I don't want to let this thread end! I have been a conspiracy buff for a long time, and I have been reading about 9/11 for the past year, but I just discovered the JREF about 3 weeks ago.
I have used my available leisure time over the past couple of weeks to read virtually all 4000+ posts in this thread. Given the ‘progress’ that has been made, I’m unsure as to whether I should be proud of myself for that or embarrassed about it. Regardless, I have enjoyed the thought-provoking and mostly-civil debate that is often difficult to find elsewhere on the web.
I just wanted to comment that I believe Chris7 is an intelligent skilled debater, staying, for the most part, on the original thread points, choosing words carefully, making a fairly convincing argument. (Except for the ‘fake NIST photo’ debacle.) I think you would make a fine criminal defense lawyer, in that, to be successful, one would not be required to prove anything definitively in the defendant's favor, but rather only to cast enough reasonable doubt of the evidence to get the defendant set free.
Your three primary points from your original post (paraphrasing): there is no 10 story gouge in the south face, no evidence of debris damage in the area of the initiating event and no evidence of diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event (AIE) are completely accurate and cannot be disputed. It is an indisputable fact that there are conflicting descriptions of the dimensions of the south face damage. It is an indisputable fact that there is no known direct evidence of structural damage to the AIE. It is an indisputable fact that there is no known direct evidence of a diesel fire in the AIE. You’ve won the debate on these three points. Congratulations.
However, the conclusions you have chosen to draw from these statements (debris damage and fuel fires did not contribute to the collapse) are not sufficiently supported. The additional assumptions that must be made are too great. Evidence, with respect to damage and fires, is either that which has been observed and reported by witnesses or that which has been documented in photos and videos. To make the leap from “no evidence of debris damage or fire in AIE” to “definitively no debris damage or fire in AIE” you must assume that ALL of the debris damage and fire is KNOWN and that NONE of it is UNKNOWN. You must assume that ALL of the debris damage and fire progression was observed, reported and documented and that NO DAMAGE OR FIRE went undetected by the witnesses and cameras. A 110 story building falling onto a 47 story building is not an event that would produce predictable results. It is a random and chaotic event. Your assumption that the entirety of the damage and fire progression is observed and known is an unreasonable assumption. I accept your analysis that NIST does not/will not have sufficient evidence to irrefutably prove the DD/F hypothesis, but I reject your conclusions based on your unreasonable assumptions. While the evidence for DD/F is admittedly somewhat hampered by unknowns, there is no evidence at all for CD.
Looking forward to continuing this and other debate topics.