10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
Grasp at straws much?

Artificially my elbow.

There is no evidence or reason to think that any of the 'possibilities' you listed actually occurred.
Or any evidence or reason to think they didn't occur. Other than your ravings.
 
No
The intake and exhaust louvers would open when the generators came on.


The intake air apparently has a fan bringing air into the room and the exhaust louvers would NOT open into the room. To do so would imply that the deisels simply run and exhaust their emissions into the room. That would be a very bad design as it would load the room up with carbon monoxide and other nasties. In the several diesel generator rooms that I have been in the exhaust manifold is vented to the outside and this is a sealed vent from the room. It has a flexible section that isolates the generator vibration from the piping to the outside.

Now , once again, why is it required that a possible desiel fuel fire be in the generator room? Just because it is easier to show that such a fire is less of a possibility? Why can the fuel fire not be anywhere along the fuel supply system? Why not just outside the generator room which you correctly(if not quite technically correct) state would be fire-proofed?

Are we done with the diesel fuel fire possibility? Would you like to look up and address any other possible senarios
 
Now , once again, why is it required that a possible desiel fuel fire be in the generator room?

Once again, it is not 'required'

The point is:

There is NO evidence that such a fire existed.

If it did exist, it did not have enough airflow to burn hot enough to weaken steel beams or columns.

Just because it is easier to show that such a fire is less of a possibility?
Actually, it's about the same.

If the area outside the generator room had no ventilation, the fire would not have enough airflow to burn hot enough to weaken steel beams or columns.

There was no debris damage 90' inside WTC 7

11qd1.jpg




Are we done with the diesel fuel fire possibility? Would you like to look up and address any other possible scenarios
Do you agree that there is NO evidence for this scenario, it is pure speculation?
Even if there was a diesel fire in the diesel room or the area along the north wall,
it would NOT have had enough airflow to burn hot enough to weaken steel beams or columns.
 
Last edited:
However, Wouldn't they shut off the diesel fuel pumps when abandoning the building?

They might as well stick their fingers in their nostrils and start chanting "la Marseillaise"

Perhaps they couldn't get to the shutoff switch because of fire.

Would that be speculation, Chris ?

1) The vents were open
and there was NO fire.

Or the smoke was drawn somewhere else.

2) The vents were closed
and a fire, if it existed, would have very little oxygen or no oxygen to sustain it. [other that what was in the room]

Aren't you forgetting other possible sources of oxygen ?
 
Grasp at straws much?

Interesting. You call a listing of possible sources of oxygen, which would cause problems to your hypothesis, grasping as straws ??

So, as long as there's no evidence that something didn't happen,
then it should be considered a possibility.

Well, that settles it! You don't understand "burden of proof".

"Allons enfants de la Patrie
Le jour de gloire est arrivé !"
 
No
The intake and exhaust louvers would open when the generators came on.

Are you being purposely obtuse? (rhetorical)

You have only a few scenarios:

Generators are on
(seems doubtful to me, since you said the FDNY would have shut things down, but for the sake of argument):

Fans are on and supply air to the supposed fire. If louvers are closed, no smoke. If louvers are open, smoke (MAYBE...it also might exit through damage inside the room: smoke rises.

Generators are off, louvers are closed: smoke from supposed fire either leaks through the louvers or through possible damage to the room. Air flow seeps through the louvers or from damage to the room.

Generators are off: louvers are open. You postulate that there must be smoke coming out of the louvers. But if they are the source of the air feeding the fire, there would NOT be smoke coming out. Air-flow would be one way.

So, as I keep pointing out, you can either have air going in OR smoke coming out, but NOT BOTH.

Of course, this all assumes a fire in the particular room, which may or may not be so. My only point is that you keep saying that the louvers have to both provide the air and vent the smoke. They can't do both.
 
If the area outside the generator room had no ventilation, the fire would not have enough airflow to burn hot enough to weaken steel beams or columns.

Still waiting for your explanation as to why there would be only limited O2 available outside of the generator room. There are whopping big holes in the south wall and a large number of broken windows,there is damage to the south wall on many floors, there are stairwells and elevator shafts and there is no reason to suspect that the entire 5th floor is air tight and sealed from the rest of the building. There is a fuel line that runs much of the length of the core of the building on the 5th floor and there is very little that can bee seen of the interior of the 5th floor from the outside. It is ONE possibility that there was a fire, including a diesel fuel fire on the 5th floor. To simply ignore the circumstantial evidence of this poissibility and declare that there was no fire or that if there was then it could never have been intense enough to cause problems to columns 79,80,81 is pure and unadulterated sophistry on your part(whether you realize it or not). Your continued harping about a fire in the diesel room itself simply underlines your blatant attempt at sophistry. Yes a fire in the gen.rm. itself is less of a probability than one outside the room. That does not equate to no fire.

Do you agree that there is NO evidence for this scenario, it is pure speculation?
Even if there was a diesel fire in the diesel room or the area along the north wall, it would NOT have had enough airflow to burn hot enough to weaken steel beams or columns.
.

There is no empirical evidence that this fire took place. No one has stated that there is. What has been stated is that the possibility exists for it to have occured and that this is ONE possibility.

Now where did you now get no diesel fuel fire along the north wall from? Did someone claim a fuel fire along the north wall?

As for air supply, deny it if it turns your crank but there are ample ways for air to supply a fire on the 5th floor.

Are YOU willing to admit that there is no evidence of the existance, or use of, explosives in the collapse of WTC 7? Do you still deny that there is a huge amount of circumstantial evidence for the debris/fire damage collapse while the amount of circumstantial evidence for a controlled explosive demolition is sparse and weak(at best)?
 
Are you being purposely obtuse? (rhetorical)
You have only a few scenarios:
Generators are on
(seems doubtful to me, since you said the FDNY would have shut things down, but for the sake of argument):
Fans are on and supply air to the supposed fire. If louvers are closed, no smoke. If louvers are open, smoke (MAYBE...it also might exit through damage inside the room: smoke rises.
Generators are off, louvers are closed: smoke from supposed fire either leaks through the louvers or through possible damage to the room. Air flow seeps through the louvers or from damage to the room.
Generators are off: louvers are open. You postulate that there must be smoke coming out of the louvers. But if they are the source of the air feeding the fire, there would NOT be smoke coming out. Air-flow would be one way.

So, as I keep pointing out, you can either have air going in OR smoke coming out, but NOT BOTH.

Of course, this all assumes a fire in the particular room, which may or may not be so. My only point is that you keep saying that the louvers have to both provide the air and vent the smoke. They can't do both.
That is precisely what they do.

When the generators were running, the fans brought outside air into the building and across the generators for cooling and combustion. [Testimony Sept. 8 2006 pg 11 on pg counter]

The cooling air exits the generator room thru the exhaust louvers.
 
Still waiting for your explanation as to why there would be only limited O2 available outside of the generator room.
There was a concrete masonry wall that ran most of the length of the 5th floor east to west
along columns 58 thru 79; 90 feet from the south face.
There were no windows on the north wall.
There may have been ventilation louvers for this area along the north wall.
Other than that, air would have to come in and out from the south west corner where the damage was.
[If there were no walls between the south west corner and the north east generator room]
There is NO EVIDENCE or reason to suspect that the supply pipe broke in this area, just wishful thinking.

There are whopping big holes in the south wall and a large number of broken windows,there is damage to the south wall on many floors, there are stairwells and elevator shafts and there is no reason to suspect that the entire 5th floor is air tight and sealed from the rest of the building.
There is no reason to suspect that the concrete wall was damaged

There is a fuel line that runs much of the length of the core of the building on the 5th floor and there is very little that can bee seen of the interior of the 5th floor from the outside. It is ONE possibility that there was a fire, including a diesel fuel fire on the 5th floor. To simply ignore the circumstantial evidence of this poissibility
There is NO circumstantial evidence that the concrete wall was damaged.

There is no empirical evidence that this fire took place. No one has stated that there is. What has been stated is that the possibility exists for it to have occured and that this is ONE possibility.
There is NO evidence period.
You are living in the blissful world of 'anything is possible'.

As for air supply, deny it if it turns your crank but there are ample ways for air to supply a fire on the 5th floor.
Not to the area in question.
 
Last edited:
Why do you artifically limit the options to two? Oh, let me guess, so you can say that as one is wrong, your's must win by default.

Well thank you PhantomWolf your statement pretty much sums up the whole motivation for JREF skeptics regarding the truth about 9/11.

For you folks it's an ego game, all about "winning", a big high five, never give an inch, never acknowledge a possibility..yada yada yada.

MM
 
That is precisely what they do.

When the generators were running, the fans brought outside air into the building and across the generators for cooling and combustion. [Testimony Sept. 8 2006 pg 11 on pg counter]

The cooling air exits the generator room thru the exhaust louvers.

To paraphrase BJ Hunnicutt, a woman can only stand so much gibberish.
 
Miragememories said:
PhantomWolf said:
Why do you artifically limit the options to two? Oh, let me guess, so you can say that as one is wrong, your's must win by default.

Well thank you PhantomWolf your statement pretty much sums up the whole motivation for JREF skeptics regarding the truth about 9/11.

For you folks it's an ego game, all about "winning", a big high five, never give an inch, never acknowledge a possibility..yada yada yada.

So... you're saying you didn't understand what he meant ?
 
Well thank you PhantomWolf your statement pretty much sums up the whole motivation for JREF skeptics regarding the truth about 9/11.

For you folks it's an ego game, all about "winning", a big high five, never give an inch, never acknowledge a possibility..yada yada yada.

MM

It's always neat to watch the CT crowd place their own feelings and belives onto others, I believe the technical term is transferance.
 
jaydeehess said:
Still waiting for your explanation as to why there would be only limited O2 available outside of the generator room.
There was a concrete masonry wall that ran most of the length of the 5th floor east to west
along columns 58 thru 79; 90 feet from the south face.
There were no windows on the north wall.
There may have been ventilation louvers for this area along the north wall.
Other than that, air would have to come in and out from the south west corner where the damage was.
[If there were no walls between the south west corner and the north east generator room]
There is NO EVIDENCE or reason to suspect that the supply pipe broke in this area, just wishful thinking.

Well then if all doors to the north side were closed tight then that would block air from entering the area from the north .
What part of 'possible' do you have a problem understanding in regards to any official mention of a diesel fire on the 5th floor?


Quote jaydeehess:
There are whopping big holes in the south wall and a large number of broken windows,there is damage to the south wall on many floors, there are stairwells and elevator shafts and there is no reason to suspect that the entire 5th floor is air tight and sealed from the rest of the building.
There is no reason to suspect that the concrete wall was damaged

Once again that wall you describe only blocks any air from north of the core on the 5th floor and then only if all doors to that side are closed tight. Your definitives require that you can show without doubt that such is the case. Can you?


Quote jaydeehess:
There is a fuel line that runs much of the length of the core of the building on the 5th floor and there is very little that can be seen of the interior of the 5th floor from the outside. It is ONE possibility that there was a fire, including a diesel fuel fire on the 5th floor. To simply ignore the circumstantial evidence of this poissibility
There is NO circumstantial evidence that the concrete wall was damaged.

So? What does that supposed prove concerning the fuel pipe?

Quote jaydeehess:
There is no empirical evidence that this fire took place. No one has stated that there is. What has been stated is that the possibility exists for it to have occured and that this is ONE possibility.
There is NO evidence period.
You are living in the blissful world of 'anything is possible'.

As stated many times you are quite fine with no evidence whatsoever of explosives being used in the WTC 7 building other than "it looked like...". Your state of "I just want it to be that way", is supposedly better than describing all possible senarios and then examining them as to probability?


Quote jaydeehess:
As for air supply, deny it if it turns your crank but there are ample ways for air to supply a fire on the 5th floor.
Not to the area in question.

You have yet to prove that beyond a doubt in order to substantiate your definitive statements concerning no fire or damage in the area of the initiating event. Given the substantial damage done to the south wall I find it quite amazing that somehow you have determined beyond a doubt that air could not get to the area of columns 79,80,81, or the columns just to the west (76,77,78).

,,, you missed a couple of my points
Now where did you now get no diesel fuel fire along the north wall from? Did someone claim a fuel fire along the north wall?

You brought it up and I asked why you mention fire along the north wall of the 5th floor? You missed answering the question.

Are YOU willing to admit that there is no (edited here to add the word empirical) empirical evidence of the existance, or use of, explosives in the collapse of WTC 7? Do you still deny that there is a huge amount of circumstantial evidence for the debris/fire damage collapse while the amount of circumstantial evidence for a controlled explosive demolition is sparse and weak(at best)?

you missed answering this as well.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom