A coherent definition of God

It is very easy to see why some people find it so easy to shoot down the straw-gods of their imaginations/definitions, and why some bleevers are so shaky and defensive/protective of their misbeliefs. I guess what amazes me most is that the non-bleevers seem as prone to naive literalism as many of the bleevers. I suspect that it is largely reflective of the more general intellectual sloth that seems to pervade most of modern society.
 
I find the discussions here quite lively. I haven't noticed any sloth, unless it from the believers too slow to catch up with the modern world.
 
It is very easy to see why some people find it so easy to shoot down the straw-gods of their imaginations/definitions, and why some bleevers are so shaky and defensive/protective of their misbeliefs. I guess what amazes me most is that the non-bleevers seem as prone to naive literalism as many of the bleevers. I suspect that it is largely reflective of the more general intellectual sloth that seems to pervade most of modern society.

I don't think it is intellectual sloth. I suspect it is that neither group is secure in an ability to prove his beliefs. He knows what he wants to be true but he cannot prove it. So far, no one has been able to really prove anything in the final analysis. And that makes us feel shaky in any effort to say "God is......".
 
Fictional.

If you are referring to scripture, I would trend more toward "mythical," but to get more to the root of the issue, "fictional" does not neccesarily or always equate to "untrue"/"inaccurate." Parables are an example of fictitous writings that embody or convey truths of human nature and tendencies. Likewise many works of historical fiction account and accord accurate background events and occurences and incorporate them into fictitous stories and tales. Prior to the development of the printing press, this was the primary means by which people learned and recounted history and fact, and such still plays a major role in most people's understandings of history.
 
If you are referring to scripture, I would trend more toward "mythical," but to get more to the root of the issue, "fictional" does not neccesarily or always equate to "untrue"/"inaccurate." Parables are an example of fictitous writings that embody or convey truths of human nature and tendencies. Likewise many works of historical fiction account and accord accurate background events and occurences and incorporate them into fictitous stories and tales. Prior to the development of the printing press, this was the primary means by which people learned and recounted history and fact, and such still plays a major role in most people's understandings of history.

I very much doubt that it is a truth of human nature that gods exist.
 
I must say I am disappointed.

Not with the contribution so far, but with the lack thereof.
You start a thread to which you don’t contribute other than to say you are disappointed, with the lack of contribution.

Jebus, I never understood the appeal of Pink Floyd or Clapton. Next it will be The Rolling Stones is God :-(
And slag the contributions.

Please show us how god should be defined.
 
Last edited:
You offer a single word and accuse others of . . .

It is very easy to see why some people find it so easy to shoot down the straw-gods of their imaginations/definitions, and why some bleevers are so shaky and defensive/protective of their misbeliefs. I guess what amazes me most is that the non-bleevers seem as prone to naive literalism as many of the bleevers. I suspect that it is largely reflective of the more general intellectual sloth that seems to pervade most of modern society.

To support your "creator" definition and demonstrate your intellectual prowess provide a single piece of credible evidence that a god created anything, let alone everything.

First of course you need to provide a single piece of credible evidence that a god exists other than being a fantasy belief in your head.
 
Last edited:
I don't think it is intellectual sloth. I suspect it is that neither group is secure in an ability to prove his beliefs. He knows what he wants to be true but he cannot prove it. So far, no one has been able to really prove anything in the final analysis. And that makes us feel shaky in any effort to say "God is......".


"Proofs" are the fodder of logic and logicisms, while that is one path to take, I rarely see much rigor in its application by either camp.

When it comes to faith, "proofs" are largely irrelevent. If you have faith and you run into compelling empiric evidences that support your faith, you no longer have faith, you have an evidence-based understanding that is as good and reliable as the empiric evidence supporting it. Likewise if you lack faith, empiric evidences aren't going to give you faith, they are merely going to present an evidence-based understanding that you will accept or attempt to refute.

Faith is not an empiric evidence-based state, it is a state of acceptance in the absence of empiric evidences. Note, not in the spite of empiric evidences, but in the absence of such evidences.
 
"Proofs" are the fodder of logic and logicisms, while that is one path to take, I rarely see much rigor in its application by either camp.

When it comes to faith, "proofs" are largely irrelevent. If you have faith and you run into compelling empiric evidences that support your faith, you no longer have faith, you have an evidence-based understanding that is as good and reliable as the empiric evidence supporting it. Likewise if you lack faith, empiric evidences aren't going to give you faith, they are merely going to present an evidence-based understanding that you will accept or attempt to refute.

Faith is not an empiric evidence-based state, it is a state of acceptance in the absence of empiric evidences. Note, not in the spite of empiric evidences, but in the absence of such evidences.

It doesn't take any faith to be of the opinion that no god or gods exist. All you have to do is think rationally.
 
Fixed that for you

The intellectual dishonesty inherent in changing my words to match your beliefs does not reflect what I stated, nor make such more accurate. You have a peculiar understanding of the term "fixed."
 
You offer a single word and accuse others of . . .



To support your "creator" definition and demonstrate your intellectual prowess provide a single piece of credible evidence that a god created anything, let alone everything.

First of course you hneed to provide a single piece of credible evidence that a god exists other than being a fantasy belief in your head.

Can you give a credible bit of evidence that God does not exist? Many of the myths can be disproven, yes, but can you definitely prove there is no superior power controlling the universe? I cannot. Nor can I prove the opposite. So, I shan't ask anyone else to do so.

That said, it is an interesting thread. It may not be what !Kaggen wanted but it is interesting.
 
The intellectual dishonesty inherent in changing my words to match your beliefs does not reflect what I stated, nor make such more accurate. You have a peculiar understanding of the term "fixed."

ftfy is just a way of expressing an opinion. He meant that all gods are creations of mankind.
 
Can you give a credible bit of evidence that God does not exist? Many of the myths can be disproven, yes, but can you definitely prove there is no superior power controlling the universe? I cannot. Nor can I prove the opposite. So, I shan't ask anyone else to do so.

That said, it is an interesting thread. It may not be what !Kaggen wanted but it is interesting.

Can you prove that leprechauns do not exist?
 
"Proofs" are the fodder of logic and logicisms, while that is one path to take, I rarely see much rigor in its application by either camp.

When it comes to faith, "proofs" are largely irrelevent. If you have faith and you run into compelling empiric evidences that support your faith, you no longer have faith, you have an evidence-based understanding that is as good and reliable as the empiric evidence supporting it. Likewise if you lack faith, empiric evidences aren't going to give you faith, they are merely going to present an evidence-based understanding that you will accept or attempt to refute.

Faith is not an empiric evidence-based state, it is a state of acceptance in the absence of empiric evidences. Note, not in the spite of empiric evidences, but in the absence of such evidences.

Maybe I am confused but, to have faith, don't you first need a belief to have faith in? Should I change "proofs" to "beliefs"? Would that do better?
 
You start a thread to which you don’t contribute other than to say you are disappointed, with the lack of contribution.


And slag the contributions.

Please show us how god should be defined.

:-)

At least someone is taking note.

As an ignostic I have yet to find a definition of God that was coherent. So I have none and therefore wondered if someone could help me out.
 
I very much doubt that it is a truth of human nature that gods exist.

Doubts are what they are, I've no intention of trying to convince you of anything one way or another, I'm merely sharing my understandings and beliefs, in the hopes that through such exchanges of perspectives and understandings I can learn more about the universe we both share.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom