A coherent definition of God

God of the bible.................Worthless.

There is your definition for that one.


Paul

:) :) :)
 
I thought the definition of a god was that they are mostly the children of Chronus and Rhea and defeaters of the Titans. Seems pretty straightforward to me.
 
Joolz,

Spinoza was in the 17th century and thus it would have been amazing for him to have become a full atheist. They did not have the answer to the final nagging question.... how was all this designed.

Had Spinoza and others after him like Voltaire and Paine... had they had the benefit of the theory of evolution and the knowledge we have about genetics and DNA as well as physics of today.... they would have become full atheists I am sure.

But Spinoza was very forward thinking in many things...you should read his Ethics and you will see.

He was an atheist for all practical purposes but he of course had to contend with the pervasive religiosity of the age. In his days the default position was God did it and the onus of proof was on the dissenters not the other way round like we take it for granted today thanks to the science we have.

So when he said that God is nature...he was trying to explain god away but in an easy step to swallow.

Also you have to consider that it was still an age of burning people who were called witches or heretics.

He was lucky he was not christian and thus did not have the persecution by the church (other than normal persecution of Jews) and was only expelled from the Jewish community who could not burn him for lack of power.
By and large, I agree with your explanation, with a couple of comments.

Spinoza was lucky to live in the Dutch Republic - by far the most tolerant European state at the moment - otherwise he'd have been prosecuted for his religious views irrespective of being Jewish or Christian, and certainly couldn't have published his books. In the Dutch context, I doubt being Jewish was a distinct advantage here: he was shunned entirely from the relatively small, tightly-knit Sephardim community, and thus lost all his friends he grew up with.

And the last witch trial in the Republic took place in 1610, before Spinoza was born.
 
My detractors are trying to get some traction out of the situation.

You called your teacher a "detractor" when s/he pointed out your errors? Weird vocabulary you got there... Might explain why you are seemingly unable to communicate efficiently and why you're incapable of understanding other people's clear explanations.
 
You called your teacher a "detractor" when s/he pointed out your errors? Weird vocabulary you got there... Might explain why you are seemingly unable to communicate efficiently and why you're incapable of understanding other people's clear explanations.

Punshhh does have a Humpty Dumpty approach to language.
 
Yeah, just like he lied last March about posters here claiming that "we know everything". It's kind of disgusting.

Mysticism has no basis in reality so if you believe in it you have to lie.
 
By and large, I agree with your explanation, with a couple of comments.

Spinoza was lucky to live in the Dutch Republic - by far the most tolerant European state at the moment - otherwise he'd have been prosecuted for his religious views irrespective of being Jewish or Christian, and certainly couldn't have published his books. In the Dutch context, I doubt being Jewish was a distinct advantage here: he was shunned entirely from the relatively small, tightly-knit Sephardim community, and thus lost all his friends he grew up with.

And the last witch trial in the Republic took place in 1610, before Spinoza was born.



I agree.... living in tolerant Holland was a lucky thing for him (and humanity). René Descartes also had to take refuge there when things got too hot for him in France.

Holland did regress a little however in later years and Papal political pressure did have some influence on it sometimes.
 
Interesting. I got the impression earlier on in the thread that Bill Thompson was the only person in the world who had ever heard of Spinoza.
 
Interesting. I got the impression earlier on in the thread that Bill Thompson was the only person in the world who had ever heard of Spinoza.



If he did in fact read his works he badly misunderstood him.


Baruch Spinoza, Gottfried Leibniz and René Descartes should be on the reading list of everyone.

Unfortunately they are a bit boring.
 
I agree.... living in tolerant Holland was a lucky thing for him (and humanity). René Descartes also had to take refuge there when things got too hot for him in France.

Holland did regress a little however in later years and Papal political pressure did have some influence on it sometimes.
You mean when pope Innocentius XI bribed William III to overthrow James II of England? :D

I'm not aware of effective papal pressure, could you enlighten me? OTOH, I think the Republic encouraged the establishment of the Old Catholic Church by Dutch Jansenists.

Of course, Dutch tolerance had its bounds: only the Dutch Reformed Church - and later the Jews - were allowed outward display of religion. And some people who went too far in their criticism of religion were prosecuted for blasphemy, such as Spinoza's friend Adriaan Koerbagh, who got 10 years jail for, a.o., calling all organized religion hypocrisy.
 
You mean when pope Innocentius XI bribed William III to overthrow James II of England? :D

I'm not aware of effective papal pressure, could you enlighten me? OTOH, I think the Republic encouraged the establishment of the Old Catholic Church by Dutch Jansenists.

Of course, Dutch tolerance had its bounds: only the Dutch Reformed Church - and later the Jews - were allowed outward display of religion. And some people who went too far in their criticism of religion were prosecuted for blasphemy, such as Spinoza's friend Adriaan Koerbagh, who got 10 years jail for, a.o., calling all organized religion hypocrisy.



You are already quite enlightened..... I cite everything you said in your post. :)

But also remember that Ferdinand II was Holy Roman Emperor and King of Holland for a while.... so obviously Papal influence was not far off.

I also remember reading (a million years ago) that Descartes was also tried for some sort of Heresy and had to leave Holland.... I may be wrong though...my memory has never been any good and now it is even worse.... I am not able to find anything on the internet.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom