10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't know how to put previous post quotes in yet,

Use the "post reply" button rather than the quick post, you'll see buttons appear that will allow you to insert a cut n' paste from somewhere else in quotes or a link to another url

You can also hit the button on someone's post that sayes "quote" and the reply you create will contain that previous post in quotes.

My main point of contention is C7's statements that such and such simply cannot be. I am sure you have seen my railing against his definitive statements.

Do JREF newbies get formally hazed/initiated?

Not unless the say sumtin stoopid. You ain't done so thus far. You might get jumped if you do though.:D
 
GStan, you keep using "DD/F hypothesis". I find that to be an interesting choice of words. Do you consider it to be only a hypothesis and not reality?

Why do you think the building fell?

Was it:
Debris damage?
Fire?
Inadequate design?
Poor construction?
CD?
Any or all of the above?
 
GStan, you keep using "DD/F hypothesis". I find that to be an interesting choice of words. Do you consider it to be only a hypothesis and not reality?

I noticed in reading this thread that that term has been used a few times by Christopher. My personal belief is that DD/F is what actually doomed the building, but as a critical thinker and debater I want to hold myself to the same standards of logic/assumptions/evidence/burden of proof/etc. that I am going to hold Chris or any other CT to. Thus, I just think it's prudent for now to call it a hypothesis.

Why do you think the building fell?

Was it:
Debris damage?
Fire?
Inadequate design?
Poor construction?
CD?
Any or all of the above?

I have no relevant technical expertise on which to base a guess. (And I'm grateful for the free education I've received from a few of the obviously competent technical JREF members.) From a layman's perspective, IMHO, I think there was probably more debris damage to the building than could be observed by those on the scene and that the overall structural integrity was sufficiently weakened and compromised that it was doomed by fire, diesel or no diesel, simply because the fires were not fought at all. I have ruled nothing out, however. I don't think it is impossible that it was a CD. I could be convinced that it was, but I haven't seen any evidence at all that it happened that way.
 
Fred Dibnah, no explosives, outside the footprint, on purpose
Niel Bush, in the elevator shafts and mechanical rooms, with C4!

Wheres yours for the fact the Army invented it?
Who cares?
You do love to go off on tangents.

So if it has similarities to a CD it is a CD and if it has things different from a CD it is still a CD. I guess you have all bases covered there eh?
You got it Buba.
Seriously, Not all implosions go exactly to plan.
Hudson's building was 439' tall and had a much larger footprint, yet some damage was done to a nearby Tramway.
WTC 7 was 576' tall and only 140' front to back.
It fell in on itself and landed mostly in it's own footprint.
The north wall buckled out and creamed 30 W. Broadway. So what?

Damage to surrounding buildings was not a consideration.
 
I can't figure out how the fire made the columns fail, therefore it must be a CD.

I can't figure out why the collapse started in the eastern half of the building, therefore it must be a CD.

I can't figure out why the building fell straight down instead of falling over, therefore it must be a CD.

Any of that look familiar?

Dave
No
 
I have no relevant technical expertise on which to base a guess. (And I'm grateful for the free education I've received from a few of the obviously competent technical JREF members.) From a layman's perspective, IMHO, I think there was probably more debris damage to the building than could be observed by those on the scene and that the overall structural integrity was sufficiently weakened and compromised that it was doomed by fire, diesel or no diesel, simply because the fires were not fought at all. I have ruled nothing out, however. I don't think it is impossible that it was a CD. I could be convinced that it was, but I haven't seen any evidence at all that it happened that way.

Against a CD...

Lack of explosive sounds...

Lack of motive...

And of course, as you mentioned, lack of evidence...

-Sporanox
 
Niel Bush, in the elevator shafts and mechanical rooms, with C4!

You were wrong then?

C7 said:
Who cares?
You do love to go off on tangents.

You make a claim that is false and you say I'm off on a tangent?

C7 said:
You got it Buba.
Seriously, Not all implosions go exactly to plan.
Hudson's building was 439' tall and had a much larger footprint, yet some damage was done to a nearby Tramway.
WTC 7 was 576' tall and only 140' front to back.
It fell in on itself and landed mostly in it's own footprint.
The north wall buckled out and creamed 30 W. Broadway. So what?

Damage to surrounding buildings was not a consideration.

So basically whatever evidence is presented, because it looks like a CD you will always think it was. Way to go critical boy!
 
I don't want to let this thread end! I have been a conspiracy buff for a long time, and I have been reading about 9/11 for the past year, but I just discovered the JREF about 3 weeks ago.

I have used my available leisure time over the past couple of weeks to read virtually all 4000+ posts in this thread. Given the ‘progress’ that has been made, I’m unsure as to whether I should be proud of myself for that or embarrassed about it. Regardless, I have enjoyed the thought-provoking and mostly-civil debate that is often difficult to find elsewhere on the web.

I just wanted to comment that I believe Chris7 is an intelligent skilled debater, staying, for the most part, on the original thread points, choosing words carefully, making a fairly convincing argument.

<snip>

Looking forward to continuing this and other debate topics.
Thank you for your kind words.

To make the leap from “no evidence of debris damage or [diesel fuel] fire in AIE” to “definitively no debris damage or [diesel fuel] fire in AIE” you must assume that ALL of the debris damage and fire is KNOWN and that NONE of it is UNKNOWN.
It impossible to prove a negative so that argument doesn't hold up.
NIST interviewed over 100 witnesses and they have photos of the south east side of WTC 7.
If there was significant damage there, they would have published the photos.
The fact that they published photos of every other side and angle except the south east side, is evidence of a cover up. [to anyone not in denial]

There is no reason to think there was a diesel fuel fire in the NE generator room or mechanical room.
There is clear evidence that there was not.
The 5th & 6th floors had ventilation louvers. These would only be closed in a blizzard, if then.

Diesel fuel fires produce a lot of heavy black smoke.
There was no sign of smoke in or near the NE generator room or mechanical room at any time.
 
Last edited:
I don't want to let this thread end! I have been a conspiracy buff for a long time, and I have been reading about 9/11 for the past year, but I just discovered the JREF about 3 weeks ago.

I have used my available leisure time over the past couple of weeks to read virtually all 4000+ posts in this thread. Given the ‘progress’ that has been made, I’m unsure as to whether I should be proud of myself for that or embarrassed about it. Regardless, I have enjoyed the thought-provoking and mostly-civil debate that is often difficult to find elsewhere on the web.

I just wanted to comment that I believe Chris7 is an intelligent skilled debater, staying, for the most part, on the original thread points, choosing words carefully, making a fairly convincing argument. (Except for the ‘fake NIST photo’ debacle.) I think you would make a fine criminal defense lawyer, in that, to be successful, one would not be required to prove anything definitively in the defendant's favor, but rather only to cast enough reasonable doubt of the evidence to get the defendant set free.

Your three primary points from your original post (paraphrasing): there is no 10 story gouge in the south face, no evidence of debris damage in the area of the initiating event and no evidence of diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event (AIE) are completely accurate and cannot be disputed. It is an indisputable fact that there are conflicting descriptions of the dimensions of the south face damage. It is an indisputable fact that there is no known direct evidence of structural damage to the AIE. It is an indisputable fact that there is no known direct evidence of a diesel fire in the AIE. You’ve won the debate on these three points. Congratulations.

However, the conclusions you have chosen to draw from these statements (debris damage and fuel fires did not contribute to the collapse) are not sufficiently supported. The additional assumptions that must be made are too great. Evidence, with respect to damage and fires, is either that which has been observed and reported by witnesses or that which has been documented in photos and videos. To make the leap from “no evidence of debris damage or fire in AIE” to “definitively no debris damage or fire in AIE” you must assume that ALL of the debris damage and fire is KNOWN and that NONE of it is UNKNOWN. You must assume that ALL of the debris damage and fire progression was observed, reported and documented and that NO DAMAGE OR FIRE went undetected by the witnesses and cameras. A 110 story building falling onto a 47 story building is not an event that would produce predictable results. It is a random and chaotic event. Your assumption that the entirety of the damage and fire progression is observed and known is an unreasonable assumption. I accept your analysis that NIST does not/will not have sufficient evidence to irrefutably prove the DD/F hypothesis, but I reject your conclusions based on your unreasonable assumptions. While the evidence for DD/F is admittedly somewhat hampered by unknowns, there is no evidence at all for CD.

Looking forward to continuing this and other debate topics.

Another lawyer saying "yes but!"

We all know once a mind is made up it becomes a matter of selecting any argument that feels comfortable.

I reject your argument as based solely on a desire to believe that which you wish to believe.

MM
 
The fact that they published photos of every other side and angle except the south east side, is evidence of a cover up. [to anyone not in denial]

Or, it could simply be evidence that current camera technologies prohibit individuals from taking photographs of objects which are on the back side of a heavy layer of black/gray smoke.

Take your pick.
 
You folks keep missing a simple point. Every NY Fire Department supervisor on the site of WTC7 concluded that it was likely to collapse before any of the alleged CT "events" took place. You can go over descriptions or accounts of witnesses, etc. but it basically does not contradict the EMPIRICAL FACT that the Fire Dept. drew this conclusion from information that they had at the time.

This means that they all had to be "in on it" if the collapse was not from the attributed causes- damage due to the towers falling. All of these veterans fire fighters who saw their colleagues die in the towers that day had to be lying about WTC7.

The chances of that occurring and being a realistic premise? Right around zero.

Randy
 
Randy,

That has been brought up numerous times, and simply ignored by the movement. It makes perfect sense to me, and is simply one of many factors which lead me to conclude the towers fell because a friggin' airliner laden with fuel slammed into them at hundreds of miles an hour.

I think the problem is that some individuals think this was some trivial collision, like a bug on the windshield of a moving vehicle. They've no idea the scale of the transfer of energy which occured during those impacts.
 
We all know once a mind is made up it becomes a matter of selecting any argument that feels comfortable.

I reject your argument as based solely on a desire to believe that which you wish to believe.

MM

MM
Thanks so much for that invaluable contribution to this debate.;)
The next time you leave the house, do yourself a favor. Purchase a mirror.
Then stare into it and repeat the above sentences until the truth sinks in.
 
Seriously, Not all implosions go exactly to plan.
Hudson's building was 439' tall and had a much larger footprint, yet some damage was done to a nearby Tramway.
WTC 7 was 576' tall and only 140' front to back.
It fell in on itself and landed mostly in it's own footprint.
The north wall buckled out and creamed 30 W. Broadway. So what?

Damage to surrounding buildings was not a consideration.


If damage to surrounding buildings was not a consideration Chris, then there was absolutly no reason to attempt to implode the structure. We also know for a fact that if this was a vast conspiracy that the perpetrators also had no concern whatsoever as to the loss of life which this would bring on.

So the only concern the supposed perpetrators would have in bringing down WTC 7 would be to make it look as likely as possible that the debris damage and fires were responsible for the collapse. According to you, a collapse starting in the core of the building is as far as one can get from a DD/F caused collapse and thus the absolute worst way to address the only concern the perpetrators would have had in the destruction of WTC 7.
According to your contentions the best way to have destroyed WTC 7 would have been to have it fall to the south and east.

Damn these perpetrators for being both very, very good at what they do and very,very bad at what they do.:rolleyes:
 
You folks keep missing a simple point. Every NY Fire Department supervisor on the site of WTC7 concluded that it was likely to collapse before any of the alleged CT "events" took place. You can go over descriptions or accounts of witnesses, etc. but it basically does not contradict the EMPIRICAL FACT that the Fire Dept. drew this conclusion from information that they had at the time.


Randy
Evidently you have been misled by "Gravy's list" as so many have.

Of the 60 quotes in Gravy's list, only a few said they thought WTC 7 was going to fall.
The rest heard it thru the grapevine.

Chiefs Fellini and Hayden thought WTC 7 was going to fall.
Chief Nigro based his opinion on what Fellini and Hayden had told him.

Gravy failed to mention Chief Norman:
"I looked at 7 World Trade Center. There was smoke showing, but not a lot and I’m saying that isn’t going to fall."
 
Or, it could simply be evidence that current camera technologies prohibit individuals from taking photographs of objects which are on the back side of a heavy layer of black/gray smoke.

Take your pick.
From 11:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m.:
• No diesel smells reported from the exterior, stairwells, or lobby areas
• No signs of fire or smoke were reported below the 6th Floor from the exterior, stairwells or
lobby areas

Looking from the southeast corner of the south face:
• Fire seen on Floor 14 (corrected to 12 in Final 4-5-05) on south face; the face above the fire was covered with smoke
• Fire on Floor 14 moved towards the east face

The area below the 12th floor was not obscured by smoke.
As the fire progressed toward the east, different parts of the SE face would be visible.

So why not publish a couple photos of the SE face along with all the others?
 
Randy,

That has been brought up numerous times, and simply ignored by the movement. It makes perfect sense to me, and is simply one of many factors which lead me to conclude the towers fell because a friggin' airliner laden with fuel slammed into them at hundreds of miles an hour.

I think the problem is that some individuals think this was some trivial collision, like a bug on the windshield of a moving vehicle. They've no idea the scale of the transfer of energy which occured during those impacts.
We are talking about WTC 7.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom