no religion defines God. So flush out your headgear, noob, and get back to me when you are ready.
Dictionary: Newbie or noob is a slang term for a novice or newcomer, or somebody inexperienced in any profession or activity. [....] It can have derogatory connotations, but is also often used for descriptive purposes only, without a value judgment.
I assume that's a derogatory comment about me, son, as I only joined JREF last month? Whilst literally true, being a newbie to a specific forum doesn't equate with ignorance. Not actually reading a post that you flame a reply to the other hand......
At no time have I said any 'religion defines god' as that is not correct. I started to type that 'there are as many definitions of god as religions' in my first draft, but instantly realised that was wrong as even individuals in the same religion have different definitions of god, as evidenced by theists posting here. Then I thought I should include my personal (atheist) definition, and realised that other atheists have different definitions, so I added more folk to my list of different definitions. The only people on the planet I could really rule out were those who were not capable of even considering the matter, hence the post I made that there is no
coherent definition. If there was then theists might not kill each other as often.
I recommend reading posts before clicking 'submit reply', it can save you making silly posts.
And as for your recommended reading, I did the search you suggested, sorry, but these are just addled logic:
Anselm's fourth argument, the argument from eternity, relies, similarly, on two premises. The maximal being, Anselm argues, can only be thought of as without a beginning. Yet whatever can be thought of as existing, but does not actually exist, can be thought of as with a beginning. Since, according to Anselm's third introductory premise, God is actually thought, he must, therefore, exist, because, if he did not he could be thought of as having a beginning, which is self-contradictory.
Anselm has, therefore, overcome much of the gap between faith and understanding; for the more one knows through faith about God's nature, the more, with the help of Anselm's techniques, can one defend that knowledge.