A coherent definition of God

My definition of God (that's God, not god)...

An incorporeal supernatural intelligence capable of interacting with the universe without being bound by the known laws of physics, generally regarded as being responsible for our existence.
A good start, but let's not beat around the bush. 'God' (AKA 'YHWH', 'LORD' etc.) is no more nor less than the Biblical god who, according to the Bible, created this little corner of the universe, including our planet and all the life on it. There were/are other gods, but they are lesser and/or false gods.

Some people claim that He is omnipresent, omnipotent, omnibenevolent and omniscient. This is doubtful though, as the evidence for this hypothesis is weak. Many other things about God have also been misrepresented, but a thorough review of the evidence should sort it out. Here's some...

Genesis 3:9
And the LORD God called unto Adam, and said unto him, Where art thou?

Genesis 3:22
And the LORD God said, Behold, the man is become as one of us, to know good and evil

Genesis 28:12-13
...and behold a ladder set up on the earth, and the top of it reached to heaven: and behold the angels of God ascending and descending on it.
And, behold, the LORD stood above it, and said, I am the LORD God

Numbers 22:9
And God came unto Balaam, and said, What men are these with thee?

Job 1:7
And the LORD said unto Satan, Whence comest thou? Then Satan answered the LORD, and said, From going to and fro in the earth, and from walking up and down in it.

Of course, whether or not such an entity exists is a different matter altogether.
Luckily for us, a thing doesn't need to exist in order to have a coherent definition of it...
 
It would be done by asking questions and evaluating the responses in the manner I laid out in the post to which you are responding.
I can only interpret that as being as being “evidences“. Why do you use “evidences“ in this case but not in the case of a possible divine creator of the Universe? Why is faith ever better than “evidences” in any case?

Donn's Questions (full):
However, when someone says that <something> is their Faith and you can't touch it, what then?
Someone can say that <something> is a matter of Faith to them. What then?
How do you make a practical decision?
<something> can be aliens, ESP, ghosts, homeopathy, tarot, divining, angels, spirits, ancient technology, etc.

Your response (full):
I don't well know how to answer for others of different beliefs and understandings, but it is an interesting question.
From my own position, I would generally first try to ascertain whether their expressions were actually based upon faith or not. If the individual tries to support their faith with evidences then we aren't dealing with "faith," but an with evidence-based understanding. At that point, you deal with the evidences and/or the understandings they are derviing from those evidences.
For instance there is a big difference between those who have faith that there are advanced technological alien species existent in the universe, and those who purport that unusual aerial phenomena represent alien starships.
This isn't to say that you can't use inductive methods of inferring some types of possibilities or potentialities, merely that such do not typically represent empiric support.


I'm not sure how or why you feel this response does not address the questions asked, but if Donn feels that it is inadequate, I would be happy to expand or clarify any issues Donn feels need additional addressment.
Here’s how and why I believe your response doesn‘t address Donn‘s questions - As I read them (can’t read them any other way) the questions are essentially asking - Given faith is purely an arbitrary personal choice/decision then there is nothing to “touch” (address, understand, question, evaluate, etc) so how can one respond to and evaluate faith in any meaningful way ("What then?")? The questions relate to the veracity of faith per se, not about any particular faith.

For some strange reason you seem to interpret that the questions are asking something like - “How does one know if a person has genuine faith or not and how do you find out?”. Please explain (using Donn's words in context) how you reach this interpretation.

I hope Donn will return to clarify the matter. Did Trakar's response address your questions Donn?
 
Last edited:
Every person that believes in a god believes it is God. The only difference between god and God is the belief of the believer.
I don't know that I would qualify that as the only difference, but I would account it as a significant difference.
Can you explain what another difference might be? Or do you merely have faith that there might be another difference?
Can you ask an honest question without simultaneously telling me what my answer should be from your perspective?
many religions have hierarchies and divisions of aspect and control in their conceptual pantheon of supernatural divinity. Which, while may have some dieties that are stronger or weaker (more influential or less influential) under certain circumstances, they do not generally acknowledge or accept as one supreme godhead. This is another often significant difference.
As well, there are a lot of minor differences even between sects of major religions and belief-systems, which we can go into further if you are interested.

Could someone that understands Trakar talk better than I do explain why this isn’t merely stating the obvious that different believers have different beliefs and therefore what they call a god or a God is dependant on the particular beliefs of the particular believers (as I said). I can't see where it offers the requested "another difference".
 
I hope Donn will return to clarify the matter. Did Trakar's response address your questions Donn?
Does anyone else think Trakar’s response addressed Donn’s questions (even slightly)?
 
Last edited:
"Proofs" are the fodder of logic and logicisms, while that is one path to take, I rarely see much rigor in its application by either camp.

When it comes to faith, "proofs" are largely irrelevent. If you have faith and you run into compelling empiric evidences that support your faith, you no longer have faith, you have an evidence-based understanding that is as good and reliable as the empiric evidence supporting it. Likewise if you lack faith, empiric evidences aren't going to give you faith, they are merely going to present an evidence-based understanding that you will accept or attempt to refute.
Faith is not an empiric evidence-based state, it is a state of acceptance in the absence of empiric evidences. Note, not in the spite of empiric evidences, but in the absence of such evidences.



Saint Augustine
"Faith is to believe what you do not see; the reward of this faith is to see what you believe."​
 
Can you give a credible bit of evidence that God does not exist?

No he can't, because god being an uncoherent concept, it makes it impossible to establish the truth value of any predicate containing it.

Many of the myths can be disproven, yes, but can you definitely prove there is no superior power controlling the universe?

Define "superior power" first... in a coherent, contradiction-free way, and then we can worry about proving or disproving it...

I cannot. Nor can I prove the opposite. So, I shan't ask anyone else to do so.

Nobody can, because it is incoherent.

That said, it is an interesting thread. It may not be what !Kaggen wanted but it is interesting.

Interesting indeed. :)
 
Sorry for taking so long. I am in a different time-zone it seems.

Trakar

Trakar said:
.. I would .. first .. ascertain .. their expressions were .. based upon faith or not. If .. tries to support their faith with evidences then we aren't dealing with "faith,"

Very good. They should be operating on a purely mental process. They should not be seeking nor offering any evidence.

but an with evidence-based understanding. At that point, you deal with the evidences and/or the understandings they are derviing from those evidences.
Also good. You have detected evidence-mongering and so you call their bluff and begin to process their evidence.

Let us say you whittle them down. By your talents as a skeptic and with your clear vision of what Faith really is, you turn them around. They reject their fake evidence. They embrace proper Faith.

Now, let us assume, for it may differ, you are left with a believer of true Faith who states the same <something> that you both started with.

What now?

How do you make practical decisions? How do you argue against their position?

.. big difference between those who have faith that there are advanced technological alien species existent in the universe,
and

those who purport that unusual aerial phenomena represent alien starships.
Just so. The first lot tend to be in cults (Heaven's gate, Rael, CO$) and the second lot tend to post here and argue with us. :)

My interest in your clarity of Faith is how to argue with the first lot?

Let us say they hatch a plot to 'externalize' the population of New York City. Now, to them, 'externalize' means dropping the body so the Thetan can fly free onto the next track. That's $cientologese, but the practical effect is that they will be poisoning the water supply so that thousands are killed.

How do you convince them they must not do it?

This isn't to say that you can't use inductive methods of inferring some types of possibilities or potentialities, merely that such do not typically represent empiric support.
I tried to parse that, but failed.





Ynot

ynot said:
Given faith is purely an arbitrary personal choice/decision then there is nothing to “touch” .. how can one respond to and evaluate faith in any meaningful way .. The questions relate to the veracity of faith per se, not about any particular faith.

That's the big picture. The feet-on-the-ground picture is exactly a "genuine" Faith detector. Let's call it a GIGO-counter :)

Once it's clear that Faith is pure (i.e. no evidence around) and <something> is held strongly, then we have a situation that I find ... puzzling, to say the least.

(I get a Kung-Fu cliche image in mind: two masters stand-off. They fight with their minds alone, so well-matched are they. We see squinting, brows wriggle, fingers twitch. Very Anime.)


So, yes, Trakar was doing pretty well, even if I found some of the writing hard to follow.
 
Sorry for taking so long. I am in a different time-zone it seems.

Trakar

Very good. They should be operating on a purely mental process. They should not be seeking nor offering any evidence.

Also good. You have detected evidence-mongering and so you call their bluff and begin to process their evidence.

While the general gist of your descriptions get the broader ideas across, the terminology seems prejudicial to a degree that would make them inaccurate in their description of what I am actually attempting to convey. For instance, in the above, "evidence-mongering" and "call their bluff" imply a deliberateness of deceit or disingenuity on the part of the believer that I would not presume. In most cases there is no such motivation in their behavior, it is, in my experience, most often simply matters of ignorance and/or misunderstanding.

Let us say you whittle them down. By your talents as a skeptic and with your clear vision of what Faith really is, you turn them around. They reject their fake evidence. They embrace proper Faith.

(again, I reject your framing, but think I understand what you are asking)
Why would I try to change anyone else's beliefs, faiths or understandings of the universe? I have no desire to do so. It is one thing to try to understand another's perspective, it is an entirely different issue to attempt to alter or change their perspective to bring it in line with your own. I'm big on learning about other's perspectives, but not really into trying to impose my perspective on others.

Now, let us assume, for it may differ, you are left with a believer of true Faith who states the same <something> that you both started with.

It matters not to me, what others believe. I am merely interested in trying to understand what they believe and if possible the considerations and understandings that motivate or led to those beliefs.

What now?

If I have come to an understanding of the nature of their beliefs and the path that led them to their beliefs, what more is there? I accept them for what they are, integrate the information and move on to discover and explore the beliefs of new individuals and to share my own evolving understandings and considerations with any who are interested in them.

How do you make practical decisions? How do you argue against their position?

Why would I argue against their position?
In a discussion, if they are pushing an evidence based position and their evidence is flawed or non-supportive of their position, I might point out the flaws or lack of support, but if they choose to dismiss my discussion and/or continue to assert such a position despite the evidence, it is no real concern of mine, they are the ones who must internally reconcile such contradictions.

Just so. The first lot tend to be in cults (Heaven's gate, Rael, CO$) and the second lot tend to post here and argue with us. :)

My interest in your clarity of Faith is how to argue with the first lot?

Let us say they hatch a plot to 'externalize' the population of New York City. Now, to them, 'externalize' means dropping the body so the Thetan can fly free onto the next track. That's $cientologese, but the practical effect is that they will be poisoning the water supply so that thousands are killed.

Don't waste time arguing with them, arrest or kill them. Belief is much less important than behavior and what you describe is an immediate sociopathic threat to themselves and others regardless of whether their motivation is black helicopters or bringing on the end times. Beliefs are one thing, criminal behavior and intent of this nature are an entirely different matter.

How do you convince them they must not do it?

Badges, guns and detention cells,...bullets if necessary.

I tried to parse that, but failed.

In my experience, most faith/belief perspectives that try to use supporting evidences are heavily invested with inductive reasoning. Using circumstantial, anecdotal, and coincidental evidences and then extrapolating from these shaky foundations to broader overarching universal precepts. Properly employed inductive reasoning can be an effective guide to further research and investigation, but improperly applied to non-empiric evidences it tends to more resemble a GIGO cascade.
 
According to the atheist scriptures, God is a sadomasochistic being that doesn't exist. If a god (as described in The Bible) existed it would be a sadomasochistic being
Had to fix that for you because you still don't understand atheism correctly.
 
Last edited:
They embrace proper Faith.
What is “proper faith”? Is it possible for a person to be so brain-dead they believe something utterly and completely without any thought other than their belief is correct?
 
Had to fix that for you because you still don't understand atheism correctly.
Your fixes vouch for another speedy detachment from reality; your fixes are decidedly not what His Serene Knowledge of Oxford Richard Dawkins preaches. Just get in touch with the high clergy of atheism to get a clear view of what atheism can really look like.
 
Your fixes vouch for another speedy detachment from reality; your fixes are decidedly not what His Serene Knowledge of Oxford Richard Dawkins preaches. Just get in touch with the high clergy of atheism to get a clear view of what atheism can really look like.

I'm an atheist. I have never read any Richard Dawkins and I don't care what the man says. Why are you so obsessed with him? Whatever atheism looks like, no atheist ever told me that it was my fault that my daughter had a brain tumour, in stark contrast to the Christians here.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom