A coherent definition of God

Joolz,

Spinoza was in the 17th century and thus it would have been amazing for him to have become a full atheist. They did not have the answer to the final nagging question.... how was all this designed.

Had Spinoza and others after him like Voltaire and Paine... had they had the benefit of the theory of evolution and the knowledge we have about genetics and DNA as well as physics of today.... they would have become full atheists I am sure.

But Spinoza was very forward thinking in many things...you should read his Ethics and you will see.

He was an atheist for all practical purposes but he of course had to contend with the pervasive religiosity of the age. In his days the default position was God did it and the onus of proof was on the dissenters not the other way round like we take it for granted today thanks to the science we have.

So when he said that God is nature...he was trying to explain god away but in an easy step to swallow.

Also you have to consider that it was still an age of burning people who were called witches or heretics.

He was lucky he was not christian and thus did not have the persecution by the church (other than normal persecution of Jews) and was only expelled from the Jewish community who could not burn him for lack of power.


In that context it sounds much more rational - no pun intended :), I was thrown by Bill getting all upset about the definition of 'god' and being rude to Daffyd as if he meant the christian god. Posting cryptic comments and calling folk idiots if they don't use the same crossword compiler as you isn't smart, it smacks of elitism and arrogance in a forum where people seem keen to discuss new ideas. If he'd explained it instead of flaming, or you had posted first, then it would have been simple to follow. We don't all specialise in the same topics, we all have our strengths and weaknesses, and good teachers pitch info around the level of the audience so they can understand. For example, I tell my trainees that they have to take the cork out and have a glass handy before they pour the Merlot ;)


I've got 'Cambridge Texts in the History of Philosophy' version of Spinoza's Theological-Political Treatise, I've marked it to load to my tab next time I connect, although the book you mention is on Amazon UK for less than a pound so it's not a bank breaker!

Thanks for the interesting info.
 
LOL

Funny.

A grape is purple.
Purple is not grape.

Linguistic "is" is not always the same thing as a mathematical "equal".

"God is that which no greater can be thought" is not an original Bill Thompson quote, by the way. Google that quote if you want to read about it.

I think people cannot get away from the idea that God is not a magical man like Santa Claus. If you are stuck in that idea maybe you should try to get yourself unstuck.

Mankind brings god into existing by thinking?
 
Ah, but punshhh knows that there are unknown unknowns. How he knows this is unknown.

What he knows about the unknowns is unknown and will forever be unknown by us yet somehow these unknowns trump all science.:boggled:
 
Who said anything about cleaving?

I see nothing in nature which suggests there is no creator. Whereas I do see something which demonstrates that creators emerge naturally in nature.

If creators are emerging in nature they couldn't have created nature.


ETA: If they didn't create nature why call them creators?
 
Last edited:
What he knows about the unknowns is unknown and will forever be unknown by us yet somehow these unknowns trump all science.:boggled:

Yes. Science has been stumbling around in the dark and giving us the internet, modern medicine, radio and TV, and many other benefits while all the time the mystics with their unknown unknowns were doing the real work.
 
Non-existent, fictional character, needed to comfort people that cannot assume responsability for their own actions. Used to keep the peasants in line for hundereds of years by offering the comfort that if they did as they were told throughout their short, down-troden lives they would be taken to a better life after they died.
 
If creators are emerging in nature they couldn't have created nature.


ETA: If they didn't create nature why call them creators?

If creators had been emerging in nature and tweeking a bit here and a bit there. Over an infinite period of time they would have tweeked everything.

If you give an infinite number of intelligent civilisations a typewriter, over an infinite period of time they will write down the theory of everything. Infact they will have written the book.


Remember I am not talking of omnipotence, or any other omni's they are a distraction due to being illogical.
 
If creators had been emerging in nature and tweeking a bit here and a bit there. Over an infinite period of time they would have tweeked everything.

If you give an infinite number of intelligent civilisations a typewriter, over an infinite period of time they will write down the theory of everything. Infact they will have written the book.


Remember I am not talking of omnipotence, or any other omni's they are a distraction due to being illogical.

If if if. Do you have anything concrete to say instead of fantasing about creators? You know all about being illogical. It's tweaking and in fact is two words. Switch on your spell checker.
 
<snipped garbage>
Or you are impelled to go down Piggy's road that nothing exists unless a human can think about it and if it does exist we would be aware of it.

Kindly show where Piggy said that or retract. Thanks.
 
Feel free to correct my interpretation of Piggy's position.

Sure. Just point me to the post(s). You could alternatively retract, before you make an even bigger fool of yourself and prove once again for the posters here just how dishonest you are. Your choice.
 
Wow. That was a classic non re-traction!
A no-traction? nyet-traction? Whatever it's called, it was slippery.

ETA: Not Iaca's post.
 
Last edited:
Sure. Just point me to the post(s). You could alternatively retract, before you make an even bigger fool of yourself and prove once again for the posters here just how dishonest you are. Your choice.

So you have a different interpretation of Piggy's position. Never mind I can live with that.
 
Wow. That was a classic non re-traction!
A no-traction? nyet-traction? Whatever it's called, it was slippery.

ETA: Not Iaca's post.

My detractors are trying to get some traction out of the situation.
 
Lol. That was clever and funny.

I know you have it in you punshhh, so come all the way out of that dark mystic closet and join us in the light! You know you want to.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom