10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
Took me awhile (and reading the NIST report) to figure out why everyone was arguing about column 79 and therebouts when I had thought that the building kink was a result of Truss 1 and/or 2 giving way as initiating events. Didn't realize that the east penthouse also had an initial kink prior to it disappearing that the NIST was determined was indicative of column 79 giving way.

Gotta give a hand to all those who videoed the collapse. Without those video recordings, likely NIST would still be trying to figure out how truss 1 and/or 2 gave way.
 
You must realize that this also means there is No evidence that there WAS not fire in the same area, don't you?
You can't hang your hat on
"No evidence that it didn't happen"

SFW?

Until NIST comes up with something a little more definitive, you [all] should stop claiming or suggesting that diesel fuel fires had anything to do with the initiating event that led to the collapse of WTC 7.
 
Sorry, but I've missed most of this debate.

Could you explain what the "initiating event" was, exactly?
You seem to have a very clear picture of it. One that has escaped me up until now.

Many thanks.
NIST Apx. L pg 30 - 33

http://wtc.nist.gov/progress_report_june04/appendixl.pdf

From pg 31 [edit mine]

areaofinitiatingeventli5.png


Core columns 73 - 81

wtc7fl8edit2vh6.png


The hypothesis is still the same. [pg 4]

http://wtc.nist.gov/media/WTC7_Approach_Summary12Dec06.pdf
 

Thanks for that.

One thing that jumps out is :
"Columns 76, 77, 78, 79, 80, and 81 appear to have direct influence on the collapse initiation of the east penthouse. A failure of any of these columns, truss #1 or #2, or the east transfer girder, or some combination of these components, with possible contribution of adjacent framing and floor systems, could be considered possible locations of the initiating events that led to the observed collapse of the east penthouse."​

My bolding.​

Meanwhile the Dec 06 document talks of investigating "up to 20 initiating event scenarios .."​

So defining the initiating event with any confidence seems a little premature at this point, no?​
 
Last edited:
Poking around the internet (looking for floor plans for floor 5 and 6 of 7 WTC), I came across this item http://www.nistreview.org/WTC7-COLLAPSE-SCHEUERMAN.pdf which provides a hypothesis that the fires on the 11th and 12th floors may be the likely cause of the initiating event (at a guess it sounds similar to the mechanism that caused the towers collapse -- heating caused or resulted in sagging and cooling pulled on key columns, etc.)

He also discusses how the horizontal progression of the collapse could happen.

My head is spinning though... :)
 
Thanks for that.

One thing that jumps out is :
"Columns 76, 77, 78, 79, 80, and 81 appear to have direct influence on the collapse initiation of the east penthouse. A failure of any of these columns, truss #1 or #2, or the east transfer girder, or some combination of these components, with possible contribution of adjacent framing and floor systems, could be considered possible locations of the initiating events that led to the observed collapse of the east penthouse."​

My bolding.​

Meanwhile the Dec 06 document talks of investigating "up to 20 initiating event scenarios .."​

So defining the initiating event with any confidence seems a little premature at this point, no?​
The area of the initiating event is under the penthouse and it is not going to change.

They could look at a hundred different scenarios as to where in this area the collapse started. So what?

Until NIST comes up with something more definitive than "appears possible",
you [all] should stop saying that debris damage and fire caused WTC 7 to implode.
 
The area of the initiating event is under the penthouse and it is not going to change.

They could look at a hundred different scenarios as to where in this area the collapse started. So what?

Until NIST comes up with something more definitive than "appears possible",
you [all] should stop saying that debris damage and fire caused WTC 7 to implode.

Chris you seem to miss the entire point of a scientific investigation. I am not surprised, to say the least.

What part of investigating all possible senarios that encompass all that is known about the contents and construction of building 7 do you take issue with? Your tilting at the diesel fire issue now makes sense to me. You will rail on against any and all senarios that are the least likely in the vain hope that this will call into disrepute the investigation by NIST or FEMA. Of course they looked at the fuel left in the tanks and of course they looked at the distribution of that fuel and of course they came up with the possible senarios that take these facts into account. Few, if any here have stated that there WAS a diesel fuel fire. You on the other hand seem to possess some special ESP that allows you to make absolute statements that there WAS NO diesel fuel fire in specific locations near the columns in question.

Despite the fact that there is no direct evidence of such a fire and the lack of any but the slimest circumstantial evidence(missing fuel) there is a possibility that there was such a fire but you steadfastly refuse to accept even the remote possibility. This is ironicomical given your insistence that WTC was demolished using explosives despite there being no empirical evidence and the slimest of circumstantial evidence (two guys claim "it sounded like...." and the building fell down) to back that contention.

So no empirical evidence and very little circumstantial evidence results in a definitive yes in one case and a definitive no in another. You are a hypocrite, a sophist and a apologist for the people who actually caused the deaths and damage on 9/11.
 
No, MM, it's quite the opposite. Skeptics consider,

Skeptics are a special breed? Elitest maybe? People who don't agree with skeptics do what?...just think evil thoughts?

study, and research facts and evidence.

Well I guess there are few genuine skeptics on JREF most seem to spend their time mocking those who don't comply with the JREF rhetoric.

Most "Truthers" on the other hand, refuse to acknowledge reality,

I suggest you take a good long look in the mirror C. Think back to when you were..oh about 18 and not so much concerned with the approval of others. Take a good hard look at reality.


make up all manner of nonsense,
It's only nonsense if it's illogical. Making it up...sigh..well that's what you are doing..stating as fact something that is nothing more than your prejudiced belief.

refuse to acknowledge their lack of expertise,
And what may I ask fair C. is your expertise beyond reciting the opinions and research of others? You live in a world of petty crime where truth takes second stage to the convincing lie. How much do you understand and how much do you blindly accept because it's easier to let others think for you?

pretend that "common sense" trumps all, knock themselves out with high fives all around, and trumpet their stupidity all over the internet in the process.

Pretend? Meanwhile you live in your smug fantasyland believing that all is well in the world and that good always triumphs over evil. You stupidly look at the evidence and apply your mind to distorting it into a form that you can digest rather than considering any new point of view that would alienate you from the JREF clowns and your no-it-all firefighter mate.

You, for instance, have not provided any substantive posts whatsoever in your time here.

Oh how good it must feel to say that which you so much want to believe.
You revel in absolute statements. There is no gray in your world. It's black or it's white. There is no sometimes, there is no maybe, no a "little". Maybe you believe the words that you spew. Do you really think you still retain the capacity to change your mind? This is where lying to yourself is a problem. It's such an easy path to maintain especially when you know your other half will never accept you thinking in opposition.



You have simply parroted tinhat theories that you've found on conspiracy fantasist sites and you have heaped unsubstantiated abuse upon those who have tried in good faith to provide you with rational, substantive and substantiated facts, evidence, and knowledge.

You have no problem self proclaiming yourself qualified to judge the merits of my opinions and the sources I refer to. What makes you so special? We both know that the JREF 'rank 'n file' will stand behind any criticism you make of a non-skeptic no matter how ridiculous or unproven. You are so smug in your unsupported declarations it leaves me to believe if you were ever called to the bar, it was never to practise law.

You appear to be incapable of rational response,

Probing for buttons to push are we? You appear to be incapable of forming your own opinions. Many here have presented thoughtful arguments but you seem content to regurgitate and mock for the crowd..the JREF lone cheerleader.


and you appear to be impervious to reason, facts, evidence, and logic. These are traits which are, sadly, typical among members of the "Truth" movement and which are, thankfully, alien to skeptics.

Well you are certainly loaded with labels to heap upon those who don't puff up your pillow princess.

MM
 
Skeptics are a special breed? Elitest maybe? People who don't agree with skeptics do what?...just think evil thoughts?

Huh ?
Well I guess there are few genuine skeptics on JREF most seem to spend their time mocking those who don't comply with the JREF rhetoric

Sorry have you actually got any facts ?
I suggest you take a good long look in the mirror C. Think back to when you were..oh about 18 and not so much concerned with the approval of others. Take a good hard look at reality.

Yes maybe you should.

It's only nonsense if it's illogical. Making it up...sigh..well that's what you are doing..stating as fact something that is nothing more than your prejudiced belief.
Yes you do.
And what may I ask fair C. is your expertise beyond reciting the opinions and research of others? You live in a world of petty crime where truth takes second stage to the convincing lie. How much do you understand and how much do you blindly accept because it's easier to let others think for you?
Not like you, nobody fools you hey? Oh wait you bought into the truth movement, so what does that make you ?
Pretend? Meanwhile you live in your smug fantasyland believing that all is well in the world and that good always triumphs over evil. You stupidly look at the evidence and apply your mind to distorting it into a form that you can digest rather than considering any new point of view that would alienate you from the JREF clowns and your no-it-all firefighter mate.
Em no and I don't need a paranoid kook to point out the worlds problems to me.
You revel in absolute statements. There is no gray in your world. It's black or it's white. There is no sometimes, there is no maybe, no a "little". Maybe you believe the words that you spew. Do you really think you still retain the capacity to change your mind? This is where lying to yourself is a problem. It's such an easy path to maintain especially when you know your other half will never accept you thinking in opposition.
The is no maybe pal it is fact or fiction. You promote fiction, fact.

You have no problem self proclaiming yourself qualified to judge the merits of my opinions and the sources I refer to. What makes you so special? We both know that the JREF 'rank 'n file' will stand behind any criticism you make of a non-skeptic no matter how ridiculous or unproven. You are so smug in your unsupported declarations it leaves me to believe if you were ever called to the bar, it was never to practise law.
Insults, insults oh dear how desperate are you ?
Probing for buttons to push are we? You appear to be incapable of forming your own opinions. Many here have presented thoughtful arguments but you seem content to regurgitate and mock for the crowd..the JREF lone cheerleader.
Yes you are incapable of forming your own opinion. You are fodder for the ridiculous movement that feeds off naive juvenile idiots, pretty much like you in fact.
You allow a few idiots who promote unsubstantiated claims of mass murder to feed you your daily BS. You suck it all up. You believe it all and promote it all because you a paranoid gullible nobody who thinks he is important.
You,like this movement are irreverent; you have proved your irrelevance time and time again. Now go back to you teenage audience at the LC forum and try to impress them. You have failed miserably here.
 
Chris you seem to miss the entire point of a scientific investigation. I am not surprised, to say the least.
You seem to have missed the point that:

You cannot say that WTC 7 collapsed due to debris damage and fire when the experts say it "appears possible".

You [all] should take your own advice and stop saying that DD/F caused WTC 7 to collapse until the 'final report' comes out.

What part of investigating all possible senarios that encompass all that is known about the contents and construction of building 7 do you take issue with? Your tilting at the diesel fire issue now makes sense to me.
Diesel fuel fires are an important element in the DD/F hypothesis.

There is NO evidence that this happened.

Of course they looked at the fuel left in the tanks and of course they looked at the distribution of that fuel and of course they came up with the possible senarios that take these facts into account.
Right, and they came up with:

FEMA Ch 5 pg 28 - 29

"The following is, therefore, a hypothesis [set of assumptions] based on potential rather than demonstrated fact"

3) ...........this hypothesis assumes that is possible that both the inner and outer pipes were severed
 
Last edited:
MM:

Welcome back.

I know you were responding to LashL, but given your comments were public, and on a public forum, I wanna make a few observations/comments (you knew I would)...

Skeptics are a special breed? Elitest maybe? People who don't agree with skeptics do what?...just think evil thoughts?

CTists and Debunkers are both "skeptics" in the purist form of the word, in that they are both "skeptical" of something.

Well I guess there are few genuine skeptics on JREF most seem to spend their time mocking those who don't comply with the JREF rhetoric.

No, the mockery comes when people provide no evidence for their outrageous claims.

I suggest you take a good long look in the mirror C. Think back to when you were..oh about 18 and not so much concerned with the approval of others. Take a good hard look at reality.

Man, when I was 18, I was concerned about what others thought more than at any other point in my life before or after. Once you actually grow up, you begin to care less about what others think, except for your family and friends.

It's only nonsense if it's illogical. Making it up...sigh..well that's what you are doing..stating as fact something that is nothing more than your prejudiced belief.

No comment.

And what may I ask fair C. is your expertise beyond reciting the opinions and research of others? You live in a world of petty crime where truth takes second stage to the convincing lie. How much do you understand and how much do you blindly accept because it's easier to let others think for you?

That is actually wild. You voiced your negative OPINION about someone daring to voice their OPINION. There must be a name for such a thing.

Pretend? Meanwhile you live in your smug fantasyland believing that all is well in the world and that good always triumphs over evil. You stupidly look at the evidence and apply your mind to distorting it into a form that you can digest rather than considering any new point of view that would alienate you from the JREF clowns and your no-it-all firefighter mate.

Last I checked life was going good for most people. Yes adolesence sucks, Illness sucks, war sucks, fear sucks, but over all, most people, in the civilized, and modernized world, live relatively good and peaceful lives. If you want to make the world a better place, start focusing on the poor and the needy, rather than raging against the machine (and I already know you are going to make some comment about how the machine is the cause of those problems, so dont bother).

Oh how good it must feel to say that which you so much want to believe.
You revel in absolute statements. There is no gray in your world. It's black or it's white. There is no sometimes, there is no maybe, no a "little". Maybe you believe the words that you spew. Do you really think you still retain the capacity to change your mind? This is where lying to yourself is a problem. It's such an easy path to maintain especially when you know your other half will never accept you thinking in opposition.

I know those comments were directed at LashL, but you have directed them at me before, and at the JREFers in general.

I have lots of room for "maybe" and "grey" in my life, but not when it comes to accusing individuals of mass murder. In my opinion there is a plethora of evidence against the hijackers, and hence in my mind they are guilty. Noone so far has presented anything close to evidence that the USG carried out 9/11, so forget "maybe".

You have no problem self proclaiming yourself qualified to judge the merits of my opinions and the sources I refer to. What makes you so special? We both know that the JREF 'rank 'n file' will stand behind any criticism you make of a non-skeptic no matter how ridiculous or unproven. You are so smug in your unsupported declarations it leaves me to believe if you were ever called to the bar, it was never to practise law.

nice personal attack. did it make you feel better?

Probing for buttons to push are we? You appear to be incapable of forming your own opinions. Many here have presented thoughtful arguments but you seem content to regurgitate and mock for the crowd..the JREF lone cheerleader.

No, I'll join in a cheer, as most of the comments LashL makes are sound in my opinion.

Well you are certainly loaded with labels to heap upon those who don't puff up your pillow princess.
MM

another smack down...congratulations.

Now I know you will whine or complain that I am butting in, but really, if you want to keep others from commenting on your squabble, than take it to PM.

TAM:
 
Anything to run your post count up eh stateofgrace?

I wasn't responding to you but apparently that doesn't stop you from answering other people's concerns.

MM

No MM, just responding,as is my right,to you for attacking people on this forum. That is allowed is it? Or would you prefer that people who find your ridiculous accusations offensive be silenced?

I don't care who you was responding to and I don't care who you think you are. You post on a public forum and people can respond.

Is that acceptable?
 
Last edited:
MM:

Welcome back.

I know you were responding to LashL, but given your comments were public, and on a public forum, I wanna make a few observations/comments (you knew I would)...


Yes I can't say as I'm surprised.

I guess it's ok for someone you agree with to make personal attacks about my record but heaven forbid I respond in kind.

Your hypocracy is duly noted Tammy.

You JREFers never see yourselves, you spend all your time defining others.

I'm glad you think we live it such good times Tammy. For the moment, those of us living in the West do have it pretty good. It's a only a bubble though and we all know what happens to them. Enjoy it while you can.

MM
 
Blah blah blah MM

Like I said, MM:

No, MM, it's quite the opposite. Skeptics consider, study, and research facts and evidence. Most "Truthers" on the other hand, refuse to acknowledge reality, make up all manner of nonsense, refuse to acknowledge their lack of expertise, pretend that "common sense" trumps all, knock themselves out with high fives all around, and trumpet their stupidity all over the internet in the process.

You, for instance, have not provided any substantive posts whatsoever in your time here. You have simply parroted tinhat theories that you've found on conspiracy fantasist sites and you have heaped unsubstantiated abuse upon those who have tried in good faith to provide you with rational, substantive and substantiated facts, evidence, and knowledge. You appear to be incapable of rational response, and you appear to be impervious to reason, facts, evidence, and logic. These are traits which are, sadly, typical among members of the "Truth" movement and which are, thankfully, alien to skeptics.

Your latest post is simply more evidence of that which I posted above.

As an aside, if you seriously doubt that I am who and what I say I am, you should take me up on my offer to meet you in person, at which time I will be happy to show you my credentials.
 
So. Have we been presented with any compelling evidence that the WTCs were destroyed with explosives, or are we still playing tit-for-tat with pedantic crap and ideological board games?

MM and Christopher7 it must really chap your hides that although you obviously 'know' that 911 was an inside job, the only evidence you have is conjecture.

I feel your pain.

If only somebody would come forward who was there AND has the expertise to defend their position, or some kind of physical evidence would surface that supports a CD theory.

If only, huh?

Good luck with this whole cloak and dagger conspiracy thingy.
 
You seem to have missed the point that:

You cannot say that WTC 7 collapsed due to debris damage and fire when the experts say it "appears possible".

You [all] should take your own advice and stop saying that DD/F caused WTC 7 to collapse until the 'final report' comes out.

Might I point out that you have no problem stating quite definitly that explosives brought the building down.

Ok then though, I will state that given the evidence supporting DD/F and the lack of evidence otherwise I believe that DD/F is the most likely cause of the collapse of WTC 7.

Diesel fuel fires are an important element in the DD/F hypothesis.

It is? Where in NIST's or FEMA's reports so far has diesel fire been claimed to be an 'important part' of the hypothesis on the collpase?

There is NO evidence that this happened.

Other than the fact that the supply pipe ran within feet of a door to the trusses and the missing fuel. Correct.

Right, and they came up with:

FEMA Ch 5 pg 28 - 29

"The following is, therefore, a hypothesis [set of assumptions] based on potential rather than demonstrated fact"

3) ...........this hypothesis assumes that is possible that both the inner and outer pipes were severed

Now that answers one question. FEMA does not consider diesel fuel fires an 'important part' of the debris damage/fire collapse hypothesis.

It is ONE senario that was brought up. Why? Because given the existance of a lot of diesel fuel in the building it was prudent and neccessary to look into possibile senarios that would have this as a contributing factor. Perhaps the full report will have more evidence for such a fire in which case the prudence of looking into even less probable senarios will be illustrated. If no further evidence is found for such fires than it may remain as a less probable senario.

You have ignored my query a few times now
Are YOU willing to admit that there is no empirical evidence of the existance, or use of, explosives in the collapse of WTC 7? Do you still deny that there is a huge amount of circumstantial evidence for the debris/fire damage collapse while the amount of circumstantial evidence for a controlled explosive demolition is sparse and weak(at best)?
 
Last edited:
Yes I can't say as I'm surprised.

I guess it's ok for someone you agree with to make personal attacks about my record but heaven forbid I respond in kind.

Your hypocracy is duly noted Tammy.

You JREFers never see yourselves, you spend all your time defining others.

I'm glad you think we live it such good times Tammy. For the moment, those of us living in the West do have it pretty good. It's a only a bubble though and we all know what happens to them. Enjoy it while you can.

MM

MM:

I didnt catch what your qualifications/career actually is. If you are an expert at something, as LashL is in Law, and I am in medicine, please tell us, and then tell us where someone doubted those qualifications.

As for your repeated attempts, now with bold for added emphasis, to try and insult me by calling me a woman, when you know I am not, well it is, well...juvenile even for you. Can't say I am surprised.

TAM:)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom