10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
The generator rooms had fans to supply air for the diesel engine intake and cooling. [Testimony Sept. 8 '06 pg 180; 11 on pg counter]
When the generators were on, the vents would open and the fans would come on.

Well, I don't know if you're saying that the generators were on or off, but if they're off, then the fans are irrelevant. You can have smoke coming out of the louvers OR air coming in, but you can't have both.

If the generators are on, then the fans would supply the oxygen whether the louvers are open or not.
 
Last edited:
And which way did the fans move the air? Into the building, perhaps?

Dave
The generator room, by necessity, would be fireproof and relatively if not completely air tight to prevent diesel fumes from being forced into the rest of the building when the high volume fans created pressure in the generator room.
The fans, located in the east wall and brought air into the generator room.
See Testimony Sept. 8 '06 pg 180; pg 11 on page counter
 
The generator rooms had fans to supply air for the diesel engine intake and cooling. [Testimony Sept. 8 '06 pg 180; 11 on pg counter]
When the generators were on, the vents would open and the fans would come on.


Yes, and the air would be forced into the room and the exhaust from the generators would be vented to the outside. The vents would be directly connected to the exhaust manifold. There would be no way that smoke could get into the exhaust manifold as this would also mean that in normal operation of the generator that exhaust would enter the room.(not a great day for anyone in the room) Now if there were a raging fuel fire in the room then heat and pressure would build up in the room enventually causing the failure of the generators or the fans,and if the fans stop then lock-outs would cause the generators to go off and then the fuel supply stops. At that point there would be smoke coming from the louvers if they are not airtight as they shut, which they would do as soon as the generators stop.

I am not argueing for a fire in the generator room, just pointing out the possibilities that would allow one without smoke from the intake louvers(as I point out there is no way to have it coming from the exhaust vent). If pressure build up in the room but the heat had not caused the generator to stop yet then it is possible that the door blows open(made more or less likely depending on which way the door normally opens). In such a case you now have air being forced into the room by the fan and a ready outlet for smoke with the open door. With no windows that smoke will find its way out via stairwells and elevator shafts.(note the proximity of these to the generator room)

But rather than consider any means by which this could occur you instead simply make your definitive statements that this or that is simply impossible in the hopes that it will somehow, by some odd twist of logic make the explosive controlled demolition contention magically stronger.
 
I must have missed a few pages. where was it decided that the deisel fire HAD to be IN the generator room? After all if a fire is outside that room then there will be no smoke from the louvers as long as (as would be common practice) the generator room doors were closed.



yes, they would shut off any natural gas to the building and the elctrical power to the building. Electrical power feed INTO the building was already off. If the building had natural gas feed then it would have been shut off at the street. The NYFD would NOT venture into the generator rooms. The doors would be shut and If there is a fire in the room they would be putting themselves in unnecessary danger, if there is no fire but a fuel leak or simply fuel fumes in the room then opening the door in a building that is on fire would again be an unnecessary risk.. They WERE NOT fighting the fires, they were not going to fight the fires, they had concerns about the building being able to remain standing. Any action that would risk further damage to the building by increasing the spread or intensity of the fires would be counter productive. The very best that the NYFD could hope for as far as #7 went was that the fires would burn out and the building remain upright and allow therefore make it possible to attempt to demolish it in a controlled fashion. In order to get to that position having them mucking around with the deisel tanks, pumps and generators would a) require more man-hours within an unstable building and b) increase the risk of spreading or increasing the intensity of the existing fires.

It is all fine and well for you to contend that, as far as you are concerned, with the inforamtion and understanding of the construction of the building and the way fire behaves, that such and such is impossible. However there are a few things that argue against you. You have only the evidence and data supplied thus far, that which was available at the time that NIST and FEMA produced the reports you refer to. This would argue for you to wait to see what, if any, further information is forthcoming. Instead you simply make your definitive statements that this or that is simply impossible in the hopes that it will somehow, by some odd twist of logic make the explosive controlled demolition contention magically stronger.

Then there is the fact that the producers or the reports that have been made thus far have training and experience in understanding building construction and the behaviour of fires in large structures whereas you do not. This would argue for you to give them some benfit of the doubt.Instead you simply make your definitive statements that this or that is simply impossible in the hopes that it will somehow, by some odd twist of logic make the explosive controlled demolition contention magically stronger.

From my understanding diesel fire isn't the only scenario that NIST is strongly looking into. NIST has stated that they are also looking into possiblilities regarding the floors above the 5th. Floors 7-13. One such report was submitted by Arthur Scheuerman former FDNY Battalion Chief.
http://wtc.nist.gov/media/ScheuermanStatementDec2006.pdf

From my understanding NIST has stated they are looking into over a dozen different scenarios.
 
Last edited:
Well, I don't know if you're saying that the generators were on or off, but if they're off, then the fans are irrelevant. You can have smoke coming out of the louvers OR air coming in, but you can't have both.

If the generators are on, then the fans would supply the oxygen whether the louvers are open or not.
No
The intake and exhaust louvers would open when the generators came on.
 
which is why arguing the semantics in a preliminary and probably already outdated report is useless.
We are not arguing semantics.
I am presenting facts contained in the Testimony of Mr. Sunder on Sept. 8 2006 and a photograph of the NE generator room at 2:00 p.m.

Give it up.
There was NO fire, or any reason to believe that there was a fire in the NE generator room.
 
We are not arguing semantics.
I am presenting facts contained in the Testimony of Mr. Sunder on Sept. 8 2006 and a photograph of the NE generator room at 2:00 p.m.

Give it up.
There was NO fire, or any reason to believe that there was a fire in the NE generator room.


why are you so focused on this "one" unimportant aspect of the report? they are reporting what was told to them and are attacking the issues from SEVERAL DIFFERENT scenarios. Why are you arguing about if there was/was not any fire in the generator rooms? Did the NIST already conclude that the fires from diesel was what contributed 100% to WTC 7 collapse? Please show us where they have made this statement.
 
We are not arguing semantics.
I am presenting facts contained in the Testimony of Mr. Sunder on Sept. 8 2006 and a photograph of the NE generator room at 2:00 p.m.

Give it up.
There was NO fire, or any reason to believe that there was a fire in the NE generator room.

Sorry but I'd much rather read a more in depth report than your handwaving. Thanks.
 
why are you so focused on this "one" unimportant aspect of the report? they are reporting what was told to them and are attacking the issues from SEVERAL DIFFERENT scenarios. Why are you arguing about if there was/was not any fire in the generator rooms? Did the NIST already conclude that the fires from diesel was what contributed 100% to WTC 7 collapse? Please show us where they have made this statement.
I focus on one thing at a time.
The fact that there was NO fire in the NE generator room is significant.

I am looking at each possible contributing factor separately.
The possibility of debris damage to the area of the initiating event is remote, and there was NO fire in the NE generator room.
That leaves office fires.
 
I focus on one thing at a time.

because you can't focus on other things that have actual importance to the collapse?

You can't "piece" out the collapse and pin it on ONLY one thing.
The fact that there was NO fire in the NE generator room is significant.

only to you. those at the NIST think its one of the MANY things that could have or not could have contributed to the collapse. Again, you are arguing from what is being said in a PRELIMINARY report.

and until you get through your thick skull, no amount of arguing on this thread is going to change that.
 
because you can't focus on other things that have actual importance to the collapse?

You can't "piece" out the collapse and pin it on ONLY one thing.


only to you. those at the NIST think its one of the MANY things that could have or not could have contributed to the collapse. Again, you are arguing from what is being said in a PRELIMINARY report.

and until you get through your thick skull, no amount of arguing on this thread is going to change that.
Wrong!
As i have stated before, right now i am quoting the Testimony of Mr. Sunder in the Testimony Sept. 8 2006 document.
 
When you and the rest of the deniers club stop lying to yourselves and acknowledge that

Running out of arguments ?

There was no fire in the north east generator room and therefore, no diesel fires in the east half of WTC 7

Your only reason for saying there was no fire is because you think that a hot fire in the generator room would have either: a) vented smoke via the louvers or b) starved.

You can't tell me if there wasn't enough oxygen, or none at all, however.

Care to adress that ?
 
Wrong!
As i have stated before, right now i am quoting the Testimony of Mr. Sunder in the Testimony Sept. 8 2006 document.

and ignoring the rest.

AGAIN, you can't take ONE report and debate just using one aspect of the report (whatever testimony that is given). YOU have take EVERYTHING under consideration, including OTHER testimonies.

What you are doing is nitpicking testimony and arguing what is wrong/right with them.

That's not how investigations work.
 
and ignoring the rest.

AGAIN, you can't take ONE report and debate just using one aspect of the report (whatever testimony that is given). YOU have take EVERYTHING under consideration, including OTHER testimonies.

What you are doing is nitpicking testimony and arguing what is wrong/right with them.

That's not how investigations work.

It is ?

I thought it was all about cherry-picking, ignoring evidence and engaging in magical thinking.

Silly me. ;)
 
The first thing firefighters do is shut off the power and gas.
They have to know how to do this.
Perhaps you think the FDNY doesn't know what it's doing.

I know jdh has already said the power was already off, but I thought I'd point this out anyway.

See, I'm not a Firefighter, but I know one (he works for the Montgomery County Volunteers) so I asked. He pointed me to this document, the 1997 NYFD Highrise tactics. In it on page 21 they state:

D. Gain control of the building systems.
1. Elevators.
2. HVAC.
3. Communications.
4. Fire pumps.


My contact states that this is because "in high rises we take control of the elevators and ride up to two floors below the fire floor."

I'd also note that the power was NOT cut to the WTC 1 & 2 and the fire crew did exactly that, used the working elevators, and even sent people out using those that were still working.

As such it is quite clear that Christopher7 is wrong about this point, they do not cut the utilities, in fact they need them on to do their job effectively (the elevators, HVAC, and Building fire pumps all need power.)
 
I know jdh has already said the power was already off, but I thought I'd point this out anyway.

See, I'm not a Firefighter, but I know one (he works for the Montgomery County Volunteers) so I asked. He pointed me to this document, the 1997 NYFD Highrise tactics. In it on page 21 they state:

D. Gain control of the building systems.
1. Elevators.
2. HVAC.
3. Communications.
4. Fire pumps.


My contact states that this is because "in high rises we take control of the elevators and ride up to two floors below the fire floor."

I'd also note that the power was NOT cut to the WTC 1 & 2 and the fire crew did exactly that, used the working elevators, and even sent people out using those that were still working.

As such it is quite clear that Christopher7 is wrong about this point, they do not cut the utilities, in fact they need them on to do their job effectively (the elevators, HVAC, and Building fire pumps all need power.)
Good point

However, Wouldn't they shut off the diesel fuel pumps when abandoning the building?
Perhaps they couldn't get to the shutoff switch because of fire.

In either case we are left with two possibilities:

1) The vents were open
and there was NO fire.

2) The vents were closed
and a fire, if it existed, would have very little oxygen or no oxygen to sustain it. [other that what was in the room]
 
However, Wouldn't they shut off the diesel fuel pumps when abandoning the building?

Why? If they are abandoning the building, there isn't a lot of point in trying to find the breakers and throwing them, you just get the heck out of Dodge.
 
In either case we are left with two possibilities:

1) The vents were open
and there was NO fire.

2) The vents were closed
and a fire, if it existed, would have very little oxygen or no oxygen to sustain it. [other that what was in the room]

Or that doors were oen letting air be drawn in, or a wall/ceiling/floor was damaged allowing air flow, or that the HVAC still working and pumping air in, or that the vent opening mechanism was damaged and failed to operate or that the fires weren't in the generator room, but that the line was broken elsewhere or that.....


Why do you artifically limit the options to two? Oh, let me guess, so you can say that as one is wrong, your's must win by default.
 
Or that doors were open letting air be drawn in, or a wall/ceiling/floor was damaged allowing air flow, or that the HVAC still working and pumping air in, or that the vent opening mechanism was damaged and failed to operate or that the fires weren't in the generator room, but that the line was broken elsewhere or that.....
Grasp at straws much?

Why do you artifically limit the options to two? Oh, let me guess, so you can say that as one is wrong, your's must win by default.
Artificially my elbow.

There is no evidence or reason to think that any of the 'possibilities' you listed actually occurred.

ETA: one of the two is correct, there would be either no heat or insufficient heat to effect column 79.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom