10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
Wrong
Inspecting the physical evidence could have determined what you referred to as the point of initiation. [which is where this started]

Which is, for the fourth time, irrelevant to the point. I'm starting to wonder if you read other people's posts at all.

The NIST hypothesis suggests debris damage and fire but there is NO evidence of debris damage or diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event. That leaves office fires.
You want avoid these facts by asking an endlessly arguable question.

No, I want to make sure if you understand that a failing column on one side of the building can cause its load to transfer onto another column, or pull on supports that might cause other columns to fail as well, even though they weren't damaged.

If you want to believe that damage to the west half of the south side could damage massive core columns in the east central part of the building, go right ahead. I don't think so.

It is not a matter of belief. I'm making a statement of possibility, a strong possibility, in my opinion. But at least this time you gave me an answer.

It is not a reasonible assumption. IMO

Good, good. Therefore the only possibility you accept is a column failing because it was itself damaged, either by debris or fire (diesel or office, doesn't matter).

See ? That wasn't so hard.

You will not talk about or even acknowledge the facts that show your DD/F hypothesis depends on office fires alone.

_I_ have no hypothesis, because I'm not qualified to invent one. I can only read the conclusions of other people who ARE qualified, and apply some logic to it to show that the twoofers are wrong.

On the contrary, i am reading the reports you site as evidence for the DD/F hypothesis and noting the facts that you would like to ignore.

I think you have me confused with someone else.

Not surprisingly, i think you are the one who is blind to the facts and statements that you don't like.

Personally, I don't care whether there was a diesel fire in that building. The facts are not dependent upon it.

If you think these facts and statements in the FEMA and NIST reports are irrelevant, then perhaps it is you who is incapable of considering a possibility other than your pet DD/F theory.

That's because you're too much of a shoe to realise why I was going through this mental exercice.
 
I started this thread about DD/F specifically to avoid subject shift.

When facing a reality that you can't deal with, you jump to "my dog is still bigger that your dog"

This thread is NOT about CD, it is about DD/F!


OK, look at it this way.

The building was hit by debris from a falling skyscraper. It caught fire, and after burning for a few hours, collapsed.

Your task is to convince us that it collapsed from some cause UNRELATED to the building falling on it and the fires that followed.

Do you think you are succeeding in this task?

(Frankly, your trying to poke uninformed holes in the preliminary NIST report just doesn't do it for me. I need something a lot more compelling. )
 
OK, look at it this way.

The building was hit by debris from a falling skyscraper. It caught fire, and after burning for a few hours, collapsed.

Your task is to convince us that it collapsed from some cause UNRELATED to the building falling on it and the fires that followed.

Do you think you are succeeding in this task?

(Frankly, your trying to poke uninformed holes in the preliminary NIST report just doesn't do it for me. I need something a lot more compelling. )

Your task aggle-rithm, as one who obviously believes that the high speed, symmetrical WTC7 collapse was simply due to debris and fire damage; is to prove that it is even remotely possible for such an event to occur without the assistance of controlled demolition!

So far, in spite of all their resources, NIST has been unable to risk a definitive report supporting your belief. I suspect they'll need maybe 100,000 pages this time.

MM
 
Miragememories said:
Your task aggle-rithm, as one who obviously believes that the high speed, symmetrical WTC7 collapse was simply due to debris and fire damage; is to prove that it is even remotely possible for such an event to occur without the assistance of controlled demolition!

Strawman. 7 WTC did not collapse symmetrically, and controlled demolitions are not characteristically symmetrical. Your entire position is based on ignorance.
 
So far, in spite of all their resources, NIST has been unable to risk a definitive report supporting your belief. I suspect they'll need maybe 100,000 pages this time.

If a thorough job requires one million pages then that is what will be required to get the job done RIGHT.

Your position seems to be that if it is longer than a comic book, and has more text than pictures, you will consider this obfuscation on the part of the gov't!
 
I started this thread about DD/F specifically to avoid subject shift.

When facing a reality that you can't deal with, you jump to "my dog is still bigger that your dog"

This thread is NOT about CD, it is about DD/F!

,,,, and I started a thread specifically on the subject of CD.

You have now ignored that thread for quite some time. Therefore I bring it up here in order to try to drag out of you just what you think is so compelling about a CD hypothesis that requires one to assume unseen installation of unseen explosives and unnoticed explosions AND that outweighs the facts; that this building had been hit and damaged , in some places known to be very severe; and had several fires, many of which would have been classified by the NYFD as severe; which support the hypothesis that debris damage/and/or fires caused the collapse.

So far in this thread you just keep harping away that "This thread is NOT about CD, it is about DD/F!".

If you refuse to discuss CD here and will not discuss it in the thread I started then what conclusions about your hypothesis do you suspect will result?

(that was a rhetorical question Chris 7 , I know that you know the answer)
 
http://72.32.2.238/forumlive/showthread.php?t=73444&page=4
Christopher 7 did say that he believes that WTC 7 was a controlled demolition BUT in his thread about WTC7 and NIST appendix L he states;

Quote:
Had you bothered to read some of this thread before posting, you would have noticed that i have repeatedly said "i'm not going to discuss CD's on this thread
Ok then perhaps we need this, a separate thread for C7 to discuss CD.

Have at it Christopher 7 ......................

Chris's last post Feb 09/07

4 pages there as opposed to 40 pages here.

Much of the 4 pages there is devoted to Chris's 'evidence' of CD being that there is no evidence of CD.
Other topics include two guys who 'know an explosion when they hear it' (a paraphrase) and the fact that most of the structure (by no means all) came to rest on the original area the building occupied.



I'll even bump the thread for you Chris 7.
 
Last edited:
Your task aggle-rithm, as one who obviously believes that the high speed, symmetrical WTC7 collapse was simply due to debris and fire damage; is to prove that it is even remotely possible for such an event to occur without the assistance of controlled demolition!

So far, in spite of all their resources, NIST has been unable to risk a definitive report supporting your belief. I suspect they'll need maybe 100,000 pages this time.

MM

Please could you answer my reply to you, from last week: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2419135&postcount=1399

Thanks.
 
Your task aggle-rithm, as one who obviously believes that the high speed, symmetrical WTC7 collapse was simply due to debris and fire damage; is to prove that it is even remotely possible for such an event to occur without the assistance of controlled demolition!

MM

Hey, weren't you paying attention? THIS IS NOT ABOUT CONTROLLED DEMOLITION!

I am not an expert in structural engineering or demolition, but I know that WTC7 collapsed, and the only precipitating event that occured was a large skyscraper falling on it. Based on this, I think it's reasonable to accept this as proof that it's possible for a building to collapse exactly the way WTC7 did, as the result of debris and fire damage, because that's exactly what happened.

To say otherwise is to make an extraordinary claim, and thus the onus is on you to prove it is NOT possible.
 
Which is, for the fourth time, irrelevant to the point.
What point?

No, I want to make sure if you understand that a failing column on one side of the building can cause its load to transfer onto another column, or pull on supports that might cause other columns to fail as well, even though they weren't damaged.
The load will be transferred to the surrounding columns. That could, but did not, cause other columns to fail. The collapse started at the other end of the building. Any stress would have been bourn by everything in between.

Good, good. Therefore the only possibility you accept is a column failing because it was itself damaged, either by debris or fire (diesel or office, doesn't matter).
See ? That wasn't so hard.
How can a failed perimeter column cause a core column at the other end of the building to fail without causing all the columns between to fail?

I have no hypothesis, because I'm not qualified to invent one. I can only read the conclusions of other people who ARE qualified, and apply some logic to it to show that the twoofers are wrong.
The 'conclusion' of the qualified people at NIST is "appears possible"
That's a double maybe. Hardly what you could call 'definitave'.

Why don't you [all] take your own advice and

Stop saying that WTC 7 collapsed due to DD/F when your experts say it "appears possible".

Stop saying or implying that there was debris damage in the area of the initiating event because there is NO evidence to support that claim.

Stop saying or implying that diesel fires contributed to the initiating event, because there is NO evidence that this happened.

When the 'final report' comes out, and IF it says something more definitive, then, and only then, can you make those claims.

Personally, I don't care whether there was a diesel fire in that building. The facts are not dependent upon it.
So, you understand that there is NO evidence for diesel fires in the area of the initiating event. Can you bring yourself to say that?

That's because you're too much of a shoe to realise why I was going through this mental exercice.
On the contrary my good sir. I realize that you are in denial when you say that the facts and statements in the FEMA and NIST reports are irrelevant.
 
OK, look at it this way.

The building was hit by debris from a falling skyscraper. It caught fire, and after burning for a few hours, collapsed.

Your task is to convince us that it collapsed from some cause UNRELATED to the building falling on it and the fires that followed.
My current task is to inform you that

There is NO evidence of debris damage or diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event.

I'm trying to get you [all] to acknowledge these facts that are stated in the FEMA and NIST reports.

Do you think you are succeeding in this task?
No one here can bring themselves to admit it, but i think some of you are beginning to accept this reality.

(Frankly, your trying to poke uninformed holes in the preliminary NIST report just doesn't do it for me. I need something a lot more compelling. )
Uninformed?
Dude, i'm reading and quoting the reports that you are using as the basis for your belief.

Please read post #1282 and check the references. Inform yourself.
 
Cnristopher7 habe you seen this photo?

wtc7band300000fh6.jpg


What is your take on it?
 
Strawman. 7 WTC did not collapse symmetrically, and controlled demolitions are not characteristically symmetrical. Your entire position is based on ignorance.
You can argue semantics if you like but the CD in this video is what some would call symmetrical.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6_czyNCNhDI

They are not exactly the same but they both fall [mostly] straight down.

People in Europe as well as here can see the obvious.

Perhaps you think that the people who produced this program are twoofers.

After all, anyone who questions the 'official story' is just being stupid. Right?
 
Last edited:
Go here http://www.911blogger.com/node/7118

This new 911 archive is a very rich resource of footage and images. I think we have to accept the damage was serious.

What are you saying caused the dark area?
Thank you for the video. It's a lot more compelling than a single frame.

It is unlikely, but not impossible, that debris could make such a perfect hole.

I'm still skeptical but i would not discount the possibility or probability that this is debris damage.
 
What point?

The one you're answering in your next sentence:

The load will be transferred to the surrounding columns. That could, but did not, cause other columns to fail. The collapse started at the other end of the building. Any stress would have been bourn by everything in between.

Well, now I guess it all depends on what the damage was to 7 WTC when the collapse began.

The bolded part shows that you still have that knack for voicing opinions as though they were divine truth.

How can a failed perimeter column cause a core column at the other end of the building to fail without causing all the columns between to fail?

Well, for the specifics, we'd need someone far more knowledgeable than either of us in that field, and we'd also need a detailed plan of the building, methinks. But at least we're on the right track.

The 'conclusion' of the qualified people at NIST is "appears possible"
That's a double maybe. Hardly what you could call 'definitave'.

I never said it was definitive. It's possible that we won't know for sure what happened.

Stop saying that WTC 7 collapsed due to DD/F when your experts say it "appears possible".

Is there ANY other scenario they consider "possible" ?

Stop saying or implying that there was debris damage in the area of the initiating event because there is NO evidence to support that claim.

Stop saying or implying that diesel fires contributed to the initiating event, because there is NO evidence that this happened.

Why is it possible to the experts if there is no evidence at all ?

When the 'final report' comes out, and IF it says something more definitive, then, and only then, can you make those claims.

Hopefully you'll stop making your own claims, as well.

So, you understand that there is NO evidence for diesel fires in the area of the initiating event. Can you bring yourself to say that?

I can.

On the contrary my good sir. I realize that you are in denial when you say that the facts and statements in the FEMA and NIST reports are irrelevant.

Again, that's because, as you proved four times, five with this one, you don't understand why it's irrelevant.
 
You can argue semantics if you like but the CD in this video is what some would call symmetrical.

I'm not arguing semantics. People say that the collapse was symmetrical and "within its own footprint" while in reality this is clearly false. If by it you mean "mostly" symmetrical and "mostly" within its own footprint then YOU're the one who's playing with words.

And as far as the controlled demolition analogy goes, they are not characteristically symmetrical, anyway.

After all, anyone who questions the 'official story' is just being stupid. Right?

Oh, no. Beign skeptical is good. It's when you take your personal bias against authority as gospel that it blinds you. THAT makes people stupid.

Honestly, the dark area looks too perfect to have been made by debris.

They are the TOP floors of 7 WTC, not the middle or bottom ones.
 
My current task is to inform you that

There is NO evidence of debris damage or diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event.

I'm trying to get you [all] to acknowledge these facts that are stated in the FEMA and NIST reports.

And, clearly, you are using this statement to suggest that WTC7 collapsed from some cause other than the heavy damage suffered by falling debris and fires.

If this is not what you're doing, then this is all a collosal waste of time. Who CARES whether your statement is true or not, if it has no bearing on the question of whether falling buildings led to the collapse of WTC7?
 
I'm not arguing semantics. People say that the collapse was symmetrical and "within its own footprint" while in reality this is clearly false. If by it you mean "mostly" symmetrical and "mostly" within its own footprint then YOU're the one who's playing with words.

"He's only MOSTLY dead."
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom