A coherent definition of God

That said, beyond the historic progenitor of the Santa myth (Bishop Saint Nicholas), there has never been any serious proposal of the reality of these characters beyond their fairy tale existence.
Irrelevant - It’s not whether anyone has seriously proposed that any mythical characters exist or not, it’s that they could do so and if they did their claim couldn’t be disproved. Serious proposal or lack thereof isn’t proof or disproof of anything other than possibly the belief and bias of the proposer.

There is no role or place outside of the human mythos
Wrong - One Santa “role” is essentially the same as one God “role“ - Behave or else.

and we have the testimonies of millions of individuals who acknowledge having acted the part these characters.
Irrelevant - That millions have acted the part of these characters doesn’t have any bearing on whether the portrayed characters exist or not. Many people have also acted the part of a god and many people have claimed to be a god or “his” personal representative. So What? It’s merely argumentum ad populum.

Additionally, the absence of these actors or the resultant indicators of existence beyond populations where the mythos exist would seem to indicate that understandings and exposure to the myths are necessary to spur individuals to act in accordance with the myths. Neither creation, nor creator are dependent upon the mythos of creation for their existence.
Don’t have the time to decipher and reply to this at present. Will do so later if not addressed adequately by others.

Please present your claimed evidences of non-existence.
I don’t make such a claim. You make that claim in regard to Santa, Tooth Fairy and Easter Bunny.
 
Last edited:
Many people have played Hamlet. No reason to believe that he exists.
 
The very idea of gods makes me laugh.
Then we are not talking about the same thing.
I had no reason to believe we were talking about mythology.
An obvious truth makes you laugh?

The question in this thread did not specify the biblical God. Why would you assume I was talking about that?
 
Last edited:
Then we are not talking about the same thing.
I had no reason to believe we were talking about mythology.
An obvious truth makes you laugh?

The question in this thread did not specify the biblical God. Why would you assume I was talking about that?

Gods are gods, whether biblical or found in some other work of fiction.
 
:-)

At least someone is taking note.

As an ignostic I have yet to find a definition of God that was coherent. So I have none and therefore wondered if someone could help me out.

Hi Kaggen,
I admit to some reservations about the term 'ignosticism'. It does seem a bit like 'fence sitting' to me - avoiding discussion after there has already been centuries of discussion. Like not wanting to address the cows wandering in the field because we can't define the barn they used to be in.

If I were to define God, it would be by activity. If God exists, what does God do? If we believed in God, how would our world be different in the absence of God? (Likewise, if we are convinced that God does not exist, what activity would convince us otherwise?) What is the relevance of God?

The best idea I've encountered is that the 'activity of God' is to serve as an ethical or moral horizon or ground. If there were such things as moral compasses, God would serve as something like magnetic north.

A 'perfect' believer in this sense, would be to align oneself with God.

(I usually hesitate to use the word moral because I think it is essentially a religious term, but in this use I'd equate it with ethics.)

I don't see how this would help an ignostic find their 'coherent God' though.

If God were a real entity, we would expect to see a similarity of 'horizons' in humanity. We would tend to nurture good in the same ways. If God were a human creation of the imagination though, we would see much the same thing.

Arguments over if (the idea of) God is real or imaginary do not really matter much to me. The constant conflict between theists and non-theists seems rather meaningless. Is that dot on the horizon really there or is it an illusion? An ignostic seems to say that until they know, they can't move one way or another. I would take a more contrarian position and say that the journey is the important part.

Move, live, do, be. Rather than think and argue.
 
Last edited:
Additionally, the absence of these actors or the resultant indicators of existence beyond populations where the mythos exist would seem to indicate that understandings and exposure to the myths are necessary to spur individuals to act in accordance with the myths.
Irrelevant - Same thing applies to all god myths. God myths aren’t known and acted out by everyone everywhere in the world either. So what? Many people don’t act in accordance with a god myth even thought they know as much if not more about it than those that do. All this has absolutely nothing to do with whether the character(s) of any myth actually exists or not.

Neither creation, nor creator are dependent upon the mythos of creation for their existence.
Are you claiming that you (and all other believers) would have independently conceived of the god/creation concept without the myth?

With the total lack of any credible evidence to the contrary, “creation” and “creator” ARE myths every bit as Santa, Tooth Fairy and Easter Bunny are.

Myth - "A traditional or legendary story, usually concerning some being or hero (god/santa) or event (creation/Xmas), with or without a determinable basis of fact or a natural explanation (you have confimed this), especially one that is concerned with deities or demigods (told ya!) and explains some practice, rite, or phenomenon of nature."
 
Last edited:
Many people don’t act in accordance with a god myth even thought they know as much if not more about it than those that do.

True. I'm an atheist and I know more about Christian myths than most Christians that I've met.
 
Gods are gods, whether biblical or found in some other work of fiction.

Writings of Spinoza are not fiction.

Your posts are emotionally charged and not very rational. Why is that? Why is that while at the same time you seem to be coping a know-it-all attitude you are also demonstrating that you don't know what I am talking about nor the subject matter?

And how is that not even more amusing?

I gave what has been generally accepted historically and logically as a coherent definition of God. The fact that you don't seem to get or appreciate it is a reflection on you, not on me.
 
Last edited:
Writings of Spinoza are not fiction.

Your posts are emotionally charged and not very rational. Why is that? Why is that while at the same time you seem to be coping a know-it-all attitude you are also demonstrating that you don't know what I am talking about nor the subject matter?

And how is that not even more amusing?

I gave what has been generally accepted historically and logically as a coherent definition of God. The fact that you don't seem to get or appreciate it is a reflection on you, not on me.
Yeah dafydd dude. Why you so “angry”? ;)
 
Not really angry. But people do not use their logic part of their brains when discussing religion. I thought we were discussing a coherent definition of God, not religion.

Same thing. Or are you saying that primitive man thought up religions and then said 'Dam, we forgot to add a god!' Or did the god come first and then they thought that they had to give him/her/it something to do?
 
Last edited:
Nobody's definition interests me. I see no point in speculating about imaginary beings.
That is not Spinoza's definition. Not knowing what you are talking about is not impressive.

By the way, did you figure out that there is no invisible man in the sky all by yourself or did someone have to tell you?
 
Last edited:
That is not Spinoza's definition. Not knowing what you are talking about is not impressive.

By the way, did you figure out that there is no invisible man in the sky all by yourself or did someone have to tell you?

No, I figured it out for myself when I was a child. When did it dawn on you? Saturation point has been reached. Hwyl nawr bachgen!
 
No, I figured it out for myself when I was a child. When did it dawn on you? Saturation point has been reached. Hwyl nawr bachgen!

I never defined God as you do.

Let me guess. Since I have been posting here you have not bothered to google Anselm or Spinoza.

Why should you? Right?

Screw learning something when it is much better to convince yourself you know better.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom