10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
No

Please read post #1282.

There were NO diesel fuel fires or debris damage in the area of the initiating event
that led to the collapse of WTC 7

Excuse me. You seem to have missed some of my posts.

Specifically the ones where I mention that the point of initiation of the collapse NEED NOT be where the initial DAMAGE took place.

Please at least tell me if you understand this point.
 
Skeptics are a special breed? Elitest maybe? People who don't agree with skeptics do what?...just think evil thoughts?

Debater 1: "Baseball players are better at batting then football players."
Miragememories: "Are baseball players a special breed ? Elitest maybe ?"

What part of the definition of "Skeptic" don't you understand ?

Well I guess there are few genuine skeptics on JREF most seem to spend their time mocking those who don't comply with the JREF rhetoric.

I'm sorry, what was that ? I was too busy mocking you.

I suggest you take a good long look in the mirror C. Think back to when you were..oh about 18 and not so much concerned with the approval of others. Take a good hard look at reality.

Coming from a Dylan Avery groupie, that's actually very funny.

It's only nonsense if it's illogical. Making it up...sigh..well that's what you are doing..stating as fact something that is nothing more than your prejudiced belief.

Speaking of prejudice, would you mind stating for the record your personal opinion of the American government in general and the Bush administration in particular PRIOR to 9/11 ?

You live in a world of petty crime where truth takes second stage to the convincing lie. How much do you understand and how much do you blindly accept because it's easier to let others think for you?

You've been watching too much X-files, son. The exact opposite, extreme view isn't healthier.

Meanwhile you live in your smug fantasyland believing that all is well in the world and that good always triumphs over evil.

Strawman.

You stupidly look at the evidence and apply your mind to distorting it into a form that you can digest rather than considering any new point of view that would alienate you from the JREF clowns and your no-it-all firefighter mate.

Are we going to discuss evidence at some point ? Or is this tomato-throwing contest going to last forever ?

You revel in absolute statements.

"9/11 was an inside job".

There is no gray in your world.

There is nothing BUT gray.

Do you really think you still retain the capacity to change your mind? This is where lying to yourself is a problem. It's such an easy path to maintain especially when you know your other half will never accept you thinking in opposition.

This is one of the problems with truthers. You are so utterly, completely convinced that your nonsense MUST be true because it is so immediately obvious to you, that the only possible explanation for dissention is willfull dishonesty on the part of your opponents. Isn't that "black and white" thinking ?

You have no problem self proclaiming yourself

Redundancy.

What makes you so special?

More special than armchair analysts thinking they know more about building construction and demolition than real experts in those fields ?
 
Last edited:
The area of the initiating event is under the penthouse

That's rather vague, don't you think ?

and it is not going to change.

You keep saying that as though you knew.

[/B] They could look at a hundred different scenarios as to where in this area the collapse started. So what?

"So what" ? Is this how you treat scientific investigations? "So what" ?

Until NIST comes up with something more definitive than "appears possible",
you [all] should stop saying that debris damage and fire caused WTC 7 to implode.

And you should stop thinking it was explosives, then. It seems that knowledge is impossible, with you.
 
Last edited:
Yes I can't say as I'm surprised.

I guess it's ok for someone you agree with to make personal attacks about my record but heaven forbid I respond in kind.

Your hypocracy is duly noted Tammy.

You JREFers never see yourselves, you spend all your time defining others.

I'm glad you think we live it such good times Tammy. For the moment, those of us living in the West do have it pretty good. It's a only a bubble though and we all know what happens to them. Enjoy it while you can.

MM

It's interesting to see that you post insults, and no actual evidence, and when people respond to you, you either ignore their posts or merely respond that your points were not directed at them. I'd say that makes you quite the coward. And considering that you're a nameless, faceless person on the internet, such cowardice is hard to understand.
 
Funny, when I go to make a cast with my fishing pole, the majority of movement in the pole is seen at the top, yet where does the motion initiate?

TAM:)
 
Might I point out that you have no problem stating quite definitly that explosives brought the building down.

Ok then though, I will state that given the evidence supporting DD/F and the lack of evidence otherwise I believe that DD/F is the most likely cause of the collapse of WTC 7.
We disagree about evidence for a CD.
This thread is about evidence for DD/F.

The only evidence for DD/F is that there were office fires in the east half of WTC 7 on floors 7, 8, 9, 11, 12 and 13.
By 4:45 p.m., the fire on floor 12 had burned out.

It is? Where in NIST's or FEMA's reports so far has diesel fire been claimed to be an 'important part' of the hypothesis on the collpase?
FEMA pg 1
"...it appears the collapse was primarily due to fire, rather than any impact damage from the collapsing towers

NIST pg 34
"....fire appears to have played a key role...."

Other than the fact that the supply pipe ran within feet of a door to the trusses
That is NOT evidence of a fire in that area.

and the missing fuel.
That is NOT evidence of fire in the area of the initiating event.

Fractured or severed supply pipes and diesel fuel fires were likely to have happened in the SW corner of WTC 7 where the heavy debris damage occurred.

Now that answers one question. FEMA does not consider diesel fuel fires an 'important part' of the debris damage/fire collapse hypothesis.
Wrong. If it were not important, then why are they looking ioto the possibility?
In the FEMA report pages 13 - 16, they lay out where the fuel tanks, pumps, risers and supply pipes were located.
On page 28 - 30 they base their 5th floor scenario on diesel fuel fires.

In the NIST report Summary pg 51
2) "Fires were not observed on Floor 5, but this may be due to the lack of windows. The presence of a fuel distribution system and the possibility of debris damage to the south face from WTC 1 debris impact, indicates that fires may have been present on Floor 5."

It is ONE senario that was brought up. Why? Because given the existance of a lot of diesel fuel in the building it was prudent and neccessary to look into possibile senarios that would have this as a contributing factor.
It is neither prudent or logical to investigate diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event when there is NO EVIDENCE that such a fire existed.

Perhaps the full report will have more evidence for such a fire in which case the prudence of looking into even less probable senarios will be illustrated.
Wishful thinking

If no further evidence is found for such fires than it may remain as a less probable senario.
Further evidence? There is NO evidence.

You have ignored my query a few times now
This thread is about DD/F, NOT CD.

When faced with the reality that there is

NO evidence of debris damage or diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event,

you try to shift the subject rather than admit that the ONLY evidence for DD/F is the office fires on several floors.
 
Christopher7, speaking of 'no evidence', now perhaps is the time you present your evidence that explosives brought WT7 down.
 
Excuse me. You seem to have missed some of my posts.
Specifically the ones where I mention that the point of initiation of the collapse NEED NOT be where the initial DAMAGE took place.
Please at least tell me if you understand this point.
[italic mine]
Yes.
There is NO evidence of damage in the area of the initiating event.

It is impossible to determine the point of initiation because the physical evidence was destroyed.
 
It's interesting to see that you post insults, and no actual evidence, and when people respond to you, you either ignore their posts or merely respond that your points were not directed at them. I'd say that makes you quite the coward. And considering that you're a nameless, faceless person on the internet, such cowardice is hard to understand.

You pretty much described yourself belz.

I ignore posts that are rhetorical or are just pissing in the wind.

Yours for instance.

MM
 
You pretty much described yourself belz.

I ignore posts that are rhetorical or are just pissing in the wind.

Yours for instance.

Oh for crying out loud, MM. It's not as if all your posts are studies in clear, rational thought. Speaking for the many lurkers and semi-lurkers on this forum any attempt by you to chastise anybody for rhetorical posts or pissing in the wind is so incredibly ironic as to be high comedy.
 
You pretty much described yourself belz.

I ignore posts that are rhetorical or are just pissing in the wind.

Yours for instance.

MM

MM - you have made 254 posts here.
Please point out a few of them that offer evidence, as opposed to rhetoric.
 
....
Fractured or severed supply pipes and diesel fuel fires were likely to have happened in the SW corner of WTC 7 where the heavy debris damage occurred....

My bolding.

Is this minor damage, by your thinking? It sure ain't in the SW corner -
Repeating the same nonsense many times doesn't make up for its defects, Chris.

WTC7_South_damage.jpg
 
C7 said:
The area of the initiating event is under the penthouse and it is not going to change.

That's rather vague, don't you think ?
You keep saying that as though you knew
The one thing OT'ers and CT'ers can agree on is that the collapse began under the east penthouse.

NIST determined the most likely area of the initiating event by reviewing videos and photographs.
[see post #1503 for ref.]

"So what" ? Is this how you treat scientific investigations? "So what" ?
When there is NO evidence for a remote possibility,

it is NOT a scientific investigation,

it is a fishing expedition.
 
We disagree about evidence for a CD.
This thread is about evidence for DD/F.

Well isn't that special!
You abandoned the thread in which I invited you to spell out the evidence that convinces you that it was CD. Now you take the stance that we don't discuss it on this thread.
I'll take that as an admission that you gots nuttin!
You had nothing to offer in the other thread and refuse to admit, except by refusal to discuss it, that all you have is a few people who say it 'sounded like an explosion" and the fact that the building fell in the direction of the force due to gravity on the Earth's surface just like they do when they are demolished by explosives.

The only evidence for DD/F is that there were office fires in the east half of WTC 7 on floors 7, 8, 9, 11, 12 and 13.
By 4:45 p.m., the fire on floor 12 had burned out.

Office fires, and debris damage. The debris damage that can be seen is only what was visible in the pictures of the building through the smoke but circumstantially we know that there were clear pictures of the SW corner where the damage was very severe and we can certainly extrapolate a possibility that there was an area of damage of similar severity elsewhere in the building. One also has to factor in the unknown trajectory and type of debris that entered the structure. You instead assume you know the exact trajectory and type of all debris that actually hit the building.(otherwise you could not make the definitive statements you do)

FEMA pg 1
"...it appears the collapse was primarily due to fire, rather than any impact damage from the collapsing towers

NIST pg 34
"....fire appears to have played a key role...."

My turn to claim mis-quote. I asked where FEMA or NIST said , as you claimed, that diesel fires were "very important" to the DD/F hypothesis.

That is NOT evidence of a fire in that area.

That is NOT evidence of fire in the area of the initiating event.

It is circumstantial evidence that makes such a fire a possibility. You really have to look up the definition of 'possible'. You seem to confuse it with 'probable' and 'definite'.

Fractured or severed supply pipes and diesel fuel fires were likely to have happened in the SW corner of WTC 7 where the heavy debris damage occurred.

Ok, I have no problem with that. Have I ever said it couldn't be.

Wrong. If it were not important, then why are they looking ioto the possibility?

Again look up the different meanings of possible,probable and definite.

In the FEMA report pages 13 - 16, they lay out where the fuel tanks, pumps, risers and supply pipes were located.
On page 28 - 30 they base their 5th floor scenario on diesel fuel fires.

In the NIST report Summary pg 51
2) "Fires were not observed on Floor 5, but this may be due to the lack of windows. The presence of a fuel distribution system and the possibility of debris damage to the south face from WTC 1 debris impact, indicates that fires may have been present on Floor 5."

It is neither prudent or logical to investigate diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event when there is NO EVIDENCE that such a fire existed.

There were fires on multiple floors, damage of varying degrees over the entire south face and there were multiple diesel fuel tanks and piping systems throughout the structure. It is therefore prudent and logical to map out those fuel systems and take stock of the remaining fuel. To not do so would be a gross incompetance.

Further evidence? There is NO evidence.

I use a future tense of possible new evidence and you make the present tense definitive statement that there IS NO evidence. Pray tell, what is the stock market going to do next week given your great ability to KNOW the future? Better yet perhaps you'd like to take the Randi Challenge and make $million.

This thread is about DD/F, NOT CD.

Addressed above. If you don't want to go into it here then go back to the thread that IS about CD and answer it there. It is YOUR deeply held belief , I find it curious why , instead of defending it you choose instead to concentrate all your energies on attacking the senarios concerning DD and fires. Even more curious is your attacking the diesel fuel fire so hard given that it recognized as not the most probable cause of fire damage.

When faced with the reality that there is

NO evidence of debris damage or diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event,

you try to shift the subject rather than admit that the ONLY evidence for DD/F is the office fires on several floors.


Once again you simply refuse/ignore anyone telling you that the damage need not be exactly along column 79,80 or 81 in order for one of those to be the first to fail. There was damage to the structure by debris and the exact nature of the effect on the structure has not been investigated thoroughly. You are making the definitive statement only because there is no EMPIRICAL evidence of damage or fire directly affecting these columns yet will adhere to another theory which has zero EMPIRICAL evidence and extremely scant circumstantial evidence to back it.

Once again I ask you why your burden of proof is so very high for the DD/F hypothesis while it is so very low for CD? If you do not want to answer that in this thread feel free to search out the other thread.
http://72.32.2.238/forumlive/showthread.php?t=73444
 
Last edited:
The one thing OT'ers and CT'ers can agree on is that the collapse began under the east penthouse.

NIST determined the most likely area of the initiating event by reviewing videos and photographs.
[see post #1503 for ref.]

When there is NO evidence for a remote possibility,

it is NOT a scientific investigation,

it is a fishing expedition.


CD is about the most remote possibility yet you adhere to it.

Seems that by your twisted logic the videos of the collapse are the most important evidence as far as determining what caused the collapse. That is truly ridiculous. It seems that you feel that the extensive investigation of the construction of the building and its contents was a great waste of time and money. I truly hope you are never in charge of any investigatory group, hell I hope you are never on a jury. Justice would be not be served well by your logic.
 
Well isn't that special!
You abandoned the thread in which I invited you to spell out the evidence that convinces you that it was CD. Now you take the stance that we don't discuss it on this thread.
I'll take that as an admission that you gots nuttin!
You had nothing to offer in the other thread and refuse to admit, except by refusal to discuss it, that all you have is a few people who say it 'sounded like an explosion" and the fact that the building fell in the direction of the force due to gravity on the Earth's surface just like they do when they are demolished by explosives.
You [all] deny any evidence presented.
I don't have time to answer all the long word bending posts on both threads so i am focusing on this one where i can use the very documents that you use as evidence for DD/F to show that it's all speculation ending in "appears possible".

As i said before, when you are cornered, rather than give an inch, you try to subject shift to CD.

Office fires, and debris damage. The debris damage that can be seen is only what was visible in the pictures of the building through the smoke but circumstantially we know that there were clear pictures of the SW corner where the damage was very severe and we can certainly extrapolate a possibility that there was an area of damage of similar severity elsewhere in the building.
You can extrapolate possibilities all you want but don't call it circumstantial evidence. It is just speculation

One also has to factor in the unknown trajectory and type of debris that entered the structure. You instead assume you know the exact trajectory and type of all debris that actually hit the building.(otherwise you could not make the definitive statements you do)
[italic mine]

There you go again. I have made no such claim.
Read post #1282 and #1308 again.
I am looking at the data in the reports Gravy and others here have insisted that i read and pointing out the stuff you [all] ignored.

My turn to claim mis-quote. I asked where FEMA or NIST said , as you claimed, that diesel fires were "very important" to the DD/F hypothesis.
You are a very clever wordsmith. They did not specifically say diesel fires were an important part of the collapse hypothesis but FEMA spent 4 pages talking about diesel fire potential and it is the basis for their 5th floor scenario. NIST included this possibility in their Summary.

The reports say that the collapse was "due primarily to fire" and "fire appears to have played a key role"

If they did not think diesel fires important, why did they spend so much time and energy investigating and talking about them?

If you do not think diesel fires are important then why are you fighting so hard to avoid admitting that

There is NO evidence of diesel fuel fires in the east half of WTC 7 ?

It is circumstantial evidence that makes such a fire a possibility. You really have to look up the definition of 'possible'. You seem to confuse it with 'probable' and 'definite'.
Saying something is possible does not give it any validity as 'circumstantial evidence'. You are talking in circles.

There is NO circumstantial evidence that there was a diesel fuel fire in the east half of WTC 7!

There is only speculation.

There were fires on multiple floors, damage of varying degrees over the entire south face
WRONG!
There was no damage reported to the east 1/3 of WTC 7.
The area below the 12th floor was NOT obscured by smoke.
There is NO debris damage to the area east of center that we can see in this photo.

sfacegraphic3np6.jpg


You can spin words in a vain attempt to ingore the facts, but you can't get arround the fact that

There is NO evidence of debris damage or deisel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event!

and there were multiple diesel fuel tanks and piping systems throughout the structure.
[italic mine]

Now you are lying. You know that is NOT TRUE.

See post #1282 for the locations of the diesel fuel tanks, pumps, risers and distribution pipes.

Once again you simply refuse/ignore anyone telling you that the damage need not be exactly along column 79,80 or 81 in order for one of those to be the first to fail. There was damage to the structure by debris and the exact nature of the effect on the structure has not been investigated thoroughly. You are making the definitive statement only because there is no EMPIRICAL evidence of damage or fire directly affecting these columns yet will adhere to another theory which has zero EMPIRICAL evidence and extremely scant circumstantial evidence to back it.
By using the word 'exactly' you give yourself some wiggle room.

NIST Apx. L pg 51
"damage....of core framing is not known"

Will you ever be able to bring yourself to admit that

There is NO evidence of debris damage or diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event

or will you just keep spinning words to infer that there was ?

Once again I ask you why your burden of proof is so very high for the DD/F hypothesis
So high?

What part of

There is NO evidence of debris damage or diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event

don't you understand?

 
Correction:
See FEMA pg 14 - 16, for the locations of the diesel fuel tanks, pumps, risers and distribution pipes.
 
Last edited:
[italic mine]
Yes.
There is NO evidence of damage in the area of the initiating event.

It is impossible to determine the point of initiation because the physical evidence was destroyed.

Irrelevant.

I'll take your post as an admission that, indeed, factors from neighboring areas could have caused the initiating event, and that, even if the fires or impact damage didn't reach the initiating event point as you claim, it wouldn't make much of a difference.
 
Miragememories said:
You pretty much described yourself belz.

Really ? Did you just say that as a tu quoque ? Or do you really think that I'm using insults instead of actual arguments or evidence, that I'm ignoring posts or responding inadequately ?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom