A coherent definition of God

"Proofs" are the fodder of logic and logicisms, while that is one path to take, I rarely see much rigor in its application by either camp.

When it comes to faith, "proofs" are largely irrelevent. If you have faith and you run into compelling empiric evidences that support your faith, you no longer have faith, you have an evidence-based understanding that is as good and reliable as the empiric evidence supporting it. Likewise if you lack faith, empiric evidences aren't going to give you faith, they are merely going to present an evidence-based understanding that you will accept or attempt to refute.

Faith is not an empiric evidence-based state, it is a state of acceptance in the absence of empiric evidences. Note, not in the spite of empiric evidences, but in the absence of such evidences.
Okay - I have faith that no god exists and that your faith belief is the fodder of your emotional fears and desires. Why gives your faith any more rigor than mine?
 
Last edited:
Doubts are what they are, I've no intention of trying to convince you of anything one way or another, I'm merely sharing my understandings and beliefs, in the hopes that through such exchanges of perspectives and understandings I can learn more about the universe we both share.

Believe me, gods exist. The world is full of them. I think !Kaggan is asking about God. There really is a difference.
 
:-)

At least someone is taking note.

As an ignostic I have yet to find a definition of God that was coherent. So I have none and therefore wondered if someone could help me out.

I still think "God's Universe" would help. He doesn't force an answer on you. He just gives you enough thought to leave you more secure in what you decide.
 
Can you give a credible bit of evidence that God does not exist? Many of the myths can be disproven, yes, but can you definitely prove there is no superior power controlling the universe? I cannot. Nor can I prove the opposite. So, I shan't ask anyone else to do so.

That said, it is an interesting thread. It may not be what !Kaggen wanted but it is interesting.
As I'm not making the claim that no god exists I'm not required to prove that one doesn't. My claim is that I have never seen a single piece of credible evidence to support the claims of others that a god does exist. The onus of proof is on those making the claim.
 
Believe me, gods exist. The world is full of them. I think !Kaggan is asking about God. There really is a difference.

I'm sure to your considerations there is. I've simply shared my definition, considerations and understandings, and I thank you for the courtesy with which you appear to be doing the same.
 
I still think "God's Universe" would help. He doesn't force an answer on you. He just gives you enough thought to leave you more secure in what you decide.
Provide at least one single piece of credible evidence a God exists let alone that this God is a “He”.
 
I still think "God's Universe" would help. He doesn't force an answer on you. He just gives you enough thought to leave you more secure in what you decide.

Hazel, you have lost me here. Perhaps you could expand on what your saying?
 
I'm sure to your considerations there is. I've simply shared my definition, considerations and understandings, and I thank you for the courtesy with which you appear to be doing the same.

I don't see why there have to be any god or gods.
 
Believe me, gods exist. The world is full of them. I think !Kaggan is asking about God. There really is a difference.
Every person that believes in a god believes it is God. The only difference between god and God is the belief of the believer.
 
Okay - I have faith that no god exists and that your faith belief is the fodder of your emotional fears and desires. Why gives your faith any more rigor than mine?

If those are your beliefs, they are what they are, only you can change them. I care little whether or not you do. If you wish to understand and discuss my beliefs, understandings and considerations, I will be happy to engage in such an exchange. Given your propensity in the last few posts directed at my postings to alter my words and statements with your own confusions and disingenuities, I have strong doubts with regards to your intentions.
That said, and being a Christian, however, I'm more than willing to offer another cheek (...or two, should the situation merit it).
 
If those are your beliefs, they are what they are, only you can change them. I care little whether or not you do. If you wish to understand and discuss my beliefs, understandings and considerations, I will be happy to engage in such an exchange. Given your propensity in the last few posts directed at my postings to alter my words and statements with your own confusions and disingenuities, I have strong doubts with regards to your intentions.
That said, and being a Christian, however, I'm more than willing to offer another cheek (...or two, should the situation merit it).

Are you related to Jeeves?
 
If you have faith and you run into compelling empiric evidences that support your faith, you no longer have faith .. Faith is .. a state of acceptance in the absence of empiric evidences. Note, not in the spite of empiric evidences, but in the absence of such evidences.

Very good definition of Faith. This is why some atheists prefer fundamentalists to the interpretive branches! They laud and actually display faith.

However, when someone says that <something> is their Faith and you can't touch it, what then?
Someone can say that <something> is a matter of Faith to them. What then?

How do you make a practical decision?

<something> can be aliens, ESP, ghosts, homeopathy, tarot, divining, angels, spirits, ancient technology, etc.
 
I don't see why there have to be any god or gods.

I agree with your perception! I, likewise, see no compelling reason or need for any god, gods or even God.

Neither, however, the limitations of my understandings and perceptions, nor the apparent absence of a requirement for the Divine, is relevent to issues of faith in the Divine.
 
If those are your beliefs, they are what they are, only you can change them. I care little whether or not you do. If you wish to understand and discuss my beliefs, understandings and considerations, I will be happy to engage in such an exchange. Given your propensity in the last few posts directed at my postings to alter my words and statements with your own confusions and disingenuities, I have strong doubts with regards to your intentions.
That said, and being a Christian, however, I'm more than willing to offer another cheek (...or two, should the situation merit it).
Vice versa applies of course (except for the "being a Christian" bit)
 
Every person that believes in a god believes it is God. The only difference between god and God is the belief of the believer.

I don't know that I would qualify that as the only difference, but I would account it as a significant difference.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom