A coherent definition of God

I agree with your perception! I, likewise, see no compelling reason or need for any god, gods or even God.

Neither, however, the limitations of my understandings and perceptions, nor the apparent absence of a requirement for the Divine, is relevent to issues of faith in the Divine.

It is extremely relevant.
 
Very good definition of Faith. This is why some atheists prefer fundamentalists to the interpretive branches! They laud and actually display faith.

However, when someone says that <something> is their Faith and you can't touch it, what then?
Someone can say that <something> is a matter of Faith to them. What then?

How do you make a practical decision?

<something> can be aliens, ESP, ghosts, homeopathy, tarot, divining, angels, spirits, ancient technology, etc.
I have a faith that all other faiths are wrong. My faith has as much rigor as any other faith (hint - none).
 
It is extremely relevant.

Then either we understand the term "faith" differently, or we understand the term "relevent" differently (or perhaps both), please feel free to expand upon and clarify your objection to my statement.
 
I don't know that I would qualify that as the only difference, but I would account it as a significant difference.
Can you explain what another difference might be? Or do you merely have faith that there might be another difference?
 
On cheeks:
Jesus II The Movie - The Return! He's back, he's p*ssed and he's all out of cheeks!

:D
 
Very good definition of Faith. This is why some atheists prefer fundamentalists to the interpretive branches! They laud and actually display faith.

However, when someone says that <something> is their Faith and you can't touch it, what then?
Someone can say that <something> is a matter of Faith to them. What then?

How do you make a practical decision?

<something> can be aliens, ESP, ghosts, homeopathy, tarot, divining, angels, spirits, ancient technology, etc.

I don't well know how to answer for others of different beliefs and understandings, but it is an interesting question.

From my own position, I would generally first try to ascertain whether their expressions were actually based upon faith or not. If the individual tries to support their faith with evidences then we aren't dealing with "faith," but an with evidence-based understanding. At that point, you deal with the evidences and/or the understandings they are derviing from those evidences.

For instance there is a big difference between those who have faith that there are advanced technological alien species existent in the universe, and those who purport that unusual aerial phenomena represent alien starships.

This isn't to say that you can't use inductive methods of inferring some types of possibilities or potentialities, merely that such do not typically represent empiric support.
 
On cheeks:
Jesus II The Movie - The Return! He's back, he's p*ssed and he's all out of cheeks!

:D

LOL, my favorite line from B-SciFi "They Live"

"I'm here to chew bubblegum, and kick ass, and I'm all out of bubblegum"
 
From my own position, I would generally first try to ascertain whether their expressions were actually based upon faith or not.
Would this ascertaining be done by way of “evidences“ or faith? What would you recommend as the best method to use?
Regardless, ascertaining whether a claimed faith is genuine or not doesn’t answer the question posed.
 
Would this ascertaining be done by way of “evidences“ or faith? What would you recommend as the best method to use?
Regardless, ascertaining whether a claimed faith is genuine or not doesn’t answer the question posed.

We're used to that from Trakar. All you'll get is another thicket of verbiage.
 
Can you explain what another difference might be? Or do you merely have faith that there might be another difference?

Can you ask an honest question without simultaneously telling me what my answer should be from your perspective?

many religions have hierarchies and divisions of aspect and control in their conceptual pantheon of supernatural divinity. Which, while may have some dieties that are stronger or weaker (more influential or less influential) under certain circumstances, they do not generally acknowledge or accept as one supreme godhead. This is another often significant difference.

As well, there are a lot of minor differences even between sects of major religions and belief-systems, which we can go into further if you are interested.
 
Can you ask an honest question without simultaneously telling me what my answer should be from your perspective?

You have told me (us) that you reach some conclusions merely by way of faith. Why is it not an honest question to ask if you are using this method to ascertain (conclude) whether people are genuinely employing faith or not? In what way is this telling you what your answer should be from your perspective? Is attack and obfuscation your best method of defence and argument?
 
Last edited:
Would this ascertaining be done by way of “evidences“ or faith? What would you recommend as the best method to use?

It would be done by asking questions and evaluating the responses in the manner I laid out in the post to which you are responding.


Regardless, ascertaining whether a claimed faith is genuine or not doesn’t answer the question posed.

questions posed:
...However, when someone says that <something> is their Faith and you can't touch it, what then?
Someone can say that <something> is a matter of Faith to them. What then?

response:
...From my own position, I would generally first try to ascertain whether their expressions were actually based upon faith or not. If the individual tries to support their faith with evidences then we aren't dealing with "faith," but an with evidence-based understanding. At that point, you deal with the evidences and/or the understandings they are derviing from those evidences...

I'm not sure how or why you feel this response does not address the questions asked, but if Donn feels that it is inadequate, I would be happy to expand or clarify any issues Donn feels need additional addressment.
 
You have told me (us) that you reach some conclusions merely by way of faith...

Reference and context?

...Is attack and obfuscation your best method of defence and argument?

you should perhaps try dimming the background lighting where-ever you are posting from, you seem to be seeing yourself in my remarks. I am not attacking, obsfucating, defending or arguing. Merely sharing and discussing my understandings and considerations.
 
Last edited:
"Proofs" are the fodder of logic and logicisms, while that is one path to take, I rarely see much rigor in its application by either camp.

When it comes to faith, "proofs" are largely irrelevent. If you have faith and you run into compelling empiric evidences that support your faith, you no longer have faith, you have an evidence-based understanding that is as good and reliable as the empiric evidence supporting it. Likewise if you lack faith, empiric evidences aren't going to give you faith, they are merely going to present an evidence-based understanding that you will accept or attempt to refute.

Faith is not an empiric evidence-based state, it is a state of acceptance in the absence of empiric evidences. Note, not in the spite of empiric evidences, but in the absence of such evidences.
Since faith isn't an empiric evidence-based state then Islam or any other religion is just as likely to be true as your faith.
 
:-)

At least someone is taking note.

As an ignostic I have yet to find a definition of God that was coherent. So I have none and therefore wondered if someone could help me out.

Gladly, the egrets is that way.>>>>

:)
 
Since faith isn't an empiric evidence-based state then Islam or any other religion is just as likely to be true as your faith.

I have yet to see any religion or system of beliefs that did not embody truths. Islam, being one of the Judeo derived belief systems, shares and honors many, if not all, of the same truths expressed in both Judaism and Christianity. I, however, am not acquainted in-depth with all the particular dogmatic distinctions inherent to the various sects of Islam so it would not be appropriate to comment much more fully upon such.

If you are asking me if I consider my religious beliefs to be superior to other's religious beliefs, the only honest answer I could give to you would be: for me, my current religious beliefs are the best that I know of.

But even here, my faith in the Creator is at the top of my heirarchy of beliefs, my personal belief in the greatness of the prime tenet of Christianity "place the welfare and happiness of others before your own," would come a close second, and my generalized liberally modern varient of Catholicism would come somewhere much further down the line. I don't hold other's religions above my own Catholic beliefs, but I don't know as much about them either so that may one day change (it has in the past).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom