A coherent definition of God

From what you've posted it seems they are fiction. Like this statement:



God and nature are two different things. One is a myth and the other is real. I didn't need to study that for very long so Spinoza must have wasted a lot of time on that nonsense claim.




Bill does not know what he is talking about. He is misinterpreting Spinoza.

Spinoza's argument is that God is nature and thus is not anything other than nature.

Spinoza was an atheist of sorts (as much as one could be in those days) and was shunned out of his Jewish community due to his arguments that God is just nature.

See this article
On 27 July 1656, the Jewish community issued him the writ of cherem (Hebrew: חרם, a kind of excommunication).

While the language of the cherem is unusually harsh, the exact reason for expelling Spinoza is not stated.[8] However, according to philosopher Steven Nadler an educated guess is quite straightforward: "No doubt he was giving utterance to just those ideas that would soon appear in his philosophical treatises. In those works, Spinoza denies the immortality of the soul; strongly rejects the notion of a providential God—the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob; and claims that the Law was neither literally given by God nor any longer binding on Jews. Can there be any mystery as to why one of history's boldest and most radical thinkers was sanctioned by an orthodox Jewish community?"


Also see this
Spinoza was raised in the Dutch Jewish community. In time he developed highly controversial ideas regarding the authenticity of the Hebrew Bible and the nature of the Divine. The Jewish religious authorities issued a cherem (Hebrew: חרם, a kind of excommunication) against him, effectively dismissing him from Jewish society at age 23. His books were also later put on the Catholic Church's Index of Forbidden Books.
 
Last edited:
Spinoza said that God and Nature cannot be two different things. Saying God does not exist is like saying Nature does not exist.

God and nature are two different things. One is a myth and the other is real.

I think he is talking about the pantheist 'God' which is basically nature. It's an answer to the OP as much as any other flavour of god.
 
I speak of Faith in a God; perhaps not your peccadillo.
Yes I do have some faith, but I regard it as part of my conditioning or some biological phenomena. My intellect is in charge.


You see selectively.
This is debatable.



So, they emerge in nature? Nature thus precedes them? Sorted.
Not necessarily, I see no reason to conflate God with first cause, they are quite different.

The idea of an omnipotent God creating everything in a first cause is nonsensical and illogical. I doubt that the scholars who first coined the phrase meant it literally in the way we understand it today. Especially if one looks at the likely circumstances in which it was used.

Also the infinite regression conundrum is present in any explanation of existence. We have to live with it.
 
Last edited:
I think I'm getting the hang of this God talk thing. Must be what Theology is founded on.


  1. The basic rule is never claim anything.
  2. If you are pressed on a concept, slip out by "I meant—" and then invent some new concept.
  3. If you go round in a loop and get caught, claim it's a mystery.
  4. When pressured say "Have you read ____?" And wave your hand.
  5. Aquinas. He's the Einstein of God.
  6. Be hyper-acute to any perceived slight. Magnify it. Add the word "strident", "militant" or "angry" into the mix.

Got any more?
 
I think I'm getting the hang of this God talk thing. Must be what Theology is founded on.


  1. The basic rule is never claim anything.
  2. If you are pressed on a concept, slip out by "I meant—" and then invent some new concept.
  3. If you go round in a loop and get caught, claim it's a mystery.
  4. When pressured say "Have you read ____?" And wave your hand.
  5. Aquinas. He's the Einstein of God.
  6. Be hyper-acute to any perceived slight. Magnify it. Add the word "strident", "militant" or "angry" into the mix.

Got any more?

Are you referring to the atheists or the theists? (before I answer)
 
I think I'm getting the hang of this God talk thing. Must be what Theology is founded on.


  1. The basic rule is never claim anything.
  2. If you are pressed on a concept, slip out by "I meant—" and then invent some new concept.
  3. If you go round in a loop and get caught, claim it's a mystery.
  4. When pressured say "Have you read ____?" And wave your hand.
  5. Aquinas. He's the Einstein of God.
  6. Be hyper-acute to any perceived slight. Magnify it. Add the word "strident", "militant" or "angry" into the mix.

Got any more?

You got it right. Just add to the mix

  1. Warping and contorting and writhing every possible way to fit in any crack
  2. Warping and contorting and writhing every possible way to get out of any hole
  3. Throwing red herrings all over the place
  4. Using ad hominems every possible way to divert attention from their attempts in 1 and 2 above
  5. Claim any rebuttals or attack to their claims to be personal attack on them and then do 6 below
  6. Demand respect all the while they are dishing out personal insults



 
Last edited:
I think I'm getting the hang of this God talk thing. Must be what Theology is founded on.


  1. The basic rule is never claim anything.
  2. If you are pressed on a concept, slip out by "I meant—" and then invent some new concept.
  3. If you go round in a loop and get caught, claim it's a mystery.
  4. When pressured say "Have you read ____?" And wave your hand.
  5. Aquinas. He's the Einstein of God.
  6. Be hyper-acute to any perceived slight. Magnify it. Add the word "strident", "militant" or "angry" into the mix.

Got any more?

That is the mystic's methodology in a nutshell.
 
I think I'm getting the hang of this God talk thing. Must be what Theology is founded on.


  1. The basic rule is never claim anything.
  2. If you are pressed on a concept, slip out by "I meant—" and then invent some new concept.
  3. If you go round in a loop and get caught, claim it's a mystery.
  4. When pressured say "Have you read ____?" And wave your hand.
  5. Aquinas. He's the Einstein of God.
  6. Be hyper-acute to any perceived slight. Magnify it. Add the word "strident", "militant" or "angry" into the mix.
Got any more?
Here’s my take on Trakar Godtalk . . .

(1) Claim to believe in only one thing - a creator of everything (only one thing to be debated).
(2) Claim to believe purely by faith - merely choose and want to believe (no substance to be debated).
(3) Claim faith is a total lack of “imperic evidences” - blind acceptance (no substance to be debated).
(4) Claim to have considered and analysed faith subjectively - by personal opinion (no substance to be debated).
(5) Communicate as if you’re compiling wordy clues for a criptic crossword puzzle.
(6) When challenged on (1) cite (2), (3), and (4) in the manner of (5).
 
Here’s my take on Trakar Godtalk . . .

(1) Claim to believe in only one thing - a creator of everything (only one thing to be debated).
(2) Claim to believe purely by faith - merely choose and want to believe (no substance to be debated).
(3) Claim faith is a total lack of “imperic evidences” - blind acceptance (no substance to be debated).
(4) Claim to have considered and analysed faith subjectively - by personal opinion (no substance to be debated).
(5) Communicate as if you’re compiling wordy clues for a criptic crossword puzzle.
(6) When challenged on (1) cite (2), (3), and (4) in the manner of (5).

(7) Channel Jeeves.
 
"Yes sir? Oh? Very droll, sir. May fill you mustard jar with sherry? A pleasure sir. Yes, I entirely agree. The poor should be shot. May I light that for you?"

BTW, Jeeves enjoys ynot's point six above. Cite and run, leaving a cloud of inky words.
 
Bill does not know what he is talking about. He is misinterpreting Spinoza.

Spinoza's argument is that God is nature and thus is not anything other than nature.

Spinoza was an atheist of sorts (as much as one could be in those days) and was shunned out of his Jewish community due to his arguments that God is just nature.

See this article

Also see this


When I did some reading on Spinoza, as Bill instructed, I saw about Spinoza being kicked out of the church and tried to find something specific in his writing that said whether he believed in the god of the bible or not and whether that was the cause. I didn't get the impression he believed from what I found, but his language seemed a bit obscure at times. Thanks for confirming my suspicions as I couldn't find text making that clear.

I still feel it's illogical to call 'nature' 'god' when we already have a perfect word for it ie 'nature'. I have several philosopy books and may take a gander to see why he's playing with semantics.

All those words just say that 'nature' is 'nature'. No wonder he needed a day job.
 
Joolz, I posted this above, Spinoza is claimed by the pantheists. What Dawkins calls 'sexed-up atheism' iirc.
 
Joolz, I posted this above, Spinoza is claimed by the pantheists. What Dawkins calls 'sexed-up atheism' iirc.

Thanks, I saw your post Donn, but I was still wondering whether he believed in the 'god' god and the 'nature' god was just him having a philosophical meander - and whether one or other was a cause for him being ostracised. I've only skimmed through the net and one book so I didn't trust myself to judge his theory on that dip alone.

Still don't know why you need to add in any type of god and say nature is sacred when it is already wonderful anyway, but maybe that's why I'm not a philosopher by trade :)

I gave up reading The God Delusion, maybe I'd better go and finish it :)
 
When I did some reading on Spinoza, as Bill instructed, I saw about Spinoza being kicked out of the church and tried to find something specific in his writing that said whether he believed in the god of the bible or not and whether that was the cause. I didn't get the impression he believed from what I found, but his language seemed a bit obscure at times. Thanks for confirming my suspicions as I couldn't find text making that clear.

I still feel it's illogical to call 'nature' 'god' when we already have a perfect word for it ie 'nature'. I have several philosopy books and may take a gander to see why he's playing with semantics.

All those words just say that 'nature' is 'nature'. No wonder he needed a day job.


Joolz,

Spinoza was in the 17th century and thus it would have been amazing for him to have become a full atheist. They did not have the answer to the final nagging question.... how was all this designed.

Had Spinoza and others after him like Voltaire and Paine... had they had the benefit of the theory of evolution and the knowledge we have about genetics and DNA as well as physics of today.... they would have become full atheists I am sure.

But Spinoza was very forward thinking in many things...you should read his Ethics and you will see.

He was an atheist for all practical purposes but he of course had to contend with the pervasive religiosity of the age. In his days the default position was God did it and the onus of proof was on the dissenters not the other way round like we take it for granted today thanks to the science we have.

So when he said that God is nature...he was trying to explain god away but in an easy step to swallow.

Also you have to consider that it was still an age of burning people who were called witches or heretics.

He was lucky he was not christian and thus did not have the persecution by the church (other than normal persecution of Jews) and was only expelled from the Jewish community who could not burn him for lack of power.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom