A coherent definition of God

Some more waffle from Spinoza

CONCERNING GOD.

DEFINITIONS.

I. By that which is self-caused, I mean that of which the essence involves existence, or that of which the nature is only conceivable as existent.

II. A thing is called finite after its kind, when it can be limited by another thing of the same nature; for instance, a body is called finite because we always conceive another greater body. So, also, a thought is limited by another thought, but a body is not limited by thought, nor a thought by body.

III. By substance, I mean that which is in itself, and is conceived through itself; in other words, that of which a conception can be formed independently of any other conception.

IV. By attribute, I mean that which the intellect perceives as constituting the essence of substance.

V. By mode, I mean the modifications ["Affectiones"] of substance, or that which exists in, and is conceived through, something other than itself.

VI. By God, I mean a being absolutely infinite--that is, a substance consisting in infinite attributes, of which each expresses eternal and infinite essentiality.
Explanation.--I say absolutely infinite, not infinite after its kind: for, of a thing infinite only after its kind, infinite attributes may be denied; but that which is absolutely infinite, contains in its essence whatever expresses reality, and involves no negation.

VII. That thing is called free, which exists solely by the necessity of its own nature, and of which the action is determined by itself alone. On the other hand, that thing is necessary, or rather constrained, which is determined by something external to itself to a fixed and definite method of existence or action.

VIII. By eternity, I mean existence itself, in so far as it is conceived necessarily to follow solely from the definition of that which is eternal.
Explanation.--Existence of this kind is conceived as an eternal truth, like the essence of a thing, and, therefore, cannot be explained by means of continuance or time, though continuance may be conceived without a beginning or end.

AXIOMS.

I. Everything which exists, exists either in itself or in something else.

II. That which cannot be conceived through anything else must be conceived through itself.

III. From a given definite cause an effect necessarily follows; and, on the other hand, if no definite cause be granted, it is impossible that an effect can follow.

IV. The knowledge of an effect depends on and involves the knowledge of a cause.

V. Things which have nothing in common cannot be understood, the one by means of the other; the conception of one does not involve the conception of the other.

VI. A true idea must correspond with its ideate or object.

VII. If a thing can be conceived as non-existing, its essence does not involve existence.




''If a thing can be conceived as non-existing, its essence does not involve existence.'' Deep stuff. Straight out of Monty Python.
 
Last edited:
I was not endeavoring to excuse or enucleate the comportment of the esteemed member. Rather, I was attempting to elucidate to you that the member referred to was merely enunciating that your missives are redolent of the Star Wars character Yoda.

Bodacious dude!
:wackynotworthy:
 
Some Geese

EVERY child who has the use
Of his senses knows a goose.
See them underneath the tree
Gather round the goose-girl's knee,
While she reads them by the hour
From the works of Schopenhauer.

How patiently the geese attend!
But do they really comprehend
What Schopenhauer's driving at?
Oh, not at all; but what of that?
Neither do I; neither does she;
And, for that matter, nor does he.

Oliver Herford
 
''It is said of a certain poet that, though he tortures the English language, he has never yet succeeded in forcing it to reveal his meaning.''' Beachcomber.
 
How far have we got? We have one side that says gods are imaginary. Anyone want to get back on topic?
 
HUH?
Looks like a logical fallacy to me.

The first line is not factual.

God does not equal Spinoza's definition.

The second line is also supposition.

Therefore, you don't know what you are saying.

Much like Spinoza.
 
WHAT?! That does not make any sense.

I am quoting people who have thought about this topic longer than you and I and are respected in scientific communities and by noteworthy scientists.

It is like saying "my definition of hydrogen is just as valid as yours and I say it does not exist".

You define God as an invisible man in the sky and that defintion is valid to you? Are you serious?

Of course. Gods are primitive concepts, a relic from past times. They have no place in an educated modern world. Hydrogen does exist, you miss the point yet again. No evidence of the existence of a god has ever been presented so my definition of an imaginary being or spirit is as valid as anyone else's. I cannot take self-deluded theologians and philosophers seriously, no matter how long they have thought about this subject. The scientists are just humouring them.
 
Last edited:
Speaking of things Anselm (which should be a synonym for slippery) here's a classic quote from TGD, pg 83. Douglas Gasking's proof that God does not exist, Anselm style.

  1. The creation of the world is the most marvelous achievement imaginable.
  2. The merit of an achievement is the product of (a) its intrinsic quality, and (b) the ability of its creator.
  3. The greater the disability (or handicap) of the creator, the more impressive the achievement.
  4. The most formidable handicap for a creator would be non-existence.
  5. Therefore if we suppose that the universe is the product of an existent creator we can conceive a greater being - namely, one who created everything while not existing.
  6. An existing God therefore would not be a being greater than which a greater cannot be conceived because an even more formidable and incredible creator would be a God which did not exist.

    Ergo:
  7. God does not exist.
 
Speaking of things Anselm (which should be a synonym for slippery) here's a classic quote from TGD, pg 83. Douglas Gasking's proof that God does not exist, Anselm style.

An excellent parody of philosophical waffle.
 
Speaking of things Anselm (which should be a synonym for slippery) here's a classic quote from TGD, pg 83. Douglas Gasking's proof that God does not exist, Anselm style.

An excellent example of the futility of using human thought to asses the nature or origin of existence!

Regarding existence the only thing we can work with is what we observe in nature. Through which we are each well acquainted with what exists and its nature.
 
An excellent example of the futility of using human thought to asses the nature or origin of existence!

Regarding existence the only thing we can work with is what we observe in nature. Through which we are each well acquainted with what exists and its nature.

Reality, in other words. No need for gods or mysticism.
 
An excellent example of the futility of using human thought to asses the nature or origin of existence!

Quite, a priori arguments tend this way.

Regarding existence the only thing we can work with is what we observe in nature.

Indeed. I don't get how you can hold your mystical views given what you have just said.

To leap to God from an armchair, is hubris. To cleave to God is madness.
 
Quite, a priori arguments tend this way.



Indeed. I don't get how you can hold your mystical views given what you have just said.

To leap to God from an armchair, is hubris. To cleave to God is madness.

Who said anything about cleaving?

I see nothing in nature which suggests there is no creator. Whereas I do see something which demonstrates that creators emerge naturally in nature.
 
I


So, they emerge in nature? Nature thus precedes them? Sorted.

Yes the creator comes second, which rather defeats the object of being a creator. Don't worry, you will get used to punshhh's skewed logic. He will come back with some guff about infinite chains of creator gods or some such nonsense.
 
Last edited:
Writings of Spinoza are not fiction.<snip>

From what you've posted it seems they are fiction. Like this statement:

Spinoza said that God and Nature cannot be two different things.

God and nature are two different things. One is a myth and the other is real. I didn't need to study that for very long so Spinoza must have wasted a lot of time on that nonsense claim.

Saying God does not exist is like saying Nature does not exist. <snip>

Wrong again. I believe that god does not exist, but I believe that nature is all around us. See? They are not equivalent statements at all.

I am quoting people who have thought about this topic longer than you and I and are respected in scientific communities and by noteworthy scientists.

Maybe that's the problem, you need to think about it longer so you come to realize that that baseless claim by Spinzoa is false. He starts from the assumption that there is a god, and then defines it. Not a good place to start from.

Maybe he wrote better stuff on other topics that was appreciated by scientists, I doubt many serious scientists would endorse the nature = god fallacy. Or maybe they are "Michelle Bachman's scientists", the hundreds of Nobel science prize winners that she claims don't believe in evolution and agree with creationism. Jeez if 'merkans vote her in then they deserve all they get!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom