10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
The one thing OT'ers and CT'ers can agree on is that the collapse began under the east penthouse.

Yes, but the thing was bloody large, wasn't it ? So, which column was it ?

When there is NO evidence for a remote possibility,

it is NOT a scientific investigation,

it is a fishing expedition.

I'm not interested in hyperbole. You said "They could look at a hundred different scenarios as to where in this area the collapse started. So what?".

A scientific investigation looks at all possibilities, even the remote ones. You seem to be thinking that they should be focusing on YOUR pet theory.

That you think "NO" evidence exists of our theories doesn't really matter. Before they STUDY the evidence, there's no way to know WHICH theory has any evidence as support.

Further evidence? There is NO evidence.

Actually, there is. See Jay's post.
 
Christopher7 said:
There is NO evidence of debris damage or diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event

Again, why is that significant ?

You are aware that the various structural elements of 7 WTC were connected, right ?
 
Irrelevant.
The intentional distruction of evidence is relevant and wrong.

I'll take your post as an admission that, indeed, factors from neighboring areas could have caused the initiating event,
No

and that, even if the fires or impact damage didn't reach the initiating event point as you claim, it wouldn't make much of a difference.
I am stating facts from government reports.
Your characterization of 'claim' is incorrect.
Do you accept the statements by FEMA and NIST that there is NO evidence of debris damage or diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event.
 
If NIST doesn't investigate this WTC 7 thing, I'm going to throw a tantrum! I swear!

Damn them for not investigating WTC 7!
 
You [all] deny any evidence presented.
I don't have time to answer all the long word bending posts on both threads so i am focusing on this one where i can use the very documents that you use as evidence for DD/F to show that it's all speculation ending in "appears possible".

As i said before, when you are cornered, rather than give an inch, you try to subject shift to CD.

YOU have stated that it WAS controlled demolition, not that is was possible and you have extremely little to base even a speculation of such an occurance on.
On the other hand the possibilities inherent due to the fact of fires and debris damage have been investigated to back up the 'speculation' that they were the cause of the collapse.
I don't deny your evidence. I find it sparse and very much lacking in substance on which to hang a speculative CD hypothesis on let alone a definitive statement such as you have made. I would put it at less probable than a diesel fuel fire right up next to column 79 given the 'evidence' you have illustrated.

You can extrapolate possibilities all you want but don't call it circumstantial evidence. It is just speculation

Then you would agree that CD is highly speculative?

There you go again. I have made no such claim.
Read post #1282 and #1308 again.
[/SIZE]I am looking at the data in the reports Gravy and others here have insisted that i read and pointing out the stuff you [all] ignored.

Sure you have. You have stated several times that debris Could not have damaged any core columns in the eastern part of the building.

You are a very clever wordsmith. They did not specifically say diesel fires were an important part of the collapse hypothesis
but you did claim that very thing
but FEMA spent 4 pages talking about diesel fire potential and it is the basis for their 5th floor scenario. NIST included this possibility in their Summary.

Yes, and as you point out they do state that it is a lesser probability senario.

The reports say that the collapse was "due primarily to fire" and "fire appears to have played a key role"

Yes..........

If they did not think diesel fires important, why did they spend so much time and energy investigating and talking about them?

So as to better understand the possibility. Where's the beef?

If you do not think diesel fires are important then why are you fighting so hard to avoid admitting that

I simply want you to understand that it is ONE possibility. The possibility of a diesel fuel fire IS important. So is understanding the probability of one.

There is NO evidence of diesel fuel fires in the east half of WTC 7 ?

Saying something is possible does not give it any validity as 'circumstantial evidence'. You are talking in circles.

There is NO circumstantial evidence that there was a diesel fuel fire in the east half of WTC 7!

A man stands accused of killing his wife. The police time how long it would take to travel from where he says he was to the scene of the murder and find that there is a time period during which he could have driven to the scene, killed her and returned. THAT is circumstantial evidence!
In this matter we have a fuel system nearby and apparently missing fuel. THAT is circumstantial evidence.


WRONG!
There was no damage reported to the east 1/3 of WTC 7.
The area below the 12th floor was NOT obscured by smoke.
There is NO debris damage to the area east of center that we can see in this photo.

Given broken windows on the south side of the Post Office Building I am quite sure the eastern part of WTC was not unscathed.
Let's see a picture of the lower south east face.
You can see the east side of the building in that picture?


You can spin words in a vain attempt to ingore the facts, but you can't get arround the fact that

Ignore what FACTS? That a couple of guys claim that what they heard had to be explosives and that only CD could cause a building to come down mostly within its original footprint? That is all you have.

There is NO evidence of debris damage or deisel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event!

There is NO evidence of explosives anywhere in building 7 other than the two circumstantial points listed above. There is a lot of empirical evidence of fires and damage in various places of WTC 7 which circumstantially suggests that debris damage and/or fire caused the collapse.



Now you are lying. You know that is NOT TRUE.

<<sighs>>
How about; there were multiple diesel fuel tanks and piping systems scattered on various lower floors, mostly on the west side of the structure.. Feel better?


By using the word 'exactly' you give yourself some wiggle room.


You are the one demanding empirical evidence so as to pinpoint what damage WOULD have caused the collapse. Odd that you will simply NOT apply the same measure to your own hypothesis.

NIST Apx. L pg 51
"damage....of core framing is not known"

Will you ever be able to bring yourself to admit that

There is NO evidence of debris damage or diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event

or will you just keep spinning words to infer that there was ?

I will not make such a definitive statement even though I do admit that deisel fuel fire in the east part of the building has a lesser probability than other senarios. Debris damage to the eastern part is by no means ruled out.

So high?

What part of

There is NO evidence of debris damage or diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event

don't you understand?


You assume that all the evidence presented rules out such damage. That is a leap of logic.


You refuse to apply the same measure of evidence to CD that you insist must apply to DD/F. WHY?

WHY?WHY?WHY?
 
C7 said:
There is NO evidence of debris damage or diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event

I will not make such a definitive statement even though I do admit that deisel fuel fire in the east part of the building has a lesser probability than other senarios. Debris damage to the eastern part is by no means ruled out.

I am not asking you to make a definitive statement,
I am just asking you to acknowledge the above.

You can comfort yourself with
"there is still a remote possibility that there was diesel fires and/or debris damage to the area of the initiating event.
Maybe there will be some proof in the final report."


How many ways can you avoid dealing with reality?

Subject change, nitpick and babble, play word games, put up long posts with anything and everything but an honest acknowledgement of the truth:

There is NO evidence of debris damage or diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event


This is what the 'official' government documents say.

FEMA pg 28: " there is no physical, photographic or other evidence to substantiate or refute the discharge of fuel oil from the piping system.

NIST pg 50: Summary of Working Collapse Hypothesis

"the following sequence of events appears possible"

NIST pg 51: "damage.....of core framing is not known"
 
Last edited:
The intentional distruction of evidence is relevant and wrong.

But it IS irrelevant to the point.

I'll take your post as an admission that, indeed, factors from neighboring areas could have caused the initiating event,

No

Therefore, let's make this clear, you believe it is IMPOSSIBLE for stress of any kind, ELSEWHERE in the building, to have caused, in ANY WAY, damage (let's call it "indirect damage") in the initiating area ?

I am stating facts from government reports.
Your characterization of 'claim' is incorrect.

I am making a hypothetical, something you seem to be unable to either do or accept. That kind of black-and-white, yes-or-no thinking on your part cannot lead to a functional theory.

Do you accept the statements by FEMA and NIST that there is NO evidence of debris damage or diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event.

Whether or not I do is irrelevant to my point.
 
Okay, Chris, in a contest of competing conjectures, exactly how much evidence to you have for yours?

The coup de gras, the 'pwonage' that you so dearly want to give to the official story could be delivered in one clean swift stroke:

Show us some real evidence of explosives. A rational person would expect that a CD large enough to collapse a building of that size to leave plenty of evidence. Give us some residue, give us some audio of CD-type explosions going off just before the building goes down. Something more than a couple anomalous witnesses claiming they heard something that sounded like explosions. Without that you have nothing, and your CD theory is even more conjecture than the official story.

You certainly don't have enough to claim that the only thing that could have felled the building is CD in such a bold way that you do. Only somebody ideologically predisposed to believe in a conspiracy would think that.
 
Last edited:
You can comfort yourself with
"there is still a remote possibility that there was diesel fires and/or debris damage to the area of the initiating event.
Maybe there will be some proof in the final report."


How many ways can you avoid dealing with reality?

Subject change, nitpick and babble, play word games, put up long posts with anything and everything but an honest acknowledgement of the truth:

There is NO evidence of debris damage or diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event


This is what the 'official' government documents say.

FEMA pg 28: " there is no physical, photographic or other evidence to substantiate or refute the discharge of fuel oil from the piping system.

NIST pg 50: Summary of Working Collapse Hypothesis

"the following sequence of events appears possible"

NIST pg 51: "damage.....of core framing is not known"

There is no direct, empirical evidence of debris damage or deisel fires in the immediate vicinity of the columns 76 to 81.

It is absolutly undeniable that there was indeed debris damage, in places very severe damage, to WTC 7 and that fires , many of which would be classified by the NYFD as large and dangerous, in WTC 7 and in combination they provide circumstantial evidence that they each contributed to the initiation and totality of the collapse.

On your side of the arguement you have NO direct empirical evidence of the existance or use of explosives in the collapse of WTC 7. You have very scant circumstantial evidence of the use of explosives in the collapse of WTC 7.

As pointed out above , when weighing the evidence , as it stands now, the hypothesis that debris damage and/or fire caused the collapse vastly out weighs, out does, and out classes the evidence of a controlled demolition using explosives.

Why can't you be bothered to address that?
WHY, WHY, WHY??
 
BTW, I am not sorry that I try to explain my POV using so many words Chris.
To my mind using words is not to be considered a bad thing.

If you were upset in school when you were told to read "Wuthering Heights" or "Heart of Darkness" and that has stuck with you through to adult life that cannot be helped by me.
 
BTW, I am not sorry that I try to explain my POV using so many words Chris.
To my mind using words is not to be considered a bad thing.

If you were upset in school when you were told to read "Wuthering Heights" or "Heart of Darkness" and that has stuck with you through to adult life that cannot be helped by me.

Yes jaydeehess the nice thing about words is that you can say anything you want and use as many as you want.

Apparently you prefer 'flights of fantasy' which explains why you are so at odds with Christopher's non-fiction research.

MM
 
C7 said:
The intentional destruction of evidence is relevant and wrong

But it IS irrelevant to the point.
If the physical evidence had not been destroyed, this investigation would have concluded years ago with a definitive answer as to what caused the collapse of WTC 7.

Therefore, let's make this clear, you believe it is IMPOSSIBLE for stress of any kind, ELSEWHERE in the building, to have caused, in ANY WAY, damage (let's call it "indirect damage") in the initiating area ?
Indirect damage? No. Perhaps you mean stress.
Damage elsewhere would put stress on the entire building, not just the area of the initiating event.

I am making a hypothetical, something you seem to be unable to either do or accept. That kind of black-and-white, yes-or-no thinking on your part cannot lead to a functional theory.
Your hypothetical is just a word game.
I'm talking about facts and statements in the official government reports that you site as evidence for your hypothesis.

C7 said:
Do you accept the statements by FEMA and NIST that there is NO evidence of debris damage or diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event.

Whether or not I do is irrelevant to my point.
You just can't do it. You can't be honest and acknowledge that

FEMA and NIST state that there is NO evidence of debris damage or diesel fires in the area of the initiation event.

You [all] will allude to it, dance around it, change the subject, make up a hypathetical, etc.

You can fool yourself with cleverly crafted words, but anyone with an IQ larger than their shoe size can see that you [all] refuse to acknowledge anything, even from FEMA and NIST, that might burst your bubble.
 
Yes jaydeehess the nice thing about words is that you can say anything you want and use as many as you want.

Apparently you prefer 'flights of fantasy' which explains why you are so at odds with Christopher's non-fiction research.

MM


I have yet to see you write a consise post concerning any evidence of the extrodinary claims you hold as 'true'.

The nice thing about words is that they are very useful in describing one's point of view. Unfortunatly the ability to do so is a skill that is not taught in today's education system in many parts of N.America. In fact if you and Chris are to be examples of said system then it would appear that such a skill (wordsmith as C7 called it) has become something to be derided.

As for the 'flight of fantasy' that is the CD hypothesis, I reiterate; "It is absolutly undeniable that there was indeed debris damage, in places very severe damage, done to WTC 7, and that fires , many of which would be classified by the NYFD as large and dangerous, in WTC 7, and considered in combination they provide circumstantial evidence that they each contributed to the initiation and totality of the collapse.

On your side of the arguement you have NO direct empirical evidence of the existance or use of explosives in the collapse of WTC 7. You have very scant circumstantial evidence of the use of explosives in the collapse of WTC 7.

As pointed out above , when weighing the evidence , as it stands now, the hypothesis that debris damage and/or fire caused the collapse vastly out weighs, out does, and out classes the evidence of a controlled demolition using explosives.

Why can't you be bothered to address that?
WHY, WHY, WHY??"


Chris has yet to explain why a lack of direct empirical evidence for damage and fire in a specific area of WTC 7 is required to back a probable collapse senario yet that same lack of evidence is not a factor concerning his(and your?) belief in a CD of WTC 7.

I certainly don't expect you to answer that since you seem to be the type that might have trouble following the plot in a "Little Lulu" comic book.
 
Last edited:
"It is absolutly undeniable that there was indeed debris damage, in places very severe damage, done to WTC 7, and that fires , many of which would be classified by the NYFD as large and dangerous, in WTC 7, and considered in combination they provide circumstantial evidence that they each contributed to the initiation and totality of the collapse.

You do have a way with words.
The debris damage was to the west half of the south face and did NOT contribute to the initiating event.
The stresses caused by the missing perimeter columns were transferred throughout the building.
Those large and dangerous fires were office fires.


On your side of the arguement you have NO direct empirical evidence of the existance or use of explosives in the collapse of WTC 7. You have very scant circumstantial evidence of the use of explosives in the collapse of WTC 7.
As pointed out above , when weighing the evidence , as it stands now, the hypothesis that debris damage and/or fire caused the collapse vastly out weighs, out does, and out classes the evidence of a controlled demolition using explosives.

Why can't you be bothered to address that?
WHY, WHY, WHY??


Chris has yet to explain why a lack of direct empirical evidence for damage and fire in a specific area of WTC 7 is required to back a probable collapse senario yet that same lack of evidence is not a factor concerning his(and your?) belief in a CD of WTC 7.

I certainly don't expect you to answer that since you seem to be the type that might have trouble following the plot in a "Little Lulu" comic book.
:D :D :D

I started this thread about DD/F specifically to avoid subject shift.

When facing a reality that you can't deal with, you jump to "my dog is still bigger that your dog"

This thread is NOT about CD, it is about DD/F!
 
Last edited:
If the physical evidence had not been destroyed, this investigation would have concluded years ago with a definitive answer as to what caused the collapse of WTC 7.

Which is, AGAIN, irrelevant to the point.

Indirect damage? No. Perhaps you mean stress.

Which is why I said this:

Belz... said:
Therefore, let's make this clear, you believe it is IMPOSSIBLE for stress of any kind, ELSEWHERE in the building, to have caused, in ANY WAY, damage (let's call it "indirect damage") in the initiating area ?

Chris said:
Damage elsewhere would put stress on the entire building, not just the area of the initiating event.

Not necessarily, but assuming that you're correct, there would still need to be AN initiating area. So why would this particular area fail first ? Any ideas ?

Your hypothetical is just a word game.

I don't see how it's a word game. You are incapable of admitting that damage to one part of the building could damage ANOTHER part of the building in such a way as to cause a collapse STARTING from that second point.

Now, I'm no engineer or architect, so perhaps someone can correct me, but this seems a reasonable assumption, so why can't you admit that it's a definite possibility, especially in light of the damage we SEE in 7 WTC ?

I'm talking about facts and statements in the official government reports that you site as evidence for your hypothesis.

Well, I'm not. I'm trying to see if your mind is set on another possibility, which has ZERO evidence for it, and if that blinds you to any other possibility.

You just can't do it. You can't be honest and acknowledge that

FEMA and NIST state that there is NO evidence of debris damage or diesel fires in the area of the initiation event.


Irrelevant. Please answer my question. Any further dodging on your part will be construed, by me, as an admission that you are incapable of even considering another possibility than your pet CD theory.

You [all] will allude to it, dance around it, change the subject, make up a hypathetical, etc.

Useless rhetoric. I await your answer.

You can fool yourself with cleverly crafted words, but anyone with an IQ larger than their shoe size can see that you [all] refuse to acknowledge anything, even from FEMA and NIST, that might burst your bubble.

I guess that makes you a shoe.
 
Which is, AGAIN, irrelevant to the point.
Wrong
Inspecting the physical evidence could have determined what you referred to as the point of initiation. [which is where this started]

Not necessarily, but assuming that you're correct, there would still need to be AN initiating area. So why would this particular area fail first ? Any ideas ?
No
The NIST hypothesis suggests debris damage and fire but there is NO evidence of debris damage or diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event. That leaves office fires.
You want avoid these facts by asking an endlessly arguable question.

I don't see how it's a word game. You are incapable of admitting that damage to one part of the building could damage ANOTHER part of the building in such a way as to cause a collapse STARTING from that second point.
If you want to believe that damage to the west half of the south side could damage massive core columns in the east central part of the building, go right ahead. I don't think so.

Now, I'm no engineer or architect, so perhaps someone can correct me, but this seems a reasonable assumption, so why can't you admit that it's a definite possibility, especially in light of the damage we SEE in 7 WTC ?
It is not a reasonible assumption. IMO

C7 said:
I'm talking about facts and statements in the official government reports that you site as evidence for your hypothesis.

Well, I'm not.
Of course not.
You will not talk about or even acknowledge the facts that show your DD/F hypothesis
depends on office fires alone.

I'm trying to see if your mind is set on another possibility, which has ZERO evidence for it, and if that blinds you to any other possibility.
On the contrary, i am reading the reports you site as evidence for the DD/F hypothesis and noting the
facts that you would like to ignore.
Not surprisingly, i think you are the one who is blind to the facts and statements that you don't like.

C7 said:
FEMA and NIST state that there is NO evidence of debris damage or diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event.

Irrelevant. Please answer my question. Any further dodging on your part will be construed, by me, as an admission that you are incapable of even considering another possibility than your pet CD theory.
If you think these facts and statements in the FEMA and NIST reports are irrelevant, then perhaps it is you who is incapable of considering a possibility other than your pet DD/F theory.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom