10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
And you have presented no evidence that debrisdamage or diesel fires did not exist in the same area.
It's a TIE!
A very safe statement
Debris damage and diesel fires were likely to have occurred in the south west corner of WTC 7.

Food for thought:

If the impact of debris could cause a double wall steel pipe to fracture at the other end of the building, it would cause double and single wall pipes in the immediate area to fracture also.
 
You didn't say you believe that debris damage could have knocked a hole in the wall of the generator room in the north east corner of WTC 7 because you know that's freakin' impossible.
Pray for a miracle in the final report if you like but i'm going to look at the evidence we have.
There was no major damage reported to he east half of WTC 7 below floor 12.
Debris would have to enter between columns 8 and 11 [Spak#] to damage core columns in the area of the initiating event.

http://img224.imageshack.us/img224/3880/sfacegraphic3np6.jpg

Column 79 and the NE generator room are beyond the range of falling debris.
wtc7fl8edit2vh6.png


I'm looking at that column spacing and comparing the spans between other columns in this floor plan. Doesn't the supported floor area for that particular column 79 seem disproportionate to you? Also assuming the beam connections between the columns spans is more robust than simple web truss connections. And imagining the floor beam layout to act like a spiders web. Wouldn't debris in the NIST shaded damage area tend to exert a south westward pull on column 79?
 
Well thank you PhantomWolf your statement pretty much sums up the whole motivation for JREF skeptics regarding the truth about 9/11.

For you folks it's an ego game, all about "winning", a big high five, never give an inch, never acknowledge a possibility..yada yada yada.

MM

No, MM, it's quite the opposite. Skeptics consider, study, and research facts and evidence. Most "Truthers" on the other hand, refuse to acknowledge reality, make up all manner of nonsense, refuse to acknowledge their lack of expertise, pretend that "common sense" trumps all, knock themselves out with high fives all around, and trumpet their stupidity all over the internet in the process.

You, for instance, have not provided any substantive posts whatsoever in your time here. You have simply parroted tinhat theories that you've found on conspiracy fantasist sites and you have heaped unsubstantiated abuse upon those who have tried in good faith to provide you with rational, substantive and substantiated facts, evidence, and knowledge. You appear to be incapable of rational response, and you appear to be impervious to reason, facts, evidence, and logic. These are traits which are, sadly, typical among members of the "Truth" movement and which are, thankfully, alien to skeptics.
 
Last edited:
Well then if all doors to the north side were closed tight then that would block air from entering the area from the north .
What part of 'possible' do you have a problem understanding in regards to any official mention of a diesel fire on the 5th floor?
from anywhere except perhaps vent louvers along the north wall
The part where OT'ers claim that diesel fuel fires had something to do with the initiating event that led to the collapse of WTC 7.
Official 'mention' of this remote possibility with NO evidence to back it up should not be used as evidence or suggested as a contributing factor.

Once again that wall you describe only blocks any air from north of the core on the 5th floor and then only if all doors to that side are closed tight. Your definitives require that you can show without doubt that such is the case. Can you?
Your question is rhetorical as there is no way anyone could state without doubt weather or not doors were left open.
Doors closed is the normal contition in a mechanical area.
Your statement 'only if all the doors to that side are closed tight' is incorrect.
All the doors would have to be open for air to flow thru this area.

So? What does that supposed prove concerning the fuel pipe?
My bad. Should read:
There is no circumstantial evidence that there was a diesel fire on the 5th floor near the initiating event, only speculation about a 'possibility'.

As stated many times you are quite fine with no evidence whatsoever of explosives being used in the WTC 7 building other than "it looked like...". Your state of "I just want it to be that way", is supposedly better than describing all possible senarios and then examining them as to probability?
This thread is about the 'debris damage and fire caused the global collapse of WTC 7" hypothesis.
There is NO evidence that there was a diesel fuel fire in the east half of WTC 7.
It is very unlikely that a double wall steel pipe fractured at the valve connection so far from the debris damage.
There is no good reason to investigate this unlikely 'possibility'.
The people at NIST were assigned the task of proving that debris damage and fires brought down WTC 7.
They are doing their best.

You have yet to prove that beyond a doubt in order to substantiate your definitive statements concerning no fire or damage in the area of the initiating event. Given the substantial damage done to the south wall I find it quite amazing that somehow you have determined beyond a doubt that air could not get to the area of columns 79,80,81, or the columns just to the west (76,77,78).
You are misquoting me.
There would have been little or no airflow in the NE generator room or the area outside the generator room near column 79, 76 or 73. [north core column row in the area of the initiating event]

You brought it up and I asked why you mention fire along the north wall of the 5th floor? You missed answering the question.
You left out the word 'area' [along the north wall]

you missed answering this as well.
There is NO 'circumstantial' evidence that there was debris damage or diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event.
 
But WTC7 *was* on fire for several hours before the collapse.

Do you dispute that?
 
But WTC7 *was* on fire for several hours before the collapse.

Do you dispute that?

Don't bother. hes just going to used the oxygen starved canard or cool fire to explain that the fires in his opinion weren't hot enough to cause damage. Why i bet it was so cool you could have hung around the generator room in T shirt soaked in baking soda during the fires to plant demo charges!
 
Don't bother. hes just going to used the oxygen starved canard or cool fire to explain that the fires in his opinion weren't hot enough to cause damage. Why i bet it was so cool you could have hung around the generator room in T shirt soaked in baking soda during the fires to plant demo charges!

Seems like a lot of trouble to go through for...hmmm...now, WHY did they do this, again...?
 
Christopher7,

Since you troofers seem to have such a profound failure of imagination when it comes to constructing a plausible narrative in which to frame your allegations, I'm going to do you a favor and provide you with one. Ready? Here goes.

OK, let's say the US government, headed by a fairly new president with little political and virtually no foreign policy experience, has decided to commit mass murder of its own citizens to further its foreign policy goals. We'll put aside the implausity of this scenario and just take it as a given, since we're only looking at WTC 7.

Let's say that the government has helpfully informed Larry Silverstein that the attack is coming, or perhaps his Jewish friends in the Mossad have tipped him off. Again, implausible, but we'll take it as a given that he knew about the coming attack.

If he knew about the attacks, Silverstein would have known that his other buildings in the area would probably be damaged. Most of these could be demolished fairly easily if this happened, clearing the way quickly for rebuilding.

WTC 7, on the other hand, could not be pulled like the other buildings; it was too large. The only way to demolish it would be to painstakingly disassemble it, since explosive demolition is illegal in New York. For such a large building, this could take months, perhaps years. In the meantime, Silverstein is losing revenue.

Therefore, he could have developed a contingency plan in which a team of commando demolition experts would be standing nearby, ready to rush in and blow up the building if it is damaged.

Sound plausible? If true, the implications are staggering. It means that Silverstein broke the law by using explosives, and therefore would have to pay a hefty fine, perhaps in the hundreds, maybe even THOUSANDS of dollars!! He couldn't afford this considering the hazard pay and hush money he would have shelled out to the demolition experts.

Of course, it also means that Silverstein had foreknowledge of the attacks, no doubt from his slippery Jew friends in Israel. It says nothing about who perpetrated the attacks, however. It also, as far as I know, does not implicate Silverstein in any crime. If someone tells you that a terrorist attack is going to be committed, are you LEGALLY OBLIGATED to tell the authorities? Morally, of course you are, but legally? I don't think so. If the authorities already know about the attack and you hinder their investigation, that's one thing, but knowing about something and not reporting it is not a crime.

So, if everything you are saying is correct, then we can infer that:

1. Silverstein owes the city of New York a fine of some sort.
2. Silverstein heard about the attacks and didn't tell anyone, instead looking after his own interests.

Conclusion: Silverstein bad man. Very, very bad man! But not a criminal.
 
Do you think Shyam Sunder's testimony before the NY City Council is gibberish?

No, I think all of your drivel about louvers and interior doors/walls (which you appear to be able to see in exterior pictures) to be gibberish.

And I hope you never have a wood-burning fireplace, because you'll probably leave the draught closed and smoke yourself to death.
 
Quote:
Once again that wall you describe only blocks any air from north of the core on the 5th floor and then only if all doors to that side are closed tight. Your definitives require that you can show without doubt that such is the case. Can you?
Your question is rhetorical as there is no way anyone could state without doubt weather or not doors were left open.

Once again showing that you do not understand the term "rhetorical question" as it pertains to questions the speaker does not actually want answered (ie. how many times do I have to tell you..?)

On the other hand you have stated catagorically that there was no fire in the area of the columns 79,80,81 or columns that if damaged could affect the behaviour of those three. A fire north of the east west wall that runs along the north side of column 79 simply is not such a fire and I fail to understand why you even bring up a fire along the north side of the 5th floor. that is not the area in question.

Air would very likely be readily available for any fire south of that wall and the area between the row of columns 76,77,78 and the row of columns 79,80,81 is south of that wall.

You have also categorically stated that there was no fire in the area between those rows of columns yet you now say that there is no way anyone can say for sure if the doors on the north side were open or closed. why then can you state categorically that there is no way for there to be enough air to support a fire given that this would require that you can state for certain that there is no damage to the south wall that would allow an air supply to such a fire? You know this for certain but you don't know for certain that the doors on the north were all closed.
 
A very safe statement
Debris damage and diesel fires were likely to have occurred in the south west corner of WTC 7.

Food for thought:

If the impact of debris could cause a double wall steel pipe to fracture at the other end of the building, it would cause double and single wall pipes in the immediate area to fracture also.


How many were in the area of the intial event leading to total collapse? If there was a diesel fire in the western end of the building what does that have to do with proving that explosives were used in the collapse?
note that these are rhetorical questions as I am aware that you know the answers are zero and nothing.
 
Last edited:
But WTC7 *was* on fire for several hours before the collapse.
Do you dispute that?
No. I listed the fires in the east half of WTC 7 in my summary in post #1282

The point i have been making [with references] is:

There were NO DIESEL FUEL FIRES in the area of the initiating event.
 
I swear, if NIST doesn't investigate this building seven business, I am going to raise a ruckus!
 
Of course he doesn't. He just disputes that the impacts and fires could've damaged the structure of 7 WTC in any significant way whatsoever.
No

Please read post #1282.

There were NO diesel fuel fires or debris damage in the area of the initiating event
that led to the collapse of WTC 7
 
No

Please read post #1282.

There were NO diesel fuel fires or debris damage in the area of the initiating event
that led to the collapse of WTC 7

Sorry, but I've missed most of this debate.

Could you explain what the "initiating event" was, exactly?
You seem to have a very clear picture of it. One that has escaped me up until now.

Many thanks.
 
C7 said:
When the generators were running, the fans brought air into the building and across the generators for cooling and combustion. [Testimony Sept 8 2006 pg 11 on pg counter]
Cooling air exits the generator room thru the exhaust vents.
Jennie C. said:
To paraphrase BJ Hunnicutt, a woman can only stand so much gibberish.
C7 said:
Do you think Shyam Sunders testimony before the NY City Council was gibberish
No, I think all of your drivel about louvers and interior doors/walls (which you appear to be able to see in exterior pictures) to be gibberish.
The 'gibberish' about the louvers and fans is from an official document:
http://wtc.nist.gov/media/testimony/TestimonySept8_06.pdf

The 'gibberish' about the concrete masonry interior wall that ran most of the length of the 5th floor in an east-west direction, is in the FEMA report on pg 14.
http://www.fema.gov/pdf/library/fema403_ch5.pdf

The doors 'gibberish' was PhantomWlof's offering.
 
On the other hand you have stated catagorically that there was no fire in the area of the columns 79,80,81
Learn how to read.
You have misquoted me again on the same point.
See post #1484

or columns that if damaged could affect the behaviour of those three. A fire north of the east west wall that runs along the north side of column 79 simply is not such a fire and I fail to understand why you even bring up a fire along the north side of the 5th floor. that is not the area in question.
Same thing as above.
I said "There may have been ventilation louvers for this area along the north wall. [assuming that there were no walls between the concrete wall and the north wall]

Air would very likely be readily available for any fire south of that wall and the area between the row of columns 76,77,78 and the row of columns 79,80,81 is south of that wall.
There was NO diesel fuel in the area south of that wall.

You have also categorically stated that there was no fire in the area between those rows of columns
You are making a habit of misquoting me.
What part of:
"There were NO DIESEL fuel FIRES in the area of the initiating event"
are you having such a problem with?

yet you now say that there is no way anyone can say for sure if the doors on the north side were open or closed. why then can you state categorically that there is no way for there to be enough air to support a fire given that this would require that you can state for certain that there is no damage to the south wall that would allow an air supply to such a fire? You know this for certain but you don't know for certain that the doors on the north were all closed.
The debris damage was to the west half of the south side. The area in question is in the north east part of the building.

There in NO evidence that there was a fire in this area.

It is just your speculation about a remote 'possibility'.

NIST did NOT mention this 'possibility'

You are desperately grasping at straws.

If the double wall pipe broke outside the generator room and
if there was a fire and
if the doors were all left open and
if that would provide enough air supply to get a diesel fire hot enough to weaken steel beams and columns.....
 
Christopher7 you have the nerve to say "You are desperately grasping at straws" when you are the one grasping.

Basically you are stating something as true with no supporting evidence (the WTC was demolished with explosives), yet berating your opponents for stating something as true with no supporting evidence.

You are criticizing a report that fills in the gaps that no one could ever possibly know for sure with very educated guesses by filling in the gaps that no one could ever possibly know for sure with lazily investigated conjecture and personal incredulity.

Good luck with that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom