

[qimg]http://i.telegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/01217/ATHEIST-BUS-2_1217539c.jpg[/qimg]

Oh, God probably doesn't exist. Aha.

Evidence so far of ANY god existing: 0.

Evidence so far of Leprechauns existing: 0.

Would you say that it would be inaccurate to say that Leprechauns probably do not exist?

Or for example:

Evidence so far of Vishu existing: 0.

Evidence so far of YHWH existing: 0.

Would you say that it would be correct to say that Vishnu and YHWH, having both the same evidence to support their existence (none) have the same probability to exist? And therefore believers in YHWH should also worship Vishu? (There is of course the tiny problem that according to the bible YHWH said that it is the only god to be worshipped... but it has the same probablity to exist as Visnu (and as Zeus, and Mithra, and Quetzalcoatl, and...) how do theists reconcile with that?


I wonder what it is that prevents the radical atheists to set all parameters in the exists-doesn't-exist formula to zero, do the multiplication and let God disappear entirely. Yes, God existed a tiny bit but now he's no more. Hallelujah! Praise the Ford - or whatever.

Nothing "prevents" them from doing that. It is just that, if they do that, they do would not be acting as atheists.

I wonder what it is that prevents the radical christians to set all parameters in the exists-doesn't-exist formula to 1, do the multiplication and let Vishnu become their god too. Yes, they believed only YHWH existed but now they believe that both YHWH and Vishnu exist, and they worship both... and then what prevents this radical hindu/christians to set all parameters in the exists-doesn't-exist formula to 1, do the multiplication and let Zeusbecome their god too.

Yes, they believed only YHWH and Vishnu existed a but now they believe that YHWH and Vishnu and Zeus exist, and they worship the three of them... and so on, and so forth, until they worship every god of every religion....

Why do they stop at 1 god when the mechanism used to believe in one of the applies to all of them?
 
Last edited:
For instance .. "evidence-mongering" and "call their bluff" imply a deliberateness of deceit .. on the part of the believer .. in most cases there is no such motivation in their behavior

But how do you know? One case is this distinguishing of honest faith from self-serving deception dressed as faith.

Another case is the further interaction with the faithful wanting to continue <something> while we grow aware that such a course is not a good one.

You say:
If I have come to an understanding of the nature of their beliefs and the path that led them to their beliefs, what more is there? I accept them for what they are, integrate the information and move on ..

I think that's fair. We are not lie-detectors, our best is our best. Still, we don't know how many liars are slipping through this net.

Let's say you spoke to a psychic who believes that Angels are guiding her. She charges a lot of money to do her thing, but she appears genuine. She has a path that led her here, and so forth.

Let's say that her clients are poor and cannot afford her ministrations. Let's say that her work hurts them financially. Let's say that they do not care and continue to employ her.

Her clients claim faith in her services — when pressed they can't find any evidence, they just feel <stuff> about the Angels, or her <spiritual stuff>.

What now? How do you judge her Faith? Her clients'?

(Example: http://www.skeptic.com/doubtful-news/psychic-friends-this-isnt-a-scam-they-are-life-coaches )


You properly said (in regards an extreme faith situation):
Don't waste time arguing with them, arrest or kill them. Belief is much less important than behavior and what you describe is an immediate sociopathic threat to themselves and others regardless of whether their motivation is black helicopters or bringing on the end times. Beliefs are one thing, criminal behavior and intent of this nature are an entirely different matter.

Your highlighted words are spot-on.

When someone claims Faith in <x> and performs deeds in the world according to <x> that affect people who do not believe <x> then we have a situation.

At that point Faith in <x> has to be asked for evidence. That's the point at which Faith — "it requires no evidence" — becomes a tyranny. You are essentially saying "just because," when someone else is asking you, "why are you hurting me?"

To come back to the OP. The route from a nebulous "God" down to a personal faith in <something> to do with that "God" is the road of tyranny. You end up in a isolated echo chamber of thoughtlessness which cannot be penetrated (worst affliction) and you impose yourself upon others; for what faith lacks tenets?

If Faith in <x> were able to remain perfectly private and inspired no political power, no income, no followers then it would be acceptable. A personal quirk. Perhaps, one day, a thing done in brain-scanning devices for science.
You (a general 'you') have the right to impose a North Korea on your own mind. You do not have the right to drag anyone else into it.



In my experience, most faith/belief perspectives that try to use supporting evidences are heavily invested with inductive reasoning. Using circumstantial, anecdotal, and coincidental evidences and then extrapolating from these shaky foundations to broader overarching universal precepts. Properly employed inductive reasoning can be an effective guide to further research and investigation, but improperly applied to non-empiric evidences it tends to more resemble a GIGO cascade.

I think you are saying no reason or system of reason should be applied to Faith. If so, and as above, the question is "how do you reasonably deal with the faithful?"
 
Originally Posted by epix
According to the atheist scriptures, God is a sadomasochistic being that doesn't exist.
If a god (as described in The Bible) existed it would be a sadomasochistic being

Let's take a look at this molestation of reason: The stricken part includes a statement saying that God doesn't exist. That strike was done by an atheist who is saying that I still don't understand atheism correctly. And who does, when an atheists regards God's non-existence as a wrong statement and runs a line over it? :confused: :rolleyes:

Christianity is heavily inspired in its conduct by God through the Bible. The High Priest of Atheism, His Serene Knowledge Richard Dawkins maintains that Christianity is "sadomasochistic." And who inspired Christians to be as such? The Snow White?

The statement that God is a sadomasochistic being that doesn't exist is exactly a taylormade definition every radical atheist should have on his/her T-shirt.

If God doesn't exist, then the probability that he does is zero. In other words, there is no chance whatsoever that he exists. How do you reconcile that with the following statement made by the atheists?

http://i.telegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/01217/ATHEIST-BUS-2_1217539c.jpg

Oh, God probably doesn't exist. Aha.

I wonder what it is that prevents the radical atheists to set all parameters in the exists-doesn't-exist formula to zero, do the multiplication and let God disappear entirely. Yes, God existed a tiny bit but now he's no more. Hallelujah! Praise the Ford - or whatever.
You REALLY need to find some better and bigger stones to throw. Throwing this (bull)dust just makes you look silly(er).
 
Richard who?

I realise this will fall on deaf ears . . . but . . . There is no "atheist scriptures" or "high clergy of atheism". Atheism isn't a relgion regardless of how desperately you want it to be and claim it is.

Claiming atheists are stupid because they are as stupid as theists just doesn't work (although there's a half-truth there).

I don't give a toss what Dawkins says or thinks. I don't own any atheist books, there are no 'holy' atheist tracts. I am an atheist off my own bat, but I can't get that into epix's head, not even with dynamite.
 
But how do you know?

How do I know what? Whether or not their motivation is to deliberately deceive others or the result of simple ignorances and misunderstandings (as I stated)? I believe my words were: "it is, in my experience, most often simply matters of ignorance and/or misunderstanding." This experience is derived from engaging people in discussion and assessing their responses and considerations. It is definitely a subjective process, and I undoutably have made some mistakes or been deceived upon occassion.

One case is this distinguishing of honest faith from self-serving deception dressed as faith.

The two primary categories of division, to my considerations, are faith (based upon my earlier description) and beliefs based upon a lack of knowledge and understandings (ignorances) and/or confusions regarding basic knowledges and understandings (misunderstandings) being represented as faith. Purposeful self-serving deception is extremely rare among individuals, however, if I am reading the direction of your inquiry correctly, I would probably agree that this self-serving deception motivation is more prevelant among public figure proponents of their personal faith (religious leaders, politicians, etc.,).

Another case is the further interaction with the faithful wanting to continue <something> while we grow aware that such a course is not a good one.

I really don't grok this. If you can try to expand upon and explain this I would be happy to respond more appropriately to your comment.

Let's say you spoke to a psychic who believes that Angels are guiding her. She charges a lot of money to do her thing, but she appears genuine. She has a path that led her here, and so forth.

once it becomes a commercial venture, we aren't so much talking about only faith as we are about marketing, services and compensations, or at the least the issues become so complexly tangled that they are not easily isolated. This isn't to say that all such individuals are without faith, but merely that my assessment process isn't designed or experienced at trying to deal with those particular situations, and generally aren't something I regularly deal with or often contemplate.

Let's say that her clients are poor and cannot afford her ministrations. Let's say that her work hurts them financially. Let's say that they do not care and continue to employ her.

Much would depend upon local laws, but her actions would definitely conflict with my personal moral bearing. Probably not much differently than I would react to doctors, lawyers, or other merchants who acted similarly.

Her clients claim faith in her services...

I think we are starting to stretch fairly far away from my definition of faith and into the more generalized common (mis)usages and over applications of the term. Not that mine is right and all others are wrong, it is just that these others are not what I mean when I use the term.

— when pressed they can't find any evidence, they just feel <stuff> about the Angels, or her <spiritual stuff>.

"Feelings" are a type of evidence and/or the result of physical experiences and considerations, conscious and unconscious. As stated this is actually beyond the types of personal assessments I generally concern myself with and I've never run into such a situation. I'm not saying that the hypothetical you present is unrealistic or circular, but, I would not be satisfied with the result that they are unaware of making any evidence-based decisions regarding psychic abilities, Angels or this particular psychic's <spiritual stuff>.

What now? How do you judge her Faith? Her clients'?

If she is breaking laws: she is a criminal.
If she is acting in a manner I would consider immoral: I would consider her immoral.
Your hypothetical does not include me discussing her faith with her, so I really am not given the information I would need to assess her faith.
If her clients are behaving in a manner that is causing themselves and those dependent upon them serious harm: then what is there to judge or assess, their actions speak pretty much for themselves.

I don't consider life-coaches to be any more reputable than psychics. In fact I generally don't consider them to be as reputable, merely because I've met plenty of self-claimed psychics who aren't interested in compensation for their "gift," but I've never met a life-coach who wasn't interested in their fee.

I really don't see that this example fits your criteria (ie., interviewed and they didn't find any evidence, they just feel <stuff> about the Angels, or her <spiritual stuff>)

Your highlighted words are spot-on.

When someone claims Faith in <x> and performs deeds in the world according to <x> that affect people who do not believe <x> then we have a situation.

At that point Faith in <x> has to be asked for evidence. That's the point at which Faith — "it requires no evidence" — becomes a tyranny. You are essentially saying "just because," when someone else is asking you, "why are you hurting me?"

again not real clear in this section, but perhaps I am getting lost in your attempts to create what looks to me like a generic over-simplification. Please expand and clarify and I will try to give you a better response.

To come back to the OP. The route from a nebulous "God" down to a personal faith in <something> to do with that "God" is the road of tyranny.

Tyranny is an issue of the human condition, and it can express itself in many forms and through many faces to include religion, politics, economics, nationalism, racism, or virtually any belief system that incorporates exclusionary or exceptionalist precepts, but its root is in the personal perception that their individual preferences are inherently superior to all others.

You end up in a isolated echo chamber of thoughtlessness which cannot be penetrated (worst affliction) and you impose yourself upon others; for what faith lacks tenets?

attempting to avoid confusing personal issues of faith with religion, is one of the reasons I offered the previous definition of "faith."

I think you are saying no reason or system of reason should be applied to Faith. If so, and as above, the question is "how do you reasonably deal with the faithful?"

I don't know that I would agree with this characterization, and I feel that your use of the term "faithful" in this context, is not in accord with my description of "faith." But even if I make the adjustments in terminology to bring your question more into line with my understandings, I would have to understand how and why I must "reasonably deal with" these people, before I could provide you with any kind of seriously considered response. I don't seek to understand other's perspectives to manipulate those with those perspectives.
 
a coherent definition of god?

Ronnie James Dio RIP

"They say that life's a carousel
Spinning fast, you've got to ride it well
The world is full of Kings and Queens
Who blind your eyes then steal your dreams
...it's Heaven and Hell, oh well"

EQ
 
Yes. With a caveat*

My recent terms proper, true and pure were all in reference to the rather good definition of faith that Traken gave a page back:

* Caveat being a)it's my take, b)I gather that doubt forms part of the voodoo: when a doubt is felt, it is used to burn the faith hotter. Doubt is the only proof required that faith is working. Something weird like that.

Scary, and yes.

My hypothesis is that mind-control happens. Whether is subtle and almost self-done as in Christianity/Islam (mainstreams) or blatant and blunt like the CO$, the result is people who are literally operating in another mind. They have all their faculties of speech and intelligence, but their reality has been mutated 180 degrees towards a faith.

For example, suicide bombers are mostly* children who have been taken away from a young age and have been systematically (by the book, and there are such books) brain washed.

(* Evidence.. I could google, but I read this recently and have seen at least two BBC doccies on the subject.)

I recommend Xenu.net and the books found there for some chilling insights into this flowers and love stuff we call religion. Also, youtube.

If there is choice. Children of religious parents don't get that choice.
For others, it can be a bait-and-switch system like CO$ or they may have pre-set themselves to want faith, so they seek it out. The latter usually from childhood religious circs.

Yes, it's a compex subject. Neuroscience, really. My own experience has been that Faith sits like a fuse within a mind.

Anecdote:
I talked to my friend and began to press rather hard on the hypocrisy of his various Catholic/Mystic positions. It came down to the wire and I saw his fuse blow. After that it was hopeless. All I got were hurtful insults (a 20 year long friendship, mind you!) and bible verses.
Beliefs don’t just pop into peoples heads and they aren’t randomly drawn from a hat. Believers proactively choose their particular belief(s) in preference to all the other beliefs they could’ve chosen. They believe by way of a thought process that’s misguided by an emotional bias. Faith is a confidence or trust that their belief and the thought process by which they chose it are true and correct. Faith didn’t create the belief, it merely supports and sustains it.

This is why I don’t accept it when believers respond to the question - “Why do you believe in a god” with - “Because I have faith that a god exists”.

I also ended a long-time (20 year plus) friendship with a person because interacting with his paranormal beliefs became too difficult and he became too abusive. He wasn’t overly religious but that didn’t stop him from believing he was the second coming of Christ at one stage.
 
Last edited:
Beliefs don’t just pop into peoples heads and they aren’t randomly drawn from a hat.

Indeed.

Faith is a confidence or trust that their belief and the thought process by which they chose it are true and correct. Faith didn’t create the belief, it merely supports and sustains it.

That's also a good definition. I think yours is the more likely and Traken's is the more romantic — one that is polished by a lot of active mental work on the faith.

A child wanders along the beach. A bright yellow balloon bobs in the breezes; it is caught on its string. She thinks it's fine; she releases it and grabs the string. It slips through her hands. The balloon flies swiftly up and away. She watches it; before she can cry, she starts to pretend that she holds the string still.
The child wanders back along the beach, holding her balloon by the string. There is no string, no balloon. There is a string, there is a balloon. In her mind, it's yellow.

Or something :)


This is why I don’t accept it when believers respond to the question - “Why do you believe in a god” with - “Because I have faith that a god exists”.

In a way. They are answering why they still believe. You were asking for why they started at all. They've handed reason over to a subroutine running on it's own thread. When they feel any doubt, they call it up and it strokes them back into calm.

I think we atheistishes think people have these active and sound reasons all the time, when it's really a soup of feelings, consequences, investments and fantasy. Faith becomes, as you say, the word that groups all those things and is credited.

I also ended a long-time (20 year plus) friendship with a person because interacting with his paranormal beliefs became too difficult and he became too abusive. He wasn’t overly religious but that didn’t stop him from believing he was the second coming of Christ at one stage.

Ouch. I wonder if he wasn't having some physical problem in his brain. At risk of being flippant: I think barminess is the better part of belief.

I hope it worked out for both of you.

My own friend is still close (by email, since I moved) and we talk fairly well, but the 'can of worms' is always near to hand. It's amazing how many subjects lead to issues of Truth and that's where we have to stop talking.

I recognize that his reactions are emotional — there's pain when I pry. I ask myself if I am as strong as I suppose; what's my own pain? I forgive him every time. Fragile bloody things us humans.
 
god: the level of character attained when you have reached the top of your heroic echeladder, earned all the boonbucks, and then been killed while lying on your Quest Bed. May or may not be capable of killing Jack Noir.
 
How do I know what? .. It is definitely a subjective process, and I undoutably have made some mistakes or been deceived upon occassion.

That. Answered, thanks.

.. but merely that my assessment process isn't designed or experienced at trying to deal with those particular situations, and generally aren't something I regularly deal with or often contemplate.
Okay, that works. Thanks for the straight answer.

.. the term. Not that mine is right and all others are wrong, it is just that these others are not what I mean when I use the term.
That's part of the problem with words like 'faith', isn't it? We can't tell who's deceiving us and who's practicing the real thing. I'd tend to agree with you and say that if 'faith' is used as an excuse to profit or gain power over others then it's likely rotten.

(I can accept 'faith' as being a purely contemplative, inner, meditative kind of thing. If it influences emotions and/or deeds that's evidence and so BZZZ! Problem! Loop. It polices itself and turns ever inwards; very Zen.)

I still have to say I don't know what Faith (your kind) starts with. What is the seed? Would that be a religion, some concept of God? What is the process that begins Faith?


I would have to understand how and why I must "reasonably deal with" these people..
I meant deal-with as in day to day inter-human stuff. Laws, economics, rights, privacy, health, the whole ball of wax. Reasonably as in reason, logic, clarity, agreed norms of decision making, etc.
So, how to reason with a person about <something> when they are blocked from hearing you by their 'faith'.
I think you have answered that ok. You'd go by the fruits (so-to-speak) of their faith and decide as best you can.


You can tell by my other responses that I am skeptical about this faith thing, but I have found the conversation enlightening thus far.
 
How do I know what? Whether or not their motivation is to deliberately deceive others or the result of simple ignorances and misunderstandings (as I stated)? I believe my words were: "it is, in my experience, most often simply matters of ignorance and/or misunderstanding." This experience is derived from engaging people in discussion and assessing their responses and considerations. It is definitely a subjective process, and I undoutably have made some mistakes or been deceived upon occassion.



The two primary categories of division, to my considerations, are faith (based upon my earlier description) and beliefs based upon a lack of knowledge and understandings (ignorances) and/or confusions regarding basic knowledges and understandings (misunderstandings) being represented as faith. Purposeful self-serving deception is extremely rare among individuals, however, if I am reading the direction of your inquiry correctly, I would probably agree that this self-serving deception motivation is more prevelant among public figure proponents of their personal faith (religious leaders, politicians, etc.,).



I really don't grok this. If you can try to expand upon and explain this I would be happy to respond more appropriately to your comment.



once it becomes a commercial venture, we aren't so much talking about only faith as we are about marketing, services and compensations, or at the least the issues become so complexly tangled that they are not easily isolated. This isn't to say that all such individuals are without faith, but merely that my assessment process isn't designed or experienced at trying to deal with those particular situations, and generally aren't something I regularly deal with or often contemplate.



Much would depend upon local laws, but her actions would definitely conflict with my personal moral bearing. Probably not much differently than I would react to doctors, lawyers, or other merchants who acted similarly.



I think we are starting to stretch fairly far away from my definition of faith and into the more generalized common (mis)usages and over applications of the term. Not that mine is right and all others are wrong, it is just that these others are not what I mean when I use the term.


"Feelings" are a type of evidence and/or the result of physical experiences and considerations, conscious and unconscious. As stated this is actually beyond the types of personal assessments I generally concern myself with and I've never run into such a situation. I'm not saying that the hypothetical you present is unrealistic or circular, but, I would not be satisfied with the result that they are unaware of making any evidence-based decisions regarding psychic abilities, Angels or this particular psychic's <spiritual stuff>.



If she is breaking laws: she is a criminal.
If she is acting in a manner I would consider immoral: I would consider her immoral.
Your hypothetical does not include me discussing her faith with her, so I really am not given the information I would need to assess her faith.
If her clients are behaving in a manner that is causing themselves and those dependent upon them serious harm: then what is there to judge or assess, their actions speak pretty much for themselves.


I don't consider life-coaches to be any more reputable than psychics. In fact I generally don't consider them to be as reputable, merely because I've met plenty of self-claimed psychics who aren't interested in compensation for their "gift," but I've never met a life-coach who wasn't interested in their fee.

I really don't see that this example fits your criteria (ie., interviewed and they didn't find any evidence, they just feel <stuff> about the Angels, or her <spiritual stuff>)



again not real clear in this section, but perhaps I am getting lost in your attempts to create what looks to me like a generic over-simplification. Please expand and clarify and I will try to give you a better response.



Tyranny is an issue of the human condition, and it can express itself in many forms and through many faces to include religion, politics, economics, nationalism, racism, or virtually any belief system that incorporates exclusionary or exceptionalist precepts, but its root is in the personal perception that their individual preferences are inherently superior to all others.



attempting to avoid confusing personal issues of faith with religion, is one of the reasons I offered the previous definition of "faith."

I don't know that I would agree with this characterization, and I feel that your use of the term "faithful" in this context, is not in accord with my description of "faith." But even if I make the adjustments in terminology to bring your question more into line with my understandings, I would have to understand how and why I must "reasonably deal with" these people, before I could provide you with any kind of seriously considered response. I don't seek to understand other's perspectives to manipulate those with those perspectives.

If you redefine words to have your own idiosyncratic meanings soon you'll be talking to yourself because no one else will understand you.

ETA: -2 for use of the word grok.
 
Last edited:
If you redefine words to have your own idiosyncratic meanings soon you'll be talking to yourself because no one else will understand you.

ETA: -2 for use of the word grok.

If somebody uses the word 'grok' then I cannot take them seriously. It is a sure sign of new age wooly woo 'thinking.'
 
Awww. I like grok. Heinlein not so much, but grok?... :( Just pretend you are hearing a Klingon say it. :)
 
Awww. I like grok. Heinlein not so much, but grok?... :( Just pretend you are hearing a Klingon say it. :)

Unfortunately, in Klingon it means "Let us come to a mutual understanding of the rules of the duel" , followed by a fight to the death.:duck:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom