A coherent definition of God

I think people cannot get away from the idea that God is not a magical man like Santa Claus. If you are stuck in that idea maybe you should try to get yourself unstuck.

You may not use language such as god wants..., god intended..., or god loves... but there are a great many who do. Perhaps they're stuck. People who argue against such a god are not the ones who are stuck.
 
Irrelevant - It’s not whether anyone has seriously proposed that any mythical characters exist or not, it’s that they could do so and if they did their claim couldn’t be disproved. Serious proposal or lack thereof isn’t proof or disproof of anything other than possibly the belief and bias of the proposer.

Actually, it would. If there were individuals that seriously proposed a logically consistent real or even non-physical "Tooth fairy" with an identifiable role and yet without evidences supporting or negating its existence,...I would acknowledge that this might well be as actual as the God of my faith. Much would depend upon an analysis of their faith and the assertions associated with that faith.
Wrong - One Santa “role” is essentially the same as one God “role“ - Behave or else.

The extent of my faith in God, is that He is the Creator. You are speaking of a human mythos that some people often attribute to God.

Irrelevant - That millions have acted the part of these characters doesn’t have any bearing on whether the portrayed characters exist or not. Many people have also acted the part of a god and many people have claimed to be a god or “his” personal representative. So What? It’s merely argumentum ad populum.

Your understandings are incorrect. Argumentum ad populum is an argument that because many people believe something it must be true. That is not at all what I have stated. What I said is that the only physical expressions of these characters are the acts they purportedly commit (ie., the bringing of presents to children on Christmas eve, the swapping of teeth under placed under pillows for cash, and the hiding of colored eggs and candy on Easter morning). We have the testimony of millions of parents and family members who can testify that they are the ones who actually committed these acts. These are contraindicative evidences.

Don’t have the time to decipher and reply to this at present. Will do so later if not addressed adequately by others.

To assist you in your considerations -
People didn't create the Santa Clause mythos because presents started mysteriously appearing on Christmas morning and they were trying to create an explanation for them. Nor did money start appearing under pillows where teeth had been placed for safe-keeping, nor brightly colored eggs start appearing on Easter morning. IOW the myths preceeded the behavior the actors, it isn't that the acts started and then the myths were created to explain them.

I don’t make such a claim. You make that claim in regard to Santa, Tooth Fairy and Easter Bunny.

Then please clarify and explain the statement of this post, with the understanding that the only event I attribute to God is creation:

...Equally - As for god, there are evidences a plenty that confirm both the fictitious nature of "his" existence and the absence of "his" presence in the events oft attributed to "him".
 
True. I'm an atheist and I know more about Christian myths than most Christians that I've met.

From your discussions here, your accurate understanding is no greater than any, and much more distorted than many. But these are your beliefs and you are free to categorize them as you wish regardless of the accuracy of such categorizations.
 
I will start with the “easiest” one . . .
Then please clarify and explain the statement of this post, with the understanding that the only event I attribute to God is creation:
Already clarified and explained . . .
I was mimicking your claim to mock it. I don’t believe you can disprove (or prove) the existence of a Santa, Tooth Fairy or Easter Bunny any more than I can of a god.
Please let me know if I can assist you in your considerations further.
 
... People who argue against such a god are not the ones who are stuck.

I whole heartedly agree, except when they argue by trying to substitute other's distorted caricatures with a distorted caricature of their own.
 
I will start with the “easiest” one . . .

Already clarified and explained . . .

Please let me know if I can assist you in your considerations further.

If this is an example of your personal ethos and intellectual honesty, further discussion is without merit.
 
If this is an example of your personal ethos and intellectual honesty, further discussion is without merit.
Not sure what the “example” you are alluding to is. Is it the content of what I quoted, or is it that I quoted the content in response to you post?
 
Actually, it would. If there were individuals that seriously proposed a logically consistent real or even non-physical "Tooth fairy" with an identifiable role and yet without evidences supporting or negating its existence,...I would acknowledge that this might well be as actual as the God of my faith. Much would depend upon an analysis of their faith and the assertions associated with that faith.
What "it Would"? Be proof? “might well” isn’t proof.

The extent of my faith in God, is that He is the Creator. You are speaking of a human mythos that some people often attribute to God.
When did we agree that we were speaking exclusively about your particular god belief and faith?
Your faith in a God doesn’t make your belief any less a “human mythos” than would a faith in Santa, etc.
Your understandings are incorrect. Argumentum ad populum is an argument that because many people believe something it must be true. That is not at all what I have stated. What I said is that the only physical expressions of these characters are the acts they purportedly commit (ie., the bringing of presents to children on Christmas eve, the swapping of teeth under placed under pillows for cash, and the hiding of colored eggs and candy on Easter morning). We have the testimony of millions of parents and family members who can testify that they are the ones who actually committed these acts. These are contraindicative evidences.
Then why introduce “the testimonies of millions of individuals” to the debate?

And the only physical expressions of God characters are the acts they purportedly commit (i.e. creation).

They aren’t contraindicative evidences to a person that has a belief and faith that Santa, Tooth Fairy and Easter Bunny actually exist. Faith ignores evidences.

Besides you have said yourself that what is merely written or said shouldn’t be taken literally . . .
I guess what amazes me most is that the non-bleevers seem as prone to naive literalism as many of the bleevers.
 
Last edited:
If there were individuals that seriously proposed a logically consistent real or even non-physical "Tooth fairy" (The Tooth Fairy myth is consistent and non-physical) with an identifiable role (Pay for teeth placed under a pillow*) and yet without evidences supporting or negating its existence, (no evidence supports or negates the existence of a Tooth Fairy)...I would acknowledge that this might well be as actual as the God of my faith (then why don‘t you do so?). Much would depend upon an analysis of their faith and the assertions associated with that faith (what can be analysed in a faith when a faith isn‘t based on anything analysable? What can be asserted other than an assertion of faith?)
So the only thing missing for you to believe in a Tooth Fairy as much as you believe in a god is a serious proposal?

* Although the Tooth Fairy may not be the one that actually puts the money under the pillow it is responsible for influencing those that do.
 
Last edited:
A person claims to have faith that X actually exists. The person makes no claim about their faith other than they have it. What is there to be analysed? To analyse whether the person that made the claim is genuine or not is an analysis of the person not the claim. That the person may be found to be disingenuous in their claim doesn’t provide any credible evidence that the claim itself is necessarily wrong (or right).
 
Last edited:
Actually, it would. If there were individuals that seriously proposed a logically consistent real or even non-physical "Tooth fairy" with an identifiable role and yet without evidences supporting or negating its existence,...I would acknowledge that this might well be as actual as the God of my faith. Much would depend upon an analysis of their faith and the assertions associated with that faith.

and

The extent of my faith in God, is that He is the Creator. You are speaking of a human mythos that some people often attribute to God.

You have no issue with this? On one hand, you are saying that santa and god are not alike as people actually really truly believe in god, and on the other hand you are disassociating *your* god with all other gods?

so.... *one* person believes in your god, vs millions of children at any one time.... if I could find 2 adults who really believed in the santa myth, would this satisfy this particular demand?
 
I must say I am disappointed.

Not with the contribution so far, but with the lack thereof.

Ask a silly question and you'll get a silly answer. It's not possible to have a coherent (or logical) definition for something that may have as many different definitions as there are people on the planet old enough to consider the matter.


co·her·ent [koh-heer-uhnt, -her-] adjective
1. logically connected; consistent: a coherent argument.
2. cohering; sticking together: a coherent mass of sticky candies.
3. having a natural or due agreement of parts; harmonious: a coherent design.
 
Who was that vitriolic self-aggrandising nonsense aimed at?
Bill's having a bad hair day (see post #252)

Seems he holds noobs in the same low esteem he holds females (see post #259).
 
Last edited:
no religion defines God. So flush out your headgear, noob, and get back to me when you are ready.


Dictionary: Newbie or noob is a slang term for a novice or newcomer, or somebody inexperienced in any profession or activity. [....] It can have derogatory connotations, but is also often used for descriptive purposes only, without a value judgment.​

I assume that's a derogatory comment about me, son, as I only joined JREF last month? Whilst literally true, being a newbie to a specific forum doesn't equate with ignorance. Not actually reading a post that you flame a reply to the other hand......

At no time have I said any 'religion defines god' as that is not correct. I started to type that 'there are as many definitions of god as religions' in my first draft, but instantly realised that was wrong as even individuals in the same religion have different definitions of god, as evidenced by theists posting here. Then I thought I should include my personal (atheist) definition, and realised that other atheists have different definitions, so I added more folk to my list of different definitions. The only people on the planet I could really rule out were those who were not capable of even considering the matter, hence the post I made that there is no coherent definition. If there was then theists might not kill each other as often.

I recommend reading posts before clicking 'submit reply', it can save you making silly posts.

And as for your recommended reading, I did the search you suggested, sorry, but these are just addled logic:

Anselm's fourth argument, the argument from eternity, relies, similarly, on two premises. The maximal being, Anselm argues, can only be thought of as without a beginning. Yet whatever can be thought of as existing, but does not actually exist, can be thought of as with a beginning. Since, according to Anselm's third introductory premise, God is actually thought, he must, therefore, exist, because, if he did not he could be thought of as having a beginning, which is self-contradictory.


Anselm has, therefore, overcome much of the gap between faith and understanding; for the more one knows through faith about God's nature, the more, with the help of Anselm's techniques, can one defend that knowledge.​
 
Anselm's fourth argument, the argument from eternity, relies, similarly, on two premises. The maximal being, Anselm argues, can only be thought of as without a beginning. Yet whatever can be thought of as existing, but does not actually exist, can be thought of as with a beginning. Since, according to Anselm's third introductory premise, God is actually thought, he must, therefore, exist, because, if he did not he could be thought of as having a beginning, which is self-contradictory.


Anselm has, therefore, overcome much of the gap between faith and understanding; for the more one knows through faith about God's nature, the more, with the help of Anselm's techniques, can one defend that knowledge.​

:jaw-dropp :jaw-dropp :jaw-dropp :jaw-dropp
 
i don't know where she got that quote. it was not his best or final draft, I guess.

I think dafy just browsed a few lines of text and pulled out something she could make fun of.

Spinoza said that God and Nature cannot be two different things. Saying God does not exist is like saying Nature does not exist.

But there is lots and lots more. Spinoza is not even the tip of the iceburg.

She lol. Is Iceburg a town in the States?
 
From your discussions here, your accurate understanding is no greater than any, and much more distorted than many. But these are your beliefs and you are free to categorize them as you wish regardless of the accuracy of such categorizations.

Well, that's me told off by the man from Roget's Thesaurus. Carry on believing in your sky daddy, I'll stick to reality.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom