A coherent definition of God

That is not Spinoza's definition. Not knowing what you are talking about is not impressive.

By the way, did you figure out that there is no invisible man in the sky all by yourself or did someone have to tell you?

I did not say it was Spinoza's definition.
 
I never defined God as you do.

That's because you are not me. My definition is as valid as yours. I gave it sometime ago in this thread. My definition is imaginary. You may disagree with that but insults do not become you. Let's keep this at an adult level.
 
Last edited:
Because I don't take Spinoza's word as gospel?
God = Spinoza's definition.
Spinoza's definition = Bill Thompson’s belief.
Therefore - Bill Thompson’s belief = God.
And so it is with ALL believers.
 
Last edited:
God = Spinoza's definition.
Spinoza's definition = Bill Thompson’s belief.
Therefore - Bill Thompson’s belief = God.
And so it is with ALL believers.

''This proof that God—an infinite, necessary and uncaused, indivisible being—is the only substance of the universe proceeds in three simple steps. First, establish that no two substances can share an attribute or essence (. Then, prove that there is a substance with infinite attributes (i.e., God) (. It follows, in conclusion, that the existence of that infinite substance precludes the existence of any other substance. For if there were to be a second substance, it would have to have some attribute or essence. But since God has all possible attributes, then the attribute to be possessed by this second substance would be one of the attributes already possessed by God. But it has already been established that no two substances can have the same attribute. Therefore, there can be, besides God, no such second substance.''

Well, that's convinced me.
 
Last edited:
''This proof that God—an infinite, necessary and uncaused, indivisible being—is the only substance of the universe proceeds in three simple steps. First, establish that no two substances can share an attribute or essence (. Then, prove that there is a substance with infinite attributes (i.e., God) (. It follows, in conclusion, that the existence of that infinite substance precludes the existence of any other substance. For if there were to be a second substance, it would have to have some attribute or essence. But since God has all possible attributes, then the attribute to be possessed by this second substance would be one of the attributes already possessed by God. But it has already been established that no two substances can have the same attribute. Therefore, there can be, besides God, no such second substance.''

Well, that's convinced me.
It’s a pathetic believer shell game - Say proof should be provided then claim proof without providing it.

"prove that there is a substance with infinite attributes" . . . no proof provided . . . "God has all possible attributes"
 
Last edited:
God = Spinoza's definition.
Spinoza's definition = Bill Thompson’s belief.
Therefore - Bill Thompson’s belief = God.
And so it is with ALL believers.

HUH?
Looks like a logical fallacy to me.

The first line is not factual.

God does not equal Spinoza's definition.

The second line is also supposition.

Therefore, you don't know what you are saying.
 
Last edited:
I stopped reading at this point. Your tain of though is derailed and thus not worth reading on.

Your definition of God is one a 4 year old in a Lutherian daycare might have.

Your like the proverbial kid in school who is proud of completing a test first without noticing the question on the back side of the test paper.
I thought he was quoting Spinoza :confused:
 
That's because you are not me. My definition is as valid as yours.

WHAT?! That does not make any sense.

I am quoting people who have thought about this topic longer than you and I and are respected in scientific communities and by noteworthy scientists.

It is like saying "my definition of hydrogen is just as valid as yours and I say it does not exist".

You define God as an invisible man in the sky and that defintion is valid to you? Are you serious?
 
Last edited:
I thought he was quoting Spinoza :confused:

i don't know where she got that quote. it was not his best or final draft, I guess.

I think dafy just browsed a few lines of text and pulled out something she could make fun of.

Spinoza said that God and Nature cannot be two different things. Saying God does not exist is like saying Nature does not exist.

But there is lots and lots more. Spinoza is not even the tip of the iceburg.
 
Last edited:
HUH?
Looks like a logical fallacy to me.

The first line is not factual.

God does not equal Spinoza's definition.

The second line is also supposition.

Therefore, you don't know what you are saying.
Writings of Spinoza are not fiction.
Do you think his definition of God is all BS?
But let me rephrase for you . . .

Bill Thompson says God = That which no greater can be thought.
Bill Thompson can think of no greater than God.
Therefore Bill Thompson’s limitations of thought = God
 
i don't know where she got that quote. it was not his best or final draft, I guess.

I think dafy just browsed a few lines of text and pulled out something she could make fun of.

Spinoza said that God and Nature cannot be two different things. Saying God does not exist is like saying Nature does not exist.

But there is lots and lots more. Spinoza is not even the tip of the iceburg.
She? (hint - long hair doesn't = female)
 
But let me rephrase for you . . .

Bill Thompson says God = That which no greater can be thought.
Bill Thompson can think of no greater than God.
Therefore Bill Thompson’s limitations of thought = God

LOL

Funny.

A grape is purple.
Purple is not grape.

Linguistic "is" is not always the same thing as a mathematical "equal".

"God is that which no greater can be thought" is not an original Bill Thompson quote, by the way. Google that quote if you want to read about it.

I think people cannot get away from the idea that God is not a magical man like Santa Claus. If you are stuck in that idea maybe you should try to get yourself unstuck.
 
Last edited:
LOL

Funny.

A grape is purple.
Purple is not grape.

Linguistic "is" is not always the same thing as a mathematical "equal".

"God is that which no greater can be thought" is not an original Bill Thompson quote, by the way. Google that quote if you want to read about it.

I think people cannot get away from the idea that God is not a magical man like Santa Claus. If you are stuck in that idea maybe you should try to get yourself unstuck.
Good to see you have a sense of humour. I'm happy to become "unstuck" if you can provide some credible evidence why I should. Until then God = Santa for adults.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom