10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah, it's not like the fire would get oxygen from any broken windows or holes from debris.
Oh, wait...
What part of 'room' don't you understand?
The generator 'room' was in the NE corner. It did not have windows, it had louvered vents.
 
Why? They don't own the building, or work in the building, nor do they know what is in the building or what works what. They are in there looking for fire and people, not at what a pumps somewhere might or might not be doing.
The first thing firefighters do is shut off the power and gas.
They have to know how to do this.
Perhaps you think the FDNY doesn't know what it's doing.
 
funny, but I work in an office building that has no windows that open to the outside. and I breathe just fine. So where is all that oxygen coming from?
This is what you stated Chris

Here's what i posted:

copyofe5asn4.png


The NE generator room had louvers, not windows

Are you with me so far?

If there was a fire in this room, and the louvers were open, smoke would be coming out.

If the louvers were closed, a diesel fire would not have enough oxygen.

Note: Diesel fires require more oxygen that a smoke bolwin' OT'er
 
Last edited:
again, christopher 7, there is always oxygen in a building. louvers open or not.
otherwise, how would maintenance people get into those rooms on cold winter days when they would close those windows?

christopher you live in fantasyland.
 
again, christopher 7, there is always oxygen in a building. louvers open or not.
otherwise, how would maintenance people get into those rooms on cold winter days when they would close those windows?

christopher you live in fantasyland.
In order for diesel fire to burn very hot it needs a a great deal of oxygen.
If the louvers in the NE generator room were closed, there would be insufficient oxygen to sustain a diesel fire.
But, of course, you know that.

You live in denial. You can't face the fact that there were no diesel fires in the area of the initiating event, so you babble about anything but facts.
 
What part of 'room' don't you understand?
The generator 'room' was in the NE corner. It did not have windows, it had louvered vents.
Oh, so the room was hermetically sealed? The louvers were the only source of air?
Silly me!
What part of "stupid idea" don't you understand?
 
Your mastery of this field of reasoning is something I wouldn't think of challenging Belz.

And well you shouldn't :

There is no logical reason, or evidence, to assume that representatives of the NYFD had reason to logically deduce a high speed total collapse of WTC7 based on transit readings.

There's no reason to assume that the people who know this stuff could come to a reasonable conclusion about because... YOU think they were under stress ?

That's their JOB, you boob.

The fact is, fire and debris damage don't collapse buildings that way, major human intervention does!

No, and 7 WTC didn't collapse in a way that looks like human intervention. Not to the experts, anyway.

I would suggest you are the one who is guilty of clinging to your precious beliefs!

Again, please tell us what this belief is.

One aspect of engineering that is not widely understood is that structures are over-engineered as a matter of standard practice.

For what possible purpose would they want to do that ?
 
Read post #1282.
The data in the FEMA and NIST reports [that will not change in the 'final' report]

If they won't change, why are they working on a final version of it ?

Debris would have to enter between columns 8 and 11 [Spak#] to damage core columns in the area of the initiating event.

I'm going to help you with this one, since you seem incapable of reading:

THE INITIAL DAMAGE NEEDS NOT BE IN THE AREA OF THE INITIATING COLLAPSE EVENT. Stress could be transfered from one to the other, facilitated by the fire damage.

They are NOT considering the possibility of debris damage to the north east generator room because that's just bloody impossible.

Where did they say that ?

Also, if the louver vents were closed, a fire would have no plentiful supply of oxygen.

Who said it needed to be plentiful ?

You don't need x-ray vision to figure out that if the louvers were open there would be smoke coming out and if not, a fire would have no oxygen supply.

Oh, now it's "no oxygen supply" ? I thought it just had "no plentiful supply of oxygen". Which is it ?
 
The hole was nowhere near the north east generator room.

Actually, the hole was all over the place.

And please stop denying the obvious.

It's not that obvious if all the experts disagree with your conclusions, Chris.

If the louvers in the NE generator room were closed, there would be insufficient oxygen to sustain a diesel fire.

Oh, it's "insufficient" oxygen, now ?

You live in denial. You can't face the fact that there were no diesel fires in the area of the initiating event, so you babble about anything but facts.

Says the guy who can't make up his mind about the supply of oxygen to a fire.
 
You live in denial. You can't face the fact that there were no diesel fires in the area of the initiating event, so you babble about anything but facts.

In post 1308 you said,

My statement "There were no diesel fuel fires or debris damage in the area of the initiating event...." is not totally indisputable.

Is it now your contention that your statement has become totally indisputable?

Dave
 
If there was a fire in this room, and the louvers were open, smoke would be coming out.

If the louvers were closed, a diesel fire would not have enough oxygen.

If the louvers are the source of oxygen, then the smoke would not be coming out of them. The air wouldn't flow both ways.

Conversely, if the smoke is coming out of them, then that's not where the oxygen is coming in. Buildings don't breathe.
 
In post 1308 you said,

Is it now your contention that your statement has become totally indisputable?
Dave
There is a remote possibility that there was debris damage to the core columns, however, there is no evidence that there was a fire in the NE generator room and there is no sign of fire there.
You guys can babble about holes in the building or air flow, but you know it's just BS.
You are in denial and desperately trying to deny the obvious.

There was NO fire in the NE generator room.
 
Last edited:
Just checking in.
Anything new?
No, huh?
Say, when did this thread start, anyway?

January third!

Well, carry on, Christophera7.

(By the way, how will you know when you're done? Will you see a flaming chariot, or hear voices, or what?)
 
If the louvers are the source of oxygen, then the smoke would not be coming out of them. The air wouldn't flow both ways.

Conversely, if the smoke is coming out of them, then that's not where the oxygen is coming in. Buildings don't breathe.
The generator rooms had fans to supply air for the diesel engine intake and cooling. [Testimony Sept. 8 '06 pg 180; 11 on pg counter]
When the generators were on, the vents would open and the fans would come on.
 
Just checking in.
Anything new?
No, huh?
Say, when did this thread start, anyway?

January third!

Well, carry on, Christophera7.

(By the way, how will you know when you're done? Will you see a flaming chariot, or hear voices, or what?)
When you and the rest of the deniers club stop lying to yourselves and acknowledge that

There was no fire in the north east generator room and therefore, no diesel fires in the east half of WTC 7
 
so? the rooms that held those generators would need access by maintenance people. meaning that there was air in those rooms...
 
I must have missed a few pages. where was it decided that the deisel fire HAD to be IN the generator room? After all if a fire is outside that room then there will be no smoke from the louvers as long as (as would be common practice) the generator room doors were closed.

The first thing firefighters do is shut off the power and gas.
They have to know how to do this.
Perhaps you think the FDNY doesn't know what it's doing

yes, they would shut off any natural gas to the building and the elctrical power to the building. Electrical power feed INTO the building was already off. If the building had natural gas feed then it would have been shut off at the street. The NYFD would NOT venture into the generator rooms. The doors would be shut and If there is a fire in the room they would be putting themselves in unnecessary danger, if there is no fire but a fuel leak or simply fuel fumes in the room then opening the door in a building that is on fire would again be an unnecessary risk.. They WERE NOT fighting the fires, they were not going to fight the fires, they had concerns about the building being able to remain standing. Any action that would risk further damage to the building by increasing the spread or intensity of the fires would be counter productive. The very best that the NYFD could hope for as far as #7 went was that the fires would burn out and the building remain upright and allow therefore make it possible to attempt to demolish it in a controlled fashion. In order to get to that position having them mucking around with the deisel tanks, pumps and generators would a) require more man-hours within an unstable building and b) increase the risk of spreading or increasing the intensity of the existing fires.

It is all fine and well for you to contend that, as far as you are concerned, with the inforamtion and understanding of the construction of the building and the way fire behaves, that such and such is impossible. However there are a few things that argue against you. You have only the evidence and data supplied thus far, that which was available at the time that NIST and FEMA produced the reports you refer to. This would argue for you to wait to see what, if any, further information is forthcoming. Instead you simply make your definitive statements that this or that is simply impossible in the hopes that it will somehow, by some odd twist of logic make the explosive controlled demolition contention magically stronger.

Then there is the fact that the producers or the reports that have been made thus far have training and experience in understanding building construction and the behaviour of fires in large structures whereas you do not. This would argue for you to give them some benfit of the doubt.Instead you simply make your definitive statements that this or that is simply impossible in the hopes that it will somehow, by some odd twist of logic make the explosive controlled demolition contention magically stronger.
 
When you and the rest of the deniers club stop lying to yourselves and acknowledge that

There was no fire in the north east generator room and therefore, no diesel fires in the east half of WTC 7
Do you rest your case then? If so, I'll take a vote to see if your argument has been persuasive.

If if hasn't, what will you do, Christopher?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom